Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think NHS 111 is a fucking joke?

139 replies

NillyNolly · 30/03/2013 07:59

I have had the misfortune of experiencing the new NHS 111 service three times in the last week. One of my DC has a compromised immune system so often need out of hours appointments.

Before the 111 service I could call our local out of hours service who would answer straight away, listen to a brief description of symptoms, then make a doctors appointment or get a nurse to call us back. Simple.

With 111 I have waited an average of 20 mins for someone to pick up each time, had to go through all mine and my DS's details about 3 times, then had to answer a series of questions which takes a further 10 minutes ("is he breathing?" ..... Ummm, do you not think I would have perhaps called an ambulance by now if he wasn't....?)

I am so angry and frustrated with this new phone line!!! Angry !!!!

OP posts:
Kiriwawa · 02/04/2013 10:08

MissBetsy - they had no choice but to go live as of 1st April. Many areas didn't award contracts until the very end of last year which is not long enough to get adequate systems in place.

Totally agree that faxing is insane but some GP surgeries and OOH providers don't have any other facility for passing on patient notes!

Fudgemallowdelight · 01/04/2013 22:53

I just looked on the NHS Direct site and it says (as an example) that if a child under 6 months has breathing problems to ring 111. Bit worrying!

www.nhsdirect.nhs.uk/CheckSymptoms/SATs/BreathingProblems.aspx

MissBetseyTrotwood · 01/04/2013 21:42

Got through fine, on assessment the call handler said I needed to speak to a GP re. DS2's symptoms.

And... no call back.

Their system went down and they said they would fax (arf, last time I heard that verb was in about 1992) our details over to the OOS. Took him to the GP walk in in the end, which was what I had been trying not to do.

I realise they have to ask the basic safety questions etc - it's all part of the procedure and that's OK. But the basic systems that are fundamental to the safety and integrity of the service are faulty here and I don't know why they've still gone 'live' with these major issues.

BlueFishWonder · 01/04/2013 16:09

I had to call 111 last night as was concerned DS (2 years) was going down with an ear infection, temperature, complaining of ear hurting, very upset etc. what irritated me more than anything was the fact the call centre person could not understand me and I could not decipher what she was saying at all. the whole thing took nearly an hour, I was then promised someone would ring back within 6 hours. I am all for equality and diversity but do think people taking these calls should be able to understand english and be unstandable on the phone.
the series of questions was ridiculous and in no way related to DS's ailment! Luckily Ds improved over the course of the evening and night - this was especially good as no-one actually phoned us back! DS ok today on calpol and quiet rest and I will take him to my own Dr tomorrow. If he had been any worse after my experience I would have bypassed the 111 service and taken him to a&e, which is the absolute thing they are trying to avoid.
Got to say i wasn't impressed at all.

Kiriwawa · 01/04/2013 15:58

Jaywall: I haven't read your very long posts in a great deal of detail but this: "Before, every area of the country had their own OOH + NHSD, all of them needing enough staff to fulfill required services. Whereas with 111 your initial call can be answered by regional centres or national centres, in fact anywhere."

is factually incorrect.

NHSD was a national service, staffed nationally, meaning that if a service fell over or was experiencing excess demand, calls could be diverted to other call centres (or even nurses working from home).

111 has been locally commissioned so it depends what back up the local provider (in many cases private) has in place.

111 is cheaper than NHSD because it's being staffed by monkeys rather than nurses. While I agree that it's great that 111 can make direct referrals to OOH services, there's no reason that couldn't have been done with NHSD. The only reason the government has got rid of NHSD is because it is expensive - this way, the cost is pushed out of a central government overhead and down to regional healthcare budgets. Some commissioners have opted to have bolt ons to the basic service, some haven't, meaning that the functionality of 111 will differ between areas of England.

The ambulance services that already complain about NHSD advising people to call an ambulance for minor ailments (on the basis that they err on the side of caution) aren't going to know what's hit them over the next few months. This is a poorly thought through cost-saving exercise, however it's dressed up.

Fairylea · 01/04/2013 14:45

I suspect a lot of people will go straight to A and E rather than take the risk of ringing 111 and not getting any help or having a long wait, particularly parents who are worried it might be something serious but aren't sure.

A and e will suffer massive floods of people turning up for all sorts.

I doubt overall 111 will save any money when you look at it like that.

And of course waiting times in a and e will become longer as a result.

Wheresmycaffeinedrip · 01/04/2013 13:59

Well I just had to use this service as dd1s infection is spreading. The lady was very nice but I did have to go through all "the safety questions" despite already having answered yes to is she conscious and breathing . It does seem a bit like what you say doesn't matter as they have to ask set questions and don't deviate whatever u say.

Perfectly pleasant person manning phone but alot of time wated on irrelevant stuff (irrelevant in this case)

NillyNolly · 01/04/2013 12:06

I had to call again yesterday (same story) then again today. Today was slightly better, I got through quickly to a guy who didn't run through the script (hope he doesn't lose his job), simply asked what DS was doing (watching tv) and how he seemed. He gave us a doctors appointment and that was that.

Perhaps they should have a common sense/aptitude test as a prerequisite for the job?

OP posts:
Hawkmoth · 01/04/2013 11:04

Same resources? Unlikely. Using a non clinical algorithm makes it more risk averse than clinical triage models used previously, therefore more people will be referred to see doctors, attend A&E or 999. Which, of course, is safer, but it will cost the health economy more.

jojo2013 · 01/04/2013 01:45

The ohd service is a joke, at least the 111 device tries to filter out and prioritise what is more urgent and what can wait, 99% of the time the ohd will not come to your house, my partner has heart problems and is always told to drive to the local hospital 15 miles away....FYI I don't drive and have 3 kids at home.

jaywall · 01/04/2013 01:34

Why do you think they will continue to fail ?
Where you around when NHSDirect started to take calls? that didn't go well at first but after sorting the teething problems and getting the right staffing it was a resounding success.

This is NHSDirect as it would have been if invented in 2013. I fully agree its not good right now, but the scope of what it is able to do, with the same resources is a huge improvement.

I don't want to be disingenuous but seriously why should'nt we take advantage of new technologies? why shouldn't we invest our taxes in moving with the times and utilising the things that other industries take for granted ?

The local OOH services have for the most part not gone anywhere, all the doctors and nurses are still employed doing mostly the same thing, the only thing thats changed is the front end, the services are all still there.

jojo2013 · 01/04/2013 01:30

Can clearly say I had to phone 111 they were courteous and passed me straight onto a practioner who went through my partners symptoms, they were concerned they wanted me to talk to an ooh doctor, now thats where the problem. Was......6 hours later a doctor called only to say could you pop into the surgery 4 hours later, now fully exhausted I saw him to be told your own GP knows more about your partner, can you see him SHAMBLES!!!!
What is it with this uncaring government? Angry

rubytubeytubes · 01/04/2013 01:16

Unfortunately jaywalk that isn't actually happening though is it? Lots of promises there but when will that happen?

In my area it failed in the first two hours. Our local OOH service is very good and highly rated because it is staffed by well qualified local clinicians Who can advise on local services/ pharmacies/shops to buy meds from.

Lots of nurses left the ooh as they didnt want to work for 111 only to be asked to come back and help in that two hour period, they gave up their own time to ensure services for patients continued.

I think the system will continue to fail and in a few years local OOH services will be brought back!

jaywall · 01/04/2013 01:02

A little 101 about 111

Previously with the OOH set up what you had was every area of the country was covered by an OOH service + NHS Direct. Some of these OOH services were small, some were large and they ALL did things differently. You as a user could call either NHSD or your local OOH service or go direct to your hospital.

Also, many people had no idea an OOH service existed let alone the phone number for it. And i happen to know that is the case for a large number of people in this country, unless you had needed to know you probably didn't.

So 111 was dreamt up, a national number that can be utilised in so many dreamy ways. It will free up 999 operators, it can be mapped anywhere and in any way. And it fits right in with drop in centres, walk in centres, the expanding emergency dental requirements and even all the current OOH services as it can link in with any IT system able to communicate via existing standards for information interchange.
It also means every health service in the country can make themselves available, or unavailable in just one place that everyone with an interest can access. They can list what they are equipped to deal with and update this and have it known by anyone looking for that service immediately.

And it can provide a better service for less cost...it really actually can. Before, every area of the country had their own OOH + NHSD, all of them needing enough staff to fulfill required services. Whereas with 111 your initial call can be answered by regional centres or national centres, in fact anywhere. Where an operator can take your call and follow an algorithm which has been designed by a large group of NHS clinicians, and pass your case to the service that best suits your requirements wherever it is in the country. In many cases they can even book you an appointment right there and then anywhere in the country, with details of everything that happened passed automatically on to your GP for their records or action.

It will be a great asset for all of us once the teething problems are dealt with and experience in the systems is built up.

fiverabbits · 31/03/2013 23:59

Does anyone know if this service is in Wales ?

OxfordBags · 31/03/2013 22:52

Tigerbomb, I was very WTF about them sending a car; I think she said something about them usually having some sort of mini van or small ambulance or similar, but to be honest, I was so fucking tired and ill myself and so pissed off that they had woken us up needlessly after the pick-up had been cancelled and we wouldn't have been able to get in anyway, that I wasn't fully taking in what the driver was saying.

Gottalovecosta · 31/03/2013 22:49

It's a disgrace. My mum was unwell last week, in a lot of pain. I ring to ring OOH Dr's, to be put through to 111, who asked me questions about her having a stroke/heart attack that were totally irrelevant. In the end (about 20 mins later) he said he'd get a nurse to ring back, with a wait of up to 2 hours. I just wanted an appt with the OOH Dr! I vocalised this to him and he was very helpful, but seemed surprised we'd actually want to see a Dr. In the end my sister took her to A&E where she was admitted and is still in a ward now a week on.

Pitiful. I read in the local paper A&E visits were up 40% in the first week - it's just going to get worse with such a dreadful service.

Tigerbomb · 31/03/2013 19:55

you get a car come to pick you up with the 111 service?

theodorakisses · 31/03/2013 16:59

What is wrong with being ill and seeing a doctor unless it is all about cost? By all means let a nurse triage the cases but I can't imagine putting my babies life in their hands.

creamteas · 31/03/2013 14:49

Methe not necessarily. 111 went to tender regionally.

In some areas it is the same staff, in others it is call-centre workers with a few weeks training.

For example here

Methe · 31/03/2013 14:22

Kiriwawa

"And 111 is not the same as NHS Direct - there were nurses on the other end of the phone there. 111 is staffed by people who have been trained in what they call the algorithm (what the rest of the world would call a decision tree) BUT HAVE NO MEDICAL TRAINING."

Sorry but that's just no correct. There are nurses... The same nurses, the same staff, using the same system.

OxfordBags · 31/03/2013 14:21

I had to ring 111 this week, and was shocked and annoyed at how crap it was. Ds was ill in the small hours and I was exhausted and ill myself. Took ages to get through and then they kept asking for all sorts of trivial details I couldn't give off the top of my head (no, I don't fucking know the postcode of my GP's surgery at 2am, FFS, and how does it help my child right now?!). Then, without allowing me to explain anything about the situation, they went through the meningitis symptom check. Now, this is v important, but I knew it wasn't that. Then, when I did try to explain his problems, they kept shutting me up, saying they'd grasped it, when they did not have all the details, and again, kept asking me meningitis-symptom questions in relation to the facts I was allowed to give them.

I waited ages for a phone back and when they did, they had my son's age wrong by 10 yrs, and kept calling him by the first part of his double-barrelled surname instead of his first name. They just said I had to take him to an assessment centre and would send a car. I pointed out that his problem was due to an illness affecting him only as he slept, so that it was fairly pointless to have him seen when he was awake and not displaying the problem, and I just needed some advice over the phone. The nurse cursed under her breath, then I was passed onto another woman who yelled at me and told me I'd be 'no better than a child abuser' if I didn't get him seen. It was like they had some sort of 'enforcer' on hand!

I put the phone down on her and rang 111 to make a complaint. Within 20 mins, two nurses rang to apologise and the first one gave me the actually very simple (which I didn't realise when I rang) advice and reassurance. The car to take us to the centre did arrive anyway, at 4am, and there was no child seat in it, so would've been useless anyway.

Not impressed.

toboldlygo · 31/03/2013 14:15

It doesn't go live here on Monday, we've been asked to take the service back for a few weeks as 111 collapsed on day two of the pilot. And yes, it's extremely busy this weekend, only second to Boxing Day.

A great majority of the calls last night weren't the slightest bit urgent, coughs and colds of several days duration or prescriptions running out but they wait until a bank holiday weekend to try and contact a GP... Angry

Worth it for the few urgents (and, of course, all the above received a timely call back with advice anyway). And I'm infinitely more confident in our ability to handle the volume as compared to 111, despite having made a percentage of the call handling staff redundant as a result of the supposed launch. I should point out that our call handlers are also not medically trained, except in being able to spot things that require a 999 response and basic triage into urgent/non urgent categories - the difference is that we have an array of local GPs sat next to us and at any point we can snag them for advice on how to proceed or even transfer the patient straight through to them if necessary. This will not be possible with 111.

VicsterB · 31/03/2013 13:41

I called 111 last Friday and was in a queue for maybe 5 minutes before I got through. My main hope is that they sort out the queuing system. Useful to have an estimated time till answer or an option to be called back when you're at the front of the queue. Anyway the service seemed pretty similar to NHSDirect once I did get through. I would imagine they would have the same model for service. Perhaps slightly less compassion from the person I spoke to, compared with my memories of NHSDirect, but I guess they're under stress with a queue of callers. Hope the service improves for us all quickly as we could really use a service we can trust when we're in panic or ill ourselves!

ItsOkayItsJustMyBreath · 31/03/2013 03:54

I called 111 tonight and was impressed with the service and the speed in which the OOH doctor called (about 15 mins I think). However, I also called NHSD last spring for DS and they were great too so not sure, but have my suspicions, why they have changed it.