Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that 'blasting' a whistle, down the phone, into the ear of someone in a call centre is abusive?

211 replies

twinklingfairy · 14/06/2012 20:08

An old school friend has delightedly put this as her status. That her husband had the whistle ready and BLAST = call centre caller with tinitus, lol ??
How is that funny!?
My DH had someone scream into his ear, as a teenager, and has tinitus to this day. That's over 20yrs later!
I wrote a reply giving this story but omitting that it was my DH and was told to , calm down. She has been putting up with the abuse of the constant call for months etc. And that she had suffered it herself, after a rock concert.
hmm not quite the same, I think, as having a high pitch put straight into your ear that could abuse Long Term damage.
But it would seem I am a kill joy Hmm
DH says leave it, but I can't help feeling very angry on his behalf. Not to mention the poor soul, though I don't deny the calls are annoying, no one deserves abuse like that when it could cause lasting problems.

OP posts:
ChopstheDuck · 15/06/2012 15:18

I don't really have a lot of sympathy for call center staff. They CHOOSE to do that job. I get 6-7 calls a day for sales. I am registered with the TPS. I've tried saying no thank you, I've asked them to desist. I told one woman I was eating my dinner, and she simply said this won't take long and STILL launched into her sales spiel. It wouldn't be so bad if staff were taught or permitted to take no for an answer, and not continually repeat calling.

With my phone I can reject the calls. With the landline I have to either answer it or keep listening to it ringing until it goes to answerphone. I get sick of it. If I pick up and immediately drop it they STILL call back.

So, while I wouldn't go as far as a whistle, but after one company called me every day for a fortnight, I answered the phone and turned the he oover on. Unlikely to cause damage like a whistle, I shouldn't think, but they didn't call back again.

Birdsgottafly · 15/06/2012 15:15

"We screen all our calls via answerphone"

The phone still rings though ,so if you are on nights, or working, you are still disturbed.

I had a cold call at 7.30am, it would be illegal to knock on my door to canvass at that time, so what is the difference?

NoOnesGoingToEatYourEyes · 15/06/2012 15:14

HoneyDragon that is awful. I hope you didn't drop the charges against them.

LapisBlue · 15/06/2012 15:13

The trouble is, Celia - they will simply keep calling ad nauseam if you do that.

Birdsgottafly · 15/06/2012 15:12

"It's not subjective, it is intention to cause pain and discomfort to another human"

Whilst i don't agree with blowing whistle's down the phone, i have worked in call centre's, there should be a better system of stopping these, all together.

I am doing a lot of work from home and i am plagued with calls from oversea's companies, that i know are a scam, so these people are phoning me with the intent of misleading me and in some cases of committing an illegal act, there shouldbe new laws implemented to cover this.

I deal with very vulberable people, who are at risk of being taken in by these companies.

1950sHousewife · 15/06/2012 15:12

Although I don't condone what this person did, I can go part way to understanding the frustration. We were constantly plagued with cold calls from abroad (crackling phone line etc). Goodness knows what list we were on because we were on the TPS list.

It got to the point where the calls were coming several times a day, at any time of day or night, waking up DD (PFB!). I at one point lost it totally with a perfectly pleasant chap asking if I wanted to upgrade my mobile.

Personally, I think cold calling is like someone ringing your doorbell at all hours of the day. It can become really intrusive, so I can imagine why some people crack. (again, not saying I condone doing this)

CeliaFate · 15/06/2012 15:11

We screen all our calls via answerphone. Job done!

LapisBlue · 15/06/2012 15:08

OK, listen up. I'm an ex call centre specialist.

No one needs to get cold calls. You simply register on the Telephone Preference Service (put it into Google) and you can list your home and mobile numbers. What it means is that all companies doing cold calling have to check all numbers against TPS on a monthly basis to weed out those that have removed themselves from receiving cold calls.

If they DO call you, they can be fined a considerable amount of money. Simply CALMLY tell them that you are on the Telephone Preference Service and they will end the call.

No need to blow a whistle - in fact, that is indeed assault.

Don't be sarcastic, leave the phone on the hook, or whatever silly tricks people try - they will simply diarise the call again.

However:

It takes about a month before the calls stop

Overseas call centres seem to get round this

Crappy fly-by-night companies sometimes bypass this check.

HoneyDragonWearingLederhosen · 15/06/2012 14:53

One of the very cool parts of my job, was occasionally calling people to tell them we were in fact in possession of a lot of money belonging to them. Genuinely there's and no fees to us involved.

One of my staff had a whistle blown. I called the lady in question back, she did it to me. I persevered holding the phone away whilst my colleague was still crying. Before confirming it was who I was looking for so I could send her a letter if she wouldn't confirm DPA she demanded my details. I gave my full name and company address, she and a male then threatened to come and stab me and hopefully kill me.

We followed protocol and called the police. The police went the next day. Charges were pressed, two days later she called me having received the letter stating she was due £2500. She also got fined and a criminal record. She called us wanting her money and us not to continue the case as she was a nursery worker.

I realise it's frustrating. The woman's reasoning was she was ex directory so she thought anyone she didn't know calling her was breaking the law. But it is assault.

It's not subjective, it is intention to cause pain and discomfort to another human.

grimbletart · 15/06/2012 14:38

I would never do that. It's bang out of order.

But so is cold calling. It is unasked for, unwarranted, intrusive and bloody annoying, especially when they unerringly manage to call just as I have put the dinner on the table. I am TPS registered but still get calls. When I say I am TPS registered a new trick lately is to say something like "Oh, your TPS must have run out because you have to keep renewing it". That is a lie. The first time this happened I checked with TPS who confirmed it was a lie and said we can report to them any firm that tries that tack and they will follow it up. Which I now do. I also tell these firms that they are on a black list as I never buy anything firms who cold call.

LemarchandsBox · 15/06/2012 14:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

bemybebe · 15/06/2012 14:33

I was on TPS and MPS for years and it did not stop nuisance calls at all.

We had to endure anything from solar panels sales to ppi companies and they are really persistent. Told them many times "no interest" and politely put the phone down only to have another member of their staff calling several days later. Finally tracked down the marketing company that was selling my details, which came from The White Company (cancelled the catalogue immediately) and Experian. I am happy to name those companies because I have confirmation that they were selling my details to the said company in writing.

I would not whistle down the phone at anyone, but does my heart bleeds for these people? ...ummm, nope.

LurkingAndLearningForNow · 15/06/2012 14:31

Bad people do bad things. :( How heartless of her.

mumtoone123 · 15/06/2012 14:30

jaquelinehyde that's terrible Angry

habbibu · 15/06/2012 14:29

Whistle vile. Giving phone to toddler (not screaming) ok. I just tell them they have the wrong number.

ethelb · 15/06/2012 14:26

oh OP, there was a similar thread last year with a women who complained about the way she was treated by the people she cold called and she got crucified.

YANBU and some people are vile and other vile people will defend them

I wonder what halo-worthy jobs/past times other posters on here have?

jaquelinehyde · 15/06/2012 14:23

Oh and it is quite clearly abuse as it results in the physical harm of another person. I don't get why some people can't understand this.

jaquelinehyde · 15/06/2012 14:22

I have had this done to me, I was off work for weeks as I became temporarily deaf in my right ear. 15 years later and I still get bouts of tinitus.

Anyone who does this or condones it is a complete and utter cunt.

I suppose some people will be condoning stabbing chuggers next!

Ormiriathomimus · 15/06/2012 14:15

BTW TPS does work quite well.

Moving house also seems to work but quite an expensive solution....

mumtoone123 · 15/06/2012 14:14

Well said NoOnesGoingToEatYourEyes

Ormiriathomimus · 15/06/2012 14:13

"The problem with just saying 'no thanks' or putting the phone down is that it doesn't stop the same companies from calling. They phone back, even when you ask them to remove your number from their system"

And the problem with blowing a whistle down the phone at someone means they will still have your number and to top that they may well decide to prosecute you. Much better solution Hmm

NoOnesGoingToEatYourEyes · 15/06/2012 14:11

We are also ex-directory and registered with the TPS.

And we also still get some calls, usually after using a comparison site for insurance or whatever, because even when you think you have ticked all the boxes they have usually hidden another one somewhere and you miss it.

It has never once crossed my mind to blow a whistle at the people making those calls and it never will because it's a vicious thing to do that only a total shit would seriously contemplate, let alone actually do. I can't believe that people on this thread are saying they would do it.

mumtoone123 · 15/06/2012 14:08

YANBU - it's a dreadful thing to do to anyone, I don't believe anyone on here really would do anything so awful.
Tinnitus is horrible and that whistle would cause pain as well

Think the fb friend should be shown this thread as a fuck you and farewell Grin

Krumbum · 15/06/2012 13:47

Being exdirectory is irrelevant. They don't get the numbers from the telephone book. The numbers are bought from companies that you have signed up with for other reasons, eg you sign up to a catalogue and don't tick the small print then that company sell that data to telemarketers.

SusanneLinder · 15/06/2012 13:45

I briefly worked as a cold caller. One lad I worked with had a whistle blown in his ear. The whistle blower got lots of taxis and pizza deliveries that day.

And I am sure that the taxi company and pizza place whose time and money that was wasted in a pathetic tit for tat was very grateful.Angry

I am fed up with unsolicited calls.I am ex directory, hardly anyone has my number, I decline all marketing and am on TPS and I STILL get disturbed. I start off polite, but I find them harder to shift. I am also fed up of them telling me that the TPS doesnt apply to them Hmm. I do get rude at that point.

I want peace in my own home to eat dinner/watch TV without being subjected to surveys/eejits trying to sell me something I don't need/want/care less about.

I wouldn't ever blow a whistle down the phone, but let me tell you, I HAVE been tempted :o (joking)