Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the NHS Mental Health Services are USELESS?

136 replies

TeenTwinsToddlerandTiaras · 15/01/2013 13:02

I have been involved with them now for 6 years due to suffering from OCD, extreme anxiety and depression. I swear that I got worse since being involved with them in addition to the stigma and feeling of worthlessness that being diagnosed with a mental health 'illness' brings.

I went for my 2nd follow up appointment in 6 months with an NHS psychiatrist yesterday and I told him that I did not want any more involvement with them as I could manage without their 'help' and I was told that they would not discharge me from their services as they were not convinced I was better Hmm. They have had no involvement with me for 6 months since they threatened me with SS and I have never even seen that psychiatrist before! He insisted that I take a CRISIS card with the emergency helpline no. on even though I said I did not need it and never have.

I have been told that as I refused pills (tried them and they made me feel worse) I obviously did not want to get better and must be attention seeking Hmm, threatened with social services as being a risk to my children even though the nature of my 'illness' means that I am probably the least likely type of person to harm anyone which has been very well documented (I did get an apology but that still put me in a headspin), told that I would have to live with this for the rest of my life and must learn to 'manage' with it (that took me to the brink I must say).

I was absolutely no closer to getting better until I had the good luck to find myself a good counsellor a few months back, after trying a few duds, who taught me to empathise with myself rather than continuously beat myself up all the time for my failure to get better so exacerbating it. In fact she told me that rather than being mentally 'ill' I was reacting to my experiences and the mess that I had become was totally understandable and even normal as I have been in pain and I had to heal that before anything else would help.

Childhood trauma and abuse, the death of a child and the serious illness of another, the loss of a home and financial security were the cause of my 'illness' and it has been a complete nightmare but I am glad to say the tide is now slowly turning and my terrified brain is starting to calm down Grin but I really feel the NHS offered me nothing but tried to force pills down my throat and a short course of ineffectual CBT which did not even scratch the surface. Has anyone else found this to be the case?

OP posts:
BeyondTheLimitsOfAcceptability · 15/01/2013 21:40

sirboob when you track them down, dont forget to give them my patented lecture on causality Grin

I've had so much trouble with various HCPs that I never dared mention that I thought I may have CFS. "Luckily" it seems that the diagnosis I have recently for psoriatic arthritis covers a lot of what I thought could be symptoms, so maybe it is solved now. Seems a bit weird to me though that they'd rather give me a list of common illnesses (asthma, MH problems, arthritis, fainting - cause unknown, possible fits, migraines) than consider that they are all caused by one thing. But, hey ho, I'm being treated for something now, so its nice to be taken seriously about something... Grin

SirBoobAlot · 15/01/2013 21:25

I'm tempting to track that doctor down and hit him with my ever-increasing-in-size medical notes folder now...

The one that humiliated me in front of a room full of medical students when first ill with ME / CFS was the worst though. She saw "anti depressants" and "self harm" on my record, and that was it, It must be psychosomatic. I was practically bed bound at the time, but she made me walk across the room without my stick, and said to them, "And this is how a psychosomatic illness presents itself". Angry

BunFagFreddie · 15/01/2013 21:15

I think it will get worse, thanks to the bell-ends who voted Conservative.

Is out of order to secretly hope that some of them have breakdowns and find themselves without adequate care? Probably, but they would deserve it.

MurderOfGoths · 15/01/2013 21:07

"The opening lines of one doctor I saw were, "So I gather you have a mental health condition." Well yes, arsehole, I do. Strangely enough, however, I am unfortunately perfectly capable of suffering from more than one illness at a time."

Oh I love that one. If you have a mental health problem it also means that any other illnesses you struggle with will be written off as either caused by your mental illness or imagined due to your mental illness.

2wwmadness · 15/01/2013 20:56

Not read the whole thread. But for different illnesses involving different people in different parts of the country they have been horiffic and without a shadow of a doubt made things worse. It really upsets me and when I wanted to complain to someone I was passed around untill I gave up.

sj2008 · 15/01/2013 20:27

I have been in services for 8 years and have had wonderful support in the community from various professionals. I have had the same cpn throughout and she has saved my life several times. I am currently undergoing cat therapy and my psychologist could not be more caring and supportive. However my treatment as an inpatient has generally been appalling. I have probably had 10-15 admissions lasting between a week and 6 months. During those times I have twice been sexually assaulted, given heroin by another patient, found someone hanging in their room and not been kept safe countless times. These traumatic incidents only now add to my psychological difficulties. But the most upsetting experiences 'inside' have been how staff have spoken to/humiliated me. As I wasn't allowed laces, they confiscated my shoes so I had to go barefoot even when outside. They would routinely empty my bag on the floor to check I didn't have anything I shouldn't. As I have had a very good education and am from a middle class family I have been told over and over I am wasting my life and opportunities and although detained against my will that someone like me shouldn't be in hospital. My experience of inpatient care has caused irreversible damage and so I don't think yabu.

BeyondTheLimitsOfAcceptability · 15/01/2013 20:22

My wonderful lifelong GP died on christmas day :(

BeyondTheLimitsOfAcceptability · 15/01/2013 20:21

My GP was great with mental health, offered to refer to the Psychiatrist early on, and I only took up the offer before christmas. The mental health team (a male counsellor just out of uni and a female nurse who was training in MH) decided that even though a doctor who had known me my whole life had referred me, they didnt think there was anything wrong with me.

I have had depression ongoing for at least four years, and on and off before that. Yet as I have a 9m old baby, they wrote it off as PND. And refused to arrange CBT until I could think of a particular issue that I wanted them to solve. Luckily (ha) I've also recently been diagnosed with a long term health problem, so they also blamed that for my depression. And decided that the episodes my GP was concerned were manic were just how my anxiety was manifesting. Again, they aren't psychiatrists... Hmm

My experience with these two made me concerned that there are way too many MH professionals though of course, maybe just the two I met who dont seem to understand MH problems being an illness rather than something that can be solved by talking about it.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 20:17

I've been in with my GP whilst he was on the phone begging someone from the CMHT to assess me as I'd presented there with suicidal intent and a plan. He was actually begging them. The next morning I got the 'flush your pills' phonecall and that afternoon I was unfortunately discovered after having taken an overdose. I say unfortunately because I'd rather be dead than existing like this.

My sister has BPD and was sectioned and given ECT before we had chance to get a solicitor to challenge the section. She cannot remember her children being born. It made no difference to her BPD. Unfortunately it seems to me that we are still suffering from a 'stab in the dark' methodology in treating mental health issues in a way that would be completely unacceptable for physical conditions.

SirBoobAlot · 15/01/2013 20:13

Tiredemma Shock Sad Angry It's bad enough when members of the public come out with that crap, but when it is professionals...

tiredemma · 15/01/2013 20:09

I went to my own GP a coupe of years ago to get some contraception. He was completely disinterested in me until her realised I was a nurse. He asked which hospital I worked at and when I replied that I was actually a mental health nurse he asked "so what nuthouse do you work at then??"

This is a health professional that will be a 'gatekeeper' for people accessing MH services. How can he do this appropriately with that attitude?

When GP's become the 'fundholders' through the Clinical Commissioning Groups we will see a massive negative impact on people with mental health problems. A survey by Rethink found that just 31% of GP's felt confident to refer to appropriate mental health services compared to 75% for asthma.

SirBoobAlot · 15/01/2013 19:59

I saw a psychologist for a physical health condition the other week - not my normal team - who said to me, "You do realise that there is nothing that can be done for BPD, don't you? You will have this for the rest of your life?".

Thanks. Thanks for that.

And any 'physical' health doctor who sees the words ''Borderline Personality Disorder'' instantly judges you. The opening lines of one doctor I saw were, "So I gather you have a mental health condition." Well yes, arsehole, I do. Strangely enough, however, I am unfortunately perfectly capable of suffering from more than one illness at a time.

I'm lucky my local mental health team offer STEPPS, which I am finding fantastic. Friends with personality disorders in other parts of the country, however, are basically told they are too ill for casual teams, but not ill enough for the severe teams, so are left in limbo.

SminkoPinko · 15/01/2013 19:51

I work in mental health services. I have some amazing, dedicated colleagues in all disciplines who really care and go the extra mile for their clients day in day out. There are some not so good ones too. And the system sometimes utterly sucks. No beds, no access to therapies, high caseloads, no budget to get B&B for people while they wait for housing, etc etc. The threshold for accessing services is enormously high and people who only just squeak in can often access little more than risk-screening followed by discharge to "big society" type services, leaving them feeling utterly short-changed. Ime people with personality disorders and anxiety disorders tend to get a poorer service than those with a psychotic illness in my area. Personality disorder in particular is still a diagnosis of exclusion.:(

MrsBW · 15/01/2013 19:50

BunFagFreddie

Only in my experience which is limited to just me Smile

Examples;

Total misinformation given on drugs prescribed and correct drugs not prescribed resulting in unnecessary deterioration of condition.

Nurses physically obstructing a patient from receiving treatment which has been prescribed by a Doctor (yes, really)

No care coordinator being allocated despite this being in that team's charter (this is important as when my mum relapses there is a 24 hr window to start treatment. After her initial relapse a plan was put in place which we were assured would be accessible by everyone concerned ... Which was totally ignored the second time, resulting in a full on flip and her being sectioned. This could have been prevented had someone acted quickly and got her admitted and treated).

I am her next of kin and live 3 hrs away and I can therefore only get updates from the hospital over the phone mon-thurs. On getting frustrated at never being able to speak to the same person twice, i asked for a single point of contact to speak to in order to get updates on my Mum's progress and was told ...My mum (who was in the middle of an episode) Angry

I could go on.

SirBoobAlot · 15/01/2013 19:50

In our local area, they have always been superb. However half their buildings are being closed this year :( We are also lucky to have a 24hr mental health line, so when the team are closed, there is at least an option. You can only speak to them for a maximum of 20 minutes though!

ArielThePiraticalMermaid · 15/01/2013 19:48

Unfortunately and mystifyingly (given that it costs them so much money) mental health is often not seen as a priority, particularly amongst the over 65s. My dad has been ill lately and when he was discharged, we had to fight for every tiny little thing we were promised when he was in hospital, in terms of home support. Nothing has materialised that the psychiatrist promised.

When he was in hospital however, they were very good - kind, and thorough.

I think it very much depends where you are.

tiredemma · 15/01/2013 19:47

Mental illness contributes to 23% of overall disease burden in the uk, compared to 16% of both cancer and cardiovascular disease. Yet only receives about 12% funding.

This explains why services are woefully inadequate in parts.

I work in mental health. I know that the team I work with deliver the best possible care with the resources we have.

Somebodysomewhere · 15/01/2013 19:43

Depends.

My GP gave me a repeat prescription for ADs about a year ago. I havent seen anyone since. This suits me fine but i do wonder about others who might need support.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 19:42

Well, crisis team's response to a crisis was 'flush you pills down the toilet' so to be honest I doubt that them working 24 hours would make a difference. As you can see I'm very bitter about the lack of support from the CMHT. They want you off their books one way or another.

DioneTheDiabolist · 15/01/2013 19:41

YANBU. I work for a MH charity and often GPs will refer clients to us rather than put them through the underfunded and often ineffectual services offered by the NHS.

BunFagFreddie · 15/01/2013 19:38

We have a 24 hour number for the crisis team here, there is always someone on call.

I'm about to start group art therapy. I'm clearly very lucky to live where I do, considering my mental health issues.

marjproops · 15/01/2013 19:36

YANBU. been there, done that, useless useless useless. for me AND DC.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 19:36

My GP is stuck because he is only allowed to refer to crisis or CMHT, who then gatekeep all other services. Crisis team stop working at 9pm, so heaven forbid you have a crisis after then. I have also found that in my area I am treated like an idiot because I have mental health issues - as if I can't understand what they are saying to me. CBT is thrown at me even though I have failed at it in the past.

MHS have always been the Cinderella service of the NHS and unfortunately it is only getting worse, ime.

BunFagFreddie · 15/01/2013 19:32

What do you mean by negligence MrsBW? Is it really that bad?

MrsBW · 15/01/2013 19:29

I think that NHS mental health teams must work with huge challenges.

But in my experience (34 years worth), the service now offered doesn't just border on, but crosses the line into negligence... It genuinely frightens me how little support we receive and I have feared for my Mum's life on more than one occasion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread