Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers are taking the piss by striking?

207 replies

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:09

They get decent pay.
Even after pension reforms, their pensions will still be way better than the private sector.
They get great holidays.
They have reasonably good job security (again, compared with private sector)
Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach. And yet these lazy bleeders have the audacity to go on strike? Meanwhile, in the real world, people continue to lose their jobs...

OP posts:
emptyshell · 16/06/2011 09:48

Society gets the schools society deserves. When you have a view that it's acceptable to call the educators of your children "trained chimpanzees", or "idiots", or "lazy" or any of the other insults hurled about on this thread - what message is that sending to your kids about listening in school? What message is that sending about complying with requests?

The first day of my PGCE we were told a number of things - that we'd get nits, worms and every bug known to man, and that everyone in the world is an expert on teaching and telling you how to do your job because everyone went to school once.

As for this whole perception we go into teaching because we're thick and not good at anything - I have a string of A grades at GCSE and A level, a first class degree from one of the top universities in the country and I went into it because it was the one thing that "clicked" with me as something I got a genuine buzz out of doing. Not because I was a thicko or anything like that - I turned down an office job working in regeneration to take my course. However, I opted out of the full-time game a few years ago, because of parents like the OP and me deciding that I was bloody well sick of putting my health and wellbeing and family life on the line, sick of being insulted and assaulted, of putting myself in the firing line of some children who really needed help and were being failed by all the systems going in order to protect the other members of the class - for parents like the OP who just would hate me whatever the fuck I did. So because of attitudes like that - teaching lost someone very capable (and those who know me will vouch that I lack confidence in my own abilities with anything - but the one thing I AM confident on, and backed up by ofsted, is that I'm an excellent teacher who made lessons so fun I couldn't get the damned inspector away from joining in with the science!) who did give a fuck, and I went off onto supply where I could walk away from the whining, the teacher-bashing, the ridiculousness at the end of the day. I'm posting in the middle of the day because, well, I can - I chose not to work today - that's the path I chose.

Like I say - the pensions thing doesn't affect me, and since the full-timers stood and watched their supply counterparts be hurt and laughed at our misfortune - I've got minimal sympathy, but the fact we're in for more than the usual summer of teacher bashing is really going to get boring fast.

Someone go start a breastfeeding dogs with kids party invitations thread.

2rebecca · 16/06/2011 09:40

I think teaching is hard work, but also think there is a culture of moaning within teaching, often due to many teachers not socialising much with nonteachers, particularly those in low paid crap jobs, so teachers moan to each other about how hard done by they are.
My job can be stressful but I know there are alot of worse, much poorer paid jobs out there.
I agree if teachers think their jobs are so awful they should leave, but I'm never sure why the people who think teaching is easy don't become teachers themselves, same with people who think doctors, lawyers, etc are overpaid.
If you think it's an overpaid easy job then why aren't you doing it?

Bankers with bonuses are overpaid though, that's a totally different scale of salary that bears no resemblance to life as most of us know it.

Hammy02 · 16/06/2011 09:10

If teaching is so easy, I assume you are saying it is a piece of piss to get the attention of, teach and look after the welfare of 30 children. Fine. Being a parent must be an absolute doddle then, just looking after a couple of kids.
One of the most idiotic OP's I have ever read.
I wouldn't be a teacher for £100k a year.

mdowdall · 16/06/2011 09:03

allegrageller - education has decreasing value because of the ridiculous grade inflation that got totally out of control under Blair's lot.
as for the cuts you allude to in the public sector, they are taking place because if they dont, the country will go bankcrupt and end up going cap in hand to the world bank and imf like greece, ireland etc. however, im sure teachers and other public sector workers would be happy to see that - and the disasterous consequences it would have for the wider reconomy - as long as they get to keep their cushy existence.

OP posts:
allegrageller · 15/06/2011 22:29

well, fakeplastic, I think a series of strikes is going to start actually and the disruption will last for several years. People like myself who could possibly still find better paid work in the private sector see this as more than an issue of 'our jobs'. The fabric of a once-decent country is being destroyed.

Frankly though,the Tories want an impoverished public sector employing as few people as possible. Even in prisons, police and the army- something I never thought I'd see from a Tory government. They will get it in the end, though not without a great big fight, and the country will suffer.

Personally i am predicting a massive brain drain, mostly to the East, from education in particular. Why would anyone decently qualified who gives a shit about teaching or education want to work in a country where education has decreasing value?

StanHouseMuir · 15/06/2011 22:28

YAB a bit U - Ask almost any partner of a teacher if they would like to become a teacher and I bet the vast majority would run a mile, I certainly would. That said, in certain aspects they have it good - e.g. almost impossible to be sacked no matter how incompetent and a pension that every financial advisor says cannot be beaten and to stay in it. They cannot be immune to the current financial downturn IMO.

TheFlyingOnion · 15/06/2011 22:20

has the OP said what her job is anywhere?

From the tone of the OP I'm presuming General Secretary to the UN? Brain surgeon? Astrophysicist?

Or just another disgruntled, unfulfilled "jobseeker"?

lynehamrose · 15/06/2011 22:17

Good post flyingonion. And remember, even the best teachers can only do so much. If the raw material is poor quality......!!!

FakePlasticTrees · 15/06/2011 22:15

Well, whatever the rights or wrongs of what they are striking over, strikes won't get them what they want. Strikes work for businesses where they lose money by production stopping, or hurts paying customers who will pressurise management to fix the problem to get service back as it was.

This only 'hurts' the teachers themselves (who lose a days pay) and the children they teach (and therefore pisses off their parents). It in no way will force the government's hand unless teachers were prepared to walk out for a long time, not just a day at a time (think weeks, not days).

This is a Tory government, not Labour, they dont need the unions to like them and they don't need to be seen as the party of the public services. This will only embarrass the government if it is more than a day at a time and will start to seriously effect children's education, or if they 'give in' to unions who strike. Once strike action is started, it's harder for the Tories to U turn, rather than easier.

So it's a day lost pay for teachers, it's a high profile protest, but it'll change nothing.

allegrageller · 15/06/2011 22:14

anyone who thinks teaching requires 'relatively little brain power' is an idiot frankly, mrdowdall. Teachers are postgraduates, and education is a discipline in itself, as you'd know if you bothered to research the topic.

Your argument seems to be that if teachers were 'any good' at anything they would all, er, leave teaching. Again, idiocy. They trained to do this job because (incomprehensible to someone like you) they wanted to do something worthwhile. Also most of them are now qualified as (duh) teachers.

At this rate, however, you'll get your wish. Degrade pay and conditions any further and the best teachers will all leave and do something else.

Our loony society thinks that educating the next generation isn't worthwhile. Fair enough then. Just don't expect a competitive economy in the next few decades because we ain't going to have the skilled workers to produce one.

Igetknockeddownbutgetupagain · 15/06/2011 22:14

You said you lived with a teacher, but have you been one?

No?

Then how could you possibly judge?

TheFlyingOnion · 15/06/2011 22:13

mdowell you are tarring all teachers with the lefy unionist brush when a lot of teachers on this thread have agreed with you about the strike.

You obviously had shit teachers who failed to teach you empathy, compassion, common sense and the validity of a soundly researched argument.

meh

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 21:57

Sorry FreudianSlipper, just re-read my last post and not sure why I put teacher types. I meant, erm, teachers.

OP posts:
StealthPolarBear · 15/06/2011 21:54

hmm so this shit stirring thread stays, despite the fact it's obviously started to rile people up.

FreudianSlipper · 15/06/2011 21:51

well yes i did type those words followed by a question mark, which means i am asking a question

so what does teacher types actually mean?

goinnowhere · 15/06/2011 21:51

Finally, in general, teachers do not moan about pay IME, at all. I never expected to make vast amounts of money as a teacher. If that had been important to me I would have chosen a different career. I did like the feeling of security that a pension gave me though. I read on here ages ago, that teachers are fantastic value as child care though. If a CM had 30 mindees and charged £4.50 an hour, that would be £135 an hour, so throw in a bit extra for the educating bit, and you've got yourself a bargain all you taxpayers! Smile

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 21:47

Your words, not mine FreudianSlipper.

OP posts:
goinnowhere · 15/06/2011 21:45

I am not complaining about my job. I teach because I enjoy it and I think it is important. I do however have to think about the future too. Again people only compare with the other people they know. In addition to the things i mentioned earlier about all my friends getting rises, benefits etc, I don't know a single one who works regular overtime or ever brings work home so if I were to generalise, I would say people in the private sector have a cushy time of it. Fortunately, I know that what I see in my friends does not necessarily tell the whole story.

lynehamrose · 15/06/2011 21:40

Obviously. With sandals and the Guardian under their arm !

FreudianSlipper · 15/06/2011 21:38

are teacher types left wing feminist lesbians by any chance?

lynehamrose · 15/06/2011 21:32

Moaning whingers? Look no further than your op, love

ShellyBoobs · 15/06/2011 21:32

Tidey Do you really believe any teacher earns less that NMW if you take into account all their 'unpaid' hours?

Even on a salary of only £25k they would have to work over 80hrs per week EVERY week (both term-time AND holiday weeks) to be under NMW. It's just not realistic to expect us to believe that's happening.

I think teachers generally do a great job and deserve a decent salary and conditions. I really don't envy anyone who has to tackle 30, often unwilling kids every hour of their working day but some teachers need to realise they're onto a good thing compared to most of the private sector as far as salary and benefits.

My sister teaches so I do have some idea of what goes on (for her at least) and it's nowhere near comparable to the working hours and employment conditions of the (degree qualified) staff I manage. I would estimate that at least 70% of our staff on £30k+ are doing 55+ hour weeks, every week except their 4 weeks of holiday, plus doing work most weekends and still answering emails during their holidays, etc.

I'm not for one minute suggesting that everyone should be dragged down to the lowest terms rather than trying to protect what they have, but it's worth bearing in mind that the grass is certainly not greener in the private sector.

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 21:30

Loads of teacher types on here moaning. If it is so hard and badly paid, why not get another job??? I will tell you why - because you know that you will struggle to get an equally well paid job with as many hols that takes as (relatively) little brain power. Come on, admit it!
On the pensions thing, most people's pensions are knackered (or on paper at any rate due to falling stock markets blah blah) both in the public and private sector. Demographic changes and all that stuff. The thing is, the teaching union knows this yet still looks to stir up trouble - basically because they are now dealing with a Tory govt (of sorts). They would never have done this when Labour were in power.

OP posts:
LadyOfTheCuntryManor · 15/06/2011 21:29

Quite a few teachers graduated when I did. I lived with 2 trainee teachers during university.

One of them thought Taiwan was the capital of Thailand and that New York was the capital of America.

Thankfully I know where he teaches, and it's no where near where I live.

VivaLeBeaver · 15/06/2011 21:26

Agree with goinnowhere, my dh is in private sector - still getting pay rise, still getting bonus, pension scheme in place.

Me in nhs, pay freeze for two years, no bonus, pension scheme slashed so I'm no longer on a final salary scheme and won't get pension till I,m 65. No breaks, finish late and shit pay. Oh and rather than sitting around at a desk job drinking tea like dh I,m running round saving lives on a daily basis and getting abuse from patients and relatives.

I feel like bloody striking.