Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what your bottom-line for friendship is?

84 replies

ARealDame · 29/07/2013 18:19

I have a chronic illness (don't talk about it much, and to a large extent its invisible). But I have decided new (and old) friends who just ignore this completely, are being put in the out tray ...

Its a bit sad. Selfish people are often exciting people (why is that?). But it gets old, and draining. Should I look out for more gentle kind of people?

Whats your bottom-line?

OP posts:
Nancy66 · 30/07/2013 15:23

In the past few years I have dropped:

one friend for being continually flaky. Always cancelling at last minute, totally unreliable.

One friend for being too much of an emotional vampire. Constantly needing help, reassurance, guidance, advice for the most petty and inane of problems.

a friend with addiction issues that she lied about/refused to address.

On the whole my criteria is that they must be: easy going, fun, loyal and good company. Why bother if they're not?

elinorbellowed · 30/07/2013 15:17

I only have a handful of close friends. That way I avoid the situations of which you speak.
I have twice consciously 'dropped' people. Once, a very intense dramatic girl who I lived with at college. She was very full-on to my face, loved and trusted me, couldn't cope without me, I was the only person who knew the real her etc. Behind my back she was bitching about me to everyone and stirring up trouble with my boyfriend. I hate hypocrites.
The other was a woman I had known since childhood. She became a teacher and slept with one of her students (the student wasn't under-age). That crossed a line for me morally and I let her know I thought that before breaking contact.
I think a lot of people only like you when you are strong and fun. A lot of people can't cope with weakness, perceived or otherwise.

GoodTouchBadTouch · 30/07/2013 15:02

Yes, good point Crinkle. OP do you mean that you think your friends should ask how you are?

If you don't talk about it why would they? They would assume you are fine and talk about normal things.

It really depends on what your illness is, if its something serious which could get worse, Id be very concerned and ask how you were all the time. If it was something to do with mental health, I wouldn't bother.

Crinkle77 · 30/07/2013 14:49

OP maybe you are being a little unfair on your friends? You say that your illness is largely invisible and you don't talk about it very much. Maybe your friends have sensed that you don't want to talk about it or perhaps feel that you don't want to so avoid it so as not to upset you. Do they never ever ask? As you said your illness is invisible so maybe they just forget as it is not obvious. Surely it is not intentional.
But I do have to agree about the exciting friends being selfish. One of my friends is like this. She is good fun to be around but is totally unreliable and only does what she wants to do. It used to do my head in but I have made the decision to just accept the way she is. I never make plans with her as I know she is unreliable and just take it as it comes. Plus I don't feel guilty if I let her down as she does it to other people.

fabergeegg · 30/07/2013 14:14

Funny old world...

Solari · 30/07/2013 12:29

I try to keep a combination of friends.

Obviously, for myself, I like the upbeat, positive ones, because they do give a 'lift' to the day. But equally I keep a small number of friends I would describe as more draining, because I still believe they are good/nice people, just needy.

I don't mind fulfilling other peoples' needs in their turn, I just have to make sure I rotate time spent so that I don't get too bogged down myself. I also don't allow the needier friends to progress beyond a certain point. My boundaries are sharp these days!

Deliaskis · 30/07/2013 12:19

This is interesting reading for me and has helped me define what I'm going to do next. Having recently spent a weekend with an old friend, I'm now convinced I need to back off from the friendship. I only see her maybe 2-3 times a year for a weekend at a time, but for the past 3 or so meet-ups I've just felt like she has become so utterly self-absorbed, we just don't connect, our lives are too different, but more importantly than that, our values are so different. I think I have become more certain of my own values, and she has become more outspoken about hers, but I spent the weekend being half offended, sometimes almost disgusted, pi$$ed off, baffled and just wishing myself elsewhere.

I could have been spending time with my lovely DH and DD :-(

So it's for the bin that one.

D

ARealDame · 30/07/2013 12:02

As FourWillies has just said I don't think anyone has said friends should be dropped for casual reasons, well I certainly didn't. I don't think its a casual reason to distance yourself from a "friend" who dismisses your health problems because it gets in the way of their high maintenance practical (and neurotic) demands. Perhaps that clears up the "illness" question, i.e. I'm not being precious about it at all. The uncaring attitude however, I've decided is a bottom line for me ... but others may have very different ones, depending on their values and needs.

I think as we are all individuals, and imperfect, there is inevitably a lot of give and take and forgiveness necessary in friendships as well as acquaintances and neighbours and co-workers. THATS why I asked was there a "bottom line" in friendship, something you would simply not put up with? Some friendships, like any relationships, can be abusive. I've seen more than a few threads on here where I think Shock really, that's a friend?

Anyway, thanks for sharing all your thoughts. I will go back and read a the interesting posts once thread has finished. (Shame some posts got a bit angry/accusatory towards other posters but anyway).

Here's to new and happy friendships Brew and Biscuit and Wine.

OP posts:
GoodTouchBadTouch · 30/07/2013 10:15

I think the only thing that matters is that you share a sense of humour. I love Jimmy Carr, so if someone says they cant stand him, Id know there is no future for us, because Id offend them with un pc jokes.

Once in group I made a "joke" about John Prescott forgetting to throw up after he binged.. a couple thought it was hilarious, and the rest gasped in horror

Oh and negativity, obviously nobody is happy all the time, but if the first thing someone says to me is "I suffer from depression" Id think YAWN. Like someone said, joy suckers.

Other than that Im really laid back, I don't ask anything from my friends, don't have standards at all, except the sense of humour thing. For example, I have one great friend who is a terrible criminal - she cracks me up with stories of drug busts and police raids... Id never leave my children with her, but I could talk to her on the phone for hours.

I suppose Im a bit shallow really

My husband is really my best friend and I don't really need anyone else

Fourwillies · 30/07/2013 06:57

" You must be fun, healthy, have no inconvenient "draining" problems, cook well, dress well, be interesting, a great conversationalist without getting deeply into anything that actually matters, on time, find it really easy to change things you're not happy about, have a tidy house, blah blah blah. Otherwise you'll be dropped. Is that really what friendship is?"

I don't think anyone has said that. But if they did, so what, it's their choice to be with the people that suit them.

Wbdn28 · 30/07/2013 00:19

Surely we all have our imperfections? Or is everyone here never in the slightest bit self-absorbed, unhelpful, sad, late, unhealthy or less-than-uber-positive?

Some people's criteria are like friendships for Stepford Wives. You must be fun, healthy, have no inconvenient "draining" problems, cook well, dress well, be interesting, a great conversationalist without getting deeply into anything that actually matters, on time, find it really easy to change things you're not happy about, have a tidy house, blah blah blah. Otherwise you'll be dropped. Is that really what friendship is?

WilsonFrickett · 30/07/2013 00:18

I only have friends whom I look forward to seeing. I'm not great with 'why didn't you call me' people because I used to work away a lot and found that filtered a few people off. But apart from that, nah. I'm just happy the world is full of such diverse people who want to be friends with me.

MammaTJ · 30/07/2013 00:06

Everyone has there own issues, and the people whos issues overcome yours, no matter what, are the people not worth bothering with!!

quesadilla · 30/07/2013 00:02

Hester raises an interesting point. I have a small handful of friends I have known for 20 years plus and I will tolerate - up to a point - shit from them which I won't from newer friends.

The bond of a lifetime's shared experience is very strong and sometimes with people who you have been through that much with the memories and nostalgia can blind you to who they are. It sometimes becomes almost irrelevant whether you actually like them or not.

As I now have such limited time in my life (due to motherhood and full time work) I have less tolerance for the downsides of friendship (flakiness/self obsession/bitchiness) and tend to be pretty intolerant of this when I meet potential new friends. Yet I accept this to a degree in older ones.

It's one of life's weird ironies that although you need friends more the older you get, you tend to erect more barriers to finding them. At least that's my experience.

Fourwillies · 29/07/2013 23:36

Bumblequeen: "When being around them makes you feel bad or question yourself"

This.

Wbdn28 · 29/07/2013 23:17

Spot on, fabergeegg

Doodlez · 29/07/2013 23:10

Lukewarm - that's the very type I mean! Entertaining right up to the point they adopt YOU as their new life-long buddy. Then you have to ditch them. They're like the Dementors in Harry Potter - they suck the joy out of life!

Madeyemoodysmum · 29/07/2013 23:08

Flakiness is my pet hate, I have to bin anyone who is repeatedly flaky

I don't have enough hours in the day to waste on people that continually let me down at the last minute

And I can't bear over dramatic drama queens. Sorry but NO!

LukewarmBath · 29/07/2013 23:03

Doodlez, there is a mum at my DC's school who, when asked how she is always says 'Oh, don't ask!' and then launches into a big spiele about her latest ailment/problem. It's getting quite entertaining listening to the latest instalment each week

Bumblequeen · 29/07/2013 23:01

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Doodlez · 29/07/2013 22:55

Real - do they seem to ignore it in order to just treat you normally? Are they trying not to make your illness in to an issue?

My bottom line is moaning minnies - those folk who moan about everything and play the vicitim, even don to asking "How ya doin'?" and them replying "Oh, you know. Surviving." - FFS - just say I'm fine thanks!

Beastofburden · 29/07/2013 22:49

I have never deliberately ditched a friend for falling short in some way. What does seem to happen is that I retain one good friend from every five years or so of life. It's a ratio I am pretty happy with, actually. The others are not rejected, it's just that they were warm colleagues but we never grew close.

pourmeanotherglass · 29/07/2013 22:04

I don't really have a bottom line. I'm not so overwhelmed with friends I can afford to ditch some. I'd be happy to go for a beer with most of the school mums and/or most of my work colleagues if they asked on a night I was free.
If I was going to be fussy, I guess I find people who winge a lot a bit wearing.

FreudiansSlipper · 29/07/2013 21:58

I am very forgiving but those that expect too much from me and I do not or can not give them what they want will drift away and probably do the same again with their new friends i

Sometimes my friends drain me, sometimes I drain them but many times we laugh together and help each other out. I have one friend who has always been totally self absorbed it is just the way she is but when I had no where to stay with a 1 year old she was there and always thinks of ds and she makes me laugh like no other friend

I could never lose a friendship over forgetting birthdays or someone not calling when I needed them too there have their life and at times I am not a perfect friend but other times I am and they are too

Fourwillies · 29/07/2013 21:55

Fabergeegg I knew there would be someone who misunderstood what I meant as I didn't put it very well. All I can do is use an example.
Saw friend A last week - she rang in a state, please can I meet her in town, it's all gone wrong with her DP etc. I was there that evening, and listened to a whole sad litany. It wasn't a happy evening but I came away thinking "life is so unfair, she is so lovely and deserves happiness." I was pleased to see her, she is my friend and I love her. Even though the evening was sad she wasn't toxic or draining in any way.

Friend B came over for drinks on Saturday. She is very witty and funny, we have a lot in common and she lives locally. But despite plenty of laughs and bright conversation there was an edge I felt, which I know makes her an acquaintance not a friend, and although I'll see her socially, I won't be taking our friendship any further.

Does that make better sense?