Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers are taking the piss by striking?

207 replies

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:09

They get decent pay.
Even after pension reforms, their pensions will still be way better than the private sector.
They get great holidays.
They have reasonably good job security (again, compared with private sector)
Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach. And yet these lazy bleeders have the audacity to go on strike? Meanwhile, in the real world, people continue to lose their jobs...

OP posts:
fedupofnamechanging · 15/06/2011 14:28

Just to add, I've been a teacher (but have no pension, so no personal axe to grind here) and it's not as easy as it looks. I've dealt with teenagers who tower above me physically and whose behaviour has been 'challenging' to say the least. I've had mountains of assessments to do and essays to mark. I've spent many a night marking course work.

I'm not saying that it is harder than every other job or that I worked harder than people not in teaching, but it's not a job that everyone can do. Plenty of people on my PGCE struggled to complete the training.

LadyClariceCannockMonty · 15/06/2011 14:27

Well, I don't really think YANBU about the pensions, but I find your attitude very offensive and it makes me want to say yes, YABU.

A monkey could not be taught to teach.
Teachers very much operate in the real world.
In my experience teachers do not spend the school holidays loafing about, but spend a great deal of the time working.

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:27

chosenone - I dont see the point of salary comparisons because salaries will always be driven by supply and demand, surely? Teachers, for me, get reasonable pay for what they do but not as good as some other professions because, let's face it, it is a job that many people could easily do.

OP posts:
LRDTheFeministDragon · 15/06/2011 14:27

Teach a monkey to teach? No.

But OP, you must have had a brilliant teacher ... s/her taught an idiot to type.

KeepOnSwimming · 15/06/2011 14:26

Staffroom talk at my school was that us teachers don't want to strike BECAUSE IT'S UNFAIR ON THE KIDS. Hence the low turnout.

Doesn't mean we don't feel strongly about it. I think a legal action from the unions would be better, so I changed union to one that is not proposing strike action, but is taking legal action instead.

manicinsomniac · 15/06/2011 14:26

Teaching shouldn't be treated as some special job for saints. It's hard work but no more so than countless other jobs, many of which are far less well paid. I agree that the reforms are a bad thing for teachers and that agreements aren't being honoured - but that is life when our country is in the state that it's in. Everyone's having to make adjustments.

I've already posted my views on the 'in the news' forum but re-writing the relevant bits for here.

  1. The strike will not hurt the people it is aimed at (the govt), it will hurt children and their parents. I know one day of missed education isn?t a massive problem but it?s a pain for working parents and on 30th June my school has a lunchtime fete, a charity cricket match and a big play rehearsal ? the children will therefore miss out in other ways and don?t deserve that.

  2. Teachers do get a much better deal than many other public sector workers. The changes are negative yes, but big deal, so are everyone else?s prospects at the moment.

  3. I have to work till 65 anyway. So does any teacher who started work after December 2006. 3 extra years don?t seem worth making a huge fuss over.

  4. Teaching is not the horrendous job that so many people think it is. I work between 55 and 85 hours a week in termtime BUT I work for probably 10-15 hours a week in the holidays. They pay off is totally worth it. Teachers get to spend time with children, family and friends in holidays and work to their own flexi schedules in a way few other people can. I?m on half term at the moment and, although I?m in the staff room printing end of year exam papers I?m also browsing mumsnet (clearly!) and my children are outside playing on our adventure playground ? not exactly a hardship is it! I wouldn?t go so far as to say that teaching is a cushy job but it really isn?t up there with the hardest.

  5. I think my salary is pretty good. 5 years post graduating and I earn £26000 ish. I don?t believe I deserve any more for what I do. I love my job and sometimes find it hard to believe that I?m actually getting paid to have so much fun.

Peachy · 15/06/2011 14:25

No job security for teaching as a whiole any more;; 3 redundancies in our school, 40% unemployment amongst NQTs. not so cushy as people think.

teach a monkey to teach? really? would you be OK with a monkey taking your child's class? my kids all have SEN at varying levels and they need properly qualified professionals.

Pensions- meh. Not sure either way on that one. My parents lost theirs years ago as a result of loopholes. OTOH I sure don't want someone pushing 70 trying to restrain DS1 in his ASD Base. Just would not work.

I'd love to teach and be an ASD specialist but 40% unemployment is pretty damned scary and I may well take my MA elsewhere. Too huge a risk sadly. I imagine lots of specialists will feel the same.

ilovemydogandMrObama · 15/06/2011 14:24

I support the teachers, and don't subscribe to there needing to be a threshold for strike action.

chosenone · 15/06/2011 14:23

YABU we're not selfish as if we were we'd all work to rule and clear off at 3.30 with the kids, most teachers put kids 1st and put in extra time and effort to be a councellor, confidante, behavioural manager etc alongside their'duties...you clearly have never been in a school since you were in one!! Teachers in inner city schools deserve a medal.

If you compare our salaries with postgraduate professionals in the private sector ours is far lower. The pension was always seen as a perk for lower pay than other professionals. That extra % is being stolen off us even though there was a review of our pensions recently. The NASUWT is taking the govt to court as this is an illegal action and we are not prepared to bend over and be shafted by a government that lies about the deficit and where this money is going. My pension being used to bail out the banks again probably. We are fortunate that we can still have recognised Unions and we can fight unlike many in the Private sector don't begrudge us that or they really have won!

KeepOnSwimming · 15/06/2011 14:21

Oh and lots of schools are making teachers redundant at the minute, so job security is not there either!
With regards to holidays - teachers are actually not paid for the holidays! The pay we receive for working term time is just equally shared around the months. |This also means though that our allocated 2 weeks holiday could be said to be in any of the school holidays, so cannot be accrued for maternity leave!

TeamDamon · 15/06/2011 14:21

Hmm - might be inclined to join a reasonable discussion about this but not one where the OP is clearly a bored shit-stirrer with nothing of intelligence or worth to contribute.

fedupofnamechanging · 15/06/2011 14:21

This isn't about the amount of money a teacher will get upon retirement. This is about agreements being honoured. The teacher has fulfilled their part of the bargain - they have done the job and paid into their pension schemes. The government has no right to change the terms of the agreement on them after the fact. It's breach of contract.

This is also about divide and rule. If we are all busy at each others throats, because public sector workers might be getting more than private sector ones, then the government is free to continue unchallenged.

I notice the MP's aren't having their pensions put in line with everyone else's.

Ormirian · 15/06/2011 14:20
Grin

V funny.

Don't be a twat.

As it happens I am not sure they are being fair re their pensions and I do agree that those of us in the cold scary world of the private sector have been dealing with this for a while (as I told DH who teaches!). But the rest of your post is simply wank.

HTH

aliceliddell · 15/06/2011 14:20

It's slightly disturbing that there seem to be more people upset about defence of good terms and conditions than are upset about the complacent acceptance of gross exploitation, lack of protection, no health & safety regs, etc. Should we all have shit jobs bcause some people do? Shouldn't we fight to maintain the good and raise the rest? Why is it preferable to watch people treated like doormats?

FoofffyShmoofffer · 15/06/2011 14:19

Yabu.

That's it really.

TheMagnificentBathykolpian · 15/06/2011 14:19

Teach a monkey to teach?

Are you kidding?

I am not a teacher. I couldn't do it.

To be a good teacher (a good teacher) you have to be an amazing person! Organised, calm, reliable, flexible, capable of keeping track of 30 kids, assessing and understanding them all.

Coping with 30 children in a confined space day in day out Grin

Being able to explain the same thing in a dozen or more different ways so that you find a way to explain it to everyone in a way they can understand.

I couldn't do it.

I could stand in front of a group of kids and churn information out at them, sure.

But I couldn't be a teacher. An educator.

Hell, I couldn't even home school my own children without taking to the bottle! Grin

So I think you are being very unreasonable to belittle teachers.

And I don't think that teachers get pay comparable to other graduate professions. (or do you not go to university to become a teacher any more?)

Gilberte · 15/06/2011 14:19

I know plenty of teachers. Many are working 12 hour days and weekend, especially in struggling schools. Yes the pay is good but it's not brilliant for what they do until they have been working a few years. Yes the pension is good but most aren't concerned about the pension being cut but having to find an extra £100 plus a month to pay into it. If your income just about covers your mortgage and bills and you have a family support it's not easy to stump up the extra cash. That would be the same for anyone.

Yes they have job security and good holidays but the teachers I know are stressed/ overloaded with ridiculous paperwork/consequently subject to criticism and inspections and not able to get on with the job. Rather than get on and teach a more creative lesson they have to spend hours proving they taught it by taking photos etc and pasting them into books etc.

Dead poet's society it aint no more.

wannaBe · 15/06/2011 14:19

I wouldn't want to teach and I have no issue with teachers.

But given that essentially only 36% of them voted in favour of strike action (only 40% turnout) the whole thing is a farce.

I suspect that as is often the case where unions are involved, many are too afraid of intimidation to vote no, so don't vote at all.

The problem is that the low turnout and the impact on parents is not going to do the cause any favours.

cjbartlett · 15/06/2011 14:19

Does the private sector get pensions still?
Don't the army and civil service workers contribute to their own pensions?

JudysJudgement · 15/06/2011 14:18

the thing is, when you have been told your pension is going to be xy&z and you have financially planned around that figure, then at the last minute almost they say oh no sorry, its now going to be 30% less (figure plucked from air) and you need to work 5 years longer as well, that does tend to put all your plans into disarray

KeepOnSwimming · 15/06/2011 14:17

Currently teacher pensions are totally funded by teacher contributions from salary - and the pot is also regularly raided to subsidise other pension pots such as civil servants and army.
The proposals are to raise contributions, and lower benefits from the pension so it can subsidise other peoples pensions and the government more.

Currently teachers pensions are not better than private sector pensions, and they want to make them a LOT worse. OK maybe some people's are worse, but teachers salary sacrifice about 10% of salary for 1/80th final salary per year.
Not that great!

cjbartlett · 15/06/2011 14:17

Grin wowoo, agree, someone is after some midweek argy bargy

pooka · 15/06/2011 14:17

YABU.

Hope this helps. :)

upahill · 15/06/2011 14:16

I think you are out to get a reaction with that post and you know it!!!
By the way I think YABU.

WowOoo · 15/06/2011 14:16

Got to be a joke. Or simply a twat cj.