Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many cigarette breaks while at work?

64 replies

Booboostoo · 16/04/2013 09:12

OK this is driving me bonkers and I need some perspective.

I have a nanny/groom who works 9-12 and 2-5. She smokes which I knew before she started and we agreed that she would not smoke around DD (she doesn't smoke around the horses either as it's dangerous when handling them and also hay is very flammable).

I am annoyed that she takes so many cigarette breaks. Typically she arrives for work at 9am but has a cigarette break straight off so she can't help out until 9.15. She then takes another cigarette break somewhere in the middle of the morning and tries to leave at 11.45 to have another cigarette break (she doesn't smoke in her car, but only lives 5 minutes drive away so I don't know why she doesn't smoke at home). Same thing in the afternoon, has a cigarette break as soon as she arrives, another one in the middle and one before she leaves.

She smokes so often she now smokes around DD on walks - DD on one hand, cigarette on the other. She is trying to hide the cigarettes from DD but I don't see how this will work longterm.

She did say when she started work that she was trying to quit but that was two years ago and if anything she smokes a lot more now. I appreciate smoking is addictive and she doesn't have control over it and I don't smoke but AIBU? Should I just live with it?

OP posts:
mrsjay · 16/04/2013 11:41

I work with children and I am not allowed to smoke an hour before I come into contact with them some sort of EU law ( i think) anyway your employee is breaking your job description no smoking with your child or near your horses a break is just that a break she isn't taking breaks she is taking the piss

waikikamookau · 16/04/2013 11:38

imagining

waikikamookau · 16/04/2013 11:38

I was imaging it was a teenager

Booboostoo · 16/04/2013 11:30

I've had a chat with her and said that since DD is now copying behaviours and is more impressionable she mustn't smoke around her at all and also mentioned that she can smoke before she comes for 9 and after she leaves at 12. Hopefully that will sort things out.

It's very difficult to have someone come over for short periods of time because I need to take the time to show them how to do the horses and it's not worth it if they only stay for a few months. The horses are competition horses and require someone with some experience so I don't think it would be suitable for a teenager.

OP posts:
arabesque · 16/04/2013 10:38

There are no official smoking breaks where I work either. Most people don't take the piss but some really do and seem to spend more time outside smoking than inside actually working. People also round each other up to go on smoking breaks and have turned it into a social occasion, often being gone for up to twenty minutes at a time. They will probably be the first ones to moan if an official policy is put in place even though its their carry on that will have prompted it in the first place.

AnyFucker · 16/04/2013 10:14

ok, fair enough re the mid day break

the rest...not so much

erm, I can think of quite a few UK teenagers that would jump at this chance, but likely only for short periods

LtEveDallas · 16/04/2013 10:12

There are no 'official' breaks in my job. Somkers can nip outside and spark up whenever they want - I reckon it's probably once an hour for 5 mins at a time.

Put the smoking aside for a moment. Is she good at her job? Do you like her? Does your child like her? Does she give you value for money?

If you cant say yes to the above and don't want your employee smoking then you have no choice but to give her notice, and specify a non-smoker when employing someone else. You bought this on yourself really by not doing that in the first place.

Booboostoo · 16/04/2013 10:07

Sorry I should have said that we are in France. Almost no one works 12-2 here, it's the sacred lunch hour!

I am not sure how easy it would be to find someone else. It's very difficult to find someone with adequate grooming skills - not that childcare is not important but I am around all the time for that so she's not left sole charge and I can keep an eye on things.

She wants to leave anyway in a few months so I might look to see if someone from the UK wants to come over but it's such a big move we'd need to find someone who was fairly committed.

OP posts:
BegoniaBampot · 16/04/2013 10:03

how can you trust her judgement. what kind of person whose job is with children, thinks it's acceptable to smoke around children. i'm surprised you seem more concerned with the fag breaks than that TBH.

specialsubject · 16/04/2013 09:59

sack. Reason - not doing enough work and breaking your conditions. Clearly she is completely ruled by the stinky-sticks and not concentrating on much else.

plenty of people do give up smoking so it is not an incurable addiction. This might encourage her to get help.

flowery · 16/04/2013 09:41

Good grief, please don't get employment law from wiki!

Breaks are 20 minutes for shifts of longer than 6 hours.

OP if you want to keep her I'd give her a chance to sort this, and be clear that she is not to either take breaks during her 3 hours, and must smoke before and after, is to start work on time at 9, not at 9.15 and under absolutely no circumstances must she smoke while caring for DD.

SchroSawMargeryDaw · 16/04/2013 09:39

I've only ever smoked before work and one on a break (break that everyone else is taking too). I haven't worked in a couple of years but surely people aren't now allowed more time to smoke?

Btw, walking with your DD, holding her hand and smoking with the other is actually disgusting. I wouldn't do this with my own child and I have no idea why your Nanny would think this was okay. Confused

Iwantmybed · 16/04/2013 09:35

If you allow breaks at all they do not need to be any longer than 5 mins. Yes she's taking the piss and will continue to do so until stopped.

MusicalEndorphins · 16/04/2013 09:33

From en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Break_%28work%29
"In the United Kingdom the law states that employers are legally required to provide at least a 10-minute break for every four consecutive hours worked and that a person must not work more than four hours in succession. When working in a restaurant environment, staff can be required to work up to six hours straight before having a break but must be given at least 20 minutes break for each six hours worked. Employers are not allowed to make a member of their staff take a break earlier in the shift then work more than four consecutive hours or six consecutive hours in one go without a further break; for example, if an employee was working ten hours the company could not give him twenty minutes' break two hours into the shift and then expect the employee to work the rest of the shift without a further break."

ENormaSnob · 16/04/2013 09:31

Get rid.

She isn't trust worthy and is taking the piss with breaks and timekeeping.

MusicalEndorphins · 16/04/2013 09:31

Well, I never heard of a job giving any breaks other than the mandatory ones. Which would be 15 minutes coffee break in am, a 30 minute lunch, and 15 min. pm break. If you smoked, that was when you had the chance to light up. A 3 hour shift such as she works would not even get any break.
If she were working for me, I would tell her no more breaks in those 2 3 hr shifts. And no smoking while out and about with the child, and if she did you would have to let her go.

ShadowStorm · 16/04/2013 09:30

The smoking policy at my work is that smokers are only allowed one 5 min cigarette break in the morning and one 5 min cigarette break in the afternoon (plus as many as they can fit into their lunch break).

I think if she wants a cigarette before starting work, she should arrive at 8:45 so that she's ready to actually start work at 9am. Equally, she should wait until after working hours are finished to have her last cigarette, instead of trying to finish 15 minutes early to have the cigarette.

BegoniaBampot · 16/04/2013 09:25

would be a no way for me thought TBh I probably wouldn't employ a smoker who would have sole charge of my children as I wouldn't trust them not to smoke when they were on their own.

waikikamookau · 16/04/2013 09:25

never mind the smoking, you have issue with her taking Breaks. might be an easier way of raising it.

StuntGirl · 16/04/2013 09:24

Also, if she starts work at 9am she needs to be arriving about 5/10 minutes earlier so she is ready to actually start at 9am. If she wants to smoke before starting she needs to arrive even earlier.

D0oinMeCleanin · 16/04/2013 09:24

I smoke and can set my own smoke breaks at work. I do not bother having one at all on my three hour shift, unless it is exceptionally quiet and I've done all the cleaning.

On my evening shift (7 hours) I have one after three or four hours work, depending upon how busy it is and then a further one or two an hour or two later, again depending on how busy it is.

I don't have one as soon as I start, because I arrive 5 minutes early in order for me to have a smoke before I start, anything else would be taking the piss.

Give her a warning.

waikikamookau · 16/04/2013 09:24

I think you should mention that she should be starting working at 9, rather than 9.15,

Crinkle77 · 16/04/2013 09:22

I am a smoker but even I find this unacceptable behaviour. You need to tell her that if she smokes then she must have one before she gets to your house. If she is entitled to a break tell her she can have a cigarette when she is on her break but not during her work time. She should not be smoking before she leaves. She should have one on her way home. Saying that I would be inclined to get rid as she is smoking around your daughter and that is not right

waikikamookau · 16/04/2013 09:22

I have one before work, 8.50, one at 11 ish, one in lunch break and one around 3.30 ish, finish 5. 5.30 ish and have one then

so in reality during working hours it is 3

tazzle · 16/04/2013 09:21

She will just have to control it like anyone else that smokes and works many of them unable to take a break when they want and have to wait till its possible / convenient / scheduled. Three hours is not unreasonable to go without .

Swipe left for the next trending thread