Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
redwineformethanks · 22/06/2012 15:56

I think if you're lucky enough to have a child, then you should take whatever sex you're given and get on with it. It's not mail order, sale or return....

StepOutOfSpring · 22/06/2012 15:54

Also if couples "pick/choose" embryos this will be to avoid a medical issue. Again very different from sex selection (unless it's to avoid an illness which only affects one sex). I object to your term "pick/choose" as "picking and choosing" usually means people are being unnecessarily fussy, and this is definitely not the case with trying to avoid a medical problem for their future child.

StepOutOfSpring · 22/06/2012 15:52

YABU. Couples who freeze embryos following IVF will be doing so because they'd like a sibling for their child later, or they'd like embryos ready for the next cycle if this one doesn't work, or perhaps the woman is just about to have a full hysterectomy due to cancer and hopes a surrogate will carry the embryos later. This is very different to sex selection.

BarbarianMum · 22/06/2012 15:52

Thank you ViolaCrayola - one of the things I love about mumsnet is there is always someone who says what you want to say but puts it better.

Posterofapombear · 22/06/2012 15:47

I really really wanted a boy. I was wrong, my DD is my world and I could never imagine anything else.

I had worked with kids for 10 years and always worked better with boys so I assumed thats how it would work with my own kids. I was just wrong and I'm glad I wasn't allowed to select gender.

I understand wanting a baby of a particular sex when you live in that naive world before you have a baby but I can't understand how you can still feel like it afterwards. I now officially don't give a hoot if my next DC is a boy or a girl.

I don't have time to be a self absorbed knob anymore Grin

lilypainter · 22/06/2012 15:45

YABU.

As others have said, in some parts of the world, the desire for boy babies has skewed the gender balance quite away from the natural ratio of about 103 boys being born for every 100 girls. Especially now that ultrasounds can be used to determine a child's gender before it's born.

Here's a link to an article on the subject: www.economist.com/node/15636231

I think it's dangerous to assume that parents in the UK would use sex selection simply to 'balance', and that they would pick roughly equal numbers of girls and boys.

I also disagree with the point of view that parents in the west prefer girls. Sure, a lot of posters here may prefer girls, but most people posting here are women.

I work in a male dominated industry, and the overwhelming majority of my male colleagues expecting their first babies have said that they would prefer a boy (as did DH). The only exceptions to that have been colleagues whose wives have had multiple miscarriages or have had difficulty conceiving.
None of my colleagues have complained about having a daughter after the baby arrives BTW.

IME, men are more likely to want a son, and women are more likely to want a daughter, and the reason some people think most parents in the west prefer girls is because women tend to be more vocal about their preferences.

I think the only valid reason to choose your child's sex is if you or your DH can pass on a genetic disease that only affects girls or only affects boys.

StuntGirl · 22/06/2012 15:43

fullofregret's posts are so odd. Anti-male society? Not bloody likely. Celebrities have more girls? Show me some actual evidence for that. In fact, all your posts are weird half-baked theories. I feel sorry for your son.

Beamae · 22/06/2012 15:43

I have done IVF and there was no picking and choosing. I was surprised because I assumed that embryos were at least screened for genetic disorders but they weren't. In my experience it was a hugely stressful and traumatic experience, despite it's success in my case. As much as I want another child I will never put myself through it again. I can't imagine why anyone who can create a baby naturally would want to do IVF at all!

CharltonHairstyle · 22/06/2012 15:39

I really, really do not understand caring whether your child is a boy or a girl.

I just don't understand what difference it makes.

Quenelle · 22/06/2012 15:37

I think this sort of thread is really hurtful to those struggling to conceive.

It is hurtful for a lot of people

Yes it is.

IsItMeOr · 22/06/2012 15:36

Statistics for England and Wales here if you're interested Whenshewasbad (BTW, my mum used to say that rhyme about me Blush)

I always thought I wouldn't know what to do with a boy, and therefore hoped for a girl. Got DS Grin. I can't imagine loving any other child as much and while I very occasionally wonder what it would be like to have a DD too, DS is likely to be our only child.

I do agree with all who have said that there are so many uncertainties when deciding to have a child, obsessing over, and seeking to control, one detail seems a bit daft. DH and I took the view that we shouldn't have children if we weren't prepared to love and do our best for whatever child arrived (we have disability in the family and understand the extra commitment that can mean for parents).

awhistlingwoman · 22/06/2012 15:30

itdoesnthurt I'm so sorry for the loss of your child and I wish for the very best for your pregnancy.

I had two DDs but one of my little girls passed away. I then had my DS1. And you'd be surprised how many people told me that I had a 'pigeon pair' and how lucky I was to have one of each. Sigh. And if they had just totally forgotten that I had, once upon a time, had a slightly less desirably balanced family. Sigh again.

Some people can't have any children when they would dearly love a child of either sex. Some of us lose children that we love dearly. And I don't think that choosing the sex of your child is any different to choosing their eye colour. It doesn't guarantee anything about personality or the contribution that this person will make to the 'family dynamic.' What if they aren't a typical girl? What if your daughter grows up and decides she prefers to live as a man?! Would you be wanting your money back?! In my opinion I think you should just thank your lucky stars for your three glorious boys OP.

Happiness isnt thinking what you would love to have - it's loving what you have .

Twee or not, it's very true. Especially when it comes to children. Love what you have.

Mindyourownbusiness · 22/06/2012 15:30

I have the 'perfect' family a boy and a girl. Lots of shallow people used to harp on at me how 'lucky' l was - one of each, a pigeon pair etc etc. Must admit it genuinely used to baffle me and l only ever thought l was 'lucky' because l had two children, not because l had one of each.
I'll never forget a liitle boys face one day

Empusa · 22/06/2012 15:27

"People say things like 'typical boy' if they see behaviour in a boy that is not appropriate. Apparently bad behaviour is expected in a boy."

So for that reason you think you should be able to choose not to have a boy?

CaveMum · 22/06/2012 15:26

You have to remember that IVF stats are easily skewed. My fertility nurse told me that, should I need IVF (not quite there yet!) the odds of it bring successful ate very high because my eggs are healthy and DH has good sperm. My problem is that I do not ovulate regularly, so it is an issue of timing.

A lot of people undergoing IVF have pretty serious issues already, do their odds of conceiving are already lowered.

Psammead · 22/06/2012 15:24

Agree with the poster who said that the human race is bcoming too obsessed with control.

I think it is fine in cases where a boy or a girl might have a high chance of a genetic defect because of their sex. But just because someone wants one or the other - no.

BarredfromhavingStella · 22/06/2012 15:23

YABU-Really don't agree with gender selection, you should be happy to be blessed with any child no matter what sex it is IMHO & as others have said what if the child doesn't conform to it's gender anyway?? Hmm

Crazyfatmamma · 22/06/2012 15:22

What gives people the right to choose their childs gender, all children are precious. Why is there a need to control what gender a child is- does it really matter that much.

I personally think an element of vanity is involved- people believing that the perfect family is a boy and a girl, with people thinking they are missing out not having both sexes when they should appreciate the child/ren they have.

Society is becoming very much a society where I need, I want, I must is becoming more and more important to people, somethings in life we cant change and theres good reason for this.

As for the boys arent valued as much as girls comment I have found this to be very much the opposite in my case, a lot of men prefer sons initially, most of my friends wanted boys and my son was treated like a little prince by both mine and my husbands family.

DamselInTornDress · 22/06/2012 15:21

This craze took of in China because of a shortage of girls

JodieHarshHasALumpyPennie · 22/06/2012 15:20

I agree with Supergah and Exotic and...oh, yeah: everyone who thinks the idea of gender selection is like something out of a horror-satire on the consumer culture.

FFS.

WhenSheWasBadSheWasHorrid · 22/06/2012 15:19

isitme was thinking back to an article I read a few years ago. It was about more girls being born in the west possibly due to changes in eating habits.

Will see if I can find it somewhere.

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 15:16

I wonder how many people who say it's pefectly reasonable have ever felt how painful it is to be doing all you can month after month, year on year to conceive a child, just one, any gender, and for nothing to happen. That's real disappointment.

MrsSnow · 22/06/2012 15:16

IVF stats are 35% sucess rate.

MrsSnow · 22/06/2012 15:16

How about you look at China, where the age 20 male population is now so high there are few girls to marry/procreate with. They couldn't gender select but they did dump baby girls where in orphages/abort. The same in India.

In all seriousness, the people who are having IVF are desperate to have A baby. What happened to just wanting a happy, healthy baby?

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 15:15

It generally boils down to shopping and clothes-despite the fact that a DD may hate it-wouldn't consider shopping with mother and doesn't want to look pretty!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.