Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 17:24

"Creating a desired gender"?! What a wonderful attitide to have towards having a child!

FreeBirdsFlying · 22/06/2012 17:22

From what I've read about PGD and gender disappointment,one thing always leaps out at me and thats the fantasy lives the people create for their future child based on gender. Mothers and daughters doing girly things,boys being sporty and athletic. Very rarely does fantasy ever fit the reality,so the 'chosen' child will disappoint in some way.

fullofregrets your posts are very strange and in my completly lay view,some counselling or therapy may be required. Opting for a girl due to abuse issues,husband traits etc are shaky reasons as are your weird view of sons. IMVHO

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 17:21

My reference to IVF is In relation to unused frozen embryos - where there was once moral judgement 20 years ago on what happened to them, it is now accepted that it is okay. So perhaps in time, views on PGD will change.

For those of you horrified by this thread, believe me, I am more horrified by what some women are prepared to do...you can now test for a baby's gender at 7 weeks and then choose to keep/not keep the baby.

As someone else said, I see a huge difference in selectively aborting an unwanted gender over creating a desired gender.

And FWIW, it is ridiculous to suggest I don't love my other children or that if I had a DD that I would love her more than my boys? And arguments about whether I am cut out to be a parent or how my boys would feel if they knew we wanted a daughter are silly.

The good thing is, lots of you don't agree with it, so at least if it was legal, the service would not be oversubscribed Grin. Many progresses in science enable us to achieve something beyond what mother nature intended, surely this is just another?

OP posts:
FreckledLeopard · 22/06/2012 17:18

But a parent who honestly believes they would be a better parent to a child of a particular sex, who chooses that sex - how are they different from parents who truly believe that they may or may not be able to cope with a child who has a cleft palate or a club foot (both of which have been given as reasons why a pregnancy has been terminated). I know that the examples I'm giving are extreme, but to me, it's splitting hairs to say that you can choose whether to continue with a pregnancy or not, because of x,y and z, but you can't choose on other grounds.

Nature, in this respect, doesn't really come into it, since any kind of screening, assisted conception etc could surely be argued to be 'unnatural'.

And the argument about self-esteem? Really? There are numerous ways to screw up a child. Not sure that yearning for a particular sex, having a baby of that sex and being a happy and contented parent to that child is necessarily going to be an issue. Having a child that you wish was the opposite sex could be far more detrimental to that child's self-esteem.

LimeLeafLizard · 22/06/2012 17:17

So sorry, playground, not park. My mistake.

Lovecat · 22/06/2012 17:14

In the playground, actually. I was simply offering it up as an example of unrealistic gendered expectations.

Feel free to ignore the rest of my post, though.

LimeLeafLizard · 22/06/2012 17:10

Hey Lovecat please don't judge Mums of 4 boys based on one loon who you met in a park.

LimeLeafLizard · 22/06/2012 17:07

OK, fuzzpig, that is a really good response - you've convinced me! I'm not a fan of nanny state but I am a big fan of Mother Nature.

Lovecat · 22/06/2012 17:06

As someone who has had IVF treatment both unsuccessfully and successfully I can tell the OP that she is out of her tiny mind if she thinks it is that simple.

"IVF Couples" Hmm have no choice at all to which embryo(s) are implanted, the embryologist will choose the healthiest ones with the most chance of successful implantation.

IVF has a low success rate.

The drugs involved in IVF screw you up physically, mentally and emotionally.

YABVU.

And that's before I even get to the 'balancing' of families Angry

Children aren't toys or accessories. I was accosted once by a mother in the playground who has 4 boys who told me quite aggressively that I shouldn't have had a daughter if I was going to dress DD (then a toddler) in denim dungarees, stripey t-shirt and trainers. Apparently I should have had her in a lovely dress with frilly socks and Lelli Kellis and pierced her ears for her, as that's what she dreamed of doing with her DD should she ever have one Hmm. I walked away feeling quite glad that she hadn't had a girl if that was what lay in store for the poor child - what if that little girl had been a tomboy?

As a side note - Worra, where did you get that about Asian families from? DD goes to an all-girls school, something like 75% of her classmates are of Asian origin and every single one of them is a first-born girl (and often an only child).

AGiraffeUnderTheFloorBoards · 22/06/2012 16:59

Some people simply believe that one gender is "better" for their family than another and that's why they want to control it. Surely that has to be wrong?

There's a lot of nonsense and myths stated about boys and girls. Cordelia Fine's book will say it much better than I ever could -

www.amazon.co.uk/Delusions-Gender-Science-Behind-Differences/dp/1848312202/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1340380500&sr=8-1

tiddleypompom · 22/06/2012 16:59

There are some truly disturbing posts on this thread - reading it has made me feel dreadfully sorry for little boys already born and those to come. I have a DS and am pregnant with no 2 and would consider myself incredibly fortunate to have a healthy baby at the end - a brother or sister for DS would be just perfect.

Why the hell would a sister be better?? I have a great relationship with my mum too, fwiw - and a crap one with mil. Christ, I will have to hide this thread before I implode.

grimbletart · 22/06/2012 16:56

I believe that those who are anti one sex or the other should examine whether they are the right people to be parents.

At the best they have pre-conceived ideas of gender roles that may have a lifelong influence on the child they bring up.

At the worst they could be seriously damaging their child's self esteem.

fuzzpig · 22/06/2012 16:55

people should be free as far as possible to make their own decisions, rather than rely on the state to tell them what to do

I agree with that usually but the gender of a child has nothing to do with the state to begin with does it Confused that's just nature. Leaving nature as it is intended to be is nothing like "relying on the state to tell them what to do"

NannyPlumIsMyMum · 22/06/2012 16:54

chocolate IVF couples generally don't pick/choose their embryos to be frozen or used.
That's the embryologists job.
Please don't simplify IVF it is actually a very emotionally , physically and financially exhausting process.

awhistlingwoman · 22/06/2012 16:53

I really don't feel that prenatal screening to check for genetic disorders is in the same league.

Accepting that I would give birth to a child who might live a short and painful life is not comparable to accepting that I might have to give birth to a healthy boy as opposed to the girl that I might have preferred Confused

As to selective reduction, I would be interested to know how many of these are carried out purely for lifestyle reasons as they are, obviously, many, many health risks to both the mother and the babies in a triplet or quad pregnancy.

Thank you limeleaf

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 16:51

There are cpeople I feel sympathy for on this thread. Funnily enough, the one with three healthy dcs isn't one of them.

CailinDana · 22/06/2012 16:50

Limeleaf - how do you know only very few people would do it though? And should it be the preserve of the rich to control their families?

Freckled - it's a question of ethics and the motivation for the choice. Children are aborted due to disabilities or due to multiple pregnancies because the parents honestly feel they wouldn't cope with those prospects. The motivation is entirely different than that of a parent who preselects a child before they're even conceived simply on the basis of preference. It subtly says something about the worth of a child of the opposite gender as it implies that even though a girl or boy would be healthy and cared for they wouldn't be loved or wanted simply because of their gender. Do you see what I'm getting at?

fuzzpig · 22/06/2012 16:48

I'm getting increasingly frustrated at today's society where some people seem to think they should have everything they want.

Well said.

Angelico · 22/06/2012 16:48

I do have sympathy for you OP but the trouble is when we make decisions based on individual reasons you have to multiply those decisions by populations as a whole before you can start measuring impact.

Angelico · 22/06/2012 16:47

YABU because it is impossible to predict the long term consequences of gender selection. There are major issues in countries like China where boys have been preferred over girls, leading to huge 'excess' numbers of young men who cannot find women to marry. Because of this they have a very extended 'youth' which has the potential to lead to major social unrest in the future.

There were a few articles about this a number of years ago, can't find the one I wanted but this one gives the jist.

FreckledLeopard · 22/06/2012 16:42

Cailin - I can see the line of reasoning you're taking, but I suppose, at the stage that science is at, there isn't the ability (AFAIK) to select for characteristics such as IQ, hair type, athletic prowess etc. So it's somewhat irrelevant to say the line must be drawn, if selection bases on other characteristics is just not possible because science hasn't yet advanced enough to do so. If it does become so advanced, then cross that bridge as and when. But to me, if one can choose pre-natal screening, can choose to reduce multiple pregnancies (triplets to singleton, quads to twins) for lifestyle reasons, why can't someone choose the gender of a much-wanted child?

Unbeliever · 22/06/2012 16:41

The systematic abortion/murder of girls in China has led to a real imbalance in the proportion of women in the population. Leave it to nature - slightly more boys conceived because they are not as robust.

rainydaysarebad · 22/06/2012 16:40

But op, couples going through IVF to have a child do that as a last resort to just have a child - it is not the same as choosing the gender of a baby. You're lucky that your body is working properly for you to concieve and hold a pregnancy. I think people should be thankful for the children they have.

LimeLeafLizard · 22/06/2012 16:39

Interesting point Cailin, because no I wouldn't have the same opinion - selecting for skin colour or academic ability is a very unsettling thought.

Just because something should be discouraged doesn't necessarily mean it requires legislation though. If only a very few people did this, I'm not sure how it would affect society as a whole?

How would such a choice affect the child? For better or worse? Not sure how I'd feel if I knew my parents chose me over a boy. I quite like knowing what my name would have been (Henry).

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 16:35

It puzzles me that if I were to make a comment about 'I think boys need........' I would get attacked as 'why are boys a special case-girls can do the same/need the same'- which would lead you to suppose that gender didn't matter, but clearly it does.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread