Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that 'blasting' a whistle, down the phone, into the ear of someone in a call centre is abusive?

211 replies

twinklingfairy · 14/06/2012 20:08

An old school friend has delightedly put this as her status. That her husband had the whistle ready and BLAST = call centre caller with tinitus, lol ??
How is that funny!?
My DH had someone scream into his ear, as a teenager, and has tinitus to this day. That's over 20yrs later!
I wrote a reply giving this story but omitting that it was my DH and was told to , calm down. She has been putting up with the abuse of the constant call for months etc. And that she had suffered it herself, after a rock concert.
hmm not quite the same, I think, as having a high pitch put straight into your ear that could abuse Long Term damage.
But it would seem I am a kill joy Hmm
DH says leave it, but I can't help feeling very angry on his behalf. Not to mention the poor soul, though I don't deny the calls are annoying, no one deserves abuse like that when it could cause lasting problems.

OP posts:
MirandaGoshawk · 15/06/2012 20:00

Pseudonym - so that's OK then. Reminds me of the school that told a parent her child wasn't being bullied because they have an anti-bullying policy.

SardineQueen · 15/06/2012 19:55

YANBU what an utterly shitty thing to do to someone.

And because they've got headphones on they won't be able to get them off quickly.

Of course it can cause temporary or permanent damage to hearing Confused obvious isn't it.

Pseudonym99 · 15/06/2012 19:34

Blowing a whistle down the phone wouldn't harm the person on the other end, as the equipment wouldn't be capable of reproducing sound at a volume to do harm. If it does to harm, it is the employer's fault for putting their workers in danger, rather than the person defending themselves by blowing the whistle.

tuffie · 15/06/2012 19:34

Agree with misslinnet. I have a great respect for people who are prepared to do a horrible job rather than claim unemployment benefit. Their persistence is because they are under huge pressure to get sales.
I think anybody who is rude to them ought to spend a day doing the job themselves.

HoneyDragonWearingLederhosen · 15/06/2012 19:19

A very effective way to get rid and taken off call lists, is to say you are in the profession of what they are selling. Especially the poi calls from abroad. Simply state firmly you are a financial advisor and you specialise in PPI etc. they always hang up straight away.

Tell window sellers your other halfs a window fitter or your dad does lift insulation. They never call back.

monkeymoma · 15/06/2012 19:08

YANBU it is deliberately causing physical pain/damage

noone deserves that at work!

maybenow · 15/06/2012 19:08

last one i answered last week because i was expecting a call - he starts with 'is that mrs marriedname?' now i know it's already a cold call as i dont' use my married name so i say 'no' but still he blusters through starts with 'how long is it since you had your kitchen redone' would you say your bathroom or kitchen were older' 'if you won a free bathroom or kitchen which would you choose'?
they do not and will not say what their actual proposition is. they try to keep you on for as long as possible before you can actually say 'no' to anything.. by relying on the fact that you don't wnat to be rude. It's not the individual speaking, it's 'the script' but you don't get to speak to the script writer and it is all designed to take advantage of social niceities and our reluctance to be rude.. people say 'there's no excuse to be rude' but that's what these companies rely on. I do not want the product and there's zero chance i'll buy anything from a cold caller but I also do not want to wait five to ten minutes waiting to be told the proposition to which i can say no.

ChopstheDuck · 15/06/2012 19:05

Ok, but even if you say that the call Center worker has no choice but to be there, do they REALLY have to be so rude, and persistent? They soon stop when you do take action, so why not be a little more polite to begin with, before it gets to the stage when people do get that frustrated they resort to such measures.

If I could answer the phone, be told directly what they want and then give a yes or no, or it's not convenient to talk, and for the cold callers to listen to tha,t, I'd be happy! It's the eprsistsnce and rudeness that pisses people off, and then they don't really deserve sympathy, no!

maybenow · 15/06/2012 19:02

redpanda - we checked again last week that we are on TPS and we definitely are. it seemed to work for a year or two but we've been on the same number now for 5-6yrs and somehow a load of companies have our number. i don't want to have to keep changing it to avoid them. as i said i'd like to use the number for my at-home business but i'm too scared to as then i'd have to actually answer rather than let the answer machine get them. as it is the answer machine does get them and we erase about six 'silent' calls which are definitely not people we know per week.

ravenAK · 15/06/2012 18:55

Hate call centres. Horrible shitty places that make people do a shitty job that involves inflicting unsolicited shit on other people whilst being treated like shit.

No need to blast a whistle at some poor desperate sod trying to earn a crust. I tell them I have TPS. If they persist, I hand the phone to dd2 (four). She loves talking to god botherers & conservatory salesbods.

LineRunner · 15/06/2012 18:46

One of the businesses mooted in final of The Apprentice was a massive call centre.

redpanda13 · 15/06/2012 18:46

I registered with TPS due to a spate of cold calls. I have had none in over a year since doing it. Handful of texts to my mobile since then too. Same with anyone else I know who has done it. I don't believe people are still getting called night and day have really registered with them.

misslinnet · 15/06/2012 18:32

To all the people saying call centre staff deserve abuse because they choose to work there in the first place -

There's not always much choice. An article I read in a local paper last year said that about 1 in 20 people in my region work in call centres. We had the highest unemployment rate in England between Jan and March this year, and unemployment is likely to rise as the public sector starts to cut jobs, given that they're one of the biggest employers round here.

Realistically, a lot of these call centre staff have a choice between staying at the call centre and going on the dole.

AlpinePony · 15/06/2012 18:13

No, but if someone says "I'm going to keep calling you until... " - it doesn't take a genius to join the dots.

  1. I rarely answer the phone.
  2. Unlike a vast majority on mn, I don't campaign to abuse minimum wage employees or get them fired.
ariadne1 · 15/06/2012 18:02

Not everyone has caller display

AlpinePony · 15/06/2012 17:55

If you know it's "them", why on earth do you answer the phone? :S

ariadne1 · 15/06/2012 17:55

We are registered with TPs and still get at least half a dozen cold calls a day.Nobody with any sense of decency would work as a cold caller.

whathaveiforgottentoday · 15/06/2012 17:37

my mum had a caller 2 weeks ago that she very politely told that she wasn't interested in answering his questions. He replied that she might as well answer them as he would be ringing back until she did!
He then rang back about 5 times to which she got progressively less polite each time. I picked up the last call and was very abusive down the phone laying it on heavy about elderly mother having to get up and answer phone blah blah blah and that there was no way we would answer any of his questions ever. After that I did suggest if he rang again that she should whistle down the phone but luckily that was the last call. I think that would have been fair enough as he was harassing my mum. but I would not suggest whistling down the phone normally and certainly haven't ever done it but I have putt he phone on people before mainly because they won't let you ask a question. I normally ask what company they are calling from and if they don't answer me because they are following their script, I put the phone down.

jaquelinehyde · 15/06/2012 17:10

For those of you who don't think blowing a whistle down the phone causes damage to the ear/hearing can you please pop along to my Doctors and the ENT department at my local hospital and let them know as they are obviously wrong and you are right.

My ear damage must have just been a total coincidence, silly me!

I have many, many years of experience of working on the phones. Some in cold calling but most on helplines etc and I cannot begin to tell you how disgusting some people are, the rudeness, nastiness and down right aggressiveness of people.

I have dealt with everything from death threats to suicidal callers and will never be shocked by what some people feel is acceptable behaviour.

DilysPrice · 15/06/2012 16:49

Obviously lots of people are saying that this is a dreadful thing to do to people who are just doing their (very annoying) jobs, and actually a criminal offence, and I agree.

Would you be ok doing it to people who are actual thieves? Where do we stand on that?
Of course the problem is that every now and then people do ring up like the PP to offer "too good to be true" deals that sound like scams but aren't. And some callers (like the PPI, and the mobile phone companies) tread a fine line between legal and fraudulent.
But the "Microsoft" people who are 100%, no shadow of a doubt, in the act of attempting a crime against you personally (which the UK police have a negligible chance of prosecuting them for). Would you go as far as assault?

maybenow · 15/06/2012 16:37

funkybuddah - people are saying 'don't be rude to them', imo putting the phone down is rude... imo they set up the "script" with no closed questions and no room to say 'no' so that you can't be anything but rude.

AlpinePony · 15/06/2012 16:29

Yanbu, it's a horrible thing to do and there can be no defence.

ChopstheDuck · 15/06/2012 16:24

Because half the time, they then call straight back!

funkybuddah · 15/06/2012 16:17

Why do you need them to stop talking/to say no thank you? You can just hang up you know, you don't have to say anything to them at all.

LapisBlue · 15/06/2012 16:16

bit of rogue comma there, for some reason.

Swipe left for the next trending thread