Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers are taking the piss by striking?

207 replies

mdowdall · 15/06/2011 14:09

They get decent pay.
Even after pension reforms, their pensions will still be way better than the private sector.
They get great holidays.
They have reasonably good job security (again, compared with private sector)
Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach. And yet these lazy bleeders have the audacity to go on strike? Meanwhile, in the real world, people continue to lose their jobs...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shinyandnew1 · 02/02/2023 10:20

Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach.

Why don’t you write to Gillian Keegan and suggest it-that would solve the recruitment crisis overnight. Would she even pay the monkeys at all?!

Who would teach the monkeys though…

Neededanewuserhandle · 02/02/2023 10:14

Let?s face it, you could teach a monkey to teach.
Who taught OP to type?

Radiatingradiator · 02/02/2023 09:57

SavageSeraphim · 02/02/2023 09:30

You do not really project your profession in a good light do you? You are really going to compare the amount of hours that you work with that of nurses, I mean REALLY? It must be so demanding and brain draining having to mind your P’s and Q’s around children for the 6 or 7 hours while around them, whereas nurses have to mind everything in case you know, someone dies by one of their slip ups!
I would have expected a much more mature response from someone that is teaching our future generation on how to handle life to the best of their abilities instead of some dim witted passive aggression towards the town where I live. Honestly the only disagreement that I had with the OP was the fact that you could train a monkey to do a teacher’s job, but after your response I am now not so sure. Have a great day back helping the children catch up (again) on their education. In fact if you were not out all day picketing in defence of your belief that you deserve a raise more than anyone else in the public sector then your commitment to the job you are paid for should be put under scrutiny.
*fixed as I had to take a call, posted and thought I could come back and edit the post.

Hi
I’m very sorry to cause offence. I was being flippant and unthoughtful and absolutely acknowledge that there are many professions where people work extremely hard and have an extremely stressful time.
I have been to Blackpool and had a great time. Just not thinking in the middle of the night.
Don’t worry, am a very thoughtful teacher in real life and not damaging any kids.

💐

SavageSeraphim · 02/02/2023 09:30

You do not really project your profession in a good light do you? You are really going to compare the amount of hours that you work with that of nurses, I mean REALLY? It must be so demanding and brain draining having to mind your P’s and Q’s around children for the 6 or 7 hours while around them, whereas nurses have to mind everything in case you know, someone dies by one of their slip ups!
I would have expected a much more mature response from someone that is teaching our future generation on how to handle life to the best of their abilities instead of some dim witted passive aggression towards the town where I live. Honestly the only disagreement that I had with the OP was the fact that you could train a monkey to do a teacher’s job, but after your response I am now not so sure. Have a great day back helping the children catch up (again) on their education. In fact if you were not out all day picketing in defence of your belief that you deserve a raise more than anyone else in the public sector then your commitment to the job you are paid for should be put under scrutiny.
*fixed as I had to take a call, posted and thought I could come back and edit the post.

SavageSeraphim · 02/02/2023 09:23

Radiatingradiator · 02/02/2023 02:00

you really are insightful. I’m actually a monkey and also a teacher. My fellow monkeys work in many different fields such as banking, customer facing, hospitality, admin and advertising. I feel lucky to have found a profeshun which seems to keep me on my toes, develops my organisation skills, allows me to nurture baby monkeys, gives me the opportunity to share knowledge which we have learnt through our many wise years on the planet and has allowed me to teach other monkeys to develop there skills to work in high end jobs which help to boost their egoes and gives them the skills necessery to slag off those monkeys who end up in lowly professions such as teaching.
don’t really know why I’m writing this but maybe it’s because I’m a monkey who’s got nothing better to do with their time. Ps. Apologies for any grammar/spelling errors and if this is coming across as nonsensical, I think it’s just part of the parcel of being a teaching monkey.
also am so tired as I had to get up at 5 to get to school. Ate a quick banana for breakfast and lunch (didn’t have time for anything else) and didn’t get home till 7. Yawn. I get tired as well coz if I meet any non- monkeys it tires me out trying to get my head around their tiny heads, funny views of the world and odd superiority complex’s. On the plus side- at least I will have my pension to take me in to retirement - they’ll all be scraping together their pennies and going on holiday to Blackpool (no offense intended) whilst I am sunning myself on the beach in the Maldives and paying for a private nanny for my grandkids so I don’t have to get off my lazy arse and help out.
also, sorry about my flaky nails. They keep getting paint stuck under them and I keep accidentally trimming them in the paper cutter. Keep meaning to have a manicure but don’t seem to have time in the day. Omg and my wardrobe! Yes, I know. But y’a know. When I’m so lowly and in such a dead end profession, it’s not worth it really. I’ll leave the glam to the other monkeys.
wow. This really doesn’t make sense .
have a good day fellow monkeys!

You do not really project your profession in a good light do you? You are really going to compare the amount of hours that you work with that of nurses, I mean REALLY? It must be so demanding and brain draining having to mind your P’s and Q’s around children for the 6 or 7 hours while around the children, whereas nurses have to mind everything in case you know, someone dies by one of their slip ups!
Honestly I would have expected a much more mature response from someone that is teaching our future generation on how to handle life to the best of their abilities instead of some dim witted passive aggression towards the town where I live. Honestly the only disagreement that I had with the OP was the fact that you could train a monkey to do a teacher’s job, but after your response I am now not so sure. Have a great day back helping the children catch up (again) on their education. In fact if you were not out all day picketing in defence of your belief that you deserve a raise more than anyone else in the public sector then your commitment to the job you are paid for should be put under scrutiny.

Radiatingradiator · 02/02/2023 02:00

you really are insightful. I’m actually a monkey and also a teacher. My fellow monkeys work in many different fields such as banking, customer facing, hospitality, admin and advertising. I feel lucky to have found a profeshun which seems to keep me on my toes, develops my organisation skills, allows me to nurture baby monkeys, gives me the opportunity to share knowledge which we have learnt through our many wise years on the planet and has allowed me to teach other monkeys to develop there skills to work in high end jobs which help to boost their egoes and gives them the skills necessery to slag off those monkeys who end up in lowly professions such as teaching.
don’t really know why I’m writing this but maybe it’s because I’m a monkey who’s got nothing better to do with their time. Ps. Apologies for any grammar/spelling errors and if this is coming across as nonsensical, I think it’s just part of the parcel of being a teaching monkey.
also am so tired as I had to get up at 5 to get to school. Ate a quick banana for breakfast and lunch (didn’t have time for anything else) and didn’t get home till 7. Yawn. I get tired as well coz if I meet any non- monkeys it tires me out trying to get my head around their tiny heads, funny views of the world and odd superiority complex’s. On the plus side- at least I will have my pension to take me in to retirement - they’ll all be scraping together their pennies and going on holiday to Blackpool (no offense intended) whilst I am sunning myself on the beach in the Maldives and paying for a private nanny for my grandkids so I don’t have to get off my lazy arse and help out.
also, sorry about my flaky nails. They keep getting paint stuck under them and I keep accidentally trimming them in the paper cutter. Keep meaning to have a manicure but don’t seem to have time in the day. Omg and my wardrobe! Yes, I know. But y’a know. When I’m so lowly and in such a dead end profession, it’s not worth it really. I’ll leave the glam to the other monkeys.
wow. This really doesn’t make sense .
have a good day fellow monkeys!

SavageSeraphim · 01/02/2023 22:52

I know this is reopening an old thread but has much changed?
I agree with the OP and also think we can throw train drivers in with the original question too. As the husband of a nurse who would love a pay rise in line with inflation I would love to know why teachers and train drivers believe that they deserve so much more of the money that is no longer there? After all the problems with COVID and the education of our future generation any teacher that puts themselves out there to strike instead of committing to getting the children back on track is selfish and not worthy of the position they were entrusted with.
You will get no love or support from me as all you are doing currently is making matters worse for others, the cost of living crisis is affecting everyone right. Plus have you seen your wages in comparison to nurses? Don’t talk to me about long hours and your future plans 30 or 40 years in the future because not so long ago a lot of nurses were thinking they may not have one. But they were still there working everyday instead of abandoning their patients!

Peachy · 20/06/2011 12:35

SMART targets useful for iep setting, only way to stop senco setting vague targets such as 'stops being naughty'.

Mind, I did civil service SMART training pushing twenty years ago so very used to it

allegrageller · 20/06/2011 11:06

It's also happening in universities alistron. Talk of 'value added' and 'target-driven performance' imposed by people who have no idea what academics actually do, but think that 'market values' (bleurgh) and 'competition' will improve it- against all the evidence.

What then reduces me to hollow laughter, is that Tories and private-sector mavens then come on threads like this claiming that due to declining standards, teachers have been proven to be 'lazy' and 'incompetent' when in fact they are exposed to more stress and crap than ever and most of them are still doing a great job despite continuous attempts by successive governments (including Nu Labour) to eff it up.

bitemabum · 19/06/2011 19:20

i'm coming to this discussion late on but as far as the op is concerned YABVU. I want my kids to be taught by people who feel valued, yes they get great holidays blah blah blah, but the job they do is too important to treat them badly.

alistron1 · 19/06/2011 19:08

Agree allegrageller. I worked in a corporate private sector environment in the late 90's and it's scary to see how many shite ideas have made it into education. SMART objectives anyone?

allegrageller · 19/06/2011 18:58

And how exactly is grade inflation teachers' fault? If anything, it is the fault of the ludicrous school 'performance' tables system in which schools are valued according to the number of As they can produce, and a dreadful managerial culture of targets and constant 'improvement' of what did not need meddling with in the first place. Values borrowed entirely from your beloved private sector and completely misplaced when it comes to education.

allegrageller · 19/06/2011 18:56

no, mdowdall, I am not a Labour supporter. But I do'nt blame the entire global economic meltdown on any one party. I loathed Blair, and didn't think Brown was quite so bad, but I have no allegiance to any party because basically I think they have all sold us down the neoliberal river.

mdowdall · 19/06/2011 15:43

Well fair enough echt not being a teacher I bow to your greater knowledge. But humour me for a minute - isn't grade inflation the major problem? As a layperson, that seems to me to be where the issue lies in terms of just making a mockery of the system and making it hard for employers to distinguish between one kid and the next.

OP posts:
echt · 19/06/2011 09:35

Er...because the alternative is horrendously shite?

Actually, and I can't quote the research, but the average teacher voter in the early 21st century was a tory-voting arsehole. And judging by staffroom conversations and seeing union action at the time, I'd endorse this.

Education was joke looong before Nulabour got in. I can't think of a single sentient socialist teacher who didn't think that Labour would shit on the teachers. The lesser of two evils, as they say.

mdowdall · 19/06/2011 09:05

I take it from your post allegrageller that you are a labour supporter? If so, how on earth can you talk about 'undervaluing' education? Education lost its value when grade inflation went rampant under which, erm, administration? I dislike Cameron and his posh mates as much as the next man. But I also struggle to understand why teachers continue to swear allegance to a party that basically made education in this country an absolute joke.

OP posts:
tazmosis · 18/06/2011 21:16

Yes YABU as well as coming across as quite ignorant and rather thick.

And I'm not a teacher.

shiporsheep · 18/06/2011 21:15

Actually, you could say there is a lot of "martyrdom" in teaching - all the ones I know make massive sacrifices to help (in many ways) the children (that's YOUR DC) they teach.

Having two sisters as teachers I know they conclude that some schools are "easier" than others but during any position they worked most of the holidays and never worked less than 10 hours a day. Think about all the marking, all the preparing - and standards are so high nowadays -it can only be doing in the evenings and weekends. It cost them their health and their marriages (typical of teaching)

allegrageller · 18/06/2011 21:07

Yeah I wish they'd piss off back to the Daily Fail mouth-foaming comment forums frankly

Realitystrikesback · 18/06/2011 21:00

What is it with all the right wing, teacher hating trolls tonight? Doesn't the conservative club bar open on a Saturday night?

allegrageller · 18/06/2011 20:58

martyrdom my arse. Angelhouse is simply pointing out how utterly undervalued teaching is. Your 'raw economics' makes not a jot of difference to that. Tax the idle rich more and ban pointless wars to pay teachers according to the contracts of employment they signed? No problem for the sane.

I am so bored with teacher bashers and their two-bit arguments. Blah private sector pensions are crap too (agreed; that is an argument for better State provision). Blah Labour sent the country bankrupt (Cameron is spending more on his failure to tax the rich and corporations appropriately, loony plans for university loans and frankly out of character foreign aid plans). I've heard nothing except inarticulate jealousy and a pretence of 'pragmatism' (i.e. short termism) from teacher bashers and I suspect that they simply undervalue education because they were not able or willing to benefit from it themselves.

alistron1 · 18/06/2011 19:28

mdowall, I don't see angelmouse being a martyr. She's spelling out the realities of teaching. I said it earlier, in the 'boom' years I didn't see the private sector calling for the wages of teachers/nurses/police officers to rise, I didn't see the private sector calling for public sector workers to get bonuses.

If those in the private sector think that teaching is such a good deal then maybe they should do the training and do the job?

littlestressy · 18/06/2011 18:45

I do so love being compared to a monkey, thank you so much.

I came to teaching after working in the private sector, I have been a teacher for over 8 years now and I cannot think of a job I would rather do since I love teaching, watching children grow in knowledge and self esteem. However, I sacrifice a lot in order to give the most to my job. I work 8.00 - 6.00 pretty much every day (what's a lunch hour?), I work at the weekends, every weekend. Yes we do get good holidays but guess what, I also work in the holidays and when that holiday arrives I NEED IT.

Why shouldn't I be angry that the things we were promised are going to be taken away from us?

mdowdall · 18/06/2011 17:29

angelmouse75 - you have taken martyrdom to new heights with your last post.
Consider the following:
Unions claim that the average Public Sector pension is just £4200.
What the unions don't tell you is that this figure excludes the highest earners.. but includes people who have worked for in a Public position for just a few months.
Private sector employees would need to build up a pension pot of £189,151 - equivalent to £6,300 each year for 30 years, to receive the average annual pension paid to civil servants.
Private sector workers would need to contribute 37% of their salary to their pension pot of their working lifetime to match the retirement income paid to a public sector on an equivalent wage.
My point being that the pensions being paid to public sector workers - including teachers - don't stack up. This isnt public sector worker-bashing. It is just blunt economics.

OP posts:
Peachy · 18/06/2011 17:18

Harriet how can we evidence the redundancies witgout outing the schools where our children attend? Two at our 250 child primary is all I can offer.

When I was a student nurse we used to get long lectures from our course leaders on how important it was to retain a sense of ourselves as employees with rights and not just get stuck with some angel / state worker / can;t stick up for ourselves badge. I used to say I would enver strike and wonder why the emphasis. Now I understand.

Swipe left for the next trending thread