Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the NHS Mental Health Services are USELESS?

136 replies

TeenTwinsToddlerandTiaras · 15/01/2013 13:02

I have been involved with them now for 6 years due to suffering from OCD, extreme anxiety and depression. I swear that I got worse since being involved with them in addition to the stigma and feeling of worthlessness that being diagnosed with a mental health 'illness' brings.

I went for my 2nd follow up appointment in 6 months with an NHS psychiatrist yesterday and I told him that I did not want any more involvement with them as I could manage without their 'help' and I was told that they would not discharge me from their services as they were not convinced I was better Hmm. They have had no involvement with me for 6 months since they threatened me with SS and I have never even seen that psychiatrist before! He insisted that I take a CRISIS card with the emergency helpline no. on even though I said I did not need it and never have.

I have been told that as I refused pills (tried them and they made me feel worse) I obviously did not want to get better and must be attention seeking Hmm, threatened with social services as being a risk to my children even though the nature of my 'illness' means that I am probably the least likely type of person to harm anyone which has been very well documented (I did get an apology but that still put me in a headspin), told that I would have to live with this for the rest of my life and must learn to 'manage' with it (that took me to the brink I must say).

I was absolutely no closer to getting better until I had the good luck to find myself a good counsellor a few months back, after trying a few duds, who taught me to empathise with myself rather than continuously beat myself up all the time for my failure to get better so exacerbating it. In fact she told me that rather than being mentally 'ill' I was reacting to my experiences and the mess that I had become was totally understandable and even normal as I have been in pain and I had to heal that before anything else would help.

Childhood trauma and abuse, the death of a child and the serious illness of another, the loss of a home and financial security were the cause of my 'illness' and it has been a complete nightmare but I am glad to say the tide is now slowly turning and my terrified brain is starting to calm down Grin but I really feel the NHS offered me nothing but tried to force pills down my throat and a short course of ineffectual CBT which did not even scratch the surface. Has anyone else found this to be the case?

OP posts:
BunFagFreddie · 15/01/2013 19:25

I'm lucky to have a really good GP who I check in whith once a month, but the mental health services do try to get you off their books asap. I was diagnosed with bipolar, so it's not as though I'm cured.

CBT was useless for me. They should give people NLP instead. I've paid to have it privately and will do again. It's 100x more effective imo.

Varya · 15/01/2013 19:20

Yes the NHS MH services are indeed underfunded and therefore useless. No support at all from MHS you just have to cope somehow, alone.

TinyDancingHoofer · 15/01/2013 19:16

YABU.

SirBoobAlot · 15/01/2013 17:30

Doyouthink can I just say a big thank you? Thanks I wouldn't be alive today if it hadn't been for the wonderful work of some amazing people within the mental health team.

So for all you do, and for all you will continue to do. Thank you. x

BunFagFreddie · 15/01/2013 17:20

I've had a very positive experience, but I think it depends on where you live and who you deal with. It shouldn't be that way though. Sorry to hear that so many people have had a rough time, some of the CPN's and psychiatrists sound very unprofessional.

raininginbaltimore · 15/01/2013 17:11

I've had some poor service, but in the last year the mental health service, specifically the perinatal team saved my life. I was an inpatient at a Mother and Baby unit. They were wonderful. And my CPN is wonderful.

LadyBeagleEyes · 15/01/2013 17:05

Because it didn't work for you doesn't mean it wouldn't for others, you can't generalise like that.
A thread like this may put people who are reading this off, who really need the help of MHS.
I've been on Ads for a long time, and also had psychiatric help many years ago. It helped me.

HeartsTrumpDiamonds · 15/01/2013 17:04

Doyouthinktheysaurus it really is a thankless job and some of the things you have to put up with... I was extremely manic when I was admitted, for some reason took against my nurse, and the verbal abuse I hurled at her was awful. I hate remembering that, that I did that, treated another human being that way. I apologised when I was more myself again (took a few weeks) but I still feel bad about it. It's pretty relentless for you. Hats off.

HeartsTrumpDiamonds · 15/01/2013 17:01

Fluffy nice to see you!

Definitely a postcode lottery. My NHS care was good for me, exactly what I needed at the time, (crisis team, 8 weeks in hospital, 2 or 3 years follow up with the CMHT, finally discharged over a year ago, I go to my GP for my meds which get reviewed once a year now) supplemented before and after by a private counsellor who also helped me immensely. CBT worked for me for my anxiety disorder, but it was a looooong process, certainly not the 6 sessions offered by the NHS. More like 100 sessions at a guess.

However since I was in hospital, they have closed both units where I was. No idea what the poor souls are supposed to do now.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 16:58

Not a throw-away comment, my sister has been an inpatient many times and the hospital has failed to keep her safe. There have been numerous complaints upheld against the unit (including sexual abuse) and it is now to close.

I'm sure some individuals do a great job. Just unfortunate that I am yet to come across any.

Doyouthinktheysaurus · 15/01/2013 16:55

YABU to generalise in that manner. Like everything, the quality of the service varies and with NHS cutbacks, resources are very limited.

I am a Mental Health Nurse working in an in-patient unit and we all work extremely hard for our patients. Throw away comments about there being lots of suicides in hospital make me bristle because we work so fucking hard to maintain patients safety, it's a never ending, thankless challenge! I have been involved in an incident where a patient died and I will carry that with me until the day I die. I was in no way responsible but it feels like shit and never leaves you.

I acknowledge that resources are very limited and we are limited by what services are available but certainly on my ward we all do our absolute best to ensure patients get the support and help they need.

The service as a whole is underfunded ultimately, just like the rest of the NHS.....

Binkyridesagain · 15/01/2013 16:55

YANBU, DD who has MS was depressed and having suicidal thoughts and had decided when and where it was going to happen, visits to the GP only resulted in prescriptions of AD which had no effect, her medication for MS was causing the depression, the GP refused to accept this, we couldn't see the neurologist to talk about it and the specialist nurses dismissed it as feeling a bit down. It was only when I went to the GP after reading the NICE guidelines and nicely pointing out that I will not be fobbed off that a referral was made to the mental health team, they talked to her once and sent her on her way with 'phone us if you need us'.
She was 17 years old at the time, No one gave a shit.

She became allergic to her medications so thankfully cannot take it and because if her depression can not take any of the other meds designed for MS, however if this was to happen again I would not go any where near the NHS medical health team ever again. I would pay privately.

KatyPeril · 15/01/2013 16:54

YANBU. Kind of I found them utterly appalling until it actually got so bad I had a breakdown in public and got sectioned for the second time. Then once they believed that there was actually something wrong with me, and I wasn't attention seeking, they were very good.

Crawling · 15/01/2013 16:53

I have to say services here are great the only flaw is as someone with a psychotic illness I have a high risk of admittance and the local ward has shut meaning I have to go over a 3 hour trip for the nearest one Sad

shesariver · 15/01/2013 16:52

YANBU saying that is your experience but YABU to believe this is true of all NHS Services. Im a Psychiatric Nurse working in a psychodynamic psychotherapy and I have seen personally how it can help people come to terms with past trauma. I love my job, and for this reason find it very rewarding.

JugglingFromHereToThere · 15/01/2013 16:50

It seems particularly crap if people are being told they (obviously) don't want to get better if they don't comply with XYZ.

People should be given options and they and their experiences (including with treatments) should be respected.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 16:49

Oh and my personal favourite was the (male) CPN who told me that I'd feel a lot better if I just got a boyfriend and had a good shag. Bearing in mind the reasons for my PTSD, which he knew, that was one of the most triggering things to say to me. I needed 14 stitches that night.

manicinsomniac · 15/01/2013 16:43

Pesonally, I find them to be wonderful.

But it probably depends on lots of things.

So, YABU to blanket statement like that but YANBU about your own experience.

MurderOfGoths · 15/01/2013 16:42

"So people who are not a risk to themselves but feel terrible are often left without support."

Not always. I was suicidal and under the care of a crisis team. Who told me to refuse outside help or my son would be taken off me. Which is a great thing to tell a suicidal person.

valiumredhead · 15/01/2013 16:41

Pretty awful ime.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 16:40

Advice when planning suicide by overdose: Flush your pills down the toilet. Crisis team not interested other than to say that. I flushed the pills down my throat instead. Once on medical ward in hospital, junior doctor said 'you won't do something that silly again will you' and left without waiting for an answer.

There are very few inpatient beds in my area and they are desperate not to admit you even though you are a risk to yourself. Although to be honest, there are lots of reports of suicides whilst in the hospital, so I don't think it makes much difference where you are if you are stuck in this postcode.

Fluffydressinggown · 15/01/2013 16:32

My experience has largely been very positive if I am honest. My care has been excellent and there when I need it.

I think the problem is that the teams work on risk not quality of life. So people who are not a risk to themselves but feel terrible are often left without support. I am high risk so I get lots of support. But it shouldn't be like that.

I think the A&E advice you often hear is not very useful. If you go to A&E the crisis team will see you but it can be a long wait, and unless you are a significant risk to yourself they can really only offer distraction and coping strategies. I have had mixed experiences really, sometimes they are not helpful but sometimes they are.

I think one of the problems can be the way people talk to you when you have a mental health problem. I am very well educated but so many people speak to you like you ar thick. Or say things like 'you are a clever girl.so why do you do it?' As if you should know all of the answers!

But I think they do a great job with not enough resources. I am very unwell at the moment and my team worked hard to help me and yesterday when it became apparent I needed an admission it was done quickly and in s very supportive way.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 16:24

YANBU.

Currently stuck in a loop situation because my depression and PTSD won't respond to what the Community Mental Health Team expect, therefore I can't get any other treatment as I obviously don't want to get better.

Just desperate but no-one cares.

PandaOnAPushBike · 15/01/2013 16:16

YANBU

For 25 years I was treated for depression. Counsellors, psychiatrists, psychologists, CBT, psychotherapy, group sessions, every anti-depressant under the sun at varying doses over the years. You name it, I've done it. It made not one iota of difference and I just got worse and worse and worse.

Then my husband took a job abroad. Shortly after arriving I saw the doctor for a repeat prescription. He was Hmm, 'you don't seem depressed to me', and referred me to the hospital for assessment. Assessment took 2 months, full of questionaires, medical tests, meetings with different people with different specialisms. For the first time ever I felt that what these people concluded would be right because I could see how they were looking at the whole picture and leaving no stone unturned.

Turns out I am autistic. Suddenly the past 25+ years made sense and I finally found peace within myself. Although I admit I still feel very angry at all the professionals who completely missed it over the years and the suffering I endured as a result.

MurderOfGoths · 15/01/2013 16:07

YANBU.

I've lost count of the --useless- useful help we've been given. That's if you can even get past the GP into the mental health system. And that's in 4 different areas of the country.

Swipe left for the next trending thread