Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that most people are better parents the second time around?

39 replies

messyjessie · 11/02/2011 10:26

Not saying the first child isn't much loved and well cared for... But something of a practice run?

Do most people with the wisdom of thier first do things very differently with the second?

And even look back in their first and have some slight regrets?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CharlotteWilbo · 26/12/2023 21:23

OP - did you ever have DC2? I have a 3 YO and a 15 month old and I have done things differently for sure, I’d even say better for DC2 but k still learn every day with DC1. What I know for sure is that DC1 is a sensitive soul, a poor sleeper etc where as DC2 has been a very easy baby, good sleeper, confident etc. I think it depends on the baby!

Ormirian · 11/02/2011 15:53

I don't know about better but I do know I didn't sweat it so much. And as for the third.... amazing he's survived really.

scurryfunge · 11/02/2011 15:52

I got it right first time and didn't need any more to prove the point Grin

stuffthenonsense · 11/02/2011 15:49

every child is an individual with its own needs and challenges.
1st child has less experienced parents but they have more time, on balance, as long as the parents are doing their best each time, they end up the same. i have regrets and triumphs with each of mine.
that said, im bringing up no.4 so by now i am just supermum Smile

messyjessie · 11/02/2011 14:04

DrNorthener - that really isn't what I said.

In fact, I have one child atm and think I'm a fantastic mum, but when I think about having a second child I just know that I would do things differently..

For example I wouldn't be as terrified and tentative of doing everything at the beginning... Before DD I had never fed a baby / changed a nappy or even really held one. With my second child, if we have one, I wouldn't buy as much random stuff, I wouldn't feel so stressed out about keeping the house tidy for visitors, I would have got a different everything actually!

Also, I spend so long just sitting with DD that now she's quite lost without me and is a really clingy baby, with a second child I would do something as simple as leave the room more!

I was following plans I had read in baby books to try to try and get her into a schedule.

Next time I think I would be much more relaxed about everything.

OP posts:
QuickLookBusy · 11/02/2011 13:32

I think I was better the second time around, I was much more relaxed and knowledeable.

I think it carries on as the DC go through life. My eldest just started uni, and because the whole process was new, it was kinda stressful. When DD2 applies, we will all know what we are doing!

I do think the second child has an easier time-they see their older brother or sister, starting school, brownies etc, going to clubs, starting secondary, taking exams...the second child has seen it all happening before they actually need to do it themselves.

piprabbit · 11/02/2011 13:10

I am a different parent now I have two children.

That's the point really, you don't have a trial run first time round and then a chance to learn all the lessons you need to do it perfectly second time around because second time around you are, in fact, a novice at parenting two children simultaneously - which is the really tricky bit.

camdancer · 11/02/2011 13:08

I was great first time around but a short-tempered mess with DC2. God knows how bad I'm going to be like with DC3. But I don't know whether DC1 was just generally easy whereas DC2 was a lot harder - or just that I don't cope with sleep deprivation very well.

But apparently DC3 is always the easiest. (Fingers crossed.)

Pheebe · 11/02/2011 13:00

I've certainly enjoyed it much more second time around and yes to some extent I suppose have done things 'better' or perhaps 'more effectively'. I certainly think DH and I were a better team once DS2 arrived.

I was a basket case with DS1 for his first year really. It was a MASSIVE culture shock even thought we'd waited years for him and he as very very much wanted. DS2 (when he finally arrived) just slotted into place.

KaraStarbuckThrace · 11/02/2011 12:55

I'll find out in June and let you know.

Hopefully I have learnt from the oodles of mistakes I have made with DS (who, by the Grace of God is alive and healthy still Grin) and go on and make a whole new set of mistakes Hmm

hephaestus · 11/02/2011 12:54

I was 21 when my mum had a second child and she quite brazenly told me that she was going to 'do it properly with this one'.

Unwanted trial-run fuck-up child, that's me. Hmm

WelliesAndPyjamas · 11/02/2011 12:53

Better (happier, more relaxed, and that's ds2 as well as me) the 2nd time in my case.

BuzzLiteBeer · 11/02/2011 12:51

I've got steadily worse each time.

Fernie3 · 11/02/2011 12:43

My first baby had loads of attention but i was much younger ( was 20 so aware some will have been even younger but i was at uni and still felt too young!)). I didn't have the patience i do now, i didn't try breastfeeding at all because i listened too much to what people were telling me rather tha dojgn my own thing. On the other end of the scale i sent HOURS when i was Ill making stupid little ice cube trays of baby food when really i wish i had just spent the time hugging her rather thsn keeping her quiet in the car seat while i cooked!. I also spent a stupid amount of time trying to entertain her even when she didn't seem to care,

My fourth i did breastfeed because i finally thought "shut the hell up" to people who told me it would be too hard. she has loads of hugs, she loves being carried in her sling she sleeps in my bed she lives the baby life of luxury...but she eats mostly jars and i think the most exciting thing she does in day is sit in her swing and watch the older ones play!

So not better really just different

AliGrylls · 11/02/2011 12:35

I think I am worse second time round. I have less time for both and with DS1 I was so enthusiastic.

systemsaddict · 11/02/2011 12:34

I knew I had made lots of mistakes with my first, so vowed not to do them again second time round. Especially with sleep. Having gone through terrible sleep difficulties with the first, the second was going to be put down awake from day one, and would know that her cot was for sleeping and nowhere else.....she's now 2 and a half and still co-sleeping pretty regularly now!

It's one thing knowing about your 'mistakes' and a whole nother thing not repeating them!

mamatomany · 11/02/2011 12:33

Nope i've made some shocking errors with DD3 due to being exhausted and tied up with my PFB, number 2 not so too bad and DS is like PFB again due to huge age gap but if i had my time again i'd do a lot differently with 2 & 3.

Aitch · 11/02/2011 12:30

agree with callisto. i was never neurotic with the first, and she was an easy baby, so it was all great fun. with the second, i think she gets less of me because i have her sister to look after as well. having said that, she does gain in that she gets to have a sister to worship, so she's not losing out markedly.

Callisto · 11/02/2011 12:27

I think lots of second and third children get much more neglected than the first born, so I think the opposite to you OP. I only have one child who I am a great mother to and I have no regrets about how I've raised her so far.

Changing2011 · 11/02/2011 12:27

MissFit - I used to worry about not loving another child as much as DD but due to my own 2 years of secindary infertility I think if we have another DC we will cherish it as we waited so long!

halfcaff · 11/02/2011 12:26

I certainly enjoyed ds (dc2) more than dd (dc1) in the early days, partly as I knew what to expect, partly because I think he was just an easier baby (fed better, slept better, cried less!) I have not been a better mummy to him, I am absolutely sure of it. Dd had me to herself for nearly 5 years and I could never offer that to ds. Also I went back to work when he was 8mths as I knew I was having no more dc so took the opportunity when it came up to start building a 'career' (ha!) I think he had a much more tired, stressed mummy in general.
There are loads of new issues as they get older which you never get with the first one, notably sibling rivalry, and this will change, as will the whole family dynamic, as more children come along.

Restrainedrabbit · 11/02/2011 12:26

Would agree that I was more patient with just one and notice now that those with just one child seem less frazzled and have more and 'better' quality time - do more fun things. Whereas I spend too much time just doing essential tasks.

Restrainedrabbit · 11/02/2011 12:24

Hmmm.... I make different mistakes (got 3DCS!), wouldn't say I'm 'better' but more relaxed but also more slovenly Wink

MissFit · 11/02/2011 12:23

I was extremely relaxed the 1st time. I think a did pretty well actually.

If I have a second child it will definitely be a PSB (precious second born) and I will probably be extremely anxious. That would be due to 3 years + of secondary infertility though.

lexxity · 11/02/2011 12:21

No I don't think I'm better second around, more relaxed certainly. The reason i don't think I'm better is that I still encounter first time situations and decisions. It's a constant learning curve.

Swipe left for the next trending thread