Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
CailinDana · 22/06/2012 16:34

Freckled - it's wrong because you are opening the floodgates for couples to select for other characteristics. People have already said on this thread "Well, couples choose not to have a child with a disability so..." If you can select for gender, then what's to stop people from selecting for other characteristics? The line has to be drawn somewhere.

CailinDana · 22/06/2012 16:32

Limeleaf I disagree with this opinion you gave:

"I think PGD should be legal, just because I think people should be free as far as possible to make their own decisions, rather than rely on the state to tell them what to do"

because in this case the decision doesn't just affect the people making it, it affects the child they're conceiving and society as a whole. In that case I think it is the responsibility of the state to step in and legislate.

Would you have the same opinion if the couple were selecting for skin colour or academic ability?

AnAirOfHope · 22/06/2012 16:30

The termination would be at 20+ weeks.

If you were that bothered just dont have kids or be gratful for what you have.

FreckledLeopard · 22/06/2012 16:30

Of course the 'wrong' gender isn't the same as a genetic abnormality. But, it's still within the same ball park of 'meddling' with nature, with introducing an element of control or choice over one's reproduction. Plenty of people thought that IVF was 'playing God' and were very against it back in the late 1970s. You'd be hard-pressed to find that reaction now.

If you choose to take the pill, choose when and how to conceive, choose whether to see a midwife and have check-ups, choose whether to have screening and then, if god forbid, something is wrong and a mother chooses to terminate a pregnancy or chooses to continue with it, then arguably you are 'meddling' with nature. Women had very little choice about reproduction until very recently. Now there are more choices.

I cannot see why someone choosing to have a child of one sex or another at the embryonic stage is wrong.

MrsHelsBels74 · 22/06/2012 16:29

I disagree about girl preference thing, everyone in my family was delighted we had a boy last time, they're delighted we're having a boy this time. I had about 5 microseconds of disappointment number 2 wasn't a girl because I thought one of each would be 'nice' (for want of a better word) but now just want another healthy, happy baby. We're probably going to stop at 2 so I'll never have a daughter but it doesn't matter.

And I don't understand why having a daughter means you won't be a mil or did I skim that a bit quickly & misread it?

exoticfruits · 22/06/2012 16:29

I have 3 boys and so if I was to have had a 4th then a girl would have been nice BUT I would only have done it on the full understanding that it was just as likely to be a boy.If I couldn't have been excited about the birth of another baby, who turned out to be a boy, then I wouldn't have gone ahead.

AnAirOfHope · 22/06/2012 16:27

I was offered a gendet scan and a termination if i had a girl because of my husbands condition.

we declined both and had a son first time. The secong pg we found out i was having a girl. I wasnt bothered i one way or the other i wanted to know if i could you sons old clothes or if it was going to cost me more money!

LimeLeafLizard · 22/06/2012 16:26

Awhistlingwoman i am so sorry for the loss of your daughter. Gosh how well-intended but thoughtless comments must hurt you.

Memoo · 22/06/2012 16:26

I have 1ds and 2dd's. I honestly cannot understand why people prefer one sex over the other. Can somebody explain it to me please?

I'm getting increasingly frustrated at today's society where some people seem to think they should have everything they want.

OP, you have been fortunate enough to have 3 babies and yet youre still not happy! It seriously fucked up.

SCOTCHandWRY · 22/06/2012 16:25

I still think it's wrong to select your baby's gender based on anything other than medical reasons, but why has the OP gone straight to PGD? Why not good old sperm-sorting? TRILLS, both can be used together actually, sperm sort first, then fertilise and genetic test each embryo.

Journey · 22/06/2012 16:24

I understand where the op is coming from but don't agree with gender selection unless it is for medical reasons. I have a DD after three DS. My DD has completed my family. It is lovely being able to experience the joy of bringing up a girl as well as boys. Perhaps she will be a tomboy, will hate shopping, dislike pink etc but it doesn't matter because she is my DD with her own personality and preferences.

Sometimes I think a little compassion is needed. I wish you all the very best op and if you do have a 4th child I hope you have your DD. Don't let people make you feel guilty for wanting a DD. They're your feelings.

By the way I love all my children equally and although I'm delighted to have my DD boys are wonderful!

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 16:21

Some of the comments on this thread make my skin crawl.

LimeLeafLizard · 22/06/2012 16:20

Like the OP, I have three beautiful healthy sons, and am pg with DC4. If I could choose, I would slightly prefer a daughter, just because it would be interesting to see whether it is different to having my sons. Probably not much.

I think PGD should be legal, just because I think people should be free as far as possible to make their own decisions, rather than rely on the state to tell them what to do. I agree that it isn't particularly desirable though, and I wouldn't have it myself. It would feel very disrespectful to undertake IVF purely to select gender when some of my friends have had to endure the cost and the heartache of IVF to have a child at all.

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 16:20

"anyone that decides to have any kind of pre-natal screening with a view to determining abnormalities is automatically putting themselves in a position where they may not accept what they're given"

And the "wrong" gender is, of course, the same thing as a genetic abnormality that will lead to a short and painful life Hmm

SCOTCHandWRY · 22/06/2012 16:18

Barbarianmum - yes, a HISTORY of repression based on sex, gender, race, religion and class discrimination - hopefully we are indeed more civilised and less discriminatory here, now, than in the past. There is more work to be done, of course.

There are still plenty of regimes in the world where, for example being gay, or female, or the wrong religion put your actual life at risk - am I not allowed to suggest MY country is more civilized than those countries?

I think one of the biggest differences between "the West" and most of these other countries is the autonomy of the individual - here, the INDIVIDUAL is seen as the controller of their own choice, master of their own destiny, they control the state (through democracy)...... in other places? State/country/leaders are seen as the entities which control individuals, who have little power or control.

FreckledLeopard · 22/06/2012 16:17

YANBU - gender selection is legal in the United States and I don't believe this has led to any kind of imbalance of genders (though am happy for someone to correct me if they have access to stats).

I understand people saying that if you decide to have a child, you take a risk and get what you're given. Having said that, things aren't so black-and-white, because anyone that decides to have any kind of pre-natal screening with a view to determining abnormalities is automatically putting themselves in a position where they may not accept what they're given. I have absolutely no experience of anyone in that situation and do not pretend to understand the anguish of discovering pre-natal issues. However, I think it's disingenuous to claim that you must accept the gender of a child if you don't have to accept other elements that a child might have (e.g. genetic disorder, cleft palate etc).

I think, too, there is a difference between aborting children of an 'unwanted' gender and 'creating' children of a wanted gender. The latter would normally be undertaken where certain genders had already been born and the opposite was wanted. Alternatively, if one could guarantee that a first born child would be male (in India, say), then if the next child was female, perhaps they would be kept and given birth to, rather than aborted, since a male heir had already been produced?

NarkedRaspberry · 22/06/2012 16:16

YABU. Totally.

PandaWatch · 22/06/2012 16:15

"There are far more prospects in life for women nowadays than men."

What on Earth are you talking about?!

Bartusmaeus · 22/06/2012 16:15

"There are far more prospects in life for women nowadays than men."

Hmm

Really?

CailinDana · 22/06/2012 16:11

It's illegal to abort on the basis of sex? Since when? Surely you could just have an abortion anyway and not say why?

JosephineCD · 22/06/2012 16:10

Unfortunately I think it will happen, whether or not it is illegal. You can't stop science from moving on. And I do think there is a preference towards girls in the West (or in Britain, at least). There are far more prospects in life for women nowadays than men.

ReallyTired · 22/06/2012 16:07

"why has the OP gone straight to PGD? Why not good old sperm-sorting?"

Sperm sorting is not 100% accurate and its illegal to abort on the basis of sex.

Trills · 22/06/2012 16:05

I still think it's wrong to select your baby's gender based on anything other than medical reasons, but why has the OP gone straight to PGD? Why not good old sperm-sorting?

ReallyTired · 22/06/2012 16:05

Gender disappointment is a very taboo subject in the UK. Many people don't understand why someone is a disappointed with a healthy beautiful baby. However people are disappointed in their children for all kinds of irrational reasons. I think that those with gender disappointment need councelling rather than gender selection.

Picking an embryo who isn't going to die a horrible death at an early age is not the same as choose a girl or boy.

I have one boy and one girl and I love them both. My little girl is a bit of a tom boy and doesn't do pink. Prehaps its not right for me to say gender selection is wrong when I have never experienced gender disappointment.

HipHopGorilla · 22/06/2012 16:01

If you're serious why don't you go abroad for treatment? I'm pretty sure if you research you will find clinics that will offer this service.

If you think going abroad is too expensive / too much hassle then you need to consider whether IVF is actually for you - as hassle, stress and expense are basically the 3 words I would use to describe it.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread