Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
exoticfruits · 27/06/2012 07:11

I think it is all due to the fact they are going to be Mother's soul mate and best friend for life, Sargesaweyes! They are going to think the same, be very involved with their grandchildren in future years and have lots of shopping trips!
This is despite the fact that they are individuals and might not get on well. I have rather pityingly been told that I am missing the mother/daughter relationship - from a friend who has a pretty ropey relationship with her own DD.

It is all a bit strange, because if I mention that it is because boys are noisy, messy and need lots of exercise have boring clothes and don't like shopping I would be shouted down and told it was social conditioning and there is no difference! If that was really so then it wouldn't matter which you had.

I agree with LurkingandLearningforNow.

RichManPoorManBeggarmanThief · 27/06/2012 06:37

Interestingly, in China the bias towards boys is falling, largely due to economic factors.

  • Urbanisation means that women are often more employable than men now - the types of job that typical rural-urban migrants do are are as easily done by women as by men
  • Urbanisation means that the traditional expectations that a boy child and his wife would live with his parents and support them (i.e. not with the wife's parents) have broken down. The extended family set up is far less common because increasing numbers of adult children go to the cities and dont come back to the rural areas (just send money home to both sets of parents).

In HK, amongst the educated Chinese population, I'd almost say there's a bias towards girls now- "girls are less trouble", "girls work harder at at school" etc.

The thing about China is that whilst in no way do I agree with gender selective terminations, there are tangible reasons why it happens. When you're only allowed one child and you're a poor rural peasant, if that child is a girl you are totally screwed because your daughter will leave you to live with her husband's family. China has no pension system and minimal welfare provision. These people are often dirt poor. It can be life or death.

By contrast, in the UK, our reasons for preferring one gender over another are, at best, self-indulgent and whimsical.

Sargesaweyes · 27/06/2012 06:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LurkingAndLearningForNow · 27/06/2012 05:52

If you believe you have 'the right;' to a perfect family with each gender, then you don't deserve children IMO.

Girls are already being aborted (and killed as infants) in record numbers. Personally I don't want that to start here.

nooka · 27/06/2012 05:47

For those that selective abortion of girls is just a problem in India/China, here is an editorial from the Canadian Medical Association Journal talking about some evidence of unexpected trends in the gender of third children.

Springforward · 26/06/2012 23:09

I don't like the idea very much tbh.

Friends of ours have a delightful little boy a few weeks younger than DS, he has haemaphilla (sp?) so I guess he might have been aborted if they could have chosen. Which can't be right, because he is their joy.

lilypainter · 26/06/2012 22:56

No, scans aren't 100% reliable.

It depends a lot on which position the baby's in - if they're facing the ultrasound probe with legs splayed open, the sonographer can be pretty sure. If they're facing away or sideways on with legs crossed (like DS in most of my scans), it can be very hard to see.

It's commoner for them to think it's a girl when it's really a boy, if the boy bits are tucked out of sight, than it is for them to think it's a boy when it's really a girl.

Although one of my colleagues thought she was having a boy - turned out the sonographer had mistook a bit of umbilical cord for a willy, and baby was really a girl.

exoticfruits · 26/06/2012 21:26

The woman in the next bed thought it was 100% reliable!

5madthings · 26/06/2012 21:22

nope i had a friend who in the last 6mths was told girl, the baby was infact a boy, she didnt mind at all.

i think depending on the position of the baby and the skill of the sonographer they can be more or less accurate, when i had my 20wk scan with dd we weretn planning on finding out the sex, but the sonographer said 'i have a REALLY clear view of the sex do you want to know?' whihc i took to me mean boy! ie clear view = penis! so when she then said girl dp and i were quite shocked, we had just assumed it would be a boy (didnt care either way) anyway she could see we were in disbelief, and checked very thoroughly and at the end of the scan she said 'i am not allowed to say i am 100% sure, but i am 100% sure this baby is a girl' i am assuming she wouldnt have said that had she not been properly sure! as it is we didnt buy anything 'girly' anyway just reused the boys stuff and unisex stuff and then once she was born we have bought stuff and got given loads, actually i was given girls stuff before she was born, but insisted that dp put it up in the loft until right at the last minute when i washed a few bits, but then i was like that with the unisex stuff etc as well, dont like that feeling of 'tempting fate' so yes i get stuff ready but the minimal. i guess its a bit like people that dont like buying anything before the baby arrives? daft really as its not going to change the outcome!

as for gender abortions in the uk? i would be suprised if it happened tho i guess in private clinics it may? no-one can be forced to tell the true reasons they are aborting but you would still need 2 drs to sign it off etc and surely the earliest they can sex at a scan is about 16wks i thought and then it is less accurate? i dont know how it is something that they can research very well in the uk.

incidentally, the family opposite me are Indian they have one boy and 2 girls and were delighted with the births of their girls, they had a tought time with their boy (their 1st) as he was prem and she had pre-eclampsia so they were pleased all went well like any other parents and tho they have said to me how lovely to have 4 boys, they were equally enthusiastic about the arrival of our dd as they were when we had ds4 tho. i dont know them that well but when they had their babies i put a card through their letterbox to congratulate them etc and our children play out together. i feel a bit bad actually as its the language barrier that prevents me from being friends with them, the children can speak english but the mum literally only speaks a few words, she nods hello and when behind her int he queue at the local shop and her card was declined i paid for her shopping (some milk and some electricity for her meter etc) and she thanked me and dropped the money round the next day. But the language barrier does make it hard. anyway not sure what the point of that ramble is! sorry :)

tittytittyhanghang · 26/06/2012 21:06

I always thought that they are usually 99.99999999% percent sure if its a boy but slightly less so if its a girl as the bits could be, ahem, hiding sts.

WinkyWinkola · 26/06/2012 20:48

I really thought scans were like 99% reliable?

exoticfruits · 26/06/2012 19:06

Scans are not reliable. When I had my youngest the woman in the next bed was over the moon because she was having a girl. She had a boy already and went out and bought stuff for a girl. It turned out to be a boy-it is never a good idea to get all prepared in case it is wrong.

lilypainter · 26/06/2012 17:37

All the articles I've seen about girl babies being selectively aborted refer to countries other than the UK - mostly China or India - and use birth rate statistics as evidence.

i.e. this area has 150 boys being born for every 100 girls, natural statistic is approx 105 boys born for every 100 girls, therefore selective abortion / infanticide is almost certainly happening.

Given that aborting healthy babies on grounds of gender is illegal in the UK, any people who've done that would probably be reluctant to openly admit it and talk to researchers about it.

And scans aren't 100% reliable even today, if the baby's not in the right position.

OhDoAdmitMrsDeVere · 26/06/2012 17:08

When I had my two eldest 20 and 18 years ago they would not tell anyone the sex. It was generally accepted this was because they didn't want to tell Asian parents so they didn't tell anyone.
However, looking back I have absolutely no proof that this was the case.
It might just have been down to scans being less accurate then.

Unfortunately I think there will always be people who do it. I am not convinced it is widespread but I don't work in that field. Is there any research I wonder?

buttonmoon78 · 26/06/2012 16:59

It was horribly sad. I was good friends with this woman's SiL and she was devastated. She was delighted when her DH backed her refusal to find out when she was pregnant.

His rationale? 'When this baby comes I'll be delighted it's a healthy baby whatever it is. If I find out it's a girl then my family have time to convince me I'm disappointed.'

Said baby was a (2nd) girl and my friend and her husband were delighted but went through a tough time with relatives commiserating with them. She had a boy several years later and finally felt accepted by her dh's family.

vanimal · 26/06/2012 16:48

Buttonmoon78 that's horrific :(

I live in the W Mids too, and am currently pg, and am Asian. At each of my 3 pregnancies the radiographers have asked if I wanted to know the sex of my baby, I declined each time.

But I do know of hospitals in the area that will not tell you the sex of your baby, regardless of your ethnicity.

I was bought up in a predominantly Asian area and can honestly say I have never, ever come across anyone having an abortion based on the sex of their baby.

I am not accusing you of lying, I am just very, very sad that this is exists, in this country, in this day and age.

I know if I, or anyone I knew aborted on the basis of sex and was open about it, I would lose all friends and family in an instant, it is absolutely disgusting that this goes on in the UK. Makes me sad to be Indian and associated in any way with the practice.

:(

buttonmoon78 · 26/06/2012 16:31

vanimal I can't answer for worra but I would say that she is not normally known for malicious exaggeration. Nor can I say that you're lying but what this shows is that it is a hugely emotive and subjective subject.

I would also repeat the statement that I made upthread

quickhide yes it's true. It was true when I lived in a large city in the W Midlands. They wouldn't tell you the sex of the baby unless you were paying for a private scan. And yes, I know several people who had late terminations because the babies were girls.

They were quite open about it. It was desperately sad. One of them aborted several girls, fell pregnant with a boy and the whole family was delighted. Unfortunately she lost the boy as he had major abnormalities at around the age the girls had been aborted. I'm not saying that's divine retribution or anything silly like that, but it was poignantly ironic (something of an understatement) to see the mass mourning which accompanied the loss of that boy as opposed to the relief which accompanied the abortion of the girls. Sad

5madthings · 26/06/2012 15:05

well i think you would be mad to do so, i just donated eggs to help a couple going through ivf and for me it all went fine, very straightforward, no complications, that isnt always the case and despite that it was a big ask of me and my family, hospital appointments, scans, blood tests, having to have a general which is a risk etc and i didnt have the worry of then hoping the eggs fertilise and then that they will implant and result in a pregnancy. i have 5 of my own, the regular way and thankfully very easily and without complication, i woudl never put myself through that to get a baby of a specific gender, if i couldtn have a baby any other way yes possibly.

so if it didnt work, you spent all that money and it actualy made you ill, or heaven forbid you died, you think that is a risk worth taking? to deprive yoru sons of a mother? and what if it works but you lose the baby? you would put yourself and your children through that? and what message will that send to your sons, that you are so desperate for a girl that you would do that rather than just give them a sibling of either sex the regular way?

tittytittyhanghang · 26/06/2012 14:59

5madthings, if i had the money, then yes i probably would put myself through that.

5madthings · 26/06/2012 14:21

really tittytitty you would sign up for gender selction, do you know what the process involves? how invasive it is, how much of a strain the egg collection process is and then the ivf, you would put yourself and your family through that? and then the chances are it may not work, i think generally ivf has about a 30% chance of working.

so you would happily inject yourself daily for a few weeks to stimulate your ovaries to produce extra eggs (this carries risk of hyper stimulation a side effect of which can be death) Then you need to be scanned a few times a week (at least) these are internal scans, not painful but not exactly dignified, legs up in stirrups etc during this process to check how your follicles are growing and blood tests at each scan to check on medication levels and adjust as necessary. then you would have to undergo a general anasthetic to remove the eggs.

then after all that they would see which eggs look viable, introduce the sperm and incubate to see which ones fertilise, then those embryos have to be graded to see which if any are likely to implant, and THEN you want to select from those embryos on the basis of gender? and only implant the female ones, and hope you get pregnant, which is far from guaranteed and once you are pregnant, statistically ivf pregnancies are more likely to end up in miscarriage or have other complications or the baby is also statistically more likely to have abnormalities.

so you would put yourself through that just to try and have a girl?! why not be grateful for the fact that you can have a baby the regular way? and be happy with what you have?!

tittytittyhanghang · 26/06/2012 14:14

YANBU, I have two boys and both times I have wanted a girl. But the fact that they are boys doesn't in anyway diminish my love for them, and I wouldn't change them for anything, even if I could go back and choose a girl. But I do still want a girl and would sign up for gender selection in a heartbeat if it was financially viable.

vanimal · 26/06/2012 13:55

bonkersLFDT20 and MrsDevere I also know lots of Indian families with first born DDs (myself included).

That's why I find worras comments about knowing hundreds of Indian families, none with a first-born daughter very dubious, and a deeply insulting statement to make.

I agree there is an unbalanced desire for sons in the Indian community, but I have never seen this practiced in the form of aborting female babies in the UK (assuming worra here too).

MrGrey · 25/06/2012 14:58

fullofregrets I think that you are so wrong.

And actually when I hear people say 'typical boy' I always think of that as a positive or even an excuse for boisterous behaviour.

Mindyourownbusiness · 25/06/2012 12:56

Yes Ghoulia l agree. I will never forget my mum stopping her friend in the street to 'commiserate' with her about her latest (of five) DGSs that her DD had just given birth to.

Her DD (my mums friends that is) had lost a baby girl , her second child to cot death and had been trying ever since to have another little girl. Kept saying I'll just have one more to try for a girl but kept having boys. She had only originally wanted two DCs but ended up having seven ( her last one was eventually a girl )

I will never forget because this woman was holding one of her DGSs hands (about five years old) while she and my mother very loudly and vocally bemoaned the arrival of yet another boy. His little face - he just looked so bewildered looking up at his DGM and listening to all this. I was only about eleven but l remember even at that age thinking that was so wrong but couldnt quite work out why at that age.

Just to say in the womans defence and that of her family l think it was more ignorance than anything and the boys always seemed loved and cared for but l wonder what damage that might have done to them knowing they were all 'failed attempts' to have a girl. Also tbf l have never been in the awful unimaginable position of losing a baby girl to cot death and l imagine that was their way of making it bearable - looking forward to once again having a little girl in the family.

But l still have always remembered that little boys face. Sad

AdventuresWithVoles · 25/06/2012 12:40

I enjoy mulling over what would happen if sex selection became legal & culturally acceptable.

An awful lot of random choice & unplanned pregnancies would still happen.
IVF is expensive & unpleasant, most babies would not be gender selected.

In most (vast majority) of the world boys would still be very heavily favoured.
In Britain girls would be preferred. Mixed but probably net girl bias in rest of OECD countries.
Late term abortions for sex-selection reasons would still happen (random or unplanned pregnancies, folk who couldn't do IVF). But probably a lot less often.

I think the boy:girl ratios would climb to about 140-150:100 in the most boy-favouring societies. In Uk would be boy:girl of maybe 100:115-120, not so marked imbalance.

All those surplus boys would struggle to get wives; this is already a big issue in China. Would world population actually fall? Would the social status of women increase worldwide? Would western preferred girls have to turn to the best of undeveloped world men to find a partner? Would homosexuality become better tolerated worldwide? Would girls become even more sheltered & mollycoddled & put upon to uphold family honour in the least sophisticated countries? Would incidents of rape increase? Would quality of maternal care increase due to the knowledge women were carrying boys?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread