Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To mention to DDs teacher that a classmate appears to have hygiene issues

115 replies

Crazybit · 03/04/2011 13:04

or shall I mind my own business?

DD1 is in year 6 and is always mentioning that a girl in her glass stinks. I feel really sorry for the girl. Her mum doesn't seem the type of person I could approach so would it be really wrong to mention it to DDs teacher and perhaps suggest a little chat with the whole class about the importance of person hygiene? I also wonder if the girl has an infection of some type as DD says she smells of fish and her knickers are often black from urine, I assumed meaning she hasn't wiped after going to the loo.

Or should I keep stum and tell DD to stop being so horrible and keep her mouth shut about it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thecranberiezzzz · 02/09/2023 23:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LunaticIsOnTheGrass · 04/04/2011 10:25

I'm fine now, thanks everyone Smile

My stepmum moved in with my Dad when I was 12 & fortunately she did know how to look after a family & I was ok after that pretty much but those 3 yrs were horrible.

Well done OP, you definitely did the right thing.

Niecie · 04/04/2011 10:17

Well done Crazybit. I hope the teacher does something useful with the information.

prettyfly1 · 04/04/2011 10:00

Absolutely talk to the teacher. I was another one who was left to be a bit neglected and not encouraged to take proper care of herself and was bullied horribly for it - mortifying. It does sound like the cousin and her mum are a bit bitchy to be frank, but you certainly dont, so perhaps by mentioning you are concerned that this girl is being bullied and this is the reason behind it you can help her.

booandbump · 04/04/2011 09:53

Well done OP, I would have done exactly the same. I cannot understand all the people who are calling you a busybody Confused

I hope the girl gets whatever help/support she needs.

seeker · 04/04/2011 09:49

Of COURSE talk to the teacher. Why wouldn't you?

I'm sure you''ve already talked to your dd about the reasons this girl might be finsing things difficult - and how she absolutely mustn;t talk about it to her friends because that would be unkind, but talk to the school today!

Skinit · 04/04/2011 09:41

At my school there was a girl who was so negected and sad...all the kids picked on her....my friend and I went to the HT to tell her we felt bad for her ..we were about 13. THe HT listened as we described the girls bruises (all over her body) and then did nothing. I know she did nothing because nothing changed for this girl.

OP you should definately speak for this child.

Skinit · 04/04/2011 09:38

Ah Lunatic....how awful for you..I hope you're ok now.

[hug]

chimchar · 04/04/2011 09:32

well done crazy.

i too work in a school, and would welcome any information like this from a parent...if we already know, then no harm done and we would discuss the fact that the problem is possibly not being dealt with at home, or if we didn't know, we would have a starting block to look into how we were going to approach it.

i can't believe how many people have had a go at you....totally stupid. you have written on here in a sensitive and caring way crazy...you did the right thing.

JoBettany · 04/04/2011 09:20

Crazybit as I posted upthread I think you have done the right thing. It can't have been easy but it may help.

Crazybit · 04/04/2011 09:20

Aw Lunatic :( Sorry you went through that.

I didn't want to confuse the issue yesterday and mention it...but after speaking to DD last night and clarifying...the 'aunt' did not discuss it with the girls but did say 'oh does she?' and turned her nose up when her own daughter mentioned that the girl 'really smelt today'. Also, I forgot but DD had mentioned months ago after going round to the girls house that the house was a bit, cluttered and that the mum doesn't clean up, but smokes pot all day. She said the bedrooms where so cluttered that the boys didn't have a bedroom (aged 12 and 4 I think) and that they slept in their mums bed with her. The kids always look relatively clean and tidy so I don't think it's a case of wilful neglect, maybe she just needs a bit of help..

OP posts:
BuntyPenfold · 04/04/2011 09:19

(hugs Lunatic)

LunaticIsOnTheGrass · 04/04/2011 09:14

I was the smelly kid at school Sad

My Mum died when I was 9 & my Dad really had no idea how to look after kids.
I never had clean clothes & very rarely even got to have a bath. My hair was all matted underneath & I always had nits.

I was bullied horribly for it, but no adult ever got involved - nobody asked if I was ok or talked to my Dad or did anything about it.

I'm really glad you have spoken to the teacher OP Smile & I'm especially glad because the teacher said she hadn't picked up on it.

Hopefully this child will get help now & won't go through what I did.

JenaiMarrHePlaysGuitar · 04/04/2011 09:02

Well done, crazy :)

Crazybit · 04/04/2011 08:57

Well, I had a word with the teacher, felt very guilty, but she said thanks and that she hadn't picked up on it and she'd look into it.

OP posts:
JenaiMarrHePlaysGuitar · 03/04/2011 17:19

There was a girl in my class in 4th year juniors who was a bit whiffy. People called her names.

I swear I didn't join in the name-calling, and I always sat next to her. Through choice incidentally not some charitable bollocks - I liked her!

Years later I bumped into her. She described how her dad (a widower) had really struggled. And had a go at me for bullying her. Like I said, I swear I took no part in the bullying but clearly one of us remembered things inaccurately.

Sorry, this is a self-indulgent ramble. Thing is though, if one of us had talked to our parents, and they'd talked to the school, and the school had given a fuck, maybe her dad would've got the nudge he needed and this girl would've had a far happier childhood.

lesley33 · 03/04/2011 17:11

I went through a short period of smelling at school. I regularly washed, but because of lack of money I had very few clothes - 2 pairs of trousers, no skirts. My clothes weren't washed frequently enough and so started to smell.

In my case my parents really didn't seem to notice. I was called smelly at school and finally plucked up the courage to tell my mum. She said she couldn't smell me and then asked how long I had been wearing trousers and blouse. When I said 2 weeks, she said, oh you probably do smell then!

I got her to allow me to use the twin tub washing machine and from then on I didn't have a problem. But I wasn't being abused, was well fed and loved. But it would have been good if someone had talked to my mum earlier pointing out the problem. And my teachers did absolutely nothing - so don't assume this girl's will have.

Lancelottie · 03/04/2011 17:09

I can vouch for the fact that teachers DON'T always notice a child smells. Mine went on a residential trip and wet the bed every night (unexpectedly) so smelt bloody awful by the end of the week, and not one teacher noticed, but every child in the class knew.

Three YEARS later, it's come back to haunt him at secondary, with the result that, oh joy, now he's bedwetting again from misery, so the teasing cuts right to the bone.

Niecie · 03/04/2011 16:54

Doormat - you say that you don't think this girl is being neglected but you do think she might be being bullied. Surely, the fact that she is being bullied is reason enough to speak to the teacher? The teacher may well not be aware of it - bullies are, after all, pretty sneaky and are smart enough not to get caught easily.

I would also point out that you work in a nursery with small children who have presumably wear nappies and have related accidents or are just plain smelly. Of course some of the children would smell a little occasionally, until they have been changed.

You wouldn't expect a 10 yr old to smell though, not one that was properly cared for and had been taught personal hygiene skills appropriate for their age and stage of development.

JoBettany · 03/04/2011 16:54

Crazybit - as a teacher of some 20 years experience I would thank you for your information. I would not think you were interfering. You clearly care enough about this child to worry about her. You have done nothing wrong.

Crazybit · 03/04/2011 16:14

*word with the teacher not work

OP posts:
Crazybit · 03/04/2011 16:12

Zelly-thank you for your input and sorry that you went through that.

Doormat-I gave what I thought was the relevant 'facts' as I know them and was simply wondering what other people thought would be the right course of action, or not. Also, i did not once mention that I thought she was being abused or neglected.

Princessparty-I do not know if the cousins mum was 'bitching' as I wasn't there. My dd and her friends may habe been bitching but at the same time there was an element of concern or she wouldn't have kept mentioning it.

Worraliberty-I do not believe this is simply a nasty rumour, my DD has enough to talk about with me and her friends without entering into nasty bullying talk.

For all those that have not tried to make me into a nasty interfering busybody, I thank you for your input. I will have a work with the teacher and let you all know what she says. I suspect she will simply thank me for letting her know and I will be none the wiser of the outcome. However, at least i will not be worrying over whether should I/shouldn't I any longer and hopefully if there is a problem that is not already being dealt with, it should be at least looked into.

OP posts:
Zellys · 03/04/2011 16:10

Even if nothing had changed, even if I'd reacted badly to being asked if I was okay, I'd be looking back now knowing someone had given a shit.

This situation could be nothing, could be something. I 100% don't see how mentioning it, sensitively, to the teacher or other professional would be a bad thing. If the teacher secretly thinks the OP is being an 'interfering old busybody', so what? The OP will have done the right thing.

It must be so lonely for the girl, whatever is going on. I think a class talk about hygeine is a terrible terrible idea, kids aren't stupid. But a "I've heard from my DD that X is being picked on because the other kids think she smells, and she's being discussed by the other children - I wanted to let you know", could make all the difference.

If the girl has started her periods and isn't coping with them, that can be fixed easily before secondary school. If she has a medical problem, her parents will know to tell her new teachers ahead of time and she can be taught not to be ashamed and to explain to her classmates if necessary. What's happening at the moment is just going to shame and isolate her.

Geistesabwesenheit · 03/04/2011 16:00

I was in a similar situation to Zellys. Just one person speaking to either the teacher or maybe pastoral manager could make a huge difference.

worraliberty · 03/04/2011 16:00

There was a boy in my year at senior school who apprarently 'smelled'.

He actually didn't smell at all. One nasty child put the rumour around and after that, not a single child would sit next to him Sad

Swipe left for the next trending thread