Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be a bit cross about the Playmobil Nativity set?

66 replies

Clawdy · 30/11/2011 22:14

Have just bought it,and really like it,sure DCs will too. But surely it should include the Three Kings? Apparently they have to be bought separately! Just not on.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustifiedAncientOfMuMu · 08/12/2023 18:25

Aw I was on this thread. My DD is at college now!

We still have the nativity scene, but my youngest isn't really into playmobil, so it's rather unloved and I don't think we even set it up last year. Maybe this year for old times sake...

ScrollingLeaves · 08/12/2023 15:38

No I was never on the thread but just came across it by sure chance. I think it was magical!

I especially loved the appeal to someone mathematical to work out how many playmobil king footsteps to a human footstep in order to work out how long it would take them to travel like the human kings!

SnowMuchToBits · 08/12/2023 08:36

We also still have just the one camel! Although an awful lot more Playmobil than we had then. Ds finally outgrew it as a teenager, but I use it to make scenes myself now! Xmas Grin

Clawdy · 08/12/2023 08:30

I did add the Three Kings to the collection (I started the thread, years ago!) Still only one camel though! 😀

OP posts:
SoMuchToBits · 08/12/2023 08:17

Thank you for resurrecting this thread @ScrollingLeaves ! Can't believe it was 12 years ago. Were you on it (under a different name)? I was under a seasonal name change (SnowMuchToBits). I still get our Playmobil nativity out every year, even though ds is now 23...

ScrollingLeaves · 07/12/2023 23:19

I know this is twelve years later but what a lovely thread this was.

hackmum · 05/12/2011 13:54

I don't want to rain on anyone's parade, but historical evidence shows us that there was never any census at around that time that required people to visit their home town to register. I mean, think about it: what a daft way to carry out a census.

GrendelsMum · 05/12/2011 12:01

What an interesting thread! And I'm pleased to see that other children are as pedantic as we used to be about everyone arriving at the stable at the right time. Our Magi travelled around the house to arrive on the Ephiphany, and we moved them to a different location every night. Because we were little pedants, we agreed that they were the Magi from two years before, now arriving.

Speaking of little Biblical pedants, was anyone else always outraged as a child about Jesus running off to the temple without telling his parents where he was going?

DandyDan · 05/12/2011 11:36

We have both sets, but it's annoying that they are sold separately. The main set represents the story as Luke told it (although he didn't mention oxen or donkeys), and the supplementary set is Matthew's bit about the Magi.
The problem with Bethlehem was that, although Joseph had family connections there, no-one would put them up. The word we translate as "inn" is 'katalumen' which means 'guest room' which is the same word used for the "Upper Room" that Jesus uses for the Last Supper: it's the only two uses of that word in the gospels. They were not given room at his relatives' homes essentially, probably because of the dubious situation concerning Mary's pregnancy. This was shown well in the Tony Jordan Nativity that was on the BBC last year.

The Magi arrived at their home in Nazareth once they were back in their home-town after the flight to Egypt.

NoHaudinMaWheest · 05/12/2011 11:15

Clawdy No the nativity set stays up until Candlemas (2nd February) which celebrates the Presentation of Jesus in the temple 40 days after the birth. This fits with the church calendar though not necessarily with the biblical accounts - if you can put them into a strictly chronological order.

aldiwhore · 05/12/2011 10:55

They had to go to Bethlehem for the census, Joseph was orginally from Bethlehem.

I'm originally from Devon but if I had to return there for a census, I'd have to stay in a hotel.

Makes sense to me.

belgo · 05/12/2011 10:53

Love this thread.

My dd1 is being very pedantic and keeps on confiscating the playmobil baby Jesus because he is not born yetXmas Grin

earlyriser · 05/12/2011 10:34

You learn something new everyday!

I knew i should have gone with Playmobil, our lego one so far has produced a baddie, a policeman with handcuffs, a snow ball launcher (at least i think that is what it is- snow'balls' are actually cylindrical) and 2 sides to the police station, complete with bars on the window!

Hmmmm, how is this in any way related to christmas???

WTAF · 05/12/2011 10:30

The way I would read that is that they were originally from Bethlehem,

Then why did they need to stay in an inn? If they lived in Bethlehem they could have just gone home.

hackmum · 05/12/2011 10:25

We have a Playmobil nativity set and it does include the three wise men. However, we bought it several years ago, so perhaps Playmobil are being cheapskates?

AKMD · 05/12/2011 10:24

FairPhyllis sorry but that doesn't quite stack up. If Joseph & Mary were originally from Bethlehem then why did they have to stay at an inn/stable?

Clawdy · 05/12/2011 10:21

But, MillyR surely the day after Epiphany the whole set is put away for another year? They hardly see the baby!Sad

OP posts:
MillyR · 05/12/2011 10:14

My parents had wise men figures out at Christmas, but put in a different part of the room. They were not allowed near the Holy Family until Epiphany.

In fact my mum now has a nativity set in the garden, and the wise men are placed at the other end of the garden.

FairPhyllis · 05/12/2011 09:55

Question for theologians: Why were Mary and Joseph still in Bethlehem 2 years later. I thought thy just nipped there to sign the census or whatever. Why hadn't they gone back to Nazereth?

Luke is the only gospel that says Mary and Joseph were originally from Nazareth and travelled to Bethlehem for a census. Matthew just says that Jesus was born in Bethlehem and then has the family settling in Nazareth after they returned from Egypt. Matthew doesn't say anything about a stable or shepherds either - those are only in Luke.

The way I would read that is that they were originally from Bethlehem, left for Egypt during Herod's persecution and when they returned decided to go to Galilee instead of Judea (where Bethlehem is) because a) people in Judea might realise Jesus had escaped the massacre b) if they didn't know anyone in Galilee they would escape the stigma of Mary having been pregnant out of wedlock.

The account in Luke could come from a source for Luke knowing that Jesus grew up in Nazareth but was born in Bethlehem, trying to reconcile the two, and deciding the most plausible story was that Joseph had travelled down for the census, but getting it wrong. This would explain why the date of the census doesn't fit - it was in 6AD, whereas Jesus must have been born before Herod's death in 4BC.

SnowMuchToBits · 04/12/2011 00:26

I think our Playmobil wise men took turns on the camel.......

Maybe we should order another couple of camels a spare parts..........

We had noted the donkey problem though - and the corresponding camel problem. All the people who are supposed to ride on donkeys/camels have either long dresses or long robes/cloaks which prevent them from doing so. Never mind, NormanTheForeman has hitched a ride on our camel, so it has not been wasted! Grin

Kladdkaka · 01/12/2011 14:00

Damn. Didn't factor in the night-time walking ...

NorfolkNChance · 01/12/2011 13:59

Best quote today:

Therefore I deduce that the wise men in fact lived in the house next door to the stable and really need to invest in a better sat nav.

Grin
Kladdkaka · 01/12/2011 13:58

Well average walking speed is 2.8 mph. Assuming they walked an 8 hour working day, that's 22.4 miles per day. 2 years is 730 days. A day off for packing leaves 729 days. Actual distance covered is 16,352 miles. The tropic of cancer is approx 23,000 miles long. The arctic circle is approx 10,000 miles long. And Nazareth is sort of mid way between these 2 points. Therefore I deduce that the wise men in fact lived in the house next door to the stable and really need to invest in a better sat nav.

So playmobil wise men can be by the stable but facing the wrong direction and looking confused.

sarahfreck · 01/12/2011 13:54

Question for theologians: Why were Mary and Joseph still in Bethlehem 2 years later. I thought thy just nipped there to sign the census or whatever. Why hadn't they gone back to Nazereth?

It is possible that Nazareth had got a bit dangerous for them. After all most people would think of Mary as an unmarried single mum and in Biblical times that could be punished by stoning. They might also not believe Joseph's assertions that he had nothing to do with it.

Have you also wondered why Joseph took a heavily pregnant Mary with him on a 70 mile journey for the census? After all I think it would only have been the men who would have been required to register. A woman's testimony wasn't even permitted in a court of law at the time!

I think that perhaps Mary would have been far too vulnerable to have been left alone in Nazareth. She would at the very least been subject vicious verbal attacks and may well have been in physical danger. There may have been no safe option other than for her to go with Joseph.

NorfolkNChance · 01/12/2011 13:52

Good point CinnamonStar, visibility would have been poor (even with the huge fuck off star in the sky) so travel time will need to be reduced per day (night)