Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
helloclitty · 22/06/2012 23:04

Not having read the whole thread, sorry, I would say that we have no idea how nature balances the sexes and therefore we shouldn't intervene.

Only in societies where we accept a healthy child as expected do we start to want to manipulate the sex and as others have said where does this lead?

EveryPicture · 22/06/2012 22:56

I am wondering if the OP has read the recent fiction novel by Peter James "Perfect People".

fuzzpig · 22/06/2012 21:53

I admit to knowing nothing about the details of IVF, but I think the chance of multiple births is much higher, right? So theoretically you could have a girl and choose to select a boy second time round... But then end up with twin boys which would imbalance the perfect family again? (apologies if I've totally misunderstood)

CatholicDad · 22/06/2012 21:51

Yes.

PipFEH · 22/06/2012 21:45

I haven't read all the replies - I expect some of them would make me hopping mad. I will caveat this by saying that I have 2 boys and a girl (girl in the middle), so I can't be certain of how I would feel if I'd had all the same gender but I find the idea of gender selection extremely distasteful. I think of each of my children as a gorgeous, perfect individual and not as a 'girl' or a 'boy'. My boys are incredible - I can't imagine how anyone could possibly be disappointed with a boy, it makes me feel very sad.

Empusa · 22/06/2012 21:43

"If anyone thinks they will have an 'unwanted, second best child' they are not fit to be a parent in the first place."

This ^

fuzzpig · 22/06/2012 21:38

if you can't find joy in the child you get, gender selection is not the problem

YES

fuzzpig · 22/06/2012 21:36

I don't think anyone here is saying that a mild desire for a particular sex is abhorrent. It's fairly natural to lean towards one or the other I'd say as when you imagine yourself with your future child you see them as a boy or girl rather than an androgynous blob. :o Presumably. Plenty of people have said that they wanted a girl and were a bit disappointed at first, etc. That is worlds apart (IMO) from 'grieving' for the other sex or demanding the option to choose, and the idea that they deserve the wanted sex, and going through massive medical intervention in order to get it, and the idea that the 'wrong' sex is intolerable (I am not aiming that at you OP, just summing up what lots of people say)

ScrambledSmegs · 22/06/2012 21:32

I'm very sorry, but Hahahahahahaha!!! Grin at the idea of a daughter being 'for you'!!!!

I was and still am my father's daughter. I get on well with my mum, she's a great woman, but my dad is still the one I really talk with. My DD is going the same way - I know she loves me, but gawd, Daddy is king in her world.

YABSoU - I can't even explain coherently how U! I'll leave it up to the more intelligent posters upthread, and keep having a good old laugh at your OP.

Cabrinha · 22/06/2012 21:31

WTF OP, re IVF couples getting to pick and choose?
Do you know anything about IVF?
I wasn't too happy having to choose IVF in the first place - pumped full of drugs, time off work, strangers sticking cameras into my vagina, an operation - oh and paying £5K for all that too.
But there is no picking and choosing embryos, by the IVF couple.
You pray / cross your fingers / whatever that you'll even get an embryo for your trouble / money.
The choosing, if you're lucky to have a choice, is done by the embryologist.
Our embryologist didn't have to make any choices as we only had two by the end of the process.
I have a wonderful girl. I wanted a boy (for reasons that having a girl has helped me totally overcome). You know what? I'd swap preferred gender for not having to go through the subfertility and IVF and cost.

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 21:26

If anyone thinks they will have an 'unwanted, second best child' they are not fit to be a parent in the first place.

Lambzig · 22/06/2012 21:21

Sorry embryologist - good job I am not one as I cant even spell it!

Lambzig · 22/06/2012 21:19

Having gone through ivf more times than I care to mention myself, I dont think it would be that easy. I am not an embyologist, but hopefully I can explain as far as I understand it.

Each ivf cycle aims to collect between 6-10 eggs (if the numbers go up too high, the quality can go down). Fertilisation is attempted and it is very unusual to get all eggs fertilised, although it does happen. A good result might be 8 eggs collected, 6 fertilised. They then wait for two days to see which if any of these develop and multiply good cells (and would be worth putting back and trying with).

PGD carried out for IVF (usually for health reasons) is done on the fertilised embryos. The embryos are graded and typically for ivf your consultant will put those back that are the highest grade. So you might have 4 embryos that are worth trying with if you were lucky, PGD for gender might lose at least half of those then the remainder (which may not be the higher quality ones) put back. IVF rates in the UK range from an averag of 25% to 50% depending on the clinic. The older you are, the more those rates drop.

Not sure if I have explained this well, but just trying to say, even if you were still in your twenties and super fertile, the ivf/PGD process might knock down your odds a little.

Interesting debate though. I have one DD and am pregnant again and I had my 20 week scan today and found out the gender and feel a bit weird about it. This thread has really helped me get some perspective, so grateful for that.

RubyrooUK · 22/06/2012 21:13

Um, fullofregrets one of your reasons for not wanting a boy is not wanting to be a MIL? Hmm

My MIL is great. She brought up the amazing man I love and no doubt installed in him all the things that make him lovely (he is 50-50 on all domestic stuff or better than me; he loves the fact I'm a brainy nerd and have a good career; he is the most loving dad who has done at least half of all nappy changes etc). So I think: respect, what an incredible human being my MIL created. So what's bad about that relationship?

It took us three years to have DS. I'd have been glad of either sex. Now I have DS, I'd love another child but I just want "them" whoever they might be.

I don't actually think gender selection would make people happier overall. I think if you can't find joy in the child you get, gender selection is not the problem.

soverylucky · 22/06/2012 20:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Mibby · 22/06/2012 20:47

Firstly, YABVU, gender selection for anything other than medical, diease preventing reasons is totally unjustifiable

Secondly It is possible to become pregnant with a girl if I choose to go down the IVF route. why do you think this? We were offered ivf after DHs chemo and it was explicitly stated at the very begining there could be no possibility of sex selection

Thirdly, I think this was asked previously but Ive not seen an answer, what happens if you get a girl who wants short hair, jeans, plays football and is gay? Will she be a disappointment? What if one of your boys is gay? Loves shopping? Will that make him better?

buttonmoon78 · 22/06/2012 20:39

Grin @ quickhide!

Someone upthread mentioned about how people would argue that it should be done because they felt it was affecting their mental health not having the sex of child they wanted. I wonder how long it is before someone actually does that?

After all, a very loose precedent has been set. Plastic surgery is done purely on MH grounds (as it should be for some people), caesarians are done purely on MH grounds (as they should be for some people). If you take the argument to the nth degree then I bet it won't be long before some NHS trust is up before the European Court of Human Rights for not allowing someone the sex of choice.

It's an odd world!

buttonmoon78 · 22/06/2012 20:35

quickhide yes it's true. It was true when I lived in a large city in the W Midlands. They wouldn't tell you the sex of the baby unless you were paying for a private scan. And yes, I know several people who had late terminations because the babies were girls.

Not all doctors respect the stringency of the abortion laws. Especially if they're from the same culture as those wishing to get rid of a girl.

quickhide · 22/06/2012 20:35

So, like, if I've just ALWAYS wanted a child with curly hair, I should be able to use selection techniques to get one too, right? Cos otherwise it's not fair- I mean I've just always pictured us bonding over untangling our hair together, buying frizz-ease together... And I mean don't get me wrong, I love my straight haired kids and all that but I just feel I have the right to parent a curly haired child. Better than bringing any more unwanted straight-haired kids into the world, right?

ophelia275 · 22/06/2012 20:23

I think it should be allowed.

There are so many "unnatural" medical advances which we now take for granted which change the makeup of the population as a whole and demographics and so many things which mess up the ecosystem and so forth. Nature tends to adapt and find its own equilibrium.

I think it is better for people to be able to choose to have the gender they specifically desire rather than bringing an unwanted/second best child into the world or have numerous of a certain gender until they can get their "desired" gender. But it should obviously be at their own cost and not available on the NHS.

Empusa · 22/06/2012 20:20

OP why do you think you need a girl to make your family "balanced"? What do you think you are missing by having boys?

quickhide · 22/06/2012 20:13

Picking up on something that has been mentioned a few times- is there really any truth to the idea that the reason they don't tell you the gender of the baby at the 20 week scan in some areas is because in some cultures (eg Indian) a girl baby would be aborted? This is something I hear a lot in our area but I just can't believe it's true- for one, surely it is incredibly difficult to have an abortion on demand in the UK past 20 weeks to a healthy foetus?

Also, OP YABU- there is so much more to a child than gender. In our family on DH's side all the grandkids are girls- 6 of them! They are each wonderful and unique.

buttonmoon78 · 22/06/2012 20:01

Wine for Northern. I reckon you need a lie down after that!

And OP - don't ask for opinions and then tell people you don't want them. It's not really done, dontcha know?

JenaiMarrHePlaysGuitar · 22/06/2012 20:00

I can't imagine a group that wouldn't be offended by gender selection tbh.

Those of us who believe that the differences between the sexes are, beyond the reproductive bit, minimal.

Those who think boys and girls, men and women have different qualities but see the value in both (and therefore wouldn't want to see an imbalance)

Prolifers

Ummm, pretty much everyone I should think bar the terminally shallow.

GnocchiNineDoors · 22/06/2012 19:55

YABU

Part of knowimg that you are ready for another child is being happy with whatever comes your way.

They could.and should spend the money involved with picking what gender your baby is on working out how to fix the people that are allready here on the planet

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.