Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How not to get a job

260 replies

beanlet · 01/04/2011 12:44

Having just advertised a (very) part time admin post I have been inundated by emails from people who have not read the ad properly, and it's taking up most of my working day answering them. Please, people:

If the advertisement says apply using the application form, don't email me your CV; that doesn't constitute applying, and I won't read it.

There's a reason I didn't attach my phone number to the advertisement; don't expect me to be available to talk to you on the telephone.

For god's sake don't send me an email with a naff graphic across the bottom of a hipster crowd-surfing; it gives me the impression you're a waster.

If the adrvertisement says high level of literacy required, don't send me an email in txt spk.

It's usually a good idea not to irritate your potential boss at the first interaction by sending a series of emails that indicate you can't read a basic form and require your potential boss to download something for you that you could easily find yourself.

(rant over)

Any more gems?

OP posts:
KatieMiddleton · 03/04/2011 13:58

You try shagging a balding toff and sucking up to the family and try telling me that's not work! Wink

The hair alone takes 2 stylists and an hour of blow-drying

ninah · 03/04/2011 13:46

you've done well at not getting a job Katie Wink

KatieMiddleton · 03/04/2011 13:45

It all comes down to context. In some industries you know people across the industry. In others they are very organisation centred and mixing with the competition is not on so you just might not have contacts elsewhere.

I think the trouble with the job centre is that the staff aren't equipped to deal with anything above junior/menial roles. Their support for professionals being made redundant is poor so they give blanket instructions without thinking: does this make sense? Will it just piss off the recruiter? Will this get the applicant a bad name? Does doing this make the applicant look stupid/ignorant/arrogant/like they have no judgement?

I can also remember a poor woman exasperatedly explaining to the woman at the desk that there was quite a bit of difference between Director of marketing, her former role, and marketing assistant and that if she started applying for those jobs she would lose her career and her mortgage insurance would stop paying out and she wouldn't be able to pay the mortgage.

That said there are some very lovely and sensible people working in job centres but anyone with half a brain seems to be promoted to supervisor and then no longer deals with job seekers directly.

onlion · 03/04/2011 13:39

I dont want people's old school exam results at all.

Xenia · 03/04/2011 13:21

Just the job centre trying to go through the motions and wasting people's times although some of those such as asking around, contacting people you k now to see if they have a job can be worth it. I know a few of my daughters' friends have got jobs because someone mentioned to them there was a job going at XYZ where the other friend worked. So I don't think that is a bad recommendation.

Also leaving off exam grades doesn't help - it means I am not very clever and messed up by GCSEs.

microserf · 03/04/2011 13:19
  • don't make me fly to Germany to interview you for a senior role and then answer all of my questions with one sentence. then, when asked to expand your answer, respond with "i feel i have fully answered the question". shortest interview ever.
  • don't take out a notebook and spend the entire time we spend describing the role and company to you flicking through it. then, when asked what questions you have for us, don't spend an etttterrrnittty looking through it to find the questions you wrote last night. and read them all to us, regardless of whether we already answered them during the interview.

and for interviewers: don't ask the candidate, "this is a white male [country name] culture company. how do you feel you will fit in with us? i made some non-committal answer and rang the recruiter afterwards to say HELL NO to the job, but i always wish i'd replied: "actually i decided in the first 5 minutes of the interview that i hate you". as that was the truth. i thought his HR person was going to burst into tears, she looked so miserable.

chubsasaurus · 03/04/2011 13:03

I used to work in recruitment doing retained searches for renewable energy jobs in Germany. If the advert reads 'Engineering degree and German speaker essential' PLEASE do not apply if you do not speak German, don't have a degree (oh but years of vital experience, piss off) and are not eligible to work in the EU

KaraStarbuckThrace · 03/04/2011 13:03

Xenia - I completely agree, that is why I always liked application forms.
I can assess the candidate's handwriting (a lot of instructions/results from tests have to be handwritten so needed to ensure candidates could write legibly) and also their ability to follow instructions (the application form the company I worked for had at the top "please complete in full in black or blue ink". I would reject any application that said "see CV" all over it - they clearly were filled in by someone who is lazy/ignored the instructions.
Now I have terrible handwriting, but I always took time and care to fill in any form so that it could be read clearly.

It is frustrating for job seekers and employers that the Job Centre forces people to apply for unsuitable jobs. I remember going to the job centre when I was graduating from Uni and them trying to get me to apply for shift work in the middle of absolute no-where, miles and miles from where I was living, when I didn't even have a driving license, let alone a car!

StealthPolarBear · 03/04/2011 12:52

When asked at interview what specific part of your job motivates you, don't reply "Nothing, I'm pretty miserable at the moment"

Don't day you want this job "because it's 9-5 and will allow me to spend more time with my husband" (I suspect the husband actually completed the form on her behalf!)

When applying to the NHS don't talk about how your skills will help "our business to be profitable"

actually - ignore that last one - screw the mental health patients, there are hip replacements to churn out!

KatieMiddleton · 03/04/2011 12:41

Xenia you ask a good question. From my limited experience I have seen the following:

A man with severe learning difficulties being told to apply for admin jobs but protesting he can't read/write very well.

Being told to apply for a job where Arabic was a "highly desirable skill" when the person spoke no Arabic.

Being told to apply for full time jobs when caring commitments meant the applicant could only do part time and being told to put in a covering letter that you can't do the full time hours they want.

Being told to apply for jobs where the applicant has no previous experience when previous experience is clearly a stated essential requirement because some of the core skills are similar to jobs the applicant has done.

Being told to send in CVs speculatively "on the off chance they have a vacancy about to come up".

Demanding an applicant "networks" (or pester by phone) with their former colleagues to see if there are any jobs going. This is despite the applicant having been made redundant from the organisation they worked for for 8 years and due to clauses in the redundancy contract (which they have seen and copied) not allowing them to work in any capacity for their former employer for the next 6 months.

Instructing applicants to take their (unsolicited) CV in directly to local offices/branches of national or multinationals they want to apply to. Even if that is not how anyone bar the most junior staff are recruited in the industry and it's wholly inappropriate to hand a CV to a junior member of staff when you applying for managerial jobs.

beanlet · 03/04/2011 11:23

Oh congratulations GOML - that's fantastic news! So pleased you're enjoying the job too.

OP posts:
Xenia · 03/04/2011 11:09

What are the things job centres tell people to do which employers on the thread do not like?

I get people applying for jobs with spelling errors. DefinATE ratehr than definite is one.

Even dyslexics can surely type first, spell check, get a friend to check and then copy on to a hard written form if it is not an on line form. If on line form then they can spell check elsewhere and then cut and paste. Of course it depends on the job too - there are plenty where spelling might not matter at all.

My older 3 children are all graduate age so we have had lots of job application, forms, on line application things in the last few years.

FreudianSlippery · 03/04/2011 10:45

Congrats on your job GOML :)
Ive had some good advice on here and hopefully in a month or two I'll be able to come back and say thanks too...

bigbeagleeyes · 03/04/2011 10:44

I'm almost tempted to copy this thread and take it to the jobcentre. As a few posters above have pointed out, the job centre encourages you to do a lot of the things employers on this thread say is a no no.
We have to apply for 3 jobs a week, if we don't we can lose our benefits,which means a lot of people who know they haven't got a chance of getting the job will apply anyway, as there is not always the jobs around
that fit your specific qualifications.
I live in a very rural area and am lucky if a job comes up every couple of months, so trying to find 3 a week is a struggle Smile

takewhatyoucan · 03/04/2011 10:24

I once received a cv printed on pink paper in landscape, with three columns of text. I think it was supposed to be folded into a leaflet!

onlion · 03/04/2011 09:31

On the other side, I once went for an interview for a post which was a lower grade and for less money, for a lifestyle change. The panel asked me a question about a policy in our field....saying I would have to occasionally help senior staff with this and did I understand it. I answered that I knew this quite well, given I had been on the international panel that set the policy and went on for a few minutes about how we established it..The look on their faces said it all and I thought fuck, I havent got this, have I. So I learned to shutup when applying for lower grade posts.

lesley33 · 03/04/2011 09:26

underachieving - I think it depends what jobs you are applying for. So for example applying for a job as a proof reader but making spelling mistakes shows you can't do the job.

If the job doesn't require excellent spelling then many employers- although not all - would forgive 1 or 2 spelling mistakes. Personally though I would always get someone to check my application form if I was worried about my spelling.

I don't think telling employers you have dyslexia will neccessarily help. Its about employers knowing you want the job enough to make sure you take care with an application and not getting someone to check it when you have dyslexia, kind of shows you aren't taking care.

onlion · 03/04/2011 09:24

We had one turn up to a profesional interview wearing a mini and hello..... kitty hair clips. Another had an email address like pinkfluffyprincess .

Thistledew · 03/04/2011 09:23

Underachieving - I have the same problem. If I ever have to write anything by hand, I compose it on the computer, run spell check, and the copy it three words at a time onto the form by hand. The 'copying' bit I find crucial. If I force myself to check the spellings every three words and just concentrate on that number at a time I can usually do it without mistakes.

Alternatively, contact the company and ask if they have an electronic version of the form.

MarioandLuigi · 03/04/2011 09:22

I had a lady turn up to an interview carrying what looked like a weeks shopping from ASDA - not a great first impression.

I worked as a manager in a credit control department. One of the questions we always asked was how you would deal with irate callers - on interviewee proudly announced 'I would tell them to piss off' - he didnt get the job.

bubble2bubble · 03/04/2011 08:55

Don't wear a cannabis leaf t-shirt to an interview.
Especially when the interview is for a job in a pharmacy which,by the way, involves working with drugs Confused
Still trying to work out what her thought process was in deciding what to wear

HarrietJones · 03/04/2011 08:39

Underachieving - some application forms have a disability section?

I once helped with some teacher& TA application forms & they were shocking.most of the teacher ones were very similar to each other and all turned out to be NQTs who obviously had university input into 'how to write a CV'.

E320 · 03/04/2011 07:56

I was interviewing a candidate for a vacancy in our IT documentation team some years ago. His CV was fine, if he had been applying for a job as a developer, but the entire team agreed that he wouldn't fit. However, our boss was under pressure at the time to recruit permanent staff (most of the team was freelance), hence the interview.
The first thing this chap did, was to tell us he wasn't switching off his mobile 'phone because he was expecting an important call - I am not sure what kind of call this was, but, at 5pm in the afternoon, I doubt that it was employment-related.
The second thing the chap did, was to tell us that he had left or been sacked from his previous two (yes, that's 2) postions because he didn't get on with other members of the team! At this point I went very quiet.
Anyway, he got the job. Stuck at it for exactly a year, nobody actually knew what he was doing, but he made sure that he took every single day's holiday going as well as getting signed off sick on several occasions.
Most amusingly, though, was his reaction to a "friendly" piece of advice from our big boss about dress code (working for a bank). Suits, or at least shirt and tie, were preferred. So chap goes off and buys himself a pale green suit (I think it was a designer one) and proceeds to wear it to the office with the label prominently displayed on the outside cuff of one of the sleeves. He really didn't have a clue!

LostInSockLand · 03/04/2011 05:48

typos however, of the kind I made in my last post are easily done in the early hours of a Sunday morning...Grin

bedubabe · 03/04/2011 05:21

Had someone recently who listed grade 1 flute as an achievement. Also, grammatical mistakes in a cover letter for a job which has specified 'native English speaker level' was a no no. As was the woman who called ke three or four times to debate whether she should send in her cv. It was a managerial position that involved decision making.

My all time favourite though was the 10 page cv that started 'I was born on a small farm in Idaho...'