Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

aibu to insist that ex hubby's new gf meet up with me?

83 replies

philherup · 05/08/2011 13:45

they have been together for ten months though i only just found out about it a week or so ago he wants to introduce her to the kids as per our agreement in mediation he said he would inform me before it happened out of "courtesy" so he did and the kids came back rambling about how much fun they had with her and her kids etc.
i want to meet her, and asked her to text me so we could me up but she refused. so i asked for her number so i could contact her. again she refused saying that she would be happy meet up at the drop up for kids but she was not willing to meet up with me on her own for coffee etc.
i want to meet her so that i do not have the humiliation of bumping in to her at the park or something and want to get to know the person who will be seeing MY CHILDREN.
i have now insisted saying this is my bottom line that i do not want my ex to be there or the children there as this would be too difficult for me. she apparently says that meeting me for coffee would be a forced environment and would be awkward for her too. my wishes as their mother are more important as is my piece of mind right?
do i have a leg to stand on legally to say she cant see the kids?

OP posts:
squeakytoy · 05/08/2011 16:58

again she refused saying that she would be happy meet up at the drop up for kids but she was not willing to meet up with me on her own for coffee etc

You should be more than satisfied with that. You have no right to demand she meet you one to one.

How about if you start seeing someone and your ex demands that he meet your boyfriend and they go out for a pint together? would you be happy with that. I think not, somehow.

You dont need to see her on her own. YABU.

Megatron · 05/08/2011 16:53

Another YABU from me I'm afraid. Of course you want to meet her and she doesn't sound like she has any objection to this at pick up and drop off times. But you are almost demanding her presence to assess her suitability for the 'job'. You need to be careful or you will earn the title of 'phsycho ex' before long and that's never good.

catsmother · 05/08/2011 16:39

My (now adult) son's father has been with his now wife for 15 years and I've never met her, though we have spoken perfectly politely on the phone on odd occasions to pass on messages etc. There is no NEED for us to meet because I had to trust that my ex wouldn't have placed my son in the company of anyone unsuitable - why the hell would he do that ? And if we had met ... then what ? What was I supposed to do, interrogate/interview her so I could assess her "suitability" to be near my son ? How humiliating and/or intimidating that would have been for her when my son had never said anything about her to cause me concern ? .... and if he had, I'd have approached my ex about it.

Similarly, my DP's ex "demanded" to meet me - in much the same manner as you're doing. No way ... this was after I'd been called every variation of slag you can imagine (despite meeting her ex 2.5 years after they split) and my son had been called a bastard. I can only imagine she wanted to meet me to have some sort of (pathetic) "go" about some imagined "crimes", and/or to glean more ammunition she could use when slagging me off in text messages, emails or on the answerphone the next time she wanted to sound off.

You should consider yourself lucky she's happy to say hello at pick up times because in all honsety I wouldn't even be prepared to do that with my DP's ex. By demanding to meet - all on your terms - you are effectively saying that you don't trust your ex's judgement. And what would happen next if you didn't take to her for some reason ? .... would you then demand your ex breaks up with her ?

madeindevon2 · 05/08/2011 16:18

Seems unnecessary to demand one to one meeting.
I have never met my husbands ex. And I have been with my husband for 10 years!!! I suppose the time will come......eventually.. She was at my husbands fathers funeral about 5 years ago and I know she saw me (made comments to others re my appearance) but I deliberately didn't want to see her so didn't set eyes on her at all. I was there for dh and dmil. Was a packed church too...

EricNorthmansMistressOfPotions · 05/08/2011 16:03

YABU
meeting her for coffee is a bit forced and unnecessary. Would you expect your ex to be there too? It sounds pretty excrutiating. Surely meeting her to say hello to at first would be better, she can see you are ok and vice versa, and as time goes on your interaction will develop naturally.

QuintessentialShadow · 05/08/2011 15:59

I am sorry, but in insisting you meet for a chat, you sound both jealous and controlling. It is not a reasonable request, and it does not put you in a good light. Laugh it off and say "ok then, I will see you next time you and ex picks up / drops off the kids. Maybe we can all have a coffee together then". Or something.

mymummyisasquarehead · 05/08/2011 15:55

Why would you want the children to stop seeing her? Your ex has done everything by the book as agreed in mediation. If you start adding things on willy nilly, then doesn't that make the whole mediation thing pointless?

If you trust him as a father and your kids got on well with her, then where's the problem.

I understand your worries, but it's probably best to let this one go.

mumofamonkey · 05/08/2011 15:53

i was the girlfriend who was made demands of exactly the same as these.
i felt it was out of sheer noseyness and that she was questioning the integrity of the father. yes she'll be seeing your children, and if things continue with them, then maybe you should ask if you could visit her and him at his, she' d feel less scruitinised.
i think expecting her to bow to your will is more than a little egotistical and APPEARS to me and possibly her that you are using your children's possible involvement with her as a tool for control.
for me this was all a number of years ago and i still fume when i think about it, this woman, put her own need for control and petty insecurities before the happiness of her own child by threatening to stop access if we did not bend to her rules, it made for a very difficult relationship, and i'm sure you don't want this woman to loathe the very mention of your name!!
our relationship ended, in part because of her. please don't make the same mistakes.

GinAndWater · 05/08/2011 15:51

YANBU to feel concerned/worried/curious/anxious (delete as appropriate) about your Ex's new partner but YABU to demand to meet her and making such a fuss.

I hope your children are not aware of your feelings because they will think they can't have a nice time at their dad & partner without upsetting mum. Such a sad thing when they are forced in a position to please/appease one of their parents.

Put your children's happiness first; be positive about it and keep all those concerns for private conversations with your Ex.

I would be pleased they had a nice time and came back happy.

Good luck.

Cheria · 05/08/2011 15:31

YABU. I have no desire to mee up with DH 's ex, though we have briefly spoken on the phone. I wouldn't refuse but I really don't see the need. Can you not trust your ex's judgement on whether or not she is suitable to be around your childern?

CurrySpice · 05/08/2011 15:29

So he did what was required of him by mediation (ie inform you) and you are trying to push it much further?

YABU you have no right to dictate to your ex who can or cannot see his children, any more than he has the right to dictate that to you

yoshiLunk · 05/08/2011 15:27

that's a bit Mary-ist

ApocalypseCheeseToastie · 05/08/2011 15:21

You sound like a bit of a scary Mary tbh.

spookshowangel · 05/08/2011 15:18

i am in a very similar situation except i am the gf. i have totally refused any one to one contact and she is simply refusing to listen and insisting upon it. its infuriating, kind of sad and makes her seem controlling and more than a little insane. she has demanded and then tried to emotionally blackmail and then threaten none of which makes me want to meet up with her.
i entered in to a relationship with her ex which over time included her children but that does not include her beyond the basics. i am of course sympathetic (though she is making it very hard) as a mum myself i am not going to love the fact that at some stage a new woman will probably come in to my childrens lives. but i also know that her and i are much more likely to have a nice relationship if i dont go demanding things of her that will ultimately make her unhappy and if it develops at its own pace.
cant help but feel op that like her meet this gf has actually little to do with the children and what not and all about a power trip.

chicletteeth · 05/08/2011 15:01

If you were my husbands ex-wife, I'd tell you where to go.
You can't just summon the woman to meet up on your terms when and where you like.

Why can't your children be there, why can't your ex-husband.

Even if you hate her guts, there's nothing you can do about it.

bananasplitz · 05/08/2011 15:01

Why does she have to automatically trust him because he is their father?

the same way he has to trust her decisions with the kids when he is not about - thats what adults do

GypsyMoth · 05/08/2011 14:58

Northernrock.....she trusted him enough when they were together!!

GypsyMoth · 05/08/2011 14:58

She isn't a stranger..... The other person with PR knows this woman very well!!

It's not obligatory ( or law) for both parents to know everyone a child spends time with.

LolaRennt · 05/08/2011 14:54

I wouldnt like a stranger spending time with my children so I understand where you are coming from. Maybe you could send a nice letter explaining that?

northernrock · 05/08/2011 14:47

Why does she have to automatically trust him because he is their father?

porcamiseria · 05/08/2011 14:46

here is my thinking

they are with their FATHER, and you have to trust him on this, I think you are coming across as angry and neurotic on this.

I really get why you feel like this, but drop it for now

TheRealTillyMinto · 05/08/2011 14:33

i cannot see the point of the meeting. if you dont like her/dont think she is suitable to be around your DCs/whatever, i cannot see you being able to change anything.

i dont think there is anything at all wrong with feeling protective but you are making yourself look a bit odd and i cannot see it being good for your DCs.

SarahStratton · 05/08/2011 14:24

You know what. The best, most adult and civilised thing you can do for your DC is to do your utmost to maintain a good working relationship with your XH. To not fill their minds with poison or make sly digs. To encourage them to have a good father/child relationship and to be supportive of decisions he makes (unless they are utterly ridiculous).

I'm in no way saying you are doing any of this, but believe me, your children will remember how you and your X behave and you are both still in a position to form their relationship blueprints.

You have no need to meet his girlfriend. Just say hello when you drop off/pick the DC up. It will not be humiliating if you bump into her. It will be humiliating if you continue to behave in a controlling manner, as she will probably conclude that you are slightly touched.

This is about your children and their relationship with their father. Not you.

rubyrubyruby · 05/08/2011 14:23

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

yoshiLunk · 05/08/2011 14:20

Good point TIFF, I'm sure the op would insist that she would suggest it.

Personally I still think that a Hello and hand shake at drop off is sufficient.

In reality though I know that many NRPs don't get to formally meet whoever the RP chooses to hook up with, spend time with their children, or even move in with them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread