Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up my sister has shown no interest in being an aunty

83 replies

1500mmania · 23/08/2012 19:35

Hi folks I could do with some mumsnet perspective on this one as it is niggling away at me.

My ds is 11 months now. My sister is not interested in kids, doesn't want them & says herself that she is too selfish to have them etc. I know this but I am still pretty upset that she has shown no real interest in DS.

We live in London and no family close by, my sister lives the closest in Surrey and comes into London approx every fortnight for work but she has never made an attempt to see him/ come across to visit ( we live 4 tube stops from her work). She offered to babysit once but cancelled the next day as she had double booked.

The only time she sees him is when GPs are visiting and then she shows no interest really, holds him for a while and then just chats to GPs and ignores him.

She is my only sister and older than me. I know she's not massively child friendly and a bit self involved but I just thought she would be a tad more interested - is that me just being a mum and wanting people to share in my lovely DS. I know she is busy with a hectic job but she finds time for other people. Maybe she will
be better as he grows up? I can't see it though.

It's really eating away at me now and making me not like my sister very much. Has anyone else experienced similar? Should I say something to her? Or am I ridiculous to think that she was going to change for DS and become a lovely aunty (when I was pregnant there were all these promises of what a wonderful aunty she was going to be!)

Sorry for the long rant!

OP posts:
JeezyPeeps · 24/08/2012 08:03

You chose to be a mum. Your sister had no choice in becoming an aunt.

It's like someone self-building a house. It takes up their entire life for a while, it's all they talk about. It's exhausting. But not everyone wants to know about every stage of its development. They want to go and have a look, tell the owners how lovely it is, and then get on with their lives.

MooseLooseAbootThisHoose · 24/08/2012 07:49

Maybe once he grows up and gets a bit more interesting (sorry!) she will be more involved. Some people just don't really like babies, I don't really have any interest in them (obviously excluding my own).

My dd has a lot of aunties and uncles, some of them have been in love with her from day one and some of them just held her at arms length with a "WTF and I suppost to do with this" look on their faces Grin Now she is 2 and can play/talk they enjoy coming to see her and spending time with her.

I don't think it is something you can force. It is your sister who gets to decide on the relationship that she has with her nephew, not you. I would try not so push it because you will just annoy her.

julieann42 · 24/08/2012 07:45

My DC are teenagers now and my brother has just has his little children! He too wasn't that bothered with children, but did send cards and presses etc! Fast forward to now and after me babysitting several times recently for him , he and GF have said if they had realised how much hard work children were they would have offered,helped out more! But his lack of contact never othered me, I loved looking after my own children but didn't expect anyone else to go Gaga over my babies!

LurkingAndLearningLovesCats · 24/08/2012 07:37

One of my mates truly dislikes kids. I emphasis because I really don't want to say 'she hates kids.' She avoids them at all costs and they make her extremely uncomfortable. Her parents begged her to go to her nephew's first birthday (very close with sister, sister always understood she doesn't like kids) she ended up going because sister applied serious guilt tactics (if dead sibling was alive, he'd want to be at his nephews first birthday...) Friend was very uncomfortable as it was a children's party. She politely said no when her sister asked her to hold the baby and her sister WENT OFF. As in, 'fuck you, you selfish cunt you're just jealous of my life and you're such a fucking bitch I never want to see you again you just hate babies because they remind you of all the guys you fuck you slut.' I cleaned that up too!!
It went on, the sister accused friend of being cruel by not holding the child and said she really hopes she's infertile (not that it matters, she's not having kids but the sentiment is bloody harsh) The father ushered friend out pretty quickly, sister has since apologised but now they have a stiff 'for our parents' relationship. It's sad because they were so close.

I wonder if the sister had stewed and stewed for awhile whilst pretending everything was okay? I CERTAINLY don't think you would EVER treat your sister like this but I mean, it's likely a matter of to what extent she dislikes children. My friend is pretty extreme, she simply will never, ever like children. Where does your sister fall?

bringmesunshine2009 · 24/08/2012 06:54

My brother, who I am not estranged from and with whom there is no family feud has not seen DS2 ever (15mths) not even new baby visit. Saw DS1 on his first BD (purported new baby visit) and never again since (DS1 not far off 3). Basically he is bloody selfish. Extended family is so important, sure don't be interested in babies, but don't disappear off your immediate family member's radar entirely.

sashh · 24/08/2012 05:48

Some people just don't lie babies. Let's face it they don't do much. You can't buy them toys to play with, there are limmited baby clothes, they don't talk, they smell (I know lots of people love baby smell, not everyone does).

Trust me she will get more interested as your dc gets more interesting to her.

TheQueenOfDiamonds · 24/08/2012 04:32

Your DS may be lovely to you. He isn't to everyone else though, especially not people who don't really like children in the first place.

iscream · 24/08/2012 04:20

YABU, because she has already expressed how kids don't interest her. I am sure your ds is adorable and lovable.

ilovesooty · 24/08/2012 00:11

I love my niece to bits but I wasn't remotely interested in her when she was a baby. When she could walk and talk I felt differently.

My sister has never liked other people's children.

scaredycat12 · 23/08/2012 23:16

As someone with no kids... they can be pretty boring until they are able to interact and communicate. I have two goddaughters who are sisters and I sometimes feel guilty that I 'prefer' the elder as I get so much more out of the relationship (the youngest is 8 months). And as someone who will never have children I have learnt to value my freedom and have filled my life with friends and activities. I might not be a parent but that doesn't make my life any less busy than my friends who do have children. Squeezing in time with friends and family gets harder as we all get busier!!!

Muxi - for those struggling to conceive a sibling's child which has a genetic link to them can be far more painful to be around than a child with no genetic link. There is also potentially some sibling rivallry between cousin A and her sister.

StuntGirl · 23/08/2012 23:14

YABU. You know she doesn't like kids. Your special little snowflake is no different I'm afraid.

Mumsyblouse · 23/08/2012 23:01

My brother was initially quite uninterested in my dd's, although polite, bought them a pressie, smiled if presented with them at family do's but no real attempt to build a relationship. This hasn't changed. So, don't depend on her suddenly loving older children, his situation is complex, but nevertheless, it does hurt that they seem to have less interest than anyone else, incuding adults in the family in your offspring. And it does affect how you feel about them, as your children are part of your family, and by being uninterested in them, they are being uninterested in you.

Secondsop, your friend sounds a bit baby obsessed, but, as you will find out yourself, very small babies suck up your time, attention and identity in a very absorbing and not that pleasant way. Your friend may well stop being all PFB about it, and go back to having a more interesting and varied life (you do rather feel like your topics of conversation contract initially because you can hardly leave the house and don't get much time/have concentration for reading the newspaper etc). But this may change, and you may also find yourself sucked in to some extent, though I think you are right that it is good to keep some semblance of self-identity from previously, and I've certainly kept all my friends from pre-children and have things to talk about (mainly their love lives!)

1500mmania · 23/08/2012 22:38

Thanks for the perspective. I know I can't just expect her to change because I've had a baby. Feel bad that I am letting it affect how I feel about her. How good would a rhino be as a nephew! Grin

OP posts:
Biggem · 23/08/2012 22:36

This is how my dad behaves with my DD.
I know he's never been child friendly, he's awkward around kids mostly, I thought he might be a bit different with her opposed to my step sis/bros kids but he is actually worse.
So I feel your pain OP

GrendelsMum · 23/08/2012 21:13

JoanOfArchitrave If my sister had a rhinoceros, I'd be round there like a shot! Much more interesting than a baby.

Bellyjaby · 23/08/2012 20:54

Its a tricky one. I never know what to do with other people's kids, and having my own hasn't really changed that except I'm a little less uncomfy around them.

Yet at least your sister shows some interest. My sister never wanted children but then got told she may never be able to have them. When I got pregnant she acted as if I'd done it to spite her, not that I had its just that I'm older and felt I was running out of time. When DD was born she played the loving aunt in public, whilst all the time having a go at me and complaining how my DD is ruining everything. I pulled contact with her after 3 weeks of it. My sister still complains about how all my parents focus on is their only grandchild, blah blah blah. Its all that she's not the centre of attention any more. Its so sad I think.

InkyBinky · 23/08/2012 20:50

Sorry but I think YABU. Some people just don't engage in babies and find them boring. I don't generally like them that much myself and I have had three of them. She may well become more interested as your DD gets older.

Secondsop · 23/08/2012 20:45

I've been in the position of your sister, but with my oldest friend from childhood. I don't have anything against children (in fact I'm currently pregnant myself) but I found it difficult to handle how, when she had her son a year ago, everything became about him and how marvellous he was and how brilliant it would be for me to meet him and coo over him with her,, and I felt that the other things that had sustained a long friendship had completely fallen away. I appreciated that her life had completely changed, but I didn't understand why, if she valued our friendship, I was expected to be the one to do all the adapting to the fact that her life had changed. She had no interest in anything apart from her son, and I for one can't sustain a friendship based wholly around someone else's son! Her difficulty in seeing beyond her boy can be highlighted by how, after my miscarriage, I asked if I could have some news that WASN'T about her baby son (who was born a week before my miscarriage) and she flatly refused to even attempt it, saying everything revolved around him!

I'm not saying for a moment that you are as extreme; only that there might be a two-way element to what is going on with you and your sister - perhaps she feels that you are only / mainly seeing her now in terms of how she relates to your baby rather than all her other qualities?

HmmThinkingAboutIt · 23/08/2012 20:32

My sister is not interested in kids, doesn't want them & says herself that she is too selfish to have them etc. I know this but I am still pretty upset that she has shown no real interest in DS.

Well there's two possibles you get from that

Either she really isn't interested in kids.

OR

Maybe there is something you don't know - perhaps she can't have kids and saying she has no interest is a defence. Perhaps she doesn't want to get emotionally involved with your child for this reason.

Either way, your son is your son NOT hers. And its up to her how involved/uninvolved she wants to be. You have separate lives to lead. Just because your son is the centre of your universe doesn't mean your sister has any obligation to be a large part of that. She has her own life to lead too.

I have to say, let it go. Back off. If there is an underlying problem issue here, I suspect if she wanted to talk about it with you she would have. Otherwise even if there isn't the more you force this issue, the more you'll end up driving your sister away ultimately. Let her do things in her own time if she wants - which may well be never.

MixedClassBaby · 23/08/2012 20:31

Same as shakey. Only I haven't yet apologised.

Shakey1500 · 23/08/2012 20:16

My sister is 4years older than I and had her children in her early twenties. I was as interested in kids as I was watching paint dry. I babysat a handful of times but never really engaged in my niece and nephew. Fast forward to me being 38 and having my first (and only!) child. I ended up apologising to the hilt for not realising how hard it was and that I should have hepled her out a TON more. Had I realised the value of an afternoons peace I would have been round there like a shot!

Thankfully she hasn't held it against me :) So yes, some people just aren't as interested. Not a fault, just different.

LunaticFringe · 23/08/2012 20:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

joanofarchitrave · 23/08/2012 20:05

If you redid your original post replacing the words 'ds' and 'baby' with 'rhinoceros', would you feel differently about your sister's lack of interest? Your ds is a specialist interest for you. A lot of people really don't like children. Unlike many of them, your sister has been sensible enough not to have her own.

Clearly you both thought that she would adore her nephew from the start, hence her comments during your pregnancy. It wouldn't be unusual for her to think that she would fall madly for the new baby as well. But she didn't. That's absolutely no comment on your fantastic ds - she just doesn't like rhinoceroses and at the moment he is a rhinoceros to her.

I think it would be sensible if you both stopped thinking of her lack of interest in rhinoceroses as 'selfishness'. I was only able to stop being angry with my first husband for not wanting a child when I fully took in that he DIDN'T want a child the way i DID want a child. We both had a right to our opinion and neither of us was wrong or evil.

PrimrosePath · 23/08/2012 19:59

Neither my sister, nor DH sister showed any interest in our children. I think they sent a congratulations card when dd was born, but nothing for ds and certainly no birthday cards over the years.

But, to be honest, I don't take it to heart. Their lives didn't involve children at the time and I don't think they appreciated how much a little interest would mean to us. I suspect that they might make better aunts of older children.

I just think back to when I was younger and my friends had children - i wasn't particularly fascinated with their offspring.

Blistory · 23/08/2012 19:48

Maybe she's picking up on your judgement of her ?

You know she isn't interested in children, you know she's busy and you claim that she's self involved. You chose to have children, she's chosen to remain child free. Each to their own.

Swipe left for the next trending thread