Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
Northernlurker · 22/06/2012 19:52

Not so excellent - forgot to add some to my running total and it's actually 30 boys to 29 girls - which just makes the point even more firmly Grin Penelope Cruz has one boy btw.

Bit Blush about how little I had to google.........

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 19:49

At least the celebrities appear to have taken my suggestion-which has been ignored-adopt-there are plenty of older DCs available. Problem solved if it bothers you that much.

JenaiMarrHePlaysGuitar · 22/06/2012 19:47

lolol @ Northern's excellent research Grin

Northernlurker · 22/06/2012 19:41

Missed the OP's riposte. Well look - that was some honest advice for me. You will not find a clinic in this country which will carry out your shabby little plan so you might as well forget it. You asked for opinions - that's mine, forget about it, don't try and do it and understand that you're wrong. I'm sorry if that isn't the supportive 'do what's right for you hun' nonsense you hoped for.

whothefuckputthebuntingup · 22/06/2012 19:41

Respect NorthernLurker Grin

whothefuckputthebuntingup · 22/06/2012 19:40

I think I agree with the things wacka and ledkr have said.

Two delicious DS and two wonderful DSS in my life. They have brought much joy, noise and delight to us. I would love to have a DD. None of those princess dreams for me though. I'm way arsey, bossy and tomboy-y still. Any DD of ours, in our household would be feisty.

I would like another one and I'd like a DD as well as dem boys in my life. I'm on the fence and not sure whether I'd ever be able to get my head around it if we could afford of it. I guess our lack of millions will mean I'll never really have to consider it.

Northernlurker · 22/06/2012 19:37

On a lighter note:

Celebrity babies - sex bias?

Madonna
1 girl, 1 boy, 1 adopted boy

Elton John
1 boy

Gwyneth Paltrow
1 girl, 1 boy

Tom Cruise
1 adopted girl, 1 adopted boy, 1 girl

Bruce Willis
4 girls

Meryl Streep
1 boy, 3 girls

Annette Bening
2 boys, 2 girls

Natasha Mcelhone
3 boys

Penelope Cruz

Rachel Weisz
1 boy

Whatserhame from Desperate Housewives
2 girls

Myleene
2 girls

Susan Sarandon
1 girl, 2 boys

Ricahrd Gere
1 boy

Matt Damon
3 girls

Catherine Zeta Jones
1 boy, 1 girl

Johnny Depp
1 boy, 1 girl

Goldie Hawn
2 boys, 1 girl

Gewn Stefani
2 boys

The Beckhams
3 boys, 1 girl

The Olivers
3 girls, 1 boy

Orlando Bloom
1 boy

Sigourney Weaver
1 girl

Julia Roberts
1 girl, 2 boys

Debra Winger
2 boys

Mary Louise Parker
1 boy, 1 adopted girl

I make that:

Adopted - 2 girl, 2 boys

birth children Girls - 29, Boys - 27.

That's honestly a completely random selection. Really suggests to me there is no widespread gender selection going on!

hoodoo12345 · 22/06/2012 19:30

Basically everything exoticfruits said.

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 19:26

It won't be legalised because it treats a DC like a commodity.
The parents get their house, have their perfect wedding and then 'tough luck' they have to put up with nature! It might come to a shock to some that not everything is under their control.

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 19:20

My last post in response to northern lurker.

OP posts:
SoleSource · 22/06/2012 19:19

It should not be made legal. Because of some other cultures wanting boys instead of girls.

OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 22/06/2012 19:19

Because you have the option of having a child without intervention. There are lots of people that aren't that lucky.

For gay or infertile couples, interventions are their only chance of becoming parents. They are in a situation that is a million miles away from being parents to three children already with an easy way to have a fourth if they want.

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 19:19

Please don't tell me what to think or to do.

Ledkr - thank you for your honesty.

OP posts:
exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 19:10

Very rarely does fantasy ever fit the reality,so the 'chosen' child will disappoint in some way.

Very true. There is the assumption that the DD will be your 'best friend' and you will think as one. This is disproved by all the difficult mother/daughter relationships. The DD may take after your MIL and the pair of them get on like a house on fire e.g. my hairdresser has a very difficult relationship with her mother, but gets on fantastically well with her paternal grandmother-who she thinks very wise. The next thing after getting a DD has to be the 'right sort of DD'!
You are less likely to have a good relationship if you have masses of assumptions on how the child comes into the world to fit in with you. Much better to wait and see- than burden the poor child with your expectations.
It is a shame in the affluent west that having a baby is all about 'me'.

Northernlurker · 22/06/2012 19:09

IVF is a hugely invasive process which should be used as an option of last resort for people desperate to become parents. The sucess rate is low, the cost - in every sense - is high.

PGD is a scientific process developed to assist in the birth of children who are not suffering from genetic life limiting conditions.

It's not there to help you 'have' the thing you want. OP - please put these thoughts out of your head. What you want to do, for the purpose you want to do it, is wrong.

Gender disappointment is another matter altogether. We all have dreams for our dcs and if those dreams have to change we may feel a sense of loss. Normal, healthy people will feel that and get the hell over it in due course.

ledkr · 22/06/2012 19:06

Gender selection shouldnt be compared to infertiltity no I agree.

However I never know why people get their knickers in a twist about people wanting the opposite sex of child to the one they already have.

I had 3 boys and love every one of them,we are close and I certainly didnt feel in any way disappointed.

However,I did often wonder what a little girl of mine would look like and if she would have my personality.
I wished that I could look forward to the closeness of a Mum and daughter relationship as id had with my Mum.
I wished I could have passed on some of my feistyness to a dd.

As it happened,against the odds-chemo-I had another baby,a girl. I was delighted,as were the rest of my family,her brothers her grandparents her Dad.
We would have been delighted with a healthy baby but it was exciting to have a different sex and dress her up in pink and choose a girls name.
She has brought us all so much joy and was a real comfort to my Nan in her last few years,sitting with her reading to her or chatting.

I had another girl recently and cant believ how lucky I have been.

Its not such a terrible thing to want what you havent got,we all do it in other areas of life.

There are no gender stereotypes in my house,ds3 was a ballet dancer so its not about that,its just nice if you can to have a son and a daughter.

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 19:05

But why are one set of rules okay for one and not for another.

And yes, my brother and cousin are both gay.

OP posts:
OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 22/06/2012 19:03

How would a gay couple have a child naturally?

They couldn't. That's the point. They don't have an option of having a child naturally. You do, and you should be grateful for that.

SageYourOracle · 22/06/2012 18:58

Medical reasons aside, the fact that someone would choose to go through the discomfort & expense of IVF when they were able to conceive in the good old fashioned way is bonkers.

Totally agree with PP re arguments about pressure felt by any would be child to conform.

There's so much more I could say on this subject but, for now: having a child is a privilege, not a right & the thought that people could actually experience disappointment & grief from having a child of the 'wrong' sex makes my blood boil, to be frank. I know this sounds unsympathetic but, trust me, when your body plays a cruel trick on you & your ovaries run out of eggs & shut up shop before you're even 30 like mine did then you are permitted to feel disappointment & grief.

I do have a DC through egg donation IVF. I could not have given a jot about their sex. I'm just delighted to have been given a chance to be a mummy.

OP- sorry but YABextremelyU!

And I'm not even going to go there with your more recent posts!

FairPhyllis · 22/06/2012 18:53

YAB extremely U and I think somewhat naive to assume that the only reason people would select sex on the basis of balancing a family. Where does this "balancing a family" mindset come from anyway? A family that has only daughters, or only sons isn't defective in some way, you know!

FreckledLeopard Sex selection might not be illegal in the US, but nobody has given any thought to the ethics of it. It is totally unregulated. There is no obligation on doctors to screen out, for example, cases of women being in DV and family abuse situations where they are being pressured to abort female embryos against their will.

Sex selection has been shown to reinforce gender inequality in countries like India and China, with serious potential consequences for social stability. It also sets a precedent for selection of other traits - OP if homosexuality was eventually shown to have a genetic predisposition, would you support a family's choice to abort an embryo that would likely be a gay person?

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 18:49

fuzzpig I am not suggesting that balancing sexes is a medical problem, only reminding people that IVF used to be frowned upon as "meddling with nature" 20 or so years ago and was widely unaccepted. As was gay men fathering their own genetic children through surrogacy (and still is taboo for many). Sex selection is another extension of IVF and is available in many countries. These countries dont have an imbalance in population! You (other posters) can't compare it to the one child policy in china!! This is where babies are terminated/killed. It is entirely different - pgd is carried out with a cluster of cells...no heartbeat...IMO not a baby.

OP posts:
whackamole · 22/06/2012 18:46

I'm really on the fence on this. Personally, I have 3 boys myself and a stepson, I'd love a daughter but I recognise my reasons are purely selfish. to have another child would be very difficult, but the desire is still there.

I think if we could afford it, and could support another child, we would at least consider gender selection - even though the thought makes me uneasy.

comptoir · 22/06/2012 18:39

YANBU, I don't see anything wrong with wanting a balance of the sexes in a family. People get on their high horse, but nobody is forcing it on them. If a couple want to make a choice to have a child of a particular sex it is fine by me. However if we had the sort of culture in the UK where one sex was valued over another, and it would result in overwhelmingly boys, for example, I wouldn't agree. But we are lucky and don't.

fuzzpig · 22/06/2012 18:31

Thanks Lime, it's not often I get told I've convinced anyone of anything! :)

OP I am totally astounded by your comparison. Infertility not a choice, it is a problem. A medical problem that can be treated with invasive and often traumatic procedures.

Being a particular sex is not a medical problem. FFS. You just cannot compare going through IVF for infertility with using PGD.

Unless gender disappointment is now a psychiatric disorder that requires medical intervention (as opposed to counselling), that is Hmm

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 18:29

Where did I say I would prefer my existing children to be a different gender. So many assumptions!

When ds3 was born I was and still am utterly delighted and in love with him. Didn't find out what he was. Love every little bit of him.

I reflect on whether we would like more children. Yes I would. I would love to have a daughter.

It is possible to become pregnant with a girl if I choose to go down the IVF route.

No less love for my boys.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.