Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 22/06/2012 15:14

Doesn't IVF only have about a 50/50 success rate at best anyway?

So you go through all the expense, drugs and operations just so that you don't have the wrong sex and after all that you end up with no baby at all. I would have a long hard look at why you want children (and whether you should have) at all if this is you.

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 15:13

I think this sort of thread is really hurtful to those struggling to conceive.

It is hurtful for a lot of people -and said by those who are not grateful for the vast amount of privilege they have and think they are entitled to get just what you want because we live in a materialistic society where generally you can. This is one of the things that you can't order like the perfect wedding day, the lovely nursery etc

DamselInTornDress · 22/06/2012 15:12

You can plan a girl without gender selection. Have intercourse the day before you ovulate. The male sperm swims faster but the female sperm lives longer Wink

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 15:12

Quite honestly EasilyBored I know you weren't being serious but I don't see any difference between selecting gender and selecting characteristics! (and your post did make me chortle!)

mamataurus · 22/06/2012 15:12

YABU I remember when I was in hospital after having my first son, there was a lady in the bed opposite who had had her third son. She was very upset and cried loads - said she was grieving for the daughter she will never have. I asked her why it was so important for her to have a daughter and she replied that she wanted someone to go shopping with, have her nails done girlie times with etc... It made me laugh but also feel sad because all this seemed more important to her than a healthy baby son!!! I reasoned with her that if she had had a girl she may grow up to be a tomboy and not be girly at all - like me I was a tomboy hated wearing dresses etc.. poor mum didn't have much girly time with me. A work colleague has one son and she is always shopping with him they have a right giggle together, so gender is not importand it is all about the person.

IsItMeOr · 22/06/2012 15:12

WhenSheWasBadSheWasHorrid - why would you say that? It certainly isn't the case in the UK that more girls are being born than boys - the pattern hasn't changed that much since 1938 in England and Wales, with between 1050 and 1060 boys born for every 1000 girls.

I'm not sure how I feel about the OP. Although I'm not sure I can see much harm in allowing somebody to "complete" their family if they already have at least two children of one gender and they want a further child of the opposite gender.

itdoesnthurttohavemanners · 22/06/2012 15:09

YABVVU. Having lost a child, and now 20 weeks pregnant, I am just hoping with many fingers crossed that I have a healthy child. I couldn't give a toss whether it's a boy or a girl. A child is not a right, it's a privilege. Stop being so bloody ungrateful. There are lots and lots of women out there struggling to conceive, or who have lost babies. Pretty sure not ONE of them would say a boy is preferable to a girl (or vice-versa). Sorry.

EasilyBored · 22/06/2012 15:08

Er, I realise that was a really flippant comment and genuinely don't want to offend anyone that's gone/going through IVF Blush

SCOTCHandWRY · 22/06/2012 15:08

Sex selection using Microsort (sperm sorting), on it's own or in conjunction with PGD is available to those who can afford to travel to America - they call it family balancing and you can have it if to have a child already, and hope for a child of the other sex - most people doing this have 2 or more children of the same sex (and more people want to conceive girls using the service).

I looked into this several years ago, before naturally conceiving DC4 (a 4th son of course! Grin).

With regards to celebs having lots of daughters - partly down to statistics, the older a woman is, the more likely she will have a girl (the male fetus is more likely to miscarry if it has minor genetic problems, and the risk of these increase dramatically as the woman gets older)

With regards to the "it's not natural" camp- almost nothing we do it the firld of science or medicine is "natural", that's not a good reason to say "this should not be allowed".

If EVERYONE was allowed to choose the sex of a second baby, if they wanted too, I think most people would chose to have "one of each" and limit themselves to 2 children - I know a huge number of people who's 3 or 4 child has been loved, and wanted - but it's been "hoped" that the child would be the opposite sex.

SO - maybe CHOICE would be better from a population control POV?

And I do think it's unfair to compare choice in the "west" with barbaric practices in rural India/China.

EasilyBored · 22/06/2012 15:07

Well, while we're at it, I would do IVF selection to get one that sleeps through the night.

Mindyourownbusiness · 22/06/2012 15:05

Happiness isnt thinking what you would love to have - it's loving what you have .

I saw this on a church notice board today.

Rather twee but true Smile.

lopsided · 22/06/2012 15:05

I'm with you supergah.

I also agree with fullofregrets that there is a girl preference, particularly amongst women. Much less excitement for boys. 2 people with girls said to me, oh I would have had another but only if I could guarantee it was a girl!

I would not allow gender selection, collectively I think we would end up with an imbalance. I also question the fitness to parent to undergo ivf and all that entails just to avoid a boy. I think this sort of thread is really hurtful to those struggling to conceive.

jammyjessica1999 · 22/06/2012 15:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Kendodd · 22/06/2012 15:04

Ok, so you have IVF to get a boy, you have four eggs fertilize, all four are female, what do you do, put them in the bin and start again?

OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 22/06/2012 15:02

Gender selection is a horrible horrible idea. Why cant people just be grateful to have healthy children?

jammyjessica1999 · 22/06/2012 15:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TitsalinaBumSquash · 22/06/2012 15:01

As someone who lived a Childhood knowing I was a dissapointlent and caused the breakdown of my patent marriage all because I didn't have a penis YABVU it's bloody disgusting to choose your baby based on their sex. Angry

TantrumsAndBalloons · 22/06/2012 15:00

I certainley don't have lower expectations of my boys.

CaveMum · 22/06/2012 14:57

YABVU

As someone who is struggling to conceive full stop, I exercise my right to tell you to be grateful for what you already have.

EasilyBored · 22/06/2012 14:56

I don't think there's anything wrong with feeling like it qould be quite nice to have one or the other, and even something like Shettles (which just cracks me up anyway) doesn't offend me; because I think it's about the strength of the feeling. If you would quite like a girl, but you get a boy and are really happy, then fine. If you would really really like a girl and get a boy and you are devestated and make crappy comments about it, then that's horrible. Does that make sense?

CailinDana · 22/06/2012 14:55

No I don't think it's morally repugnant I think it's seriously naive and misguided. I think if you are very fixated on one gender then you need to think carefully about why you're becoming a parent.

Staceisace · 22/06/2012 14:54

I was going to say 'I think it's okay if there's a genuine reason for it' but then couldn't think of a genuine reason.

From my point of view when you have children you take a risk - you don't know if it's going to be male or female (if that's important to you), you don't know if it's going to have a condition which affects your lives as a family, you don't know exactly what it's going to look like, and so on.

I'd like to think that any children I have will be desperately wanted and loved regardless.

JenaiMarrHePlaysGuitar · 22/06/2012 14:53

Or at least a shallow and selfish one with little imagination.

CailinDana · 22/06/2012 14:53

EasilyBored - IME it tends to be the older generation who say silly things about children - they seem to have fixed ideas about girls and boys behave

AGiraffeUnderTheFloorBoards · 22/06/2012 14:53

I vaguely remember being taught at school that after WWI the birth rate of boys increased in Europe - and this attributed to "nature" adjusting itself to redress the imbalance because of the vast number of men being killed. That could of course be bollocks and I've googled it and can't find anything to back up my memory....

However - the sex selection abortion in India and China will lead to serious problems. Large numbers of wifeless men are causing politicians real concern. A domination of men in a society is expected to lead to great instability (in China per year approx a million girls are thought to be aborted).

I can't help think the roughly 50/50 split of male and female births shouldn't be tampered with. Don't fuck with nature in this instance. There's a good reason why we don't choose. It's for the greater good.

As my friend with 3 DDs says - it's hardly as if they are all carbon copies of each other - they couldn't be more different. Just because they are girls doesn't make them the same.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.