Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the Weasleys arent poor, they are just shit with money?

366 replies

Bogeyface · 31/08/2013 19:12

Inspired by the HW thread, I have been thinking about this for a while.

Arthur works for the MoM so wont be on a pittance as a head of department, even a minor one as there would surely be grades?

They eat massive amounts of expensive food having three courses at every dinner, cooked breakfast every day. When they win a load of money, instead of saving it in the knowledge that they have 4 kids still at school they blow the lot on a holiday of a month in Egypt! At the beginning of CoS Mrs W takes some silver sickles and ONE gold galleon from their vault, and then happily blows 1000 galleons on a holiday rather than see them financially secure for the next few years.

Seems to me that the reason their kids are in second hand robes and reading second hand books is because they are shit with money, not that they dont have enough.

Books.....They have to have a new Miranda Goshawk book each year, so when F&G have finished with them they could have passed one to Ron who passed it to Ginny and the older ones shared the remainder if they needed it, which is unlikely. Why have several unused copies of the same book in the family and still buy another one for the youngest student? Same with robes. Rons dress robes are second hand, but Mrs W says that Arthur has some for parties so why not lend him those (with some magically performed alternations if needed) rather than pod out for horrible second hand ones? Actually, thinking further, Mrs W is supposed to be a whizz at household stuff so why doesnt she transfigure the second hand stuff to look better?

They just throw good money after bad!

OP posts:
merrymouse · 02/09/2013 23:12

I suspect Ron was keeping quiet about the wand as it was broken during the car stealing incident.

Seems a bit rough that he had a hand me down wand in the first place though.

muffinino82 · 02/09/2013 23:12

THANK YOU!

Being as arrogant and cunning as I am, these results do not surprise me Wink

Bogeyface · 02/09/2013 23:09

MrsW I am either Dobby or Narcissa depending on my mood, not sure which I prefer tbh :o

OP posts:
Bogeyface · 02/09/2013 23:08

Penguin do you get the feeling that Ron would be the OTT dad that says "yes" to everything because he still carries scars of those dress robes? And Hermyown lets him because she was an indulged PFB?

Whereas I suspect Harry and Ginny are the "earn your pocket money and save up" parents, causing much bad feeling between the Potter and Weasley cousins :o

OP posts:
MrsWeasley · 02/09/2013 23:03

BrittaPie I would love to be Dobby. more weird than normal Grin

PenguinBear · 02/09/2013 23:02

Just seen this thread but it's cheered me right up Grin

And I love the fact that as adults, Harry and Ginny and Ron and Hermione's families do not have any financial problems and their kids don't have to have anything second hand. Grin

Bogeyface · 02/09/2013 22:54

OI!!!

No fictional online pretend snogging on my thread thank you! :o

OP posts:
BellaTheGooseIsDead · 02/09/2013 22:53
Bogeyface · 02/09/2013 22:53

Right, just checked and Potter paid 7 Galleons for his wand.

He paid 10 Galleons each for 3 pairs of Omnioculars at the Quidditch world cup for him, Ron and Hermyown.

What was stopping him from buying Ron a new wand as a joint birthday and Xmas present? Apart from it would have ruined the story re Lockhart/Chamber of Secrets etc.

Seems to me that he is only sure of the Weasleys refusal of financial help when it suits him! So they are profligate and he is stingy, but with flashes of "look at me!" spending. Interesting dynamic.....

Did I mention I over think things? Blush

OP posts:
BellaTheGooseIsDead · 02/09/2013 22:52

"Gellert Grindelwald, the most evil wizard in history before HWSNBN came along"

THANK YOU!

Has anyone admitted to being Bellatrix yet?

DefiniteMaybe · 02/09/2013 22:52

I got Voldemort with Ron as my polar opposite Grin

muffinino82 · 02/09/2013 22:44

I'm Gellert Grindelwald, the most evil wizard in history before HWSNBN came along. Happily, my polar opposite is Potter Grin

BrittaPie · 02/09/2013 20:40

Dobby! Cheeky buggers.

You are Dobby, a House Elf that was previously enslaved by the Malfoys and now works as Hogwarts kitchen employee. Dobby is silly and docile, but also daring. Belonging to the Malfoys for so many years has hardened him to the point where he fights endlessly to stand up for what he believes, and no amount of violent threats can scare him into running away. In terms of friendship, though, Dobby is exceptionally faithful. He is definitely a character who grows a great deal throughout the series, seeing as his attitude changes from one of fear to one of fearlessness. You and Dobby are similar in the sense that both of you are somewhat crazy, though in actuality quite endearing. It is likely that you have a good amount of friends, and the reason they enjoy your company is because of your unfailing optimism. Sure, you can be a little weird sometimes, but in the end it is your heart of gold that draws people to you. What?s funny is that you don?t even really care about others? opinions; you appreciate a compliment every now and then, but you mainly live for yourself. You want to soak up every joyful moment that life gives you so that you can remember the good times over the bad.

In short, you are more:

Impulsive than cautious

Mature than immature

Modest than arrogant

Weird than normal

Extroverted than introverted

Although I have just left XH, so maybe he was my Malfoys and now I get to be all brave and die? Hmm
Tbh, it probably is quite accurate - the only thing that surprised me was that it said I'm modest :-D

AmazingDisgrace · 02/09/2013 20:19

I'm Grindelwald. Harry Potter is my polar opposite. Sulking a bit as I was hoping for Bellatrix. Still either way you look at it I'm bad assWink

BellaTheGooseIsDead · 02/09/2013 20:01

Luna would be cool. Has anyone got her yet? Or prepared to do the test as Luna and see if the test is accurate?

Elevader · 02/09/2013 19:57

Another Lupin here! Smile

EverythingInMjiniature · 02/09/2013 19:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

nooka · 02/09/2013 19:03

Oh and I'm another Molly Weasley, which is irritating because I really dislike her in the books/films and personally am some way off being 'practically a saint' (thank goodness!)

nooka · 02/09/2013 18:32

ha ha I gave dd the test and she came out as Gellert Grindelwald with Harry Potter as her opposite Grin Clever, conceited, and dangerous apparently!

She was not at all impressed! She wanted to be Luna. Funny quiz though :)

Lottiedoubtie · 02/09/2013 18:20

Well I suppose that some wizarding families malfoys can probably afford tutors to teach their children to read and write at home.

I think it says somewhere in the book that some go to muggle primary schools as well.

(I got Molly Weasley in the quiz as well)

merrymouse · 02/09/2013 18:16

Anyway, the Weasleys are supposed to contrast with the Dursleys and the Malfoys precisely because they aren't obsessed with getting ahead and keeping in with the right people - possibly hence Percy's frustration.

I suppose JK could go back and insert a chapter where some of these issues are clarified, but can't help thinking it might interfere with the flow.

Trills · 02/09/2013 18:05

Do all wizarding families have at least one SAHP while their children are under 11 then?

BigW · 02/09/2013 17:26

You see Merry that's another thing that bothers me. How can the likes of Harry and hermione ever hope to be as proficient at magic stuff as someone like Ron who has been exposed to it his entire life?

He will have grown up surrounded by spells and potions and port keys where as Harry only found out a few hours before setting his eyes on a wand for the first time.

merrymouse · 02/09/2013 17:16

I think JK says that wizard children are home educated before secondary school? I suspect the poor woman was trying to launch herself back into the job market, and maybe set up some kind of business selling jumpers during books 2 and 3, and then at the end of book 4, just when she's starting to make some headway, Voldemort returns and she has to set up headquarters for the resistance movement.

MinesAPintOfTea · 02/09/2013 16:36

The month in Egypt is a bit misleading: they were visiting a family member and presumably stayed with him. Also reasonable to spend a windfall on visiting family (assuming no debt etc) if you usually can't afford to do that.

As for what Molly does all day: Harry thinks the house is held up entirely by magic. Possibly Molly spends a lot of time refreshing spells.

Swipe left for the next trending thread