Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm in love with DH's best friend.

634 replies

Feronia · 04/06/2011 20:54

DH and I have been married for six years, together for ten. We have a one year old daughter and a very comfortable life.

Ten months ago DH's best friend from school and uni came to stay with us for a few weeks while the sale of his house went through. (had sold his Scottish house and moving to London.) it was the start of loads of arguments for DH and I because I wasn't happy about having a virtual stranger (to me) in the house when I had a new baby.

It was awkward at first, with breastfeeding, looking a state etc, but with DH at work, it became really lovely to have X around. I found myself making sure I put make up on and tried to dress up. X would come with me to baby clinic, for walks in the park, shopping.

He ended up staying about 9 weeks. When he moved out I felt such a sense of loss, it was like someone had died. I'd cry all the time and just be awful to DH, and I'm sure my family think I had some sort of late postnatal depression.

After three weeks of not seeing him I texted him and suggested a coffee, joking my DD was missing him. He seemed to jump at the chance and we met that day. And many days since. I can't get enough of him and I think he feels the same. When my DH was away for a night last week, X came over in the evening and after some wine he kissed me and I've never been so happy. He wanted to stay but I made him leave. Which I sort of regret.

Im completely in love with him. If I don't see him for a day it's like my heart will break.

I don't know what to do.

OP posts:
Mapley · 06/06/2011 17:34

Or "not just friends!"

Mapley · 06/06/2011 17:28

Crikey, while I agree with the general theme of advice ( ie stop talking to X and talk to your husband), there's some very unempathic, shallow, knee jerk reactions in this thread.

I'm surprised too the the poster called "whenwillifeelnormal" hasn't posted. Think she normally posts on the relationship. Board. You'll pribably get wiser and more constructive advise if you start a thread there. There's lots of people who post there who have been in your shoes. You won't get told much different to stop talking to x and talk to your husband, but you might get more of an explanation about what led you to this point.

I've been in your shoes and further on in the situation and genuinely from the heart I say DO STOP. If you carry on talking to X and the rest then only intense misery follows. For yourself and for both men. And for your daughter and wider family.

People are fragile, relationships can be fragile. All manner of normal life situations can cause both to break. If you're feeling sad, anxious, lonely, tired, stressed, unappreciated, bored or any normal life scenario you can be vunerable to having your head turned in a rationship. You maynot conciously look for an affair, but you're feeling a bit rubbish, and suddenly someone is in your life who provides a relief from those feelings. Your relationship with them becomes something that makes you feel good, initially probably totally inocently. But that good feeling is addictive and provides a salve to your sadness/boredness/stress. Then there grows a contrast between the light happiness you feel whilst in new company to the weight of your familiar relationship. And even if nothing was particularly wrong in that relationship before you met the new person, you'll start to notice and question it as it can't help but suffer in comparison.

I think you're at this point. And you've a choice here. Either continue into madness by questioning your relationship from the addictive newness and passion of the relationship with x and slide into secrecy, self hatred and misery. Or face upto the feelings and situations that left you vunerable, with your dh's help, and face then together and change things appropriately.

I don't think there should be any blame. You're just human and human's aren't perfect. Just act now and don't go any further.

There's a book "just good friends" or something by Lucy Bancroft I think. Buy three copies and all 3 of you read it

passiveaggresive · 06/06/2011 17:10

It IS an emotional gesture, her DH is taking her away for the weekend - he hasn't bought her a pair of shoes!

NoseyNooNoo · 06/06/2011 17:08

I don't think OP needs to be grateful just because her DH is wealthy and is taking her way for the weekend. The OP is not somone who can be bought through expensive gestures. This thread has shown quite clearly that OP wants an emotionla gesture, not a financial one.

Best of luck OP.

katvond · 06/06/2011 16:57

I agree passive that x is not gonna go away easily
You should get that key back off him too,sounds a right nutter OP
Sorry your having a bad day passive, sending hugs ((()))

Enjoy disneyland too we took DD when she was 3 and she loved it :)

passiveaggresive · 06/06/2011 16:47

You know what - its mine and DPs anniversary today, i am feeling pretty bloody crap because we have financial problems so there wont be any cards, any romantic meal or surprise trip to disneyland. So don't you bloody dare be blowing this gesture your DH is making for you, county your blessings, ditch the slimeball (you seem to be doing this but the once and for all way is to tell your DH what really happened) and make an effort to enjoy what could be a wonderful weekend.

TotallyLovely · 06/06/2011 16:37

How much of the X stuff did you tell him? I got the impression that you didn't tell him about your attraction or that X is pursuing you but just that he was around and took on a bit of a dad role. Is that right?

passiveaggresive · 06/06/2011 16:35

Yes, please tell your DH that he turned up, this bastard idnt taking no for an answer - i think your idea about taking your DD into work to see your old mates is a good idea, but do make a time to do it rather than just pitching up, that way everyone will have time to fuss over you and DD and you wont feel out it.

Good luck with the doctor and enjoy disneyland - im actually envious!!

emmanana · 06/06/2011 16:32

You must tell DH that X turned up. Just carry on being as truthful as you have been with him. If your husband asks him to keep away then it may knock some sense into him. You have nothing to hide now.
The Disney thing is a lovely idea. As someone said, don't slate him for choice; he is a bloke, and thought what would combine a break, with something kids love? My DH would struggle to think of Disneyland tbh.

It could possibly be very good for you. Rather than sitting across a dinner table or opposite ends of a sofa, some of the awkwardness could be bridged as you push DD around the park. She is far too young to knpw what you are talking about. Take a camera and get into the spirit taking lots of pics.
Whilst the past must be discussed, so you can move on with things, talk about the future too; maybe where you like to go for another holiday!
I hope it goes well at the weekend.

TotallyLovely · 06/06/2011 16:28

He's not exactly communicative your DH is he?!

Driftwood999 · 06/06/2011 16:18

Read inital pages then a few. Get a grip woman, you have it all, a husband a baby and a comfortable life. Build on that. Millions would change places with you. ysc. It could be your hormones/boredom/adjustment.

katvond · 06/06/2011 16:12

If I was with you now I would be shaking you! Get it into your crazy head he wants to ruin your life and he came fucking close
get this wanker out of your life NOW

katvond · 06/06/2011 16:11

X as just turned up !!! this man is turning into a loony stalker
he needs to stay away from you and your DH
Ignoring him won't work,tell DH X is bothering you and both sever ties
This mans a parasite and won't give in easy

Feronia · 06/06/2011 16:06

Othehugemanitee - he's 10 years older than me... (well, 9 actually)

X turned up here a while ago but I saw him from my bedroom window and cowardly stayed upstairs. Then I panicked that he might still have his key but must not have because after a couple of minutes he left. He must have seen my car outside though...

I've spoken to DH but he really didn't want to talk about it. It's like yesterday and this morning never happened? He just suggested I go out and buy a smaller buggy for travelling with. Literally - that's all he said.

I've booked an appointment with my GP for Thursday and will talk it through with her.

I'm also going to take DD into work with me for a visit to try and reconnect with some friends there. Maybe tomorrow...

OP posts:
passiveaggresive · 06/06/2011 16:02

Firstly - you have just dropped a massive bombshell to your DH, of course he is going to be upset, he probably acting angry because he is so upset. What i cant understand is why the two of you cant have a conversation - he left answer message for you about disneyland so this is what you do. You phone him up and say "Thankyou DH that is a lovely gesture , im really looking forward to it" You certainly don't whinge about it not being much fun for your DD. It WILL be fun for your DD if you make it fun - there are loads of things suitable for young children and there are child friendly resturants etc etc. Cut your poor DH some slack - yeah, its not ideal but hes TRYING, you actually should be counting yourself lucky he is willing to try because if it were my DP then he would have packed my bags for me and told me if i liked X that much to go and be with X.

That said, i think you have been extremely brave, i hope you have told your DH about X kissing you, if you don't it will look like it is all coming from you, rather than X being a slimey cunt and coming on to his "best mates" wife. Your DH needs to know what sort of person he is and that actually he doesnt deserve his friendship. If the friendship with X continues IF, then it will always be there - knowing glances, he wont leave it, you know that - you're even more of a challenge now. If he were a man he would leave the pair of you alone, but he hasnt done that has he, he has bombarded you with calls, probably to cover his arse make sure you are ok.

Again, well done for facing this head on, i know you have been given a hard time and ive probably been one of the harshest posters, but i do admire you because im not sure if i would have been brave enough to do that. Do try and understand about the building the business up, that will pay back in dividends later on because once its properly established he will be able to spend more time with you all - he has the long haul in mind.

So we are back to finding things to fill the time, maybe you could consider doing very part time work just to give you something other than DD and DH to focus on. Some voluntary work? That way you can do something you enjoy and money doesnt seem to be an issue.

Also, i have to say, i feel a little bit swept away by your DH's disneyland gesture - THAT is romantic, and im being deadly serious. You have a wonderful man there and he clearly loves you, and you clearly deserve his love. Work at this and i think you will be very happy x

DandyLioness · 06/06/2011 15:43

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

thingsabeachanging · 06/06/2011 15:29

I would wager that if you sort out the issues you have with your husband your feelings for X will dissapear.

I am going to give X the benefit of the doubt (and ignor the fact that he seemed to be getting off on texting his best mates wife while out with him. Thus making him a complete arse) and say that I think he is jealous of your DH's life and it is that he wants rather than you. I know that is a harsh way to look at things but those feelings appear to be quite common, although most would not try to act on them.

Your DH is showing, by booking disney, that he wants to work things out with you and show you that he can be a family man. He is going an arse about face way of doing it but he is trying so go with it!

If I were you I would get to a GP. Wanting to be with your child is normal, having a complete inability to leave her even for an hour is not. You sounds like you may have PND which is nothing at all to be ashamed of!

Weekends away and even evenings out can be a lot of pressure. After this weekend can I suggest a few day trips both as a family and as a couple. Maybe a cinema trip for you 2 then you dont have the pressure of having to make conversation but you can still be together.

Your DH deserves some him time but you and your daughter deserve to have him around too. Why dont you have a family day every weekend then every other week you could have a day for yourselves. You could look after dd while he golfs one weekend then the next he could look after dd (not forgetting he needs some time to really bond with dd as it doesnt appear you have allowed him much of an opportunity do do this thus far) while you go off and have some time for you!

Sorry for the epic post but its been 2 days in the making!

jeckadeck · 06/06/2011 15:27

I'm not going to give you as hard a time as some of the posters here -- I'm the product of a relationship which began when one party left their spouse for an affair so I'm not of the opinion that all such relationships automatically end in disaster or are delusional.

Having said that it does sound that the underlying issue is that you feel under-appreciated and under-loved by your DH and X, for whatever reason or motive, was able to step into the breach. I'm not sure that X is automatically as cynical as some of the posters here suggest -- it may be that he has genuinely been overwhelmed by feelings for you. But at best his feelings are endangering an old friendship and his old friend's marriage, at worst he gets a kick out of these sorts of situations. I think the odds are stacked against your being able to make a go of it with X. By far the most sensible option here is for you to work really hard to rebuild your marriage. If you and X are really to be then it will happen. But its not going to happen if the three of you are entangled in this difficult situation.

I also agree with other posters that you should probably front out to your DH what happened the unabridged version before X does. If X is more cynical than I'm giving him credit for, you don't want to be caught out if he takes your DH aside and tells him a different version. If you need to speak to X first so be it. But I don't think you can rebuild trust with your husband if you give him the half truth you are currently giving him.

HavePatience · 06/06/2011 15:18

Well said, NL. And nice and concise. Feronia please ignore my rambling post above and heed the advice of NL.

btw I love your name :)

Northernlurker · 06/06/2011 15:13

I think your dh is probably in a state of panic and trying to deal with everything at once. Presumably he's told X to back off. If you want your marriage to continue OP now is the time to work bloody hard at it. Disneyland is as good a place as any for both of you to start.

HavePatience · 06/06/2011 14:35

I've been reading this and lurking.
I think you should give this a try. DH is obviously trying to make things a bit better between the two of you and has decided to spend the weekend together as a family. He probably thought Disneyland would be perfect because it's marketed as the ultimate family experience.

You can make what you want of it, though, tbh. Some people are very anti-disney...etc. and it probably won't be so magical for her at 1, but she'll have a good time if you do.

"its not where you are but who you're with that really matters". So make the best of the weekend away as a family and enjoy reconnecting with DH and being a family of 3. :)

I'm not defending him completely, by the way. I think he has a lot to work on as well. But he's obviously heard that you are unhappy that he's not around much and that your relationship isn't what it used to be and is trying to make things better.

TotallyLovely · 06/06/2011 14:31

OTheHugeManatee Think you may be right.

AccioPinotGrigio · 06/06/2011 14:31

Sorry to bang on about Disneyland. I know it isn't a major issue in light of the situation and at least he is making a positive move in recognising that he needs to pay some attention to his family. Building a business can be all-consuming and I suspect that he is thinking of how his hard work will benefit his daughter (and his wife!) in the future.

MooMooFarm · 06/06/2011 14:27

By the way do you have family or friends other than x nearby who you would trust to babysit? It's really important that you try to have some time together without DD, IMO.

OTheHugeManatee · 06/06/2011 14:27

To me your DH sounds quite overbearing and not that easy to talk to. He certainly doesn't really seem to be listening, if his response to 'I'm unhappy, I just nearly had an affair and want to get back on track' is to book Eurodisney without even checking whether that's what you want Confused

You mentioned he's older than you - how big is the age gap between you? Could there be some kind of parent/child dynamic going on between you? It's not uncommon in relationships, especially where one partner is a bit older than the other, and can lead to things feeling very unequal.

There's something about the way you describe your life that leads me to suspect that you don't feel like an equal partner in your marriage - you didn't want a house guest straight after EMCS but got overruled, you're now going to Eurodisney without so much as a by your leave, etc. Something just sounds a bit odd about it. Am I completely misreading things here?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.