Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that gender selection should be legalised in the uk?

413 replies

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 22/06/2012 14:05

I have three glorious boys. I would love to have a girl as well.

I really don't understand why PGD for gender selection is illegal in the UK. I completely accept that it should not be funded through the nhs, but can not see why couples can not pay privately.

You are not choosing eye colour etc, simply the gender of your child to balance your family dynamic.

If ivf couples are allowed to pick/choose/freeze embryos, why is PGD illegal?

Aibu to think that it should be legal in this country? I would not be trying to create a 'superior race', just balance our family with a girl - a daughter for me and DH and a sister for my sons.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sickofatrocity · 01/12/2023 13:17

People tend to want more boys than girls. It would upset the balance.

Hobnobswantshernameback · 01/12/2023 13:14

THIS THREAD IS 11 YEARS OLD!!

Heidi1976 · 01/12/2023 13:11

Besides for medical purposes (if there is a gender dominant life affecting illness that runs in the family) then no. The population is split 50/50 (ish) for a reason, we start messing with that then unnatural inequalities can arise and we don't know what the repercussions of that would be.

redalex261 · 01/12/2023 09:07

No.

LauraHowe · 01/12/2023 08:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

uniofyorkstudent · 06/02/2014 15:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AnitaBlake · 27/06/2012 20:04

Goodness! What an interesting viewpoint some people have! My matriarchal line doesn't carry boys. We'd all love a boy. In four generations and a total of 13 kids, two are male. That's a family imbalance! My Nana had one brother (2sisters), no sons, and one grandson. Between my sister and I we've so far produced three girls. I would love the one I'm carrying to be a boy, for my grandad as much as anything else. But it isn't going to happen. I'm sure I'm carrying a girl. I wouldn't change it for the world.

I'm the sciency geek. I don't think I can carry boys without danger to my health tbh. There's a reason we have girls. Tbh if I could choose anything, o wouldn't choose the sex. I would choose fir my baby to have my eye colour. DH gas brown eyes, so it's likely my babies will too.

And that's where the danger lies. Where do you stop? A blue-eyed baby would give my family balance.

But I honestly don't care what I get so long as its a viable baby. My preference is for one that lives, pink, blue or bloody green I honestly don't care. And that, in my very humble opinion is how it should be.

exoticfruits · 27/06/2012 19:07

Based on my experience, I'd be surprised if men truly are biased in favour of girl babies.

I think that a lot of men want boys -they think they will be able to bond and do 'boyish' things. Just as wrong as women wanting a girl. The boy may not share any interests with the father. The father may want someone to take to football and the son may have no interest whatsoever.

There are a whole lot of assumptions made DCs and what they will be like-lots of it totally wrong.

There was a thread on here once about someone complaining that their DH was dragging the whole family off at weekends to caravan in Wales and go sailing. It sounded lovely to me! However it brought forth masses of people who were very resentful of a childhood forced to follow the parents interests. You may think that you will have a sailing mad family and yet they may all hate it.

smokeandglitter · 27/06/2012 16:17

I don't know if that came out right, I don't for a moment suggest a slight preference towards one is a problem, but when it is causing such distress it can't be healthy.

smokeandglitter · 27/06/2012 16:16

LittleWhiteMice, that sounds very similar to the lady on the C4 Documentary '8 Boys and wanting a girl' who had a DC1 who died and kept trying to have another girl. I think it does support that being that set on gender is a psychological problem - it's causing distress to the person - and that they should try to work out with a counsellor what the root of the problem is. In those cases I would guess (of course not being that person I don't know) that losing a precious child would have had influence on their desire for a specific gender. It is such a sad situation to hear of, no child can replace another and we should not nurture that painful feeling in someone through legalising GPD but encourage them to get help with healing it.

LittleWhiteMice · 27/06/2012 14:40

on another website, which will remain nameless but is not netmums there was a lady who had 7 girls hoping for a boy to replace the first child she ever had who was boy, sadly he had died.

She was raising money to do gender selection, i cant imagine how all daughters felt, each time it was a dissapointment

smokeandglitter · 27/06/2012 14:07

I haven't read the whole thread, but I'm against most things that don't work as nature intended.

My parents (whom I love deeply) could not have children. They agreed that they did not want IVF and decided to adopt (I know this is a different process, not a comparison). During the process they were matched with a little girl, unfortunately she had a very strong family history of Schizophrenia and they decided they could not cope. They ended up being matched with and adopting me. I have developed severe Schizo-affective Disorder and they've managed wonderfully. I admire their choices and the fact that they have coped with something they did not believe they could. Smile

I understand the idea of selection on medical grounds, that is not really very different to abortion on medical grounds (in cases where a condition would cause a short and painful life). No one really knows exactly what they'd do in a situation like that until they're in it. However I deeply believe that gender selection is wrong for reasons of want. The fact my parents decided they could not cope with severe mental illness in a child, and yet managed to, I think shows both that what we imagine as our child's future may not come to be and that really once that child is in our care it does not matter what gender it is, whether it becomes ill and needs extra care or what the looks and personality are because we end up loving them for being them, we want the best for them whatever that is. Gender selection where a parent is desperate for a certain gender takes away from that unconditional love and that is - to me - wrong. OP, if you were a friend in real life I would urge you to attend a counsellor and find out why you desire a certain gender, what do you feel your missing?

I think using the United States for statistics of pgd swaying the usual number of boys/girls born is difficult because it hasn't been massively popular for a long time and the US is so big with so many different cultures varying in state to state that each could viably be taken as a country.

Sorry for the length of this post. I hope I haven't offended anyone, it wasn't the intention, and I send lots of love to those who have conceived and lost or are finding it difficult to conceive. From both mine and my family's experience I know the pain involved. xxx

5madthings · 27/06/2012 13:26

musicismylife i have re-read the post, i am not sure how it is patronising, rambly maybe! i was just commenting on the scans etc and aslo others have said they only know indian families etc with sons, or more sons than daughters and that my experience doesnt match that iyswim? tho its only anecdotal of course the family i know dont seem to have a preference, like i said i dont know them all that well as there is a language barrier, but well enough to smile and wave and they certainly dont seem to treat their girls any differently from their boy. yet some posters have stated they think there is a strong cultural preference and have seen it. i am sure there is in some places, my experience is not of that tho.

as i said i think sex selection is wrong unless on medical grounds and cant understand why you would do it, and i have 4 boys and then a girl, we always wanted 4 and were very lucky to have our 4 boys easily, no 5 was a bit of a bonus baby, not exactly planned, we didnt care what gender the baby was, just hoped it was as problem free as my others pregnancy/births had been.

anyway as i said i didnt mean it to be patronising, it was just a jumble of my thoughts/comments on the thread as it has progressed iyswim?

starfishmummy · 27/06/2012 13:08

I have a child with a disability. It affects boys so if I had known that I could select have a girl then my son would not be an only child.

Gender selection was at an early stage when he was born. My only option for subsequent children would have been to have early cvs testing to find the sex and then terminate if it was a boy.

musicismylife · 27/06/2012 13:06

5madthings Tue 26-Jun-12 21:22:33

There's something really fucking patronising about your post. I just can't put my finger on it..

LurkingAndLearningForNow · 27/06/2012 12:58

Thirded. How cruel. :(

musicismylife · 27/06/2012 12:57

mmmvanilla, I second you.

mmmvanilla · 27/06/2012 12:31

picnicbasketcase

''I have a DS and a DD. I would only want another child if it was another girl. So we will not be having a third child because you don't get to choose and I would hate to have a child if I ended up having any sense of disappointment or resentment about it.''

Gosh, your post has really upset and saddened me .
You already are disappointed in a child and resent it . If you truly appreciated and loved your children equally, why would you feel so strongly about only wanting a girl next time ? What has this boy done that made you feel you would definitely not want another one of his sex, you would resent it ?
It's shocking to be honest.

Mrsjay · 27/06/2012 12:09

I just don't understand why a certain sex is so important that a couple would go through all that just to get a boy/girl I have same sex children and i didnt think oh i wish she was a boy , this I want a girl so we can bond be best friends really irks me, my girls have a great relationship with their dad he didnt want boys and was happy that we had healthy children,

lilypainter · 27/06/2012 12:02

Sargesaweyes, I've said this before, but I'm not convinced that people in the west do side towards girls.

Yes, a lot of western women want girls - I think exoticfruits explanation about that is pretty accurate.

However, I work in engineering, mostly with men, and when their wives or girlfriends get pregnant, most of them say that they hope the baby will be a boy. Some of them say that they don't mind as long as it's healthy, but I can't recall any colleagues who don't already have a son saying they hope it's a girl. I've even heard men at work saying to male colleagues who've just had daughters things like 'Bad luck it's a girl, are you disappointed?'

I'd be interested to hear whether all the people convinced that the west is biased towards girl babies are hearing 'I want a girl' comments from both men and women. Based on my experience, I'd be surprised if men truly are biased in favour of girl babies.

Katz · 27/06/2012 11:36

That's an interesting article from Canada and wonder what effect a 30 week wait until finding out the babes sex woud have.

If you want 100% accuracy then I think an amino gives you ths and it an be one earlier but it's not without it's own risks.

I still can't believe that there are people who would consider intrusive medical treatment over the good old fashioned way of making a baby just to get a girl or boy.

5madthings · 27/06/2012 11:04

yes Mrsjay they do gender selection if a specific sex is going to have a genetic condition as there are some conditions that only affect boys or vice versa and for medical reasons like that then fine but as you say purely for the sake of a boy over a girl, where will it stop? and it really is not an easy or simple process to go through either, it has many risks, its invasive and draining emotionally and it may not even work! you only have to go and look at the infertility threads to see the stress that some posters are under trying iui and ivf etc, why you would put yourself through that just to get a particular sex child i have no idea, to get A BABY, any baby as its the only way you can then hell yes, but to do it to 'balance' your family you are having a bloody laugh!

Mrsjay · 27/06/2012 10:38

gender selection is available in the uk ( I think) but it is used for genetic conditions not so you can chose your children to order, I know gender dissapointment must be difficult for parents, but once you start choosing girls over boys you will be looking for hair colour height etc, I dont think children should be designed ,

AnastasiaSteele · 27/06/2012 10:30

Another one astounded by people thinking a child is something to be chosen in a particular colour. Either is a blessing. If I closed my eyes and imagine a baby, it's a girl - I assume that's because i'm a girl and I have a sister and that's what I identify with/as. But when I love a man, the idea of having a son with him or seeing how some boys are with their mums and mums are with their boys makes me like the idea of that too.

I also don't get this 'family dynamic' thing and 'pigeon pair' malarkey works. I'm sure one of each is lovely but so are all of one sex too. So my parents weren't 'lucky' to get one of each - a world without my little sister? No thanks! That said, if I'd had a brother instead, I wouldn't have known any different and that might have been nice too.

Sargesaweyes · 27/06/2012 08:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.