Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think NHS 111 is a fucking joke?

139 replies

NillyNolly · 30/03/2013 07:59

I have had the misfortune of experiencing the new NHS 111 service three times in the last week. One of my DC has a compromised immune system so often need out of hours appointments.

Before the 111 service I could call our local out of hours service who would answer straight away, listen to a brief description of symptoms, then make a doctors appointment or get a nurse to call us back. Simple.

With 111 I have waited an average of 20 mins for someone to pick up each time, had to go through all mine and my DS's details about 3 times, then had to answer a series of questions which takes a further 10 minutes ("is he breathing?" ..... Ummm, do you not think I would have perhaps called an ambulance by now if he wasn't....?)

I am so angry and frustrated with this new phone line!!! Angry !!!!

OP posts:
Hawkmoth · 30/03/2013 09:49

NHSD is nurse led with clinical triage, 111 uses a non-clinical computer system staffed by non-clinicians which leads you to either advice or referral to another service, like OOH, nurse advice, taking paracetamol, A&E or your own GP in a week. There are lots of different end points.

Some areas have had 111 for a while and it's quite bedded in, others started last week, albeit briefly in some cases.

111 does tend to be more risk averse than NHSD, which is why there are the headlines about people getting 999 for hiccups etc.

creamteas · 30/03/2013 09:48

As I understand it the 111 system went out to tender and is being operated by different people in different parts of the country.

In many areas it is staffed by non-clinically trained call centre workers. They have no option but to follow the questions on the screen, and if you give an answer which isn't an option they don't know what to do (this happened to us).

Where I live, very few people get through to the OOH service anymore, and everyone is now turning up at A&E because they are desperate. Recently the ambulances were waiting for hours at our local hospital as they could not fit any more people in Angry

It is a complete shambles......

Wheresmycaffeinedrip · 30/03/2013 09:48

I haven't used 111 but I have used that harmoni ooh service. Now that's a joke. Told by nhs direct to get straight down there even though our appointment wasn't for a few hours. Lovely lady said shed phone ahead and say we were coming down and try to get us seen much sooner. Say in the virtually empty waiting room for two hours being ignored, receptionist constantly telling us we were next then denying she had said it. Ended up giving up completely walking round the corner to A&E who triaged and admitted instantly and gave her a nebuliser. Will never use again!!

phantomhairpuller · 30/03/2013 09:47

I've just been 'in a queue' with them for the last 15 minutes so have given up. Absolute crap Angry

Altinkum · 30/03/2013 09:46

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

theodorakisses · 30/03/2013 09:45

I would never be satisfied with being assessed and treated by a nurse and would certainly not trust them with children. I did the nurse degree and the practitioner training and they were moronic and there is little that they can offer that can't be found out by googling. Why can't doctors see people anymore?

Softlysoftly · 30/03/2013 09:44

Sat reading and thanking my lucky stars yet again for having a gp for a sister in law. Sounds a nightmare.

Also what's the difference between 111 and nhs direct Confused

x2boys · 30/03/2013 09:44

sorry altinkum i misread your post i thought you were saying nhs direct were a lot better than 111 not the other way round well i hopr they are cos you cantget much worse than nhs direct!

Altinkum · 30/03/2013 09:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Altinkum · 30/03/2013 09:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Binkybix · 30/03/2013 09:39

There seems to be a section on the NHS choices website that shows how to give feedback on the service you've received. Worth doing that?

x2boys · 30/03/2013 09:35

who had that is

x2boys · 30/03/2013 09:34

well you obviously got good service altinkum but NHS Direct once insisted on snding an ambulance all blues and twos for my DH who a severe migraine!

Hawkmoth · 30/03/2013 09:26

It lasted one day round here. Would advise trying the OOH number, there are not many places willing to risk the new system over the Easter weekend.

Altinkum · 30/03/2013 09:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Altinkum · 30/03/2013 09:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

x2boys · 30/03/2013 09:15

so is 111 worse than nhs direct because frankley i thought they were pretty useless everytime i phoned them they told me to go to Aand E even if it was just for aminor ailment so I just cut out the middle man and went to A and E myself and have you ever triedto get an emergency dentist through NHS direct what arigmorle you have to phone them and wait about 3 hrs foe a nurse to phone you back WTF a nurse would know about dental pain i have no idea than they give you an appointment!

Meglet · 30/03/2013 09:06

I've never had a problem with NHS direct. They've always called us back within a few minutes OR popped us straight through to an OOH GP. If we need to see the GP we're at the clinic within the hour. OOH was invaluable when they had dreadful chicken pox and needed to be seen on a saturday at 10pm.

I really don't like the sound of 111 at all.

nextphase · 30/03/2013 08:57

We had a fiasco with 111.
Diaed NHS direct, which when through all our details, and then got told we were out of area, and to call 111.
Called 111, had to go through all our details, and then got told to go to a ooh GP 40 miles away. Objected, and said I wanted to go to local town X. Got told to rig NHS direct. went round in circles til someone understood I wanted to travel 5 miles, not 40.. Took about an hour of back and forth.
Whole system needs sorting.

That said, I rang 101 for the police the other day, as the wind had blown the barriers into the road. When I went back, they had moved them- took them less than 30 mins

Sirzy · 30/03/2013 08:55

seems like this system is as bas as NHS direct then!

There again given OOH always refuse to see DS can't make things any worse for him!

MimsyBorogroves · 30/03/2013 08:51

No - it's bloody ridiculous.

Had to take DS2 to OOH in an area where 111 isn't rolled out yet because it IS active in our area. So we phoned them, got sorted with an appointment 15 minutes later (and even then she was giving us the 10 minute chat about things to watch out for, even though we were on the way to the GP and it was delaying us)

We got to the OOH and we were told we had a 2 hour wait at least. We said we had booked an appointment - impossible, apparently, as they don't have appointments. Due to the fact 111 isn't in this area, all appointments on their system were free - because they weren't using them.

After waiting over an hour, in which time they saw 3 people (and we still had 5 ahead of us) we gave up and went back to get DS to bed.

pumpkinsweetie · 30/03/2013 08:41

Atleast NHS direct got my children what they needed and always phoned back. On so many occasions it saved hospital/doctors time and probably money as well as simple stuff like a bang to the head or chicken pox, i was reassured if my dc needed medical attention or not. With this new system, i can see people just panicking and rushing to A&E.
I thought they weren't rolling this nonsense out yet due to there being so many flaws? [buconfused]

PinkPepper · 30/03/2013 08:39

I had a great experience. My son had an allergic reaction to egg, it was mild but pfb I didn't know if I should worry/get him checked out anyway.
Someone answered phone within 10mins, went through the serious questions, reassured us it wasn't serious serious emergency, said a nurse would call us within an hour.
Nurse rang within a further 10mins and spent ages reassuring us on phone (by this time his reaction had faded) and told us what to do in other cases.

For me it was exactly what I needed anyway.

I'm sorry other people haven't found the same :(

Kveta · 30/03/2013 08:31

it's atrocious - when I had a chest infection and UTI following 'flu, 111 triaged me and said it was 'just 'flu' and to rest. Finally got to my own GP who told me I should have been seen sooner, and got me on ABs.

I want to call NHSDirect for advice on DD's chickenpox (she is too young for most OTC drugs, and very poorly), but we can't call any more, it has to be the rigmarole of 111, so I'm about to start a thread on MN instead [buhmm]

theodorakisses · 30/03/2013 08:30

Looking back at the NHS after many years abroad (and 10 years previous NHS service which ended in bullying after whistleblowing) I cannot understand why people tolerate the way they are treated. No other health system (and the NHS is not unique in its model) would treat people this way and employ people so thick they depend on a computer to triage people and ask moronic questions.
It is one of the main reasons i couldn't live there again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread