Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU but I'm jealous of my friend's 'perfect' life and don't want to be

231 replies

TougherThanTheRest · 17/11/2011 09:27

We've recently got to know another couple and really like spending time with them but their life appears so perfect that I'm starting to feel jealous and resentful.

He's funny, successful, a great Dad and a thoughtful husband. She's a great Mum, naturally good at things like cooking and entertaining, who manages to have a job she enjoys that also fits around their clever, attractive children. They're popular, well-travelled, live in a lovely house, drive nice cars and have several holidays a year plus weekends away and nice grown up nights out. And on top of all that they're really nice people. (That's a lot of 'nice' but it sums them up).

We on the other hand muddle along like most people, never quite on the breadline (which I am thankful for) but never very comfortable money-wise either. Neither of us hates our job but nor are we especially happy with them. We haven't got as many children as I'd have liked for lots of reasons which makes me sad. My DH is a fairly good Dad and husband but will never be a go-getter (although neither am I so not in a position to complain), mostly we get on well but there are times when I wonder how the hell I ended up with him.

I think generally what I feel is that nothing we have is quite good enough or what I would have hoped for - not just material things but life in general - especially when I compare us with our friends. I'm sure their life isn't as perfect as it appears but there's no area where I feel we can even begin to compete with them (I do know it's not actually a competition) and it's beginning to really get to me.

I know I probably sound like a shallow, ungrateful bitch but this is how I feel. I don't want to but I do. How do I get some perspective and stop feeling dissatisfied with my really not that bad life?

OP posts:
Xenia · 18/11/2011 18:02

Yes, the very poor as just as likely (indeed more so) to suffer bad health. In fact some sections of society have things going wrong all the time. Life expectancy is low.

Rather than the correlation being what might seem fairer - if you have a low income you make up for it by being a lot happier, avoiding stressful jobs and living longer in fact the less power in your job and life the more stress you have (despite the myth that those at the top suffer so much more) and the lower your income the more likely you will also suffer ill health, heart attacks and die younger and lose a partner early.

Get richer and you might even get healthier and live longer.

Laquitar · 18/11/2011 17:51

Still people respond differently to divorce, illness, bussiness failure, cheating husband etc.

The 'perfect' friend i mentioned earlier had a huge failure 2 years ago, she was set up by others and she nearly went to prison. It was very dramatic time and i -being a 'chicken'- nearly had a breakdown on her behalf. I honestly couldn't handle it. Her? She just called it 'adventure' and 'interesting experience', she dusted herself and she used it for her next project. Some people got it in them imo. And good for them! Not an ounce of envy from me, i actually like watching these people and being around them. But i wouldn't live their life because i don't have the strong stomach. I know my skills and my limits and i'm ok living a less glam life.

And yes, we don't know whats around the corner but that doesn't apply only to those with 'perfect' life - i still don't understand why many posters keep repeating this to get comfort Hmm. It applies to the rest of us too. At least the people you are talking about might deal better with it.

Xenia · 18/11/2011 17:44

Cult members.. not sure if they will get bonsoir's perfect thighs but we could certainly have red shorts as the uniform. In fact on the way to the island just over a week ago I got one pair of shorts soaked as I got ashore so was stuck with one pair only left - red shorts surprisingly (bebe.com sports wear from US) althoiugh I suspect BS' thighs look better in hers than mine but then that doesn't bother me one iota as I have the secret of contentment.

I think the island is not quite what people think. It's not Branson. It's more Robinson Crusoe and quite physically challenging.

I didn't say all mental health problems were cured with either the types of diet clinics recommend (3 meals a day, slow release carbs, enough protein etc) or pills/therapy although those things do help. I was talking about risk reduction and there certainly are things we can do to reduce risk. It will not eliminate risks and we all choose our own risk levels. I had a gun on the island. There is risk there.

Also of course I am very sorry for anyone who has to deal with illness. That was my point really that doesn't matter how rich you are you still have the same terrible things that can happen to you and I've had deaths of parents etc and they are no more fun if you're reasonably well off than if you aren't.

Some people are unhappy whatever life throws at them and some bounce again after all things that go wrong although it must be hard to bounce if you're in constant pain etc.

So was I born an optimist or did I make myself one or am I happy because life played me a good hand or what?

OldGreyWassailTest · 18/11/2011 17:32

"Never compare yourself to others because thereby lies madness."

"If you compare yourself with others, you may become vain or bitter; for always there will be greater and lesser persons than yourself." Desiderata

exoticfruits · 18/11/2011 16:19

As long as you are healthy I don't think the rest matters, as long as you have enough money to live.
I think that the grass is rarely greener.
Very often you can see a celebrity in a magazine and they seem to have it all, they are successful, have an expensive 'show house', the perfect looking DCs and clothes and they witter on about how wonderful it is and then 6 months later you read that they are getting divorced so it must have been a facade-and quite a convincing one.

minipie · 18/11/2011 15:52

I don't think that's what Xenia meant what. She said "reduce" these risks. Obviously eating well and exercising do reduce the risks of some types health problems. They don't eliminate the risk of all health problems of course, but she didn't say that.

whatdoiknowanyway · 18/11/2011 15:18

"obviously some of us try to eat well, exercise etc to reduce those risks "
And some of us are just dealt different cards to others.

My DH has always eaten well, exercised etc. So has my lovely friend with terminal cancer. Shit happens and you don't help the people going through it by smug implications that of course if they only did as you did all would be well.

You may not mean to make that impression Xenia but that's how it comes across and I've seen enough of your posts to think that you're intelligent enough to realise exactly what you're doing.

Don't know why I'm bothering engaging actually but simplistic, patronising attitudes towards health drive me mad.

ViviPru · 18/11/2011 14:35
daveywarbeck · 18/11/2011 14:32

field trip to the island? I am in.

Acinonyx · 18/11/2011 14:18

I think you must include 'good mental health' in there with 'good health'. it is patronising and simplistic to assert that a healthy lifestyle is the solution for all those suffering from mental health issues that interfere with their general happiness and functioning. It is also simplistic to think that if that is not enough, then medication will be the cure. Medication, for many people, means swapping one unpleasant mental state for another - but one that is more compatible with daily functioning and social norms.

Xenia · 18/11/2011 14:10

I believe good health can make a major difference to happiness. If you are in pain it's quite hard to feel happy whatever your income level. I think I could be happy without legs for example, but it would be pain and suffering which would make it harder.

I don't think it was an assumption I made that everyone has good health, people to love and is happy. I said if you have those 3 things (and it is quite rare to have all three and I do and I'm terribly lucky subject to my points about to an extent you can improve the chances of having those) you may be content compared with people without them. I did not say everyone has good health and indeed any of us could fall sick tomorrow. Obviously some of us try to eat well, exercise etc to reduce those risks.

whatdoiknowanyway · 18/11/2011 13:56

I'm just taken aback by the assumption that we should all be glad for health, the people we love and being happy. We should of course but not everyone has good health.

I used to attend occasional presentations by motivational speakers who were full of how if you just visualise what you want you will find a way to work towards it and achieve it. They did it so I could too.

Trouble was I could never work out how visualising my DH restored to health and freed from the constraints of an incurable chronic condition was supposed to work. If I could work twice as many hours in the day to cure him I would. I'd do anything - but there is nothing to be done.

Despite that people still envy us. We love each other, we have great DC, we live within our means and we laugh a lot.

AphraBehn · 18/11/2011 13:56

I've read all of your posts and though I know lots of people that have lovely houses/perfect figures/adoring husbands I wouldn't want to swap places with any of them.

Apart from Miranda Kerr. Just for 24 hours (not that I know her!)

Xenia · 18/11/2011 13:49

I'm sitting here working and I like the work and I like posting. I have never said I had a perfect life. I just said I was happy. I'm very lucky that is so. One reason I think I'm happier than some is I don't need others to agree that nor their approval nor do I feel a need to be like others. May be that contentment in one's own self is all that is needed.

northernwreck · 18/11/2011 13:49

Xenia is probably right about the not smoking/drinking/caffiene/ three meals etc.

I do love that feeling of the vodka hitting my empty stomach as I spark up the first fag though. It would be hard to give that up in the name of material success.

northernwreck · 18/11/2011 13:47

Ayn Rand Hully. chortle Grin

otchayaniye · 18/11/2011 13:39

'of your' sorry!

otchayaniye · 18/11/2011 13:39

if you are so happy, Xenia, why are you spending so much time on a website seemingly seeking exogenous recognition for you perfect life?

Xenia · 18/11/2011 13:36

I don't think I'm vain and I said that other stuff in my life didn't matter and it doesn't. Also not everyone will have the same enjoyment of the French piano player and bell ringers. Some have almost shot off the heads of teh local bell ringers and thumped the piano player so hated do they find the sounds. Indeed one reason we're happier in the UK than France is we tend to live in houses away from others so we don't hear noise through walls. It's a different culture.

My point was you don't need Bon's red shorts, thighs or church bells to achieve happiness. You can get it walking to your local park. It's not something you do buy. I'm allowed to say that even though I do have a nicer life than some people.

I also think if you do things for others you can be happier too. All studies of the retired find that. Volunteer. Help the homeless. Wash the feet of the poor etc and that tends to cheer people up too. You don't need to be Christian or Muslim to have a moral code that involves helping others and if it also tends to make other people happy so much the better.

[We could have cult trips to the island with tents. I could guarantee weight loss too by ensuring there was hardly any food and they couldn't escape me either. They would need to covenant 10% of their income to be like many including fundamentalist Christianity's tithe - nice little earner. Not sure I can guarantee them eternal life however. I will have to work on that one]

Diamondwhite · 18/11/2011 12:55

I have not read of the thread, but wanted to add I have friends like this. My mum always says that you never know what's round the corner. She had a school friend who said she would marry a doctor and have 2children, boy and call called Susan and tim etc etc. It all happened and for years she did lead a perfect life.

Sadly in her 50's she was widdowed, her daughter got breast cancer and her son is a drug addict. The perfect life has sort of crumbled away. Not that you would ever wish this on people but you just never know.

VioletNotViolent · 18/11/2011 12:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DingbatsFur · 18/11/2011 12:42

Going to echo what the others are saying here.
I had a friend whose life I envied, big country house, SAHM, lovely husband who made an excellent wage. She had a huge engagement ring and a ride on lawnmower, chickens and two lovely boys.
Turns out he had a thing for webcams and women in the far east. She has kicked him out.

Try and make your life better and forget how perfect other people's are.

daveywarbeck · 18/11/2011 12:35

It makes the atmosphere pretty magical and perfect, but no-one created that atmosphere on purpose.

No Bonsoir, they didn't, but I doubt the same happy convergence of people going about their business occurs in a council block in Haringay.

TeWihara · 18/11/2011 12:33

I thought pneumatic breasts were standard issue?

BoffinMum · 18/11/2011 12:27

I could live without my supermodel looks, my wonderfully pneumatic breasts, my stellar IQ, my sports car and my shiny executive home as long as I have lerve.

It's about priorities, innit.