Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
Socknickingpixie · 22/06/2012 18:27

a gay couple could have a child by using a surogate or a donar either by way of natural conception or insemination if they wanted but its totally not the same thing as gender selection.

and trying to match a doner with your features is still not the same thing its still left to chance as you dont get to firmly pick you get to attempt to find simmerler eye colour ect but its still not messing with cromasones ect to actually pick.neither is ivf
to surgest that these are in anyway the same is offensive disgusting and factually wrong

Socknickingpixie · 22/06/2012 18:20

yabvu.

rather intresting debate but the very thought of it makes me want to be sick not in a icky way but an icy hand of fear round my heart sort of a way.

you may not realise but often things start of as the domain of the rich after they have been around awhile they then tend to become more afordable this means that people who can save up ect and want this will do it,we have apsolutly no way of working out who would who wouldnt so there is no way of knowing how popular it would become.

we have evolution for a reason mother nature provides us with what we need be it girls or be it boys.if we are going to mess with this but only a little bit then how do we choose who is ok to select and who isant?

gender selection may mean different things in different areas some people in some areas may prefer girls some may prefer boys in areas where they use this we know and have evidence that it results in some shocking practices most along the lines of trafficing,abuse,one sex being treated as a commodaty the other as a bind.kidnap infanticide inforced poverty,prostitution, forced abortion and murder and so many human right violations its unbelivable every single country where this is the norm ends up with issues like these it infects every area of day to day life that its like a sick twisted virus. these things become culteral norms that because they become normal get a blind eye turned towards them.at the very least we end up where one gender is valued so much more than the other think tudor england and how little girls were respected by laws ect then think places like china or india or saudi

you may be thinking just along the lines of your perfect family but what happens if it spreads to your street then your town then your country then your up shits creak without a paddle and you have just started a massive downturn in humanity.

there is a reason why lots of hospitals in the uk refuse to state the sex of a child befor 20 weeks in areas where gender related abortions are prevalent.

if it would be the end of the world to become pregnant with the sex you dont want then dont have sex or use contraception and hope to god your other children never realise that you would have prefered it if they were a different gender. children are just children all girls dont like pink and all boys arnt sporty the only thing you can almost say for certain about how they will be is that little boys find it easyer to actually hit you in the face when they wee on you.
i feel very sorry for anyone who would contribute towards this in any way other than serious medical need.

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 18:15

How would a gay couple have a child naturally Confused

OP posts:
CailinDana · 22/06/2012 18:15

Those aren't fair comparisons IMO Chocolate. Having IVF to conceive a child because you can't have one otherwise is not the same as rejecting a particular child because it doesn't have a particular characteristic that you desire.

Choosing gender is a frivolous use of medicine to play god IMO - it's totally unnecessary and just panders to people's prejudices. It crosses a significant ethical line.

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 18:14

You don't know how lucky you are OP. I'm going to hide this thread now as I find your attitude quite upsetting.

OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 22/06/2012 18:14

Shock Shock at you trying to compare gender selection to treatment for a condition like infertility!

The difference is that you are not infertile! You have three beautiful children already FFS!

And couples who use surrogacy or donor sperm or whatever are doing it because they are trying to become parents, not because they want to choose the sex of a child that they could have naturally anyway!

That last post of yours OP is horrendous. I cannot believe that you think it is ok to say that.

Tortington · 22/06/2012 18:14

is there not a cultural issue to consider. There are extremes of certain cultures that just think that girls are inferior

dancingmummy · 22/06/2012 18:13

(I mean to choose for anything other than medical reasons).

EdithWeston · 22/06/2012 18:12

No, I'm not against any of the infertility treatments or parenting arrangements you mention. Sex selection is neither inherent part nor actual purpose of those measures, and I would think it wrong if it became so.

dancingmummy · 22/06/2012 18:11

The ratio of boys:girls (or vice versa) would become horribly unbalanced if we could choose. I would have probably chosen to have "one of each" to experience raising both if I could wave a magic wand, but I have two amazing boys & now I am so glad they are both boys. Choosing your child's gender goes against nature and would have very immediate & negative consequences, in my opinion.

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 18:08

To those who think leave as nature intended, then surely you are against IVF in the first place? Or those who 'choose donor sperm/eggs' to have similar characteristics to the parents? Or gay couples who choose to have surrogate children? Or lesbian mums who use donor sperm? All these things are okay to some people and taboo/morally wrong to others. And selecting a gender is no different - taboo to some and not to others. I don't think it right or fair to accept one use of creating a baby over another. The outcome of all the above is a much loved and treasured child.

OP posts:
lovethesun1 · 22/06/2012 18:05

YABVVU. A child is an individual,not just a boy or a girl. Having watched my gorgeous 1st born be resuscitated at birth, & suffering 2 m/c, I am wholeheartedly of the opinion that ANY child is a gift-sod what sex they are!

Having gone through genetic councelling,the 1 exception I would make is certain conditions that only affect boys/girls. This is a decision being made with future health in mind,not just a parents idea of what a girl/boy will bring them.

BarredfromhavingStella · 22/06/2012 18:03

I just really struggle with it MrsDeVere, clearly Grin

OpenMindedSceptic · 22/06/2012 18:01

... Control over this...

OpenMindedSceptic · 22/06/2012 18:01

Just the thought of gender selection makes me want to vomit. Whatever next? Blue eyed, curly haired babies only? Maybe some 'clever genes' thrown in as well. It is devastating that some people think we should have control

5madthings · 22/06/2012 17:57

i think yabvu, its wrong, babies are a blessing regardless of their gender, and gender selection should only be carried out for medical reasons ie a when a child of a particular sex could have a genetic condtion.

i have 4 boys and then baby no 5 is a girl, well she is a toddler now. when pregnant with no 3 and 4 and at their births we DID get comments from relatives that were 'disappointed' at their arrival! how the FUCK can you be disappointed at the arrival of a fabulous new baby, just because htey have or dont have a penis? i mean seriously. yes its lovely having a dd, purely from my pov as i am enjoying buying girls clothes (tho she still wears her brothes hand me downs and lots of unisex stuff as well) i think that would be the same had i had 4 girls and then a boy.

i get lots of comments on how pleased i must be to finally have a girl etc which i find very rude, particularly when said in front of my sons and i feel an sense of protection towards them when comments are said infront of them.

i consider myself hugely lucky to have got pregnant easily, had easy pregnancies and births and healthy children, its all i could ever hope for.

and having just gone through the process of donating eggs to be used for a couple needing ivf, i cannot understand why you would choose to do that on the basis of a preferred gender, it was very invasive, with injections and a general anasthetic to remove the eggs, i did it as i have been so fortunate i wanted to give someone else that opportunity of having a family and feel honoured to have been able to do so, but to do it to choose gender, well that makes me feel sick tbh.

if you really think you would prefer one gender over another then why are you having a child in the first place? each child is a human being, an individual, their own person right from word go, my 5 all are incredibly different from one another, despite looking very similar, i couldnt imagine life without them or why you would actively attempt to choose the sex, they are who they are, regardless of gender.

OhDoAdmitMrsDeVere · 22/06/2012 17:53

Unfortunately our many cultures and societies see boys as a better bet.
I think ours does tbh. We may get a lot of the surface girly, pink, glitter, pampering parties stuff but when it gets down to the nitty gritty, its a different story.

BarredfromhavingStella · 22/06/2012 17:47

I really don't get the whole boys are better than girls or vice versa-maybe it's because I have one of each flavour? Hmm I can honestly say I didn't give a shit what sex I got either time (& no we didn't find out until the birth), I just knew I was bloody lucky to have had problem free pregnancies & beautiful healthy babies.

Anybody who thinks it's some sort of achievement to manage to get multiples of the same sex really is a bit of a moron.

OhDoAdmitMrsDeVere · 22/06/2012 17:37

I missed a couple of pages out but read most of this thread.
I am really puzzled that the OP seems to think the practice would not be abused or cause gender imbalance because the families who use it would surely have one of the other gender already.

No, no , no NO.

Despite the general perception that boys are the least desirable on MN that is certainly not my experience in RL.

I constantly have to bite my tongue when faced with parents who clearly and openly value boy babies over girls. They make no attempt to hide it. They love their girls but they want a boy and will keep going until they get one.

I am openly congratulated for having four boys, admired even! I would go so far to say envied.

I have noticed a distinct change in attitude towards me on a number of occassions when people find out.

If gender selection became easy in this country I would bet that boys would be the most chosen, not girls.

Look at China with their one child laws. There is such a shortage of females that girls are being kidnapped to provide future brides for the treasured boys!

We mess with this at our peril. Just because we can does not mean that we should

FreeBirdsFlying · 22/06/2012 17:34

In some countries I would have been given the option to abort my DC2 for not being stereotypically perfect,but to me she is perfect because of who she is,not what she is.

awhistlingwoman · 22/06/2012 17:32

freckled that's an interesting point. I don't really know enough about the long term implications of either of the conditions that you mention but I'm erring on the side of thinking that I would consider terminating for those reasons fairly morally suspect. But am quite ill informed, I freely confess.

However, I still don't think that the distinction between
(x) terminating a pregnancy because of a terminal prenatal diagnosis picked up via screening and
(y) terminating a pregnancy because the baby does or does not possess a penis

is hairsplitting. I just can't consider those equally justified but I suppose it is very difficult to decide where precisely to draw the line.

bobbledunk · 22/06/2012 17:32

I can't understand how somebody could purposely get pregnant with the intention of getting an abortion after 18 or so weeks (before that baby is too undeveloped to accurately tell) if they are not the preferred sex. It's a very coldhearted mentality and better if people like that are discouraged from breeding.

What if the scan is wrong and you give birth to another boy, you going to demand the right to post birth termination because it's not what you want?

SnakePlisskensMum · 22/06/2012 17:27

I can only imagine what parents of children with disabilities are thinking about this thread! Gender selection can only be followed by the 'if it's not 'perfect' get rid' type approach.
Of course we want the best for our children and I'm not talking about the parents that have had to make the heartbreaking decision to not go forward with the pregnancy due to conditions that would cause their children pain or a fulfilled life but I can just imagine some people wanting to know that all fingers and toes were there, head is the right size, ears not sticking out too much etc
People can and do live very fulfilling lives with disabilities. It's hard work but not all doom and gloom. Some of the children I know wouldn't have been allowed to have been born and that's a travesty!
Gender selection is not my cup of tea. A friend had IVF eight times until it was successful and then was sooo disappointed it wasn't a boy. I just can't get my head around that.

buttonmoon78 · 22/06/2012 17:26

Not read any of the posts other than OPP so sorry if it's moved on by now.

OP YABVU.

IVF isn't a way of choosing an embryo. The medical team choose the embryos which are healthiest. Not anything to do with their sex at all.

If you start with gender selection then I think it will very soon be a eye colour/height/hair colour etc issue.

I think you would also end up with an uneven balance of girls:boys in some areas. I've personally witnessed the pressure brought to bear on an Indian friend by her PiL when expecting her dc2. Dc1 was a girl. Her SiL had 4 late terminations before conceiving a boy. Sad

Boys and girls are all very different. I've got 2 of each. People tell me how lucky I am to have a 'balanced' family. I usually smile and nod as it's not a big deal.

It makes me sad to think of people only having a baby because they want a girl/boy. It makes me sad to hear people say within earshot of their children that they wished they'd had a boy/girl instead or that they 'should have' been a boy/girl.

Many people struggle to have children at all. I'm grateful for those I have regardless of their sex.

CailinDana · 22/06/2012 17:25

Freckled - there is predictable outcome from having a cleft palate or club foot. They are disabilities that affect the child's life. Being a boy or girl is not a disability. I think people who abort for minor disabilities are being just as unrealistic about parenting as those who choose gender by the way.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.