Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers are taking the piss by striking?

207 replies

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:09

They get decent pay.
Even after pension reforms, their pensions will still be way better than the private sector.
They get great holidays.
They have reasonably good job security (again, compared with private sector)
Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach. And yet these lazy bleeders have the audacity to go on strike? Meanwhile, in the real world, people continue to lose their jobs...

OP posts:
drivemecrazy63 · 18/06/2011 17:09

brilliant post angelmouse75 I agree wholeheartedly, I just wish our servicemen's were also allowed to fight in their own corner and strike too.

exoticfruits · 18/06/2011 17:02

Excellent post angelmouse-agree 100%

Hulababy · 18/06/2011 17:01

I know of schools with reduncancies for teachers too, esp in secondary.

alistron1 · 18/06/2011 16:59

Well said AngelMouse.

allegrageller · 18/06/2011 11:00

teacher detractors should read angelmouse's post and take note. Why are we not hearing from people like her in the press and just the loony Daily Fail crap about 'cushy' public sector jobs? So often spouted by people already about to walk into their own far more cushy private sector pension arrangements and second or third homes.

angelmouse75 · 18/06/2011 10:23

I have been a teacher for almost five years. I knew getting in that the hours would be long, the pay would be less than I was earning elsewhere and that there would be no 'perks'. However, the decision to become a teacher was mine and I wouldn't change it for the world - those that teach will recognise that total sense of accomplishment you feel when a struggling student finally makes sense of a topic and produces a brilliant piece of work, or a child with learning difficulties gets 20/20 on a spelling test because you've spent every break time with him for the last week doing extra work. It doesn't feel like a chore because, at that time, it's not, it's an absolute joy.

What I was never prepared for is the absolute vitriol that is spewed at me by non-teachers who see our lot as an easy one. To say that we have 30 children to look after is only a half-truth - yes, we may only have 30 to look after at any one time but this year, as a Secondary English teacher, I've taught 8 different classes across 5 different year groups, not including the pastoral care of my own Year 8 form. I start work at 8am and finish at 5.30pm, I work through my breaks running detentions and 'Curriculum Enrichment' clubs, I eat my sandwiches at my desk whilst marking (because I can no longer afford the school canteen that offers no subsidies and charges the teachers VAT on top of all food and drinks), I get home at 6.30pm so that I can spend a couple of hours with my own family and then, when the kids have gone to bed at 8.30pm, I begin the marking and planning that will take me through 'til about 1am. It's a hard slog and yes, I repeat, I CHOSE this.

What I didn't choose though was the torrent of verbal abuse from students when you dare to confiscate the phones they're playing with in class or the make-up they're plastering themselves with. Or the threats of physical abuse from students who don't like being told that they can't come into a restricted area. Or how about the verbal abuse form parents when you phone to tell them that their darling child has failed to do any work for the past week or perhaps the physical attacks from parents as you tell them that their child is being expelled for their own violence towards pupils and staff.

Most of the complaints I have heard so far about the forthcoming strike from non-teachers is how it will inconvenience them, how they'll have to take time off from work to look after their children - very little about the loss of education for the day. The union members care very much about pupil welfare, that's why they've chosen a date that's after the exams so pupils will suffer as little as possible. It's also why we've put up with budget cuts, redundancies, loss of authority and pay-freezes with no national strikes since 1986. As someone has already pointed out, ATL, the moderate union, has never called for strike action in its 127-year history.

The simple fact is, we were promised a good pension (one of the few upsides to this job) and now we're having it taken away. As a working parent the Government have already taken £450 a month away from me in Working Tax Credit while my childcare costs are still over a £1000 a month and now they want to take more money out of my salary so that I can work for longer but with less at the end of it.

Teaching is a vocation, and it's the one I chose. I shouldn't have to change that just to be guaranteed something I was promised in the first place.

allegrageller · 16/06/2011 13:39

for what it's worth, I met around two people in my entire 6 years banking work who would appear to have been even vaguely worthy of the ludicrous salaries they were receiving. And really, in the end banking provides silly money for work that requires very little brain power and frankly not even charm. Exactly the accusations you and others were levelling at teaching, with no foundation whatever.

allegrageller · 16/06/2011 13:33

no bigging up of self necessary, mrdowdall. That you think it is bragging to say you could have earned a lot more, says everything about you and not me.

I don't think having a six figure salary is a good thing at all. Especially for shuffling paper at a desk all day. That's why I went to work in a university for considerably less.

soverylucky · 16/06/2011 12:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

mdowdall · 16/06/2011 12:41

My best mate is a teacher at a 6th form college. Lots at his place have been offered - and taken - voluntary redundancy. Departments merging, that kind of thing.

OP posts:
harrietthespook · 16/06/2011 12:35

Are there figures anywhere I wonder? Would be keen to look at this.

harrietthespook · 16/06/2011 12:34

Interestig. Tell me more.

Blackduck · 16/06/2011 12:33

Harriet - I know of schools where there have been redundancies...

harrietthespook · 16/06/2011 12:29

DH is a teacher. Does work long hours. Thinks he gets a great deal though overall.

I work in the private sector and in 2009 65% of my team got fired, with most taking around 8 months to find other jobs. So far his school hasn't shed any staff.

This is just one example. I would be interested to hear if some schools did lose people. We have a wide network of teacher friends and I haven't heard about any redundancies.

If I were a teacher and striking about anything it would be over OFSTED related matters and their goal post changing which has made life ridiculous for schools.

Pudding2be · 16/06/2011 12:24

Why can't Teachers strike!!! I am sick and tired of public sector workers being slammed for striking

At the end of the day WE ALL HAVE THE SAME EMPLOYMENT RIGHTS REGARDLESS OF WHAT SECTOR WE WORK. Your contract of employment is something which is covered by the Employment Rights Act 1996, and if that's what you signed up to why should you be forced to accept worse terms and conditions? Would you accept worse t and c's I wonder????

You are a moron for creating this. Btw I work in the private sector, which is my choice. If you think that public sector is so great why do you work in it?

And breathe Angry

Blackduck · 16/06/2011 12:04

emptyshell - good post.
Teaching - hardest job I have ever done and whilst I think there is a lot wrong with the system I admire the majority of the people who do it becuase I know it is not a cushy number

Peachy · 16/06/2011 11:59

', people who are in positions of turning down 6 figure salaries don?t boast about it on internet forums. What a frankly embarrassing attempt to 'big up' one's self.
'

Why would that be true? Don;t we all have different sets of values after all?

I turned down an RG Uni for a new one, because it was better for my family. Others prioritise other things- faith, voluntary work and the drains it has on their time, a caring role.

That doesn't make them better people, it does mean they exist.

BsshBossh · 16/06/2011 11:59

Agreed with OP initially, but then she lost me on "you can teach a monkey to teach"....

mdowdall · 16/06/2011 11:56

allegrageller - two things. First, the bankrupt country thing isn?t bollocks. Do you think the Coalition is making these cuts just to see how unpopular it can make itself with the electorate? Do you think there is loads of money really but that Cameron and co have thought: "Ah, let's see if we can get ourselves voted out after one term by deliberately alienating half the country." Get real. Labour left a huge hole in the public finances - the figures are there in black and white on the National Office for Statistics website.
Secondly, people who are in positions of turning down 6 figure salaries don?t boast about it on internet forums. What a frankly embarrassing attempt to 'big up' one's self.

OP posts:
allegrageller · 16/06/2011 11:25

emptyshell, resentment against teachers is I think partly personal and I think it's often people who've failed at school, or just can't bear anyone with any 'authority'. Also the Daily Fail et al have relentlessly stirred up public-sector hate as they consistently spew out the kind of rubbish recycled word for word by the likes of mrdowdall on this thread.

Go ahead and wreck education mrdowdall....you'll find the country makes rather less money for the future generations you apparently care about so much as a result.

allegrageller · 16/06/2011 11:23

the 'bankrupt country' thing is bollocks, mrdowdall. As is the idea that public sector workers have a 'cushy' existence. Sheer Daily Fail bollocks.

you've clearly never done a public sector job, let alone a skilled one. So ddon't make idiotic claims about them and the people who do them.

Did you read my previous posts? I gave up a pretty much guaranteed 6 figure salary to work in the public sector, because I believe in education not pointless profit.

Cushy eh? Believe you me, if I'd stayed in the banks effing around with the country's money and getting bailed out by the government, I'd be having a far cushier existence now and doing a much easier job to boot.

Goldberry · 16/06/2011 09:58

Amongst your other ignorant claims, OP, did you actually claim that teaching requires little in the way of brain power? Why? I'd love to know what amazing job you do. No doubt it requires great brain power Hmm.

emptyshell · 16/06/2011 09:54

It's quite why people HATE teachers so much that I will never ever understand. I can understand resentment that they get your kids during the day while you have to go to work, I can understand resentment over July and August (it ain't actually that awesome - everywhere's packed, you run into kids you teach all over the place and you pay an arm and a leg for a holiday - plus you quite often get situations where your spouse isn't allowed holiday from work while you're off because parents get priority)... but the utter utter rabid hate for the people who are working to get your kids to be the best they can be? I will never understand that.

exoticfruits · 16/06/2011 09:52

I love teaching, but I opted out of full time years ago and have now opted out altogether -I wanted a work life balance. Teaching doesn't give you it. Love the DCs-love the classroom-hate the rest.

exoticfruits · 16/06/2011 09:48

Just as well you are not a teacher mdowdall, you would get a huge shock and I also don't think you would make a good one with that attitude.