Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
saggarmakersbottomknocker · 23/06/2012 12:35

I disagree with gender selection unless for serious genetic conditions.

I think that people have a rose-tinted stereotypical view of what it may be like to have a girl after 2 or more boys or vice versa. I don't get the 'balance the dynamic' thing and agree that it would be the thin edge of a very disagreeable wedge.

From my POV I had a girl after 2 boys; on the outside lovely family dynamics Hmm the reality is that she wasn't the 'perfect girl', has had some serious health issues that threw the dynamic into absolute chaos. So I'd say - be careful what you wish for and get your priorities right. Have a baby to have just that, a baby, whatever gender comes along.

LucieMay · 23/06/2012 12:01

I don't agree with gender selection. You might get a son who is effeminate or gay (not calling all gay men effeminate by the way!) or a daughter who was a tomboy or a lesbian (again not all lesbians are tomboys or vice versa)... or heaven forbid, a transgender child who wanted to change sexes! Accept our children for who they are. When I had DS, his gender was really the least of my troubles! (absent dickhead father/being a single parent etc).

WMittens · 23/06/2012 11:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

5madthings · 23/06/2012 11:52

but as you say you would have been pleased whatever boy or girl and i can relate to a niggle that you mention, i dont know i just always knew i wanted a large family and yet at the same time as having my children i had friends goign through ivf, miscarriages, still birth etc, not all close friends but it brought home to me the reality of how VERY lucky i am to conceive easily and have easy pregnancies and it also made me think that each time i had another (esp after the first 2) that maybe i was 'pushing my luck' somehow, which is crazy i know, but i def worried more in each pregnancy rather than less, i knew more of what could go wrong and felt that maybe instead of 'chancing my luck' i should be grateful for what i already had, but at the same time i really wanted a big family and maybe that is selfish as well? and to then take that selfishness one step further to actively attempt to get a child of a specific gender? it seems wrong to me.

and yes my boys dote on their little sister, they love her to bits and dont seem bothered by any comments, its me that inwardly seethes when people say things, my children know they are all loved equally and valued for the individual they are, regardless of gender.

i guess to me it just seems a step too far, if you are wanting one sex more than the other that you are prepared to pay and go through the invasive treatment (and having just donated eggs it IS invasive) i would be question why i wanted children and why only the one gender that i was so prepared to put myself through that, esp if as in the ops case she obviously can conceive naturally. its one thing to do it if you have to, its your only choice to have a child, but just to get the right sex?!! and then what next, its a very slippery slope i feel.

cory · 23/06/2012 11:50

fullofregrets Fri 22-Jun-12 14:18:09
"Past abuse, issues with husband (worried son might turn out like him) identify with girls better, don't want to be a mil, have a great relationship with my mom and would like the chance for the same."

This post sums up to me why gender selection is a bad idea.

Because it is based on the whole idea that there are things you have a right to expect from a child of X gender.

What if the poor girl turns out to resemble the abusive ex?

What is she is totally different from her mother and they do not have a great relationship?

What if she gets married and the poster finds herself with MIL problems after all.

As long as we are not allowed to select, we are forced to accept that actually we have no control over these matters: that a child might turn out to be absolutely anyone, that it is up to them and not to us who they are.

I love my mother dearly but I have always felt slightly uncomfortable with her strongly marked feelings that I have got to understand her in a special way because I am her daughter. The truth is, that I am probably the one out of her children who is most unlike her- but I have felt I had to live up to these expectations because I was the girl. I can't imagine that would have been any easier if she had been allowed to choose me specially with that goal in sight.

ledkr · 23/06/2012 11:31

Its really interesting that we dont quite agree even in similar circumstances. I admit that I often felt that something was sad about me never having a daughter,it wasnt a massive problem more a little niggle and a feeling I was missing out on something iyswim. I had cancer after ds3 so i was lucky to conceive again and there was a 10 yr age gap so I was so pleased it would have not mattered what I had.

Maybe for some people it is more important though and I just dont see it as a problem to gender select as long as you pay for it yourself and are prepared for the "wrong" outcome.

I also feel protective over my big boys too,but they were all so delighted with their little sisters that it didnt seem an issue.

Dh and I only have dd2 together and he has loads of comments from his male friends about not having a boy! Very annoying.

5madthings · 23/06/2012 10:54

no i didnt really hope for a pink one, i hoped for an easy pregnancy and birth as i had had with the other 4, she was a bit of a bonus baby, we wanted 4 and then ummed and ahhed and werent as careful as we should have been, so not totally planned ifyswim? and i just totally assumed she would be a boy, i guess i thought it would be nice to have a girl but i really wasnt fussed at all, had a boys name picked out etc and even once i was told it was a girl at two scans still didnt buy anything girly really.

when she was born i said 'is it alright' and then 'is it really a girl?' i love having a girl but i actualy feel hugely protective over my boys as i get a lot of comments and assumptions that we 'kept going to get a girl' and that 'she must be our favourite' and how happy we must be to finally have a girl yada yada and that makes me feel bad for my boys as that is not how it is at all.

i just feel incredibly lucky and blessed (in a non religious sense) to have been lucky enough to get pregnant easily and have easy pregnancies, births, healthy children etc, which is why i donated my eggs this week to give someone else that chance.

i just think if you are wanting to actively choose the sex and are willing to pay to do so then imo you need to question why you are having a child in the first place, they are individuals and you dont choose their personality or their looks or their interests etc, you get what you get and yes they are a blessing and not a designer accessory. and yes i agree with you someone so fixated on one sex needs to get help and support for that.

ledkr · 23/06/2012 10:46

5 mad, i also assumed dd would be a boy but did hope for a girl,did you really go in for your 5th baby with not one single hope for a pink one? Grin

I still think if someone feels like we did and has the money then why not go for it? If they then dislike what they get male or female then their issues run far deeper and they need to seek support.

AGiraffeUnderTheFloorBoards · 23/06/2012 10:36

Being a parent means putting our wants and needs to one side. We need to sleep, a newborn needs to feed - we get up. Same applies to wanting / "needing" your child to be a certain gender. Your "needs" don't come into it - but the need for your baby to be loved and accepted unconditionally does.

Anyone remember the OBEM episode when parents of 4(?) DDs and 1DS have another DD and how disappointed they were and then phoned their DS to apologise Sad? Juxtaposed to them were the couple who against the odds had conceived - (mother had a brain injury) - and the first thing their newborn DD heard was "I love you, I love you" . Some people don't know how lucky they are.

5madthings · 23/06/2012 09:01

ledkr no i agree that many people would of course like to parent both sexes and yes after 4 boys i was thrilled to get a girl, would have been equally thrilled with a boy but like you am enjoying buying girly clothes and shoes and my dd's hair is now long enough for clips and pig tails etc, its lovely, purely because its a change after 4 boys, and would i imagine be the same with boys clothes had i had 4 girls and then a boy.

but this poster is considering the gender selection route, that is a lot more than thinking it would be nice to have the other sex, which is a lot different from a preference iyswim? tbh i didnt have a preference, i assumed no 5 would be another boy and didnt really believe the scan telling me she was a girl.

to actively be considering sex selection is very different from that i think.

ledkr · 23/06/2012 08:16

I think people are over analysing this. Having had 3 boys and quite fancying a gilr by the 3rd I would doubt if anyone really is disappointed when they get the same gender again. Its just a preference for some,it makes anice change,its nice to choose a name,buy different clothes than you have done previously and just to experience a different gender. I dont think it runs any deeper.

I also agree with the second coming that many people who "dont get it" are people with one of each. People with all the same can be understandably defensive,I was too. If anyone expressed a preference it made me angry as it felt as if it was suggesting my family wasnt good enough.

Those with one of each,can i ask were you not secretly really chuffed to get a different sex to the one you already had? Was you dh,or your parents?

I thoroughly enjoyed raising my boys (mostly) Hmm but equally I am loving my girls,I love buying dresses and little shoes and hair clips for them. The best for me is tiny frilly swimsuits.

I even enjoyed chatting to dd1 about periods the other day and we had a conversation yesterday about how some women can be quite opressed by their partners. I like going to the cinema to watch girly films after 15 yrs of Ninja films or giant turtles.

If that sounds superficial thats because it is!
Its that simple for me. It makes a nice change.

Nobody in their right mind could ever be disappointed with their children but they may have a preference.

wildswans · 23/06/2012 08:05

I expect many people, given the choice, would choose 'a pigeon pair', which would become rather boring. It's not just what the parents want - it's lovely for children to have siblings of the same sex. I always yearned for a sister and remember being bitterly disappointed when my brother was born!

A lot of parents have in mind that they want one sex or another before the baby is born, but instantly fall in love with waht they get and wouldn't have it any other way. Anyone who doesn't love their baby is probably suffering from PND or has other issues, as this thread demonstrates.

Regarding gender preferences, I have noticed that it is more fashionable to want girls now, whereas when my DC were born (13 -19 years ago), I would have said there was a slight preference for boys. However, it is ultimately absurd to prefer one sex over the other. As others have said, a child is a blessing - the fact that it is the second or third of the same sex doesn't make it less of a blessing.

However, i do understand that someone with 2 or 3 of the same sex might want to have a different flavour next time.

holyfishnets · 23/06/2012 07:56

yes if there is a medical need

OhDoAdmitMrsDeVere · 23/06/2012 07:53

Blimey I work with families predominantly from India and Pakistan and many of them have first born girls. I genuinely have no noticed a strange gender imbalance
However as per my first post I have definately noticed an overt wish to have boys.

nooka · 23/06/2012 07:47

for a minute I wondered what sort of children might be compared to a fridge freezer Shock

I agree with all those who say easy access to gender selection techniques is a very disturbing idea. I can understand those who have several children of one sex wondering what it would be like to have the other. I can understand an initial disappointment even, but not to think through the iplications of such a move is very naive.

I live in Canada and here it is illegal to tell parents the sex of the fetus when undertaking early scans because there has been plenty of evidence that there are much higher abortion rates as a result (pretty much all of girls).

Having an 'unbalanced' family frankly doesn't really matter that much, but having an unbalanced society has hugely negative implications.

TantrumsAndBalloons · 23/06/2012 07:27

I'm sure that the second best child will be fully aware they are second best as well. What a horrible thing to say.

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 07:03

I haven't got over the statement that it is possible to have a 'second best' child.'

oldnewmummy · 23/06/2012 06:53

I'm confused - I have a "pigeon pair", but it's a fridge and freezer combo.

I'm also immensely privileged to be the mother of a wonderful little boy. Neither my husband or myself were bothered about gender, race, eye colour, hair colour, inherited characteristics etc, so we chose to adopt rather than try to reproduce. We accepted the first available child, and he's wonderful (and far better-looking than either of us.)

I don't get it.

As to whether our family is unbalanced, you'll have to ask our psychiatrist.......

sashh · 23/06/2012 03:15

Past abuse, issues with husband (worried son might turn out like him)

A daughter could turn out like husband

identify with girls better

All girls?

don't want to be a mil
and if your daughter married you would be what? And by the time she is grown up married couls be to a woman.

have a great relationship with my mom and would like the chance for the same.

And you couldn't with a son?

bonkersLFDT20 · 22/06/2012 23:46

vanimal I am 1/2 Indian and know loads and loads of families with a first born girl.

TheSecondComing · 22/06/2012 23:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RightFedUp · 22/06/2012 23:33

Years ago, I would have said YABU. Then I had 3 DC of the same gender and though I wouldn't change a hair on their heads, I yearned utterly for a DC of the other gender. I can't explain how deep and desperate that longing was - while all the time, loving and appreciating the children I have. So I would have said YANBU.

Later, I have come to realise that my family is wonderful as it is and I only get the odd twinge of the old longing. I think I kind of brainwashed myself (out of necessity) into talking up the benefits of the gender I have and playing up the disadvantages of the gender I don't - even though I know I'm doing it and dealing partly in stereotypes.

It's helped me anyway.

Claire2009 · 22/06/2012 23:21

In our family, the boys are autistic, Grandad, Uncle, Cousin, Half-Brother. I have one girl, one boy, I obviously knew it was a 'risk' having children, I carry the CF gene and the autism one by the looks of it!
In the 'ideal' world it would be great to pick and chose what sex the child is, I had an abusive childhood, and didn't really want a girl, I didn't have a great bond with my own Mother and am petrified dd is going to hate me when she is older, I am doing better with dd than I thought I would, I think we are given these children to challenge us! Grin That is not a bad thing, I have ds with asd, and dd (nt) but I would not change neither of them for the world(however, I will not be having anymore children)

vanimal · 22/06/2012 23:06

I am strongly against gender selection, and tbh, don't see why the sex of the baby is routinely revealed during baby scans.

Surely this information can be mis-used? It is really so necessary to be told the sex of your baby before it's born? (I say this as a pregnant woman, and mother of 2 DDs)

vanimal · 22/06/2012 23:04

I haven't read the whole read, but wanted to ask Worra about the statement below:

I couldn't tell you how many Indian families I know...probably 100s and yet not one single one of them has a DD as an eldest child

Is this really true? You know 100s of Indian families with first born sons, but none with first born daughters? Which country is this in?

Do you think they aborted their first babies because they were girls?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.