Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the NHS Mental Health Services are USELESS?

136 replies

TeenTwinsToddlerandTiaras · 15/01/2013 13:02

I have been involved with them now for 6 years due to suffering from OCD, extreme anxiety and depression. I swear that I got worse since being involved with them in addition to the stigma and feeling of worthlessness that being diagnosed with a mental health 'illness' brings.

I went for my 2nd follow up appointment in 6 months with an NHS psychiatrist yesterday and I told him that I did not want any more involvement with them as I could manage without their 'help' and I was told that they would not discharge me from their services as they were not convinced I was better Hmm. They have had no involvement with me for 6 months since they threatened me with SS and I have never even seen that psychiatrist before! He insisted that I take a CRISIS card with the emergency helpline no. on even though I said I did not need it and never have.

I have been told that as I refused pills (tried them and they made me feel worse) I obviously did not want to get better and must be attention seeking Hmm, threatened with social services as being a risk to my children even though the nature of my 'illness' means that I am probably the least likely type of person to harm anyone which has been very well documented (I did get an apology but that still put me in a headspin), told that I would have to live with this for the rest of my life and must learn to 'manage' with it (that took me to the brink I must say).

I was absolutely no closer to getting better until I had the good luck to find myself a good counsellor a few months back, after trying a few duds, who taught me to empathise with myself rather than continuously beat myself up all the time for my failure to get better so exacerbating it. In fact she told me that rather than being mentally 'ill' I was reacting to my experiences and the mess that I had become was totally understandable and even normal as I have been in pain and I had to heal that before anything else would help.

Childhood trauma and abuse, the death of a child and the serious illness of another, the loss of a home and financial security were the cause of my 'illness' and it has been a complete nightmare but I am glad to say the tide is now slowly turning and my terrified brain is starting to calm down Grin but I really feel the NHS offered me nothing but tried to force pills down my throat and a short course of ineffectual CBT which did not even scratch the surface. Has anyone else found this to be the case?

OP posts:
GameSetAndMatch · 24/06/2013 17:52

YANBU. I find I am worse since their 'help'. they've made me feel like I am a mental case who should be in a ''nuthouse'', that I am useless, and that I am beyond help for my various medical ailments.

and same for my offspring. It has left me more stressed than ever.

I have found that at the end of the day, the saying ''if you want something done, do it yourself'' applies.

I am not saying all are bad, it does have a lot to do with spending cuts/ resources/staffing etc but still, it is a vitally important service and should be recognised as such.

GreenPetal94 · 24/06/2013 17:40

Actually I'd say the NHS Mental Health services are pretty good. I've just been discharged from psychiatry after 14 years and 3 hospital admissions for bipolar. The staff I've met have been good and bad, but generally very good. In retrospect I was only ever in hospital when I needed to be, I just didn't see it that way at the time. The psychiatrist I saw for many years as an outpatient took me on when I complained about the house officers always changing. He said he would keep seeing me til I was better. And he stuck to that and 10 years later I'm very well (on meds).

The worst person I ever say was a private counsellor, she was obsessed with my relationship with my mother (which was actually very good).

x2boys · 24/06/2013 16:55

well I am a psychiatric nurse on a psychiatric intensive care unit I admit they are cutting resources but I think this is down to managers they just love wasting money I have to say I think we mange people with acute mental illness very well with increasingly limited staff however when it comes to anything else there are not the resources blame the managers one ward I worked on was completley revamped at the cost of 100,s of thousand only to be shut down 5 years later to be turned into a mixed ward and completely revamped again!

OnIlkelyMoorBahtat · 24/06/2013 09:23

Unfortunately - and shockingly - mental health spend is about 4% of the NHS budget, and this is unlikely to change any time soon.

4%!!! Angry

Sallystyle · 24/06/2013 08:13

Oh and we have pushed and pushed for a CPN for my husband but apparently there just isn't enough of them now so he can't have one. He lost his when we had to move.

He really wants a CPN, it takes a lot of pressure off me too because they can also help recognise when he needs med adjustments way before I can. Of course he is great at managing his own illness but he is often the last one to know that he is going downhill and a CPN can help catch it so much earlier so the crisis team doesn't have to become involved. But nope.. not enough in my area.

Sallystyle · 24/06/2013 08:10

YES they are awful.

CAMHS are awful too.

My husband has bi-polar and I have OCD. They are stretched so thin. However, I cannot speak highly enough of the Crisis team though. They have been amazing, but they only come in emergencies for a week or two.

I ended up going to hypnotherapy for my OCD and health anxiety, it was £40 a session and I had around 15 but it was worth every penny. If you want more details feel free to PM me.

I hope you feel much better soon Flowers

cory · 24/06/2013 08:09

Afraid we have had the completely opposite experience, OP: CAHMS have been brilliant with dd. It is still taking a long time though and she has had to be prepared to tell them when something isn't working.

Answering your post on that thread, Elle.

ElleMcFearsome · 24/06/2013 08:01

YABNU as we're struggling here - CAMHS have said that DD doesn't meet their criteria, as she hasn't yet acted on her strong suicidal feelings. Thread is here I'm wiping out the savings to go private...

attheendoftheday · 24/06/2013 07:49

YABU. You've had a bad experience but you haven't used all services in all areas. I imagine most of the staff are doing their best, very few people really want to make life worse for people who are struggling. Mental health problems are simply not as easy to cure as some physical problems.

BexleyFemale777 · 24/06/2013 01:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

evansthebread · 19/01/2013 02:26

In my experience, no YANBU.

I've been in the system 14 years after an attack caused PTSD. I've had several CPNs and GPs and had varied, but mostly disappointing experiences with them.

There was the CPN who suggested I'd feel better if I went home and drank a bottle of wine (despite knowing I'm on 3 different types of painkillers and 2 types of ADs, as well as other meds that all say NO ALCOHOL). She was also well aware that I have a history of self-harm, most times I'd do it after a few drinks. Then there was the CPN who suggested I take up running as it worked for other patients (I can only assume those patients took a long run off a short pier). I'm permanently on crutches btw. Then there was the GP who told me to pull myself together a month after my dad's suicide and whose wife took her own life not long after that consult - I have often wondered if his attitude contributed to her feeling so bad she had no choice but to do that.

The latest OT keeps banging on about group therapy but I don't feel talking about my most personal feelings in front of a load of people I don't know would help. She started off our first meeting by saying that anything I said would be reported on and if she felt I said anything suspect she'd have me sent in! Way to gain a patient's trust.

Until my late 30s I thought I'd dodged the bullet with regards to the MH problems that run in my family. I'm still traumatised by the experiences I had visiting a relative in a mental hospital when I was a kid. I NEVER want to go in to one of those again. I couldn't visit my brother after his suicide attempt. I've also always thought it strange that the relatives I have that have made attempts or suffered MH problems have been in hospitals but are still here, yet my dad had never seemed depressed before he killed himself. Apparently his uncle did exactly the same thing but it was way before my time.

The last few years have been the worst as far as seeing the CMHT, though. They really could not give a shit around here. They do their job 9-5, M-F and you're stuffed if you need help outside those hours. Even during work hours, the people I've had contact with make it patently obvious I'm nowt but a nuisance. I turn up for my appointments on time (and believe me, with the anxiety-fuelled IBS and fibromyalgia that I suffer with, that's quite an achievement), but am kept waiting at least 20 minutes while they sit around drinking tea and chatting in their staff room. The letter I had after I cancelled 2 appointments due to a chest infection was unbelieveable. I'm a time-waster because I was ill it seems. Though they've had no problem cancelling my appointments at short notice - twice after I'd turned up for them!

I've finally found that I'm better off going to my local MIND for talking therapy. I have a counsellor there that is sympathetic and non-judgemental, but is great in a crisis at talking me down. I even get a cup of tea! The only thing I'd ask of anyone going to MIND is to remember that they're a charity and donations are needed to keep them supporting their clients. If you go, find them good and can afford it, please give them something to help keep it going.

Mosman · 19/01/2013 01:21

is so slow that you're really very ill indeed by the time you get to see someone. Would this be acceptable for a diabetic? A child cancer sufferer?

You'd be surprised. Or maybe not.

M0naLisa · 18/01/2013 21:42

Yes DH was under our local mental health team. His psychiatric worker was a waste of time. DH had to go once a week then once every two weeks then once a month when he started working.
All the bloke talked about how a job in the NHS is brilliant and DH should get a job in that organization :-/ every week it was just about him how he felt and how his job was good with the NHS.

DH did tell him how he felt etc like he was meant too but it always went back to the bloke.

In the end he left the mental health centre and instead of signing DH over to someone else he signed him off as if his depression had gone.
He told DH if he didn't still feel himself and depressed to go back GP for another referral.

Needless to say he didn't he's given up hope because of his CPN and still suffers bouts of depression.

So yes it's utter crap.

MurderOfGoths · 18/01/2013 21:30

"Be grateful for what you have."

I get what you are saying, but at the same time you wouldn't tell someone with a physical health problem (like cancer) to be grateful for intermittent/dangerous care because some countries had none would you?

MurderOfGoths · 18/01/2013 21:28

"My GP told me that it would be irresponsible to take antidepressants in pregnancy."

Oh yes, same here. When I eventually saw my consultant and told her I'd stopped taking my antidepressants she was not impressed!

OpenMouthInsertCake · 18/01/2013 21:22

I've started to type out a reply a few times now and erased it because I honestly do not know what to say. I am so, so sorry that so many of you have had these experiences. This thread is a real eye opener. I've had shit treatment from GPs (PND/painkiller addiction went untreated after a junior doctor told me to just get out twice a day with the baby and I'd be fine) but I've been lucky enough to not need the more serious services AND also to get better enough on my own.

coldinthesun · 18/01/2013 21:17

Just because its shitter somewhere else doesn't mean its not shit and we don't deserve better in a 1st world country.

I've needed an emergency assessment in the past. Out of hours. There was 1 social worker on call to serve a population of well over 100,000. This social worker had been on duty since 6am. By the time she saw me it was 1am. I'd been waiting since just before 5pm.

So yeah I am going to say NHS mental health is useless. As much for the sake of that woman as much as anyone she serves.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 18/01/2013 21:16

Sorry, you said 'frazzled'.

Ambrosiacreamedrice · 18/01/2013 21:16

loverofwine, my sister had her brain 'fried' as you delicately put it in an NHS hospital against her will. For a condition that it isn't a recommended treatment for, before a solicitor could be engaged to challenge the decision. I'm a socialist and a big defender of the NHS, but NHS mental health services that I have experienced as a patient or family member have been crap. To be told you need a 'good shag' by a CPN to cure PTSD? That's nothing but gross misconduct.

thunksheadontable · 18/01/2013 20:54

I also believe if I hadn't been able to afford private CBT and Mindfulness at that stage of pregnancy, we wouldn't be here right now.

thunksheadontable · 18/01/2013 20:52

I can understand that, but I think it is such a lottery. When I had my intake appointment at 28 weeks pregnant, 22 weeks after referral, the psych basically told me I had severe OCD and it was a shame I wasn't referred earlier (earlier than 6 weeks pregnant, with a perinatal psychiatric disorder?) but I wouldn't feel better before the birth. He would refer to CBT but they didn't prioritise pregnant women and it would be unlikely I would be seen. See ya. I was distraught. I was 100% convinced I or the baby would die in the pregnancy and that if I didn't save us by getting help there was no future. I was also fairly lucky that I had enough support around me for this not to be the end of the road... but god, there were times I was so close to the edge it was unfunny. I would never have presented looking for a crisis team though as I was just so ashamed of how unwell I was... which I now gather is fairly par for the course. I just found it rubbish... I feel I gave them all my trust at the most vulnerable time in my life and they put my and my baby's life at risk.

Corygal · 18/01/2013 20:51

Winelover, I'm glad you're Ok about it, but your point is the same as saying "I so love London because there's more choice in the grocery shops than there is in the camps in Rwanda."

Some comparisons don't mean much. Some are rather tasteless.

Oh, and we pay A LOT OF TAX for the NHS. The US don't.

loverofwine · 18/01/2013 20:44

I agree that nothing is perfect but to me lack of money means complete lack of choice. Agreeing to have your brain frazzled because it is cheap isn't a choice.

In my case I am 'lucky' enough to be sufficiently mental to be designated severe (bipolar) and the services I have received have been good. They are not perfect but after my manhattan experience I am very thankful that I live in the UK not the US.

Corygal · 18/01/2013 20:42

YANBU. To summarise all the proven complaints of inadequate/dangerous treatment on this thread:

  1. My referral for therapy got lost, they forgot to follow up
  2. They gave me the wrong pills
  3. They told me no treatment was available when it was
  4. They failed to refer me to a psychiatrist when I was very ill

Yep, all of them have been done to me too. In varying degrees of danger, too.

What gets me most is that the treatment, if it's not denied to you, is so slow that you're really very ill indeed by the time you get to see someone. Would this be acceptable for a diabetic? A child cancer sufferer?

thunksheadontable · 18/01/2013 20:39

I don't agree loverofwine, and I work in the NHS as well as being a service user. An inconsistent service that offers very little help to a huge number of people does not constitute "luck".

I lost count of the number of parents I worked with who received "family therapy" and "parenting courses" because they presented with children who went on to be diagnosed with developmental delays and disorders such as autism etc. I saw parents told it was their "attachment issues" causing epilepsy etc. At least in the Manhattan situation, people had some choice. In the NHS, if they don't think you are "high risk" enough or have resources to treat you, you get told you don't need services or it's your own fault you are unwell because you are not trying hard enough. Essentially, it is the pracitioner (often with limited training/at graduate level) who is making the choice, often on the basis of a limited assessment.