Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
GhouliaYelps · 24/06/2012 18:59

A healthy child is obviously the most important thing. However a quiet preference for a certain sex doesn't make you evil. I always wanted a girl, I am thrilled I have DD as I knew there would be no more attempts.

My Mother was very vocal about wanting boys, she had 3 girls. That was horrible to hear all my life. The difference being she actually told us her preference.

McHappyPants2012 · 24/06/2012 18:37

I would rather it was legal, I really didn't want a daughter because I though how could I raise a daughter as I know nothing about Girly things.

However my dd is just like me :) so no needed to worry

nooka · 24/06/2012 17:58

The other thing to bear in mind is that every child has two parents and those parents have families and friends. Can you imagine the stress and pressure if they all started pitching in about what sex the child should be? I think it is a bit foolish to imagine that the choice would be entirely free, or that the 'West'/developed world is free of prejudices. Plus if you think that parents get grief now for having the families they have now, just think how much worse it would be if everyone thought that the outcome could be controlled.

exoticfruits · 24/06/2012 08:34

You need to respond to the DC that you have and not the mythical one of your imagination.

exoticfruits · 24/06/2012 08:33

Judging by MN there wouldn't be a balance-there would be too many girls.

I think people do have expectations and dreams of what their family will look like and some find that very hard to let go

This is a dream they should curb at the start.
It then leads on to the fact they want their DC to play a musical instrument, they want them to be a first class tennis player, they want them to go to a top university etc.
Wait and see what you get and support and foster what they want to do-take piano lessons yourself, learn to play tennis and it is never too late to go to university or OP-don't expect them to do it for you. Maybe they are tone deaf, hopeless at sport and want to leave school at 16yrs and be a hairdresser.

The odds are 50/50 and you know this when you start. I have 3 boys and I still have exactly the 50/50 chance if I had a 4th. I might hope for a girl but I have 9months to get used to the fact that is is equally likely to be a boy. The answer is not to bother if you don't want another boy.

I agree with fuzzpig-I think that bringing another human into the world is a miracle-a wonderful thing-I can't imagine then saying 'that miracle wasn't good enough-it was the 'wrong' sex! There are lots of fairy stories along the lines of 'be careful what you wish for.......'

WinkyWinkola · 24/06/2012 00:13

I have dcs of both sex.

When I found out for each of them at the 20 week scan, I felt very sad, disappointed and cried for a few days. I was letting go of the possibility of the other sex and for some reason, I got really upset each time. Regardless of which sex!

I don't think that makes me spoiled or not appreciate my dcs at all.

I think people do have expectations and dreams of what their family will look like and some find that very hard to let go.

Likewise, I think people also have expectations of what a boy or a girl will be like. That too is normal, just like having an expectation of what having a baby is like. I think for the majority, they very quickly realise that the reality very rarely measures up to the stereotype. We are all naive I this respect.

I'm not sure it's something necessarily to condemn people for unless they actively make a child of the 'wrong' gender feel inadequate.

I certainly do not believe that if PGD were legal in this country, we would have the same skewed population as China or India. There the sex preference is centuries old and very much ingrained in the culture. Comparing the UK to that is hysterical, IMO.

Think there would be more of a balance in the west.

TheCreepingLurgy · 23/06/2012 23:46

I understand you may be curious how having the other sex would affect your family/parenting and that may be a reason to prefer the other sex. However, it is a completely different matter to think it should be acceptable to manipulate the sex of the baby for those reasons. The consequences on a society level could be very undesirable if sex manipulation were allowed.

If you really feel strongly that you do not want another boy you probably should not have another baby. The pressure on the girl to live up to your expectations! She may be completely different to what you think she will contribute to your family (like "balancing" Hmm?). Or the poor boy who was not wanted...

fuzzpig · 23/06/2012 23:39

to actually give birth and then say 'I wanted the other sex' is greedy and selfish

Yep. Having a baby is a miracle, IMO the most fundamental miracle of life the universe and everything (I'm not religious), the fact you can actually create a whole person! How could anyone say that miracle isn't enough?

jellybeans · 23/06/2012 23:33

I have had miscarriages and lost two stillborn DDs. I am very lucky to also have my 5 living DC; 2 DDs, 3DSs. After difficult births and losses I think people should be grateful to have a child at all. It really use to annoy me listening to friends with boys go on about they are fed up with boys and desperate for girls. In my experience boys are every bit as nice as girls and you can have as much fun with boys clothes and toys etc! I had as much attention with my boys as I did with my girls so disagree that people only celebrate girls. I had 3 DDs first (lost 3rd one) but was very happy when we found out it was a 3rd DD. I never really had a desire for boys as had enjoyed my girls so much and have no boys in the family. But once - found out was having boys was so excited. And when I realised they were as fab as DDs was happy to have more of them! If I have anymore would be happy with either!

Empusa · 23/06/2012 23:19

Got to wonder, I'm assuming that even with PGD it isn't 100% reliable, in which case what would you do if (after all the hassle) you still ended up with the sex you didn't want?

5madthings · 23/06/2012 23:10

i dont understand being 'disappointed' at the birth of a baby, when we had ds3 and then ds4 a particular family member commented on being 'disappointed' they werent girls! good job they were on the end of the phone or they may have got a slap! i was and still am just in awe of the whole process tbh, it IS such a miracle and a blessing, i am not religious but i do really think children are a blessing and a gift, they are not ours to own but to love and care for, and to help grow into responsible adults. they are not an extention of us or our wants, but their own people.

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 23:02

Exactly picnicbasketcase-if there had been a possibility that I would have been disappointed if no.3 was a third boy then I wouldn't have had a third.

ginhag · 23/06/2012 23:02

Bloody hell choc biscuit! That's a bit 'anyone who disagrees with me is WRONG!' isn't it?

I have two boys. They are amazing. I am incredibly fucking lucky to have them. I have no regrets, no desire to conjure up anymore kids. Because it really didn't matter to me that I didn't have a girl (I had never even thought of it tbh.)

We had a hard time conceiving ds2. We are so lucky he is here. My heart fills up at all we have...especially as I know that friends of mine are still trying.

Now I'm not saying that it's wrong to yearn for a child of a specific sex. Just because I haven't been there doesn't mean it's not valid! BUT you can't say that people who don't feel like this 'aren't being completely honest'!!!

picnicbasketcase · 23/06/2012 22:58

I have a DS and a DD. I would only want another child if it was another girl. So we will not be having a third child because you don't get to choose and I would hate to have a child if I ended up having any sense of disappointment or resentment about it.

I think you should only have a child if you are going to be happy whichever sex it happens to be and it would be dangerous to let people choose which sex they want as there is bound to end up being an imbalance.

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 22:58

Mine are now at the girlfriend stage and that it lovely-you can really appreciate them and the female company.

5madthings · 23/06/2012 22:57

do you know when i thought about having a family i never really thought about the sex of the children! i always wanted a large family and am so grateful to have my 5, i just wanted easy pregnancies and hoped for healthy babies and was lucky enough to get that.

tbh if i could afford to i would have more! but unless we win the lottery its not happening!

and can you answer my question please op, what type of balance is it you hope to get by having a girl? i really dont understand the idea of balancing a family? you get what you get and they are all individuals and people in their own right, with different traits and characteristics regardless of gender.

DamselInTornDress · 23/06/2012 22:56

I'm a mum of boys who never wanted girls. 100% honest on that. I was/am afraid I would not be able to protect her from preditors. Having a daughter was my biggest fear. I'm happy with my boys. I would have made a good Arab wife Wink

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 22:55

It is actually a lot simpler to have 3 of the same sex and cheaper!

DillyTante · 23/06/2012 22:54

'I am yet to meet a mum of two+ boys/girls who say that they wouldn't love a child of a different gender. I think anyone who says different is saying what they think is right and probably not being deeply honest'

Honestly don't. Mum of two girls & while I was slightly disappointed I would never know what it is like to have a son, I have absolutely no desire to have boy now, not even if I could guarantee it.

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 22:52

Same here Northernlurker-having a third was nothing to do with wanting a different gender-we were just thrilled to have a healthy 3rd child.

DillyTante · 23/06/2012 22:51

I'm sure gender disappointment is a real and horrible feeling. Despite it's irrationality I'm not sure it is something people can help. I think people who can't for one moment sympathise with the fact that other people feel differently are just as small minded as they perceive the people who they are judging to be.

However I don't agree with gender selection for non-medical reasons. It's messing about with nature too much. Fine if you can't help but feel desperate for a child of a particular gender, you may not be able to help that. But you can choose not to have a child if you really can't bear the thought of having the opposite sex you desire. Ultimately, no one knows how they are going to feel when they have a child.

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 22:50

We get this terrible 'me', 'me', 'me' society where people want life the way they order it-generally it doesn't work out that way!

Northernlurker · 23/06/2012 22:50

'I am yet to meet a mum of two+ boys/girls who say that they wouldn't love a child of a different gender. I think anyone who says different is saying what they think is right and probably not being deeply honest'

Well OP - meet me. I had two daughters and we decided we wanted a third child. We absolutely 100% had no preference boy or girl. All we wanted was a healthy baby. When she arrived we were overjoyed. Had she been he we would also have been just as overjoyed, no more, no less. That's me being deeply honest with you.

exoticfruits · 23/06/2012 22:49

I just get so sad that people think they can order a baby like buying a handbag! You start knowing that you can't so why get upset?

GooseRocks · 23/06/2012 22:45

Well said exotic.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread