Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for reporting my manager

132 replies

Jillyhere · 26/07/2012 21:34

Advice very much appreciated. I work for an educational establishment. Last month we had a training session on managing students who mis-behave. My manager who i've always suspected was a racist made the following comments "the reason ethnic minorities hang around so much after class is because they know if they return home they will be forced to work in their shops". This was not said as a joke. Indeed, there were fifteen members of staff present, including someone who originated from the West Indies. This individual was rightly upset, hence, my decision to report the manager in question. The fact that he wasn't joking disturbs me even more.

I would like to ask those far clever than me whether or not I was correct in reporting this individual. Deep down, I know this statement is wrong. However, I find myself questioning myself. I'm afraid I am new on here, butr can assure you my concerns are very much genuine. If the matter is dismissed, who can I go to?

OP posts:
Canfitbackinmyjeans · 26/07/2012 23:59

Slobby that's the whole point you can not make assumptions about a person from one sentence. You are then as big a fool as the guy in question. To challenge racism you need to identify it and tackle it with reasoned arguments and factual non emotive statements. It's frustrating that cash and carry and you are showing a lack of intellect in the way you present your argument but by using big word name dropping about "noted" family members and your own well educated career does not add substance to your argument. A real intellect does not need to tell you they are intelligent it's blatantly obvious. Cash and carry IS ranting. They need to factually state their argument without criticising all MNers that is just stupid.

tethersend · 26/07/2012 23:59

Asking someone if they've had chips for dinner may or may not be racist. Perhaps your colleague is making comments about your weight, SoleSource?

The comments in the OP however, are undoubtedly racist. I can't believe anyone thinks they're not; it doesn't mean that the manager goose-steps around the office, it means he made a racist comment which may lead people to believe that he is racist. He may be horrified at the idea of being thought of as racist, or he may not care. Either way, he needs pulling up.

This kind of racism goes unchallenged far too often.

Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:58
Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:57
Slobby · 26/07/2012 23:55

Thanks - I'll rest easy knowing that someone's out their thinking about my tormented life.

Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:54

at Slobby

SoleSource · 26/07/2012 23:54

Slobby I pity you. It must be hell.

Slobby · 26/07/2012 23:53

Come on, I think it's patently obvious what the chap in the op meant.

Canfitbackinmyjeans · 26/07/2012 23:52

I'm anti racist but deal with true racism- ignorance is not the same thing. W

Canfitbackinmyjeans · 26/07/2012 23:51

Slobby you've added corner shop to the guys original comment how can you say you are judging op in a neutral manner you obviously are making assumption about what the guy meant.

Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:50

Have you met my Grandmother? Grin

Yes, Slobby "facetious" is the right word for that particular question - I love that word but can never spell it! I will endeavour to be more like your Dad I think - his gentleness sounds inspiring particularly given what he must have had to overcome to attain his role. Hopefully my kids will be less "emotional" due to the fact there will be less acceptance of fuckwitted racist comments in the future

Well ... one can only hope!

Slobby · 26/07/2012 23:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

Noqontrol · 26/07/2012 23:49

Understood. But still a bit shite.

SoleSource · 26/07/2012 23:48

Telling me what I should deem to be racist are you?

Slobby · 26/07/2012 23:48

I have to admit noqontrol that I was so flabbergasted by it, that I let it slide. I wouldn't report or do anything about it as we are genuinely friends. It's just that sometimes people do make really, really silly comments and it can be quite an eyeopener that attitudes/beliefs/assumptions like that still exist.

Slobby · 26/07/2012 23:46

Because he/she always asks sole if they've have chips for dinner. That's not racist, that's just because the chap is either a shit wind up merchant, thick or completely ignorant.

It's hardly in the same league as stating that an entire ethnicity forcibly puts their children to work in corner shops, but sole seems to think it is, or is attempting to make a facetious point by doing so.

Noqontrol · 26/07/2012 23:45

That is disgusting though slobby, and not something you should have to laugh off. What did you say to your colleagues comment?

Jillyhere · 26/07/2012 23:43

SoleSource. Why do you think your Sikh colleague is racist? Btw, racism is not acceptable in any form.

OP posts:
Slobby · 26/07/2012 23:41

I have no idea cashncarry wtf ethnic friends are! This comment came from a chap who really, really should have known better too, but yet there's still that latent thing in the back of people's minds that everyone conforms to stereotypes and probably sticks to their own - despite them having all the evidence in the world to the contrary. Drives me up the wall, but I'm learning to laugh it off and act like my Dad does Grin

SoleSource · 26/07/2012 23:40

So tomorrow I tell my manager my Sikh colleague is a racist.

Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:36

Yes Jilly - how I would LOVE to be presented with evidence that all or even most ethnic minority parents used their children as unpaid slave labour in their shops.

I must confess to have a chuckle at Slobby's scientist Dad and his polite response to the MP but also to "meeting ethnic friends" - wtf are those??

Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:33
Cashncarry · 26/07/2012 23:31

JillyHere - glad it's been a helpful thread for you. Certainly been an eye opener for me. Grin at "tarmacing" though - very apt!

I should make it clear that perhaps the reaction to my comment is because I used the word racist. Yes, I do believe the comment is racist for the reasons set out in my post where I defined what I believe to be racist. That is quite different from labelling someone racist. As others have said, I don't know the man - you do and you had those sort of vibes from him.

Casual racism is one of my personal bug-bears - as if you hadn't already guessed Wink - so I think you did a good thing and you should be proud of yourself for challenging erroneous assumptions on the basis of race wherever you find them. Did you tell your West Indian colleague what you were going to do? I wonder if he said something himself. I know I wouldn't have even if I was mortally offended - most likely because of the reactions of some of the posters on here. It's one thing defending your position on the internet to a barrage of personal comments - quite another to do it in real life.

Jillyhere · 26/07/2012 23:30

Nice one Cashncarry. The word 'Stereotype' springs to mind. To be fair if the individual in question can back the claim in question up with evidence, then I guess I owe an apology. However, why on earth would someone from France, Germany, Australia etc, be forced to work in a shop?

OP posts:
SoleSource · 26/07/2012 23:30

Being over sensitive as you are cash is not healthy. Face up to your own experiences do not project it on others. but I guess screaming racist about naff all is less scary.