Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the NHS Mental Health Services are USELESS?

136 replies

TeenTwinsToddlerandTiaras · 15/01/2013 13:02

I have been involved with them now for 6 years due to suffering from OCD, extreme anxiety and depression. I swear that I got worse since being involved with them in addition to the stigma and feeling of worthlessness that being diagnosed with a mental health 'illness' brings.

I went for my 2nd follow up appointment in 6 months with an NHS psychiatrist yesterday and I told him that I did not want any more involvement with them as I could manage without their 'help' and I was told that they would not discharge me from their services as they were not convinced I was better Hmm. They have had no involvement with me for 6 months since they threatened me with SS and I have never even seen that psychiatrist before! He insisted that I take a CRISIS card with the emergency helpline no. on even though I said I did not need it and never have.

I have been told that as I refused pills (tried them and they made me feel worse) I obviously did not want to get better and must be attention seeking Hmm, threatened with social services as being a risk to my children even though the nature of my 'illness' means that I am probably the least likely type of person to harm anyone which has been very well documented (I did get an apology but that still put me in a headspin), told that I would have to live with this for the rest of my life and must learn to 'manage' with it (that took me to the brink I must say).

I was absolutely no closer to getting better until I had the good luck to find myself a good counsellor a few months back, after trying a few duds, who taught me to empathise with myself rather than continuously beat myself up all the time for my failure to get better so exacerbating it. In fact she told me that rather than being mentally 'ill' I was reacting to my experiences and the mess that I had become was totally understandable and even normal as I have been in pain and I had to heal that before anything else would help.

Childhood trauma and abuse, the death of a child and the serious illness of another, the loss of a home and financial security were the cause of my 'illness' and it has been a complete nightmare but I am glad to say the tide is now slowly turning and my terrified brain is starting to calm down Grin but I really feel the NHS offered me nothing but tried to force pills down my throat and a short course of ineffectual CBT which did not even scratch the surface. Has anyone else found this to be the case?

OP posts:
loverofwine · 18/01/2013 20:19

YABU to make such a blanket statement. I don't know the details of your circs so you may get a YANBU for that.

I had the fortune/misfortune to be on a locked ward in Manhattan about 13 yrs ago. I was admitted for being psychotic. I was an inpatient for a week. Whilst I was there I came across people 'choosing' ECT to treat their illness because it was cheaper. Others not taking medication in the past because they couldn't afford it. In my case the insurance my employers had organised just covered my 7 day stay. I was having nothing but anti psychotic meds and monitoring. If I'd been there a day longer would have owed more than £2K.

The NHS is not perfect but we are so lucky to have it. I had brilliant support from the perinatal team after the birth of all my kids. My GP, although restricted in what he can do is great. Not all the interactions I have had with the NHS have been wonderful but the mental health teams I have encountered have been way above the other doctors.

Be grateful for what you have. Cameron and his buddies are working hard to remove it and then people may be choosing the wrong/no treatment just because it is cheaper and not because it is what they need.

thunksheadontable · 18/01/2013 19:47

It is shocking. I have been very lucky to have had 25 CBT sessions. 6 would have done nothing for me.

TempNC, I am disgusted with your story. I really don't know why some of these people work in the sector they do. I have had similar re: abuse... erm, how can the NHS peddle on the one hand the notion that everything we as parents do is of vital importance to the future wellbeing of our children and yet discount the effects our parents' much more heinous actions may have had on us?

There is something so abusive about some man you never met before, who knows you for an infinitesmally small moment of your life suggesting that your feelings and experiences "shouldn't" be. It is disgraceful.

SirBoobAlot · 18/01/2013 19:37

Some of these stories are horrible :(

Am feeling very lucky for the standard of the mental health team around here today.

TempNC · 18/01/2013 19:28

YANBU. When I had a breakdown two years ago I felt the help I received was pitiful. I was actively suicidal and went to my GP telling him that I had made a plan and I needed help, I was sobbing hysterically and in a terrible state. He referred me to the local crisis team who came to my house four hours later and they were utterly useless. I told them I didn't feel safe and that I wanted to die. Their advice? 'How about doing something to take your mind off it like dusting the house for half an hour.' Dusting the house?! I wanted to disappear into oblivion and they're suggesting I get the Pledge out?

To cut a long story short I did attempt to take my own life after they left. After a few days in hospital I was discharged and before long I was begging for help from the crisis team again. My DM was at her wits end and asked if there was any possibility of inpatient treatment - the CPN said: 'Not enough beds and tbh you wouldn't benefit from going to the local mental health unit as a lot of the patients are sex offenders.' Shock

I was put on a waiting list for CBT and was told it could be up to four months before i saw someone. I was also referred to a psychiatrist who was an arrogant shit to put it politely. He went through my history with me and I explained that I had been abused as a child which has affected my whole life. He kept saying: 'Why is that relevant? That happened years ago, it shouldn't affect you now.' I walked out.

I ended up getting help privately, it cost an arm and a leg but it saved my life. I honestly believe that if I had continued to seek help from the NHS I probably wouldn't be here now.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 18/01/2013 19:15

In my PCT the CMHT decide what treatment is appropriate. As I didn't magically get better after 6 counselling sessions, and some CBT, the 'graduate mental health worker' decided that it was because I wasn't trying, and therefore discharged me back to my GP, who can only refer back to them but they say I don't help myself so they can't. Head/brick wall situation.

thunksheadontable · 18/01/2013 19:03

Ambrosia, forgive my language, but who ARE these fuckers? How dare they play with your life like that?? Have you complained? I complained to the Head of CBT for discharging me and I got seen within about two weeks.

thunksheadontable · 18/01/2013 19:02

My GP told me that it would be irresponsible to take antidepressants in pregnancy. This goes against recommendations, but who cares? When I finally made it to secondary services a full 21 weeks later, I was far too freaked out to take the drugs prescribed by the consultant that I desperately needed.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 18/01/2013 18:33

It's all shit. 4 years and I can't see a psychiatrist because some 'graduate mental health worker' thinks I don't do enough to help myself, which reinforces my belief that everything is my fault. I truly don't know how to help myself, but hey, I know I don't matter so who fucking cares?

SminkoPinko · 18/01/2013 18:22

That's awful, Youwiththeface. It sounds like you didn't get as far as secondary mental health services though if everything was done through your useless GP surgery. (Unless it was a long time ago, in which case the CMHT might still have been the gate keepers into therapy services.) Anyway, really glad you got good therapy privately, though it's v v sad you had to do so.

YouWithTheFace · 18/01/2013 14:59

My experience with NHS Mental Health was deeply upsetting. The GP met me for the first time the day he prescribed me anti-depressants and put me on the waiting list for CBT. When I went back in a few weeks later to say I thought I was having side-effects from the meds (hallucinations, jitteriness, panic), the senior GP didn't look up from her computer once to look at me. She saw the shopping bags I came in with, and said something like, you must be feeling better if you're out shopping! I was out shopping because I was unable to sit down in one place for more than five minutes and was trying to tire myself out. I was hearing inanimate objects singing and was feeling suicidal and reckless, all as a result of the meds! She sent me off on my way, telling me to keep going with them.

My husband stormed in with me the next day and got a THIRD GP to review the meds. We went private from then on. I got a call from the NHS CBT people months later for the first time, when I'd already seen the private psych and CBT people three or four times and was getting better. They were really miffed when I said I'd gone private so I wouldn't kill myself while on the waiting list, which was the truth.

I don't know how anyone gets better mentally in Oxfordshire without private medical insurance.

BrittaPerry · 18/01/2013 00:16

I've had very good people and awful people.

In hospital, I at least couldn't take an overdose etc, but I managed to make myself unconscious for half an hour and have a bump on my forehead the size of a £2 coin. I staggered to the office. (Where all the staff were) to say that I had hurt myself and was worried, and they laughed and said that if I could talk there was no problem. It was safer in there than outside, but it wasn't safe.

Endless patronising twattish doctors.

But I had a wonderful CPN who became like a close friend, she was amazing. I really felt like she was on my side.

I've worked on MH wards too, as a HCA, so I've seen both sides. My mum is making herself ill by throwing her entire life at her job as a MH nurse.

It is basically a lottery. I would always say people should seek help, because you would have to be very very ill (and quite obviously so - I have been caught by the police and let go again in a few hours) to not have the choice to just tell them no if you don't like them. Quite often even a little bit of help is enough to send you towards recovery.

Mosman · 17/01/2013 23:53

That's right across the NHS I'm afraid I worked closely with HCP's who thought they'd grown wings and been awarded a halo just for turning up in the morning. I blame the processes and paperwork but really it's a different job these days, nurses aren't paid to care they are paid to move people through asap

WantsToBeFree · 17/01/2013 18:13

They are quite crap, so no YANBU.

The only people who will say it's fab are those who work for NHS Mental Health Services Grin

thunksheadontable · 17/01/2013 16:44

It does inhibernation and I am not sure I can go back. It is so mechanistic these days and even some of my best colleagues buy far too readily into the idea of their own expertise when so much of what they say is subjective and not at all evidence based. This always drove me nuts but now I can see that actually it can be dangerous.

inhibernation · 16/01/2013 23:04

thunk - that is truly shit! I hope you complain.

When you are a HCP/therapist yourself this kind of thing makes you despair even more.

thunksheadontable · 16/01/2013 21:35

I have had a mixed experience. I have had dealings with the Mother and baby unit for nearly a year now. At 28 weeks pregnant I was convinced my baby would die. I was told it was a shame my referral had been lost (asked for help at five weeks pregnant) and I wouldn't feel better before birth. Got a CPN at 39 weeks pregnant who was about to go on holiday for three weeks. Was given alternate keyworker. At 40 weeks pregnant, I was in a terrible, awful state. Crying nonstop, unable to do anything, had major crisis at consultant appointment and wanted to die. Called unit. No response. No support at all in fact.

CBT referral came through week ds 2 was born. I failed to respond to the letter as was unable to and was discharged. Luckily I complained and the complaint meant I accessed CBT.

CBT has been very useful to me as it has been Mindfulness/ACT based and the therapist is head of service and very good really.

CPN has been destructive. She seems to think meeting me is like catching up on an episode of Eastenders, suggesting I would need to reconsider my marriage as Dh also had anxiety and using awful, depersonalising language about me. They all went on about me disengaging when I missed ONE appointment even though I was attending punctuality for CBT every week and had had upwards of 30 appointments across services in six months due to pregnancy concerns. Was told my concerns about ds2 were all obsessive even when he was actually beginning to fail to thrive quite severely. When I said it was tongue tie, everyone said I needed to trust GP and HV who were not concerned... though I am speech therapist and they never looked in his mouth! He couldn't even drink out of a bottle! Eventually I went private and he did indeed have an 85 per cent tie! He gained a pound a week minimum for the next six weeks, with only the same amount of formula and some first taste solids.

I would have been lost without the CBT because he helped me challenge the learned helplessness I was falling into and helped me see that a perinatal mh issue does not make me incompetent as a mum. Some of the other workers I met at the MBU were kind and insightful and a great help. It is a worry when people think they know you and what motivates you based on seeing you a handful of times though. CPN was just making it up as she went along. She had cheek to mention involving external agencies about ds and his weight issues after I went to doc and he said ds was wasted.... when I was only one chasing it up and showing concern.. she was laughing at my concerns prior to GP involvement! When I tackled her on it she tried to say I was catastrophising her comments... eventually she had to admit she hadn't even read the CBT formulation report. She had no clue about my history or why I was anxious and yet she stood there in front of me telling a colleague I was someone who had a complex about being a perfect patient and the doctor thought I seemed competent and knowledgeable and she had to tell him I was very deceptive and seemed like I knew what I was talking about when I was just being obsessive and unwell. My whole formulation was about my fear of not being believed in a healthcare or other context where others were in power due to experiences of abuse disclosure not being taken seriously!

An OT I met told me her pay grade and how she was just a lowly Band 6 when she supposed I was a Band 7 as we (speech therapists) were better paid. She also told me when I said I was worried about isolation as I can't drive (terrified of being in control of a car, had v scary experiences with my dad trying to scare us by pretending he was going to drive off cliff when drunk/falling asleep at wheel Tec) and she said I could walk the 5 miles into town with my 2 year old and 3 month old while suffering OCD and panic! After all, she was up at five that morning and she had had five kids and never let it stop her going anywhere! Woo hoo for her, eh?

inhibernation · 15/01/2013 23:35

I'm a CPN. I went into work today whilst unwell because my workload is so huge and I didn't want to let patients down who needed reports from me.
All of my colleagues are over capacity on their caseloads. I work part-time and only one third of that is free for direct work with my own patients. The demands by service managers do not in any way reflect the immediacy of the demands from our patients. Betwixt the two I don't think we satisfy either group and worse still run ourselves into the ground trying to deliver

Moominsarescary · 15/01/2013 22:59

Unfortunately it will get worse, they are allready cutting services

Blizzardofbuzzards · 15/01/2013 22:52

Thanks Sirboob, you are lovely.

Sminko I am looking now, having spent a long time trying to argue with management. Too tired now. I wish everyone was educated about MH and they would realise just how common it is to have problems and how it can affect absolutely anyone. Indeed some of the most intelligent, creative, thoughtful and generous people I know have or have had MH problems.

And health service commissioners and politicians need to be told that good quality services just can't be pared down and done on the cheap

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 15/01/2013 22:38

Thank you to all those working in Mental Health who do care and try their best to help. I'm glad that services are not universally poor.

SminkoPinko · 15/01/2013 22:34

Are you looking for other jobs, blizzard? Not every team is like that, even in this terrible age of cuts and targets, I promise. I am so sorry you are having a bad time of it.:(

Stunned and disgusted at some of the stories on this thread.

SirBoobAlot · 15/01/2013 22:23

It was several years ago now... But I can't let it drop. I was sent to a psych unit as a result, and was only released to CAMHS outpatients after I saw a psychiatrist who had suffered from ME / CFS himself. He insisted on my referral to a specialist. I dread to think how long I would have been waiting otherwise.

Blizzard you poor love. A big hug for you. x

Blizzardofbuzzards · 15/01/2013 22:03

Name changed for this. I work in mental health. I am more or less bullied at work because I care about my patients and want to give the best service. But as we are so under resourced, we are told to cut down on how much help we can give, so that targets on waiting times can be met.

I am, myself suffering as a result and don't think I can cope much longer. These experiences make me feel ashamed and demoralised. No-one cares about mental health compared to other illnesses.

pixwix · 15/01/2013 21:53

Sir boobalot that is truly awful Sad

I've generally found em pretty good - I've had admissions, ECT, antipsychotics etc, and with the odd exception found them really helpful over the years. I tend to go for years absolutely fine without any meds/support, then get really ill, need lots of input for a year or so, and then am gradually myself again. I did have a brilliant CPN though - she was ace! great at crisis management, helping me along, making me feel heard, and as I was getting better, helping me to get there with support and encouragement along the way.

One thing I have noticed though - is that the individuals in MH are great - but the services have seriously deteriorated over the last few years.

Like for admission, you have to be so so sick, and when you are admitted, the environment doesn't have time to be in anyway therapeutic, as it's busy coping with really disturbed people due to absolute desperate admission policies when people are really really ill. There is such a lack of beds, meaningful OT, and when you get out, the crisis team is so overstretched..

Having said that - I've found the individual people in it, with the odd exception- remarkable and helpful.

I've been well for a few years now, no meds, no input, and back at work as a HCP -touch wood!

MurderOfGoths · 15/01/2013 21:43

SirBoob I am fuming on your behalf.