Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers are taking the piss by striking?

207 replies

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:09

They get decent pay.
Even after pension reforms, their pensions will still be way better than the private sector.
They get great holidays.
They have reasonably good job security (again, compared with private sector)
Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach. And yet these lazy bleeders have the audacity to go on strike? Meanwhile, in the real world, people continue to lose their jobs...

OP posts:
Peachy · 15/06/2011 16:48

Allina it's not just professionals who work those hours you know! Dad always did.

But I get your point.

I do think it is different to otehr jobs though. I know how aggressive ds1 can be so have seen the risks teahcers can be aplced at first hand.

pyjamababe · 15/06/2011 16:46

I'm going to step in now before all the teachers get in from work and this thread goes bonkers.

OP - here - have my very first Biscuit - because my mother (an excellent teacher) taught me that if you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all.

Allinabinbag · 15/06/2011 15:32

Lost in Wales, I agree many teachers work hard, it's just pointing this out doesn't gather sympathy from other professionals who also work evenings and weekends as standard. A new teacher will have lots more to prepare, same in lecturing, same for junior doctors, same for pretty much most professions until you make the leap to management and the demands rise again.

I support the strike, but once teachers start saying 'I work 12 hour days every day and all holidays' I do start to wonder which ones, having seen many immediate members of my own family in this profession for 40 years. I just don't think it helps the overall cause, which is a good one in my opinion.

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 15:22

ThePathanKhansWoman - English teacher by any chance?

OP posts:
lostinwales · 15/06/2011 15:14

I don't think teachers do themselves any favours though by exaggerating how much work they do all weekend and holidays though

I try never to join in these debates because frankly they make me want to cry but there is something I always want to say when people say the above. In the last term alone DH and teachers in his school have;

Got themselves and a bus load of children to a place 2 hours away for a drama competition. They had to be there for 8.15 am on a bank holiday Monday. No extra pay, and that's not counting the amount of hours put in outside school teaching the children the words and how to act them.

The older children went on a week long course accompanied by DH and other teachers, DH slept outside the doors of some of the boys rooms to ensure they stayed put as they had 'previous' on going walkabout. No extra pay, and that's 24 hours a day for 4/5 days.

School production, extra evenings every week over two months let alone planning, choreographing and making costumes and the week of the performance where I won't expect to see DH until 10pm most evenings.

I can't even count the amount of days over weekends/holidays when other people's children come ahead of our own, but they always do.

The last two years where the staff are waiting to find out who will be made redundant for about 4/5 months of the year.

And yes that's his job and he would very rarely never complain about it. He feels he is adequately paid, teaching is a vocation and he loves his job and the children he teaches. But when an arse comes on MN and starts equating these intelligent, hardworking individuals with trained fucking monkeys my blood boils and I want to defend them to the skies.

slug · 15/06/2011 15:02

Righto then OP. How about you put your children first in the line to be taught by the monkey teachers.

No? thought not Hmm

MarioandLuigi · 15/06/2011 14:56

You are being a Knobber!

ThePathanKhansWoman · 15/06/2011 14:55

Teach a monkey to teach [sceptical] ? Do fuck-away-off now, divvy.

Ormirian · 15/06/2011 14:52

And as for it being a PITA for wohm - I will use it as an excuse to work from home for the day. Hurray!

StroppyDad · 15/06/2011 14:52

Yes, what aliceliddell said.

The percentage of teachers voting for action is still higher than the percentage of people voting for Cameron's Party (whether you take turn-out into account or not). It is notable that the ATL has never voted for national strike action in its 127 year history.

The most moderate of the Unions. It has done so now.

Teachermumof3 · 15/06/2011 14:52

I don't think teachers do themselves any favours though by exaggerating how much work they do all weekend and holidays though

I really don't feel this is the case. In my experience, teachers don't mention their working hours at all until ignorant people start spouting about how teachers work 9-3 and then have six months off...

manicinsomniac · 15/06/2011 14:50

The country isn't crying out for teachers. Not all over anyway. In secondary schools for certain subjects they are but primary teaching is massively oversubscribed.

COCKadoodledooo · 15/06/2011 14:49

"I don't think teachers do themselves any favours though by exaggerating how much work they do all weekend and holidays though"

No need for exaggeration in dh's case. I see what he does. He's NQT though, and head of his subjects, plus implementing new A level programmes, so he's bound to have a lot going on, as you say, it will improve when he's a few years under his belt. Doesn't take kindly to being patronised about his hours now though, understandably.

pretentiouswasteoftime · 15/06/2011 14:46

I am a Mum whose child has amazing teachers. They work hard and are committed to DS and the children in the school. I will support them 100% in whatever action follows now.
As for the holidays, answer is simple - if you are Envy then the country is crying out for teachers. Off you go and have the same long holidays. If you are not called in that is, my sister has worked IN the holidays to offer academic support at the request of the headteacher, my sister is a TA but many teachers were requested in too. No extra cash as obviously still being paid. Long holidays are not all they appear.

Allinabinbag · 15/06/2011 14:39

Perhaps headteachers or deputies or first-time around teacher spend a lot of their holidays working (why?) but the ordinary class-room teachers who have a lot of stuff already prepared don't, my mum is one and she certainly relaxed in the school holidays as indeed she was entitled to do given how hard she'd worked all term. As someone else has said, if you love the holidays, and you love how easy it is to teach, feel free.

I don't think teachers do themselves any favours though by exaggerating how much work they do all weekend and holidays though, especially as most people in professional jobs work the odd evenings, weekends and so on.

I think they should strike, changing the pension after you've been contributing for years is really shitty and it's true that many people do put up with a lot in teaching in return for longer holidays and an ok pension (it's not the teachers now who are taking the mickey, but all the ones who went on 'ill-health' about 15 years ago aged 50 when the pension gates were closing, again members of my own family).

LadyClariceCannockMonty · 15/06/2011 14:37

Never a truer word, aliceliddell.

aliceliddell · 15/06/2011 14:36

Manicinsomniac - if you read anything but govt propaganda you'll discover the country is in pretty much the same state as most of the last century post ww2. This catastrophising is simply not true. As for 'everybody' making adjustments - Ha! George Osborne? Adjustments? The poor make adjustments, not the rich. We are not all in this together.

LadyClariceCannockMonty · 15/06/2011 14:35

mdowall, fair enough but I did say in my experience, which obviously is going to have some bearing on my opinions.

My dad, who just retired from being a headteacher, used to discourage his teachers from doing too much work at weekends and in holidays because he believed they should be resting so as to come back to school fresh, enthusiastic and able to teach well. So I guess my argument is that perhaps some 'down time' is essential for a good teacher to remain a good teacher. My dad spent many a holiday/weekend/evening working though and some of his teachers were Shock at his methods, especially in the latter days when stupid timewasting paperwork really started to fuck up dominate teachers' working lives.

Peachy · 15/06/2011 14:32

Well

A) as I understand it salaries are paid pro rate so she isn;t being paid for that time anyway

B) things change, and the admin I see going on these days- wow

COCKadoodledooo · 15/06/2011 14:32

Didn't see the bit about teaching monkeys to teach - that is really fucking offensive! YABVU to think this.

COCKadoodledooo · 15/06/2011 14:31

OP - YANBU and YABU. Not every teacher has voted for strike action. The ones who voted against (including my dh, for pretty much the reasons stated in your op) will be villified as much as those who voted yes though, and that fucking sucks.

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:31

LadyClariceCannockMonty - I used to live with a teacher. She was, as I understand a v v good teacher - when ofsted came to town she got brilliant results.
During the 6 week summer hols, each year she spent 5 weeks either on hol or in the back garden sunbathing and the final week doing a bit of planning and what-not.

OP posts:
Peachy · 15/06/2011 14:30

mdowdall could they?

I don't mean with the gifted and able kids. Although even then some people clearly much more suitable than otehrs.

But with the ones with LD, some of whom will have behavioural issues; or those with EBD?

I doubt that tbh.

SeaShellsHasSandInHerShoes · 15/06/2011 14:29

YABU, they are allowed a voice just as you are OP in your chosen profession.

aliceliddell · 15/06/2011 14:28

The Prime Minister couldn't get a majority against an unpopular opponent in a recession; his coalition supporters broke 'promises' to get power; their policies weren't announced until after the election (on what turnout? what proportion of the vote?) and nobody put a tick against 'coalition', did they? Asfor this 'intimidation'line - it's a secret postal ballot. The unions policies have been ratified at their conferences by democratically elected delegates. If they don't want to strike, they could vote 'no'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread