Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the Weasleys arent poor, they are just shit with money?

366 replies

Bogeyface · 31/08/2013 19:12

Inspired by the HW thread, I have been thinking about this for a while.

Arthur works for the MoM so wont be on a pittance as a head of department, even a minor one as there would surely be grades?

They eat massive amounts of expensive food having three courses at every dinner, cooked breakfast every day. When they win a load of money, instead of saving it in the knowledge that they have 4 kids still at school they blow the lot on a holiday of a month in Egypt! At the beginning of CoS Mrs W takes some silver sickles and ONE gold galleon from their vault, and then happily blows 1000 galleons on a holiday rather than see them financially secure for the next few years.

Seems to me that the reason their kids are in second hand robes and reading second hand books is because they are shit with money, not that they dont have enough.

Books.....They have to have a new Miranda Goshawk book each year, so when F&G have finished with them they could have passed one to Ron who passed it to Ginny and the older ones shared the remainder if they needed it, which is unlikely. Why have several unused copies of the same book in the family and still buy another one for the youngest student? Same with robes. Rons dress robes are second hand, but Mrs W says that Arthur has some for parties so why not lend him those (with some magically performed alternations if needed) rather than pod out for horrible second hand ones? Actually, thinking further, Mrs W is supposed to be a whizz at household stuff so why doesnt she transfigure the second hand stuff to look better?

They just throw good money after bad!

OP posts:
LindyHemming · 03/09/2013 19:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

NuggetofPurestGreen · 03/09/2013 19:06

Lupin! Opposite of Bellatrix. Sounds about right!!

Bogeyface · 03/09/2013 17:46

JK says that things conjured up out of thin air dont last as they have no substance, so you can change things, increase them, reduce them and summon them but not create them.

I would think then that that is why they buy second hand clothes and books but surely they could be transfigured into new looking clothes and books?

OP posts:
Pachacuti · 03/09/2013 17:33

It's the things that are exemptions to Gamp's Law that can't just be created out of thin air we are told that there are five exemptions, but the only one that we are specifically told about is food. It's likely, from the events around Order of The Phoenix (and the fact that no one does magic up huge piles of cash) that money/gold/riches is another. Various essays on the Internet speculate on the precise nature of the other three exemptions given that the Weasleys live in second-hand outdated clothes it's probable that that is indeed one of them. But it's being an exemption to Gamp's Law that stops [whatever] being magicked up, not Gamp's Law itself.

Glitterspy · 03/09/2013 16:30

Pachacuti Could be - but then wouldn't all wizards use the 5th exemption to make themselves rich rich rich?

Pachacuti · 03/09/2013 15:46

Only if clothing is the much-speculated-about fifth exemption to Gamp's Law., Glitterspy. It would make sense if it is, of course.

AintNobodyGotTimeFurThat · 03/09/2013 14:47

Re taking the test when not half asleep. :)

Seems to get me to Lupin.

Hmmmm only one dynamic changed whether I was extroverted or introverted.

Interesting though.

Glad I'm no longer Molly. Have some similar values but eh, not her biggest fan.

MischiefManaged · 03/09/2013 14:02

I'm Bellatrix! ha
I got Crookshanks the first time round so tried to be more decisive in my answers on second run.

Impulsive than cautious
Immature than mature
Arrogant than modest
Weird than normal
Extroverted than introverted

Glitterspy · 03/09/2013 13:56

Sorryif this has already been mentioned but Gamp's Law of Elemental Transfiguration prevents the Weasleys "just magicing themselves up some new gear"!!

CambridgeBlue · 03/09/2013 13:48

Thanks for the link to the Hogwarts thread. I can't get the quiz to work though! I click on 'Expecto Patronum' and nothing happens - what am I doing wrong? I'm desperate to find out who I am!

DashingRedhead · 03/09/2013 13:18

House elves go with the house and whoever inherits; I don't think they can be sold, although Harry inherits Kreecher along with all Sirius's other 'posessions'.

badtime · 03/09/2013 12:19

I'm Hermione. It's hardly surprising since I am an abrasive know-all in real life, but I would have preferred McGonagall, for the gravitas.

marriedinwhiteisback · 03/09/2013 12:04

I must let dd know how well the quiz she found has gone down on Mnet. DD has managed to hijack a thread without even being a Mnetter - but she is an avid HP fan.

Bogeyface · 03/09/2013 11:59

I think that house elves are probably considered an asset by the owning family and can be sold. :( I would imagine that they would be expensive to buy, something that Hermione would go ape about if she knew.

I think that Hogwarts is state run, so funded by the MoM with extras paid for from donations and trusts from alumni.

OP posts:
Sparklymommy · 03/09/2013 11:47

I'm a Lupin too! (Secretly wants to be Bellatrix).

Molly and Arthur are lovely people. Shit with money but happy with their lot. More people should be like them!

Cheddars · 03/09/2013 11:45

I got Luna Lovegood Smile
Matches my personality quite well.

People generally do not take her seriously because she has a tendency to spout strange, uncommon ideas off the top of her head, but Luna is the type of individual who doesn?t care much about impressing others.
And that explains why I don't do so well on the school run. Blush

MinnieBar · 03/09/2013 11:43

Another Lupin here!

I never understood why Molly says they can't afford a house elf when the annoying poor blighters don't even get paid. What's that all about then??

Agree with the bad financial management - she makes them a jumper each for Christmas, and even if she were using the cheapest granny acrylic available, for seven kids and Harry that wouldn't be a 'cheap' present?

motherinferior · 03/09/2013 10:58

WRT funding I reckon it's like statementing and you can get local authority assistance for a place.

Molly ought to get some of those damn sexist blokes she lives with to do a bit more of the housework.

Weasleyismyking · 03/09/2013 10:39

I'm Ginny Weasley. My username feels a bit weird now... Blush

mrsjay · 03/09/2013 09:21

maybe they are just eccentric aristo's and mr weasly is just playing at a job and they are loaded and when they die they will leave all their money to cats Grin

Pachacuti · 03/09/2013 09:20

I rather like merrymouse's affecting portrait of Molly as a small businesswoman struggling to get her woolly jumper business off the ground only to have it all ripped from under her by the return of the Dark Lord.

AnyoneButLulu · 03/09/2013 09:19

I thought about those threads too Boff, when I made that very same point, but surely even the most frothing of flames wouldn't say it was unreasonable to expect a mother of teenagers who were all at boarding school to get a job? Surely? Surely?

mrsjay · 03/09/2013 09:18

I think Molly is some sort of tea witch and makes the tea and cake for all the other far more important people, Hmm what page is the quiz on

Beastofburden · 03/09/2013 09:15

Boffin, nobody flamed me when I said that upthread! I think its because they are all at boarding school perhaps a little class envy creeping in but there is a theory its a big house and someone needs to be there to cast the spells all day. Dont buy it, myself.

Snazzyenjoyingsummer · 03/09/2013 09:14

would love to have been Hermione Envy