Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm in love with DH's best friend.

634 replies

Feronia · 04/06/2011 20:54

DH and I have been married for six years, together for ten. We have a one year old daughter and a very comfortable life.

Ten months ago DH's best friend from school and uni came to stay with us for a few weeks while the sale of his house went through. (had sold his Scottish house and moving to London.) it was the start of loads of arguments for DH and I because I wasn't happy about having a virtual stranger (to me) in the house when I had a new baby.

It was awkward at first, with breastfeeding, looking a state etc, but with DH at work, it became really lovely to have X around. I found myself making sure I put make up on and tried to dress up. X would come with me to baby clinic, for walks in the park, shopping.

He ended up staying about 9 weeks. When he moved out I felt such a sense of loss, it was like someone had died. I'd cry all the time and just be awful to DH, and I'm sure my family think I had some sort of late postnatal depression.

After three weeks of not seeing him I texted him and suggested a coffee, joking my DD was missing him. He seemed to jump at the chance and we met that day. And many days since. I can't get enough of him and I think he feels the same. When my DH was away for a night last week, X came over in the evening and after some wine he kissed me and I've never been so happy. He wanted to stay but I made him leave. Which I sort of regret.

Im completely in love with him. If I don't see him for a day it's like my heart will break.

I don't know what to do.

OP posts:
TheLadyEvenstar · 05/06/2011 23:27

I have been reading this and have lurked.

IMO, the OP's husband was unfair to bring a stranger into their home during the early times of being a mum. It is as well all know a difficult time for many if not all of us. Yet regardless of this he went ahead with the plans. The OP made her thoughts on him moving in very clear to her H, yet again he didn't listen and he carried on with his plans.

Throw into it that the OP ended up back in hospital due to illness when her DD was very young - this explains (imo) why she doesn't like to leave her DD. I know that being seperated from DS2 for the first 5 days of his life while he was in SCBU and I was in the maternity ward made me feel the same for a long time.

However, This is probably where I will go against the grain slightly.

Whilst I am not in agreeance with what the OP is going through her H is also partly guilty in this.

Many posters are harping on about how lucky she is to have someone who treats her like a princess right down to not letting her carry a bag. But at the same time his spare time is taken up with other things in this instance drinking and playing golf as opposed to being home with his wife and daughter. Its easy to see why when lavished with attention she has fallen in love - HOWEVER, it is plain to see that it is not the Man she has fallen in love with but the attention, care, and companionship.

Of course given these conditions she will defend him because right now he is the one who has given her her self confidence back - which is apparent from the way she said
"I found myself making sure I put make up on and tried to dress up."

This is where her husband should have stepped in and made sure he gave her a compliment regardless of how small it may be. I am not blaming him solely I am also blaming his mate.

Its as if he has been brought in to the home to be a babysitter for the OP someone who will be there to make sure everything is running smoothly. When the OP had baby clinic etc her Husband should have been the one to attend with her not his friend, and if his friend was/still is out of work and he owns his own business then why does he not employ him rather than leave a vunerable (emotionally) woman in his company. Because for the life of me I cannot believe the OP's H has no idea of the fact his so called friend is a ladies man, Now in most circumstances women see this for what it is - a chancer taking a chance. But when we are vunerable we lap up the care and attention like a cat with cream.

I have to be honest IMO the OP's main crime here is to have been pulled in by a chancer because she was vunerable. She has not slept with him but has fallen for the attention he has given her - and when the chips are down then we could all be guilty of this.

OP, I hope you get this sorted - I did, although my circumstances were different.

Joolyjoolyjoo · 05/06/2011 23:26

I read this thread last night, although was just going to bed, so didn't post. I'm afraid I agree with most of the posters- this thing with X is unlikely to work, and, harsh though some of the replies seemed to be, I do believe they were given with the OPs best interests at heart. There is no delicate way to try to tell her just how close she is to getting embroilled in a huge mess, the aftershocks of which could be devastating, especially when she does seem to be a bit vulnerable.

One thing that struck me was the actions of X. OP, is there a history of competition between DH and him? Has he been jealous of your DH in the past? Just, to me, it sounds like your DH has it all- good job, nice house, money, a alovely wife and a new baby, while X has nothing. Could it be that he subconciously wants to spoil what your DH has, or make himself feel better that he doesn't have all this?

The reason I think this is, if he was a good friend to your DH, he would have been horrified at his feelings towards you and moved out before he could act on them- that's what most people would do, I think. Years ago, my best friend "stole" my much-loved boyfriend, it started behind my back, and was no doubt an exciting affair. My friend has always been quite competitive with me, and she was not happy to come home from travelling to find me with a boyfriend- in fact she was so horrible to him at first that he hated her,as she perpetuated to hate him. I was always trying to be peacemaker, so bit of a kick in the teeth to find he was leaving me for her!! Thing was, I soon decided that I wasn't going to give him (or her) the satisfaction of knowing it had upset me to the point of destroying our friendship, so I contacted her, forgave her, gave them my blessing. Funnily enough, his attraction totally waned for her after that, and he spent the next couple of years crying on my shoulder at parties, telling me that she was cheating on (she was) and treating him like shit (she was). She never really loved him, I think- it was just a way of getting one over on me, although I'm sure she didn't actually realise that at the time. I'm worried X could be similar, and once the competition is "won", he will quickly lose interest in you and your dd. That is what posters here are trying to protect you from, because it is a real possibility that you could find yourself properly alone, with friends and family alike not speaking to you because of your actions.

Please go really carefully

mrswhiskerson · 05/06/2011 23:23

I feel for you , this man has come into your life at a very vulnerable time and because you have bonded with him and your dh is not there as much it is understandable to think you might have feelings for him but think of it this way if he were decent person he would not want to get involved with his best friends wife who is also the mother of his baby .

You need to cut contact with him and spend time with amfriend or family
member and get your thoughts together . How would you feel if the situation were reversed? And your dh fell in love with your best friend ? Your body and mind have been through a lot first having had a babythen not having your dh around as much as you need and along has come a man who has made you feel better and gave you the support you need . Have a date night with your dh and have a lovely time , tell him you need himore and you are going through a rough time emotionally .I'm sure he will want to help you might look back in a year and feel so glad you didn't ruin your marriage.

Good luck with everything .

fit2drop · 05/06/2011 22:56

It does not matter how much people try and pretty it up OP has to take responsibility for her thoughts and actions.
Her husband is not responsible for this.
He is responsible for his marriage , He is not responsible for his wife's shenanigans. Even if he was a bastard (which by OP description , he clearly isnt) and she had an affair it would still not be his fault, it would be her choice.
Any one in a marriage that they dont want to be in should walk away , falling "in love" with someone else whilst you are in love with someone is not or should not even be an option that you think of.
This X has not magically tricked her or put a spell on her .He is a player, she has allowed herself to be charmed by him. If she was not married and he had charmed her ....Maybe she deserves some sympathy, but she is married therefore this should have been trodden on the moment it got cosy, when he started saying how much time he spent with her dd opposed to her husband. She should have defended her hubby. When he offered to walk to the park with her , she should have said No , its fine , or thank you , you take the baby for a walk and I will take advantage and have some me time. He would not have offered again because it was her he was trying to get close to. She has allowed this scenario to build up into what she herself calls a Greek tragedy Hmm
She needs to take responsibility instead of acting like her husband is the pea under her princess mattresses

scottishmummy · 05/06/2011 22:32

wife getting it on with her dh best pal
well, that usually gets vigorous response or a so called pasting
really,unlikely anyone would say och poor you.what a dilemma darling

flaxensunshine · 05/06/2011 22:29

I feel for you OP, you have taken a roasting here, please give us an update..................

mathanxiety · 05/06/2011 22:24

Takeitonthechins, that suggestion of yours is a very interesting one.

(The mate was a stranger to the OP when he descended upon her and her DH right after the traumatic birth. Apparently she had never met him.)

OP, how close were your H and this man in university? (IYKWIM) It was evidently an important enough relationship that he was prepared to overrule his wife about the 2 month visit at a time when he should have been bending over backwards to make her life easier (and not by carrying shopping) and trying to ensure that his own DD got off to the nest possible start with breastfeeding. What he did in going ahead with the invitation to the friend was moronic.

zippy539 · 05/06/2011 22:17

Just checking in - hope you're okay Feronia and are getting things sorted.

ThatVikRinA22 · 05/06/2011 21:38

i think the only way to fix this mess is with total and utter honesty.

harsh though some of the replies have been, i wish i had had such straight talking when i was in a similar position.

when youre feeling vulnerable it is easy to have your head turned by someone offering you what you think you want.

it was only when i realised what i stood to lose that i wised up, told my DH everything and went to counselling.
this was 17 years ago after a particularly difficult time in our lives, we almost lost our son to illness and i lived apart from dh in hospital for 2 months with our son. not an excuse, but a reason.

the only way to fix this is to be honest with your DH. secrets will fester and it wont get better on its own.
IF you want to make a go of it with your DH then you have to get this other man out of your lives, and you have to tell your DH that he is showing an interest in you and thats why you dont want him around.

you will find out what sort of a man your dh is.
i found out mine was worth his weight in gold. faults, yes, but he accepted his part in our difficulties and fought tooth and nail to hang on to his family. I think it was only then that i realised how much he loved me, and how much i loved him.
dont throw it all away for nothing but a bit of passing attention.
i want you to listen before something goes wrong that you cannot fix.

TooImmature2BMum · 05/06/2011 20:32

Can I just point out that it is not possible for a guy to kiss you without your connivance? There's always a point at which you can turn your head away, or step back, or push him away. He has to be right in your personal space to do it. Stop pretending that he did it and that you were the innocent victim (as someone else said upthread).

FairhairedandFrustrated · 05/06/2011 19:51

How has your day been Feronia?

I hope it went as well as it could have and you've been able to spend some time with Dh.

Chin up x

scottishmummy · 05/06/2011 19:43

you have a chance to save your marriage
get shot of the geezer guy pronto.tell dh he made pass at you
invest time and effort in your relationship with dh
a new baby is tumultuous event,and to an extent requires recognition of the emotional and social changes,change of role and tempo

stop mooning around after this fancy man.its probably a daft girly crush
you have responsibility to stop this,and stop making self available emotionally and physically to another man

Xales · 05/06/2011 18:41

Hope you have had a chat with your H and sorted it all out.

Thing is your H was out with X until 5 in the morning.

Think X will be any different if you dump your H and get together with him when the initial flush has worn off and he is working so not around to romance you and you are just like any other boring couple doing boring RL things?

EmmaBemma · 05/06/2011 18:30

I see what you're saying Georgimama, and I do partly agree, but the problem with telling her husband is that it puts the responsibility for dealing with the situation at least partly on his shoulders. The rationale being, if she doesn't tell him, X won't give up. But it's unlikely that in all her married life she'll never meet anyone else she's attracted to. She needs to be sure in her own head of where her priorities lie and then stick to them. Telling her husband about his friend (and unleashing the shitstorm that is bound to follow) won't help her with that.

QuintessentialOldMoo · 05/06/2011 18:19

I dont think your husband wants to stay friends with this man, he has thoroughly betrayed him. (As have you, btw)

At the same time, it is not right to keep this from him.

Georgimama · 05/06/2011 18:09

I think the problem EmmaBemma is that X is a player who is unlikely to take no for an answer. It is quite clear that if the OP tells him to take a hike, she doesn't really want him to (I do sympathise, she knows what she should do and in a year if she gets through this she will be thinking "thank Christ" but at the moment her resolve is weak) and he will probably see that. The kind of man who thinks it is OK to make a move on his friend of 24 years' wife while said friend is putting him up, who texts the wife whilst at the pub with the husband, is a shit of the highest order. The OP has become his little project - he's in this for the conquest.

I agree with BranchingOut completely, the OP needs to tell her husband the truth. Part of this is his fault - he has neglected her, albeit possibly for the best of reasons (provider instinct) or just because he doesn't really know how he fits into the new domestic set up. I seem to remember a thread recently where everyone (everyone except me actually) thought that a MNer had to tell her friend that his girlfriend was cheating on him with another friend of his. Her husband deserves to know what a shitbag this man is.

EmmaBemma · 05/06/2011 17:46

"You are not going to be able to get rid of X without telling your husband."

I don't agree with this. I'm not sure what good telling her husband would achieve at this stage. I don't see why a simple face-to-face conversation with X wouldn't be enough to put a stop to it so long as you are absolutely clear both with yourself and with him that it's going nowhere. And then that needs to be it, finished, no moony looks across the room or little texts or anything, be cordial and friendly to him around your husband when he's invited over but no more.

I know this is possible as I have done it (though things never got beyond the moony look stage with me) and I know I'm not the only one. It's just a matter of identifying what's really important in your life, and then doing what you can to protect and nurture that. I agree with everyone who says that X sounds like an arsehole, he's not treating your husband or you with any respect.

BranchingOut · 05/06/2011 17:15

I think you have been given quite a tough time on this thread, but I think it is because so many posters can see that you are one step away from the edge of the abyss.

We can't reach into your lives and physically stop what might be about to happen, but you can.

This is your turning point. You have done nothing irrevocable. A few simple steps can get you back on the right track. They may be temporarily uncomfortable, but oh so much easier than the alternative.

I am going to spell it out for you.

You are not going to be able to get rid of X without telling your husband.

Sexual attraction is a very powerful force. It skews your judgement, your senses, your perception. I bet that every bit of you right now is in a heightened state of awareness. If you were alone with X right now then it would happen. X is in the same state. He wants you. Every part of him is seeking you and he will be as patient or as devious as it takes to get you.

Yet you are a good person. You have lived a straightforward life and you don't want this to happen - surely it will be enough to say no to him and make him stick to that refusal? Sorry - I don't think it will be enough.

You can send him a message telling him you want nothing more to do with him. He will turn up at your door. He will corner you at a social event. He will kiss you even as your husband is at the door to the room where you are standing.

You manage to get rid of him for two weeks. He will turn up out of the blue in three weeks time.

He will say 'Yes, I will do as you say', then go away for a month and a half until you are missing him. Then when he returns your yearning for him and the easy access he has to your home and social life will mean that his work will be half-done.

The only way out of this situation is to tell your husband that X has made a move on you. Put the blame on him if necessary, but you need for your husband to be sufficiently angry with X to want to get him out of both your lives.

With best wishes.

QuintessentialOldMoo · 05/06/2011 16:55

Call your dh and tell her that his friend has kissed you and were texting you all night yesterday to meet you today for lunch, and that he better be out of the house when you get back as you need to talk to your husband without his friend there.

Geordieminx · 05/06/2011 16:38

Hope you are ok. X

JamieAgain · 05/06/2011 15:58

fit2drop - what do you think she wanted to hear?

I think she wanted sympathy, but actually no-one has given her the green light to have an affair, or to think this OM is a good prospect. She's already said she's going to speak to her DH

bringmesunshine2009 · 05/06/2011 14:31

Hello feronia, I was posting last night and though I'd see what happened. Sorry you have been given such a hard time.

DH has neglected you a bit. Out until 5am with a wife and baby at home is pretty shoddy. You sound lonely. You also sound like you used to have quite a glizty life with DH (I saw he went to Raffles) and he earns relatively well. I have a lot of empathy. The gear change from professional girl about town to FT mother is immense (TELL ME ABOUT IT!). Perhaps there is a part of you that thinks other mothers don't have a lot in common with you. I used to feel like that too.

Are you in London? If so, you can PM (not sure how I receive them-assume you click my name and it goes to my email? Let me know if you do)me and I will hang out with you and DD, then no need to hang out with X dammit. I am on maternity leave with number 2. I know lots of people have been very mean, it is easy to be all moralistic if you aren't in your shoes.

Take sometime to work things through. Sounds like you have a plan. Sticking with DH. Avoid X. Get DH on his own. Have big talk. It sounds like you want to talk to DH before X decides to say something to him or he finds something out himself. Like you want to put your side of the story first. Hence not wanting to tell X to do one, in case he gets all nose out of joint and tells DH re kiss out of spite. I get it. There might be something in the telling of Dh about your feelings for X. In that if you don't DH won't really listen, particularly since he doesn't seem to be paying you much attention. Only you can judge whether that is a good idea.

After speaking with DH, if X doens't leave you alone, tell him if he has any respect for you and DD he will back off. If he doesn't, you may have to tell DH then.

Consider this from DH's angle, in terms of the work wthic thing, but don't undervalue yourself. The whole 'he deserves to stay out until 5 on the piss and spending the day golfing' stuff is a bit lame. You need some attention too. 1 year olds, lovely though they are, are not necessarily scintillating compamny. Hence why X has been able to make a move.

Hope X sods off soon and you can talk to DH and plan yer next move. Remember-you can always hang with me lol.

xx

fit2drop · 05/06/2011 14:23

wanders in to see if violins are playing yet in this self directed self starring role Greek tragedy

afwiw Every post by Morloth is sensible and wise ,

Feronia only come back once the sympathy brigade came in.
she only wants to listen to what she wants to hear which is probably exactly what she is doing at home too

cue violins and exit stage right :)

UndiscoveredApprentice · 05/06/2011 14:15

how about telling hubby how conflicting you are fniding have X there - that you find yourself being accidnetally drawn into a family live with X as he has the free time, and that you are worried that you may end up going down a path you don't want to go down.

And that for the sake of your future happiness you feel some distance between your family life and X would be healthy.

Might he understand the message and plea in that, without having to be specific?

emmanana · 05/06/2011 13:04

Well, luckily for me it's started raining! Yes, I should imagine DH has just said to X
'Sorry, it's started raining, so could you please leave and make some other arrangements for lunch' Not.
Phone DH (not text) and ask him to meet you. Alone.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread