Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to be feeling unfairly got at?

58 replies

breastbadger · 17/01/2011 20:55

At the weekend, I put a ink to this blog as my fb status. I'm a local peer supporter and do feel strongly about the shocking media coverage that this has generated, but have honesty NEVER made any judgey / derogatory / ff-bashing comments online or in rl.

I'm also a Neonatal nurse, so part of my job is gently supporting women in any feeding choice they make.

So......I was a bit surprised to get this email from a male friend. This is it, nothing edited out. Apparently a letter in The Times.

AIBU for being a bit pissed off? Was my link really that offensive? Is friend having a dig or not?

Women are rarely given sensible tips on establishing breastfeeding during ante-natal classes

Sir, In an ideal world every baby would breastfeed and reap the enormous benefits from the process. But it?s not that simple. When people take up polarised positions, all they are doing is to make it more difficult for mothers (report, Jan 15).
Women are rarely given sensible tips on establishing breastfeeding during ante-natal classes. Instead of simple guidance, they are sold an illusion of warm bonding with the baby while breastfeeding.
As a paediatrician, I constantly see this struggle mothers go through. When you are feeling vulnerable, any head-shaking is seen as terrible criticism. This is when an unbiased view is helpful, not shrill badgering.
Dr Shyla Jehangir
Cockermouth, Cumbria

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NDfamily · 03/09/2023 08:30

The breast vs bottle and weaning arguments are just so ott in my opinion. As long as basic safety is met (no solids pre 4 months, correct sterilisation and preparation of formula) I'm not sure why we are encouraging women families to tie themselves in knots over it.

The message should be left at:
Breastfeeding in the first 6 months is likely to have some positive health effects for women and their babies. There should be support for women who choose this option. Formula feeding will not harm your baby. There should be support for women who choose this option. It is unlikely that anyone could tell the difference between a breastfed or formula fed baby by the time they reach adulthood.

Is there really any need to keep researching infant feeding methods above and beyond the research already available? It does actually feel like a way to bash women from both sides.

JourneyThroughTime · 03/09/2023 00:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mumcentreplus · 17/01/2011 23:03

fuck me!! I must be a shit mother too Grin

FunnysInTheGarden · 17/01/2011 23:01

Rev do you really think that 'a mother knows her baby best' holds any weight these days? Oh no, unless you are following strict WHO guidelines, you are at best stupid and at worst a shit mother.

I, for example, am a shit mother Grin

Mumcentreplus · 17/01/2011 22:53

Totally agree Rev you know your baby best...a guide is just that..

Rev084 · 17/01/2011 22:45

I personally don't know why anyone would go to such lengths, as this analytical armadillo has, to defend DOH's guidelines of weaning after six months of being exclusively breasfed. Surely a mother knows her baby best, and after all, guidelines are exactly that, a guide not a rule. There'll always be new scientific evidence that picks apart previous evidence, and it should weighed up and taken into full consideration.

I followed BLISS guidelines as my DD was 6weeks prem, which is,

"We recommend that weaning starts when your baby is between five and seven months old, the age they are from their birth date and not from their corrected age date."

So I started my DD on solids at 5.5 months (mostly BLW on homecooked food, not jars). Could it not be said that just as every prem baby has different needs, so has every term baby?

I treat most government guidleines on nutrition, both baby and adult, with a pinch of salt and think my family are lot healthier for it.

Mumcentreplus · 17/01/2011 22:22

Yeaahh...experience..

breastbadger · 17/01/2011 22:09

I also think you are brilliant AA, and it was with the BEST of intentions that I shared the link on fb. That's why I was surprised to have riled someone.
Really, keep up the good work. Please.

Right, really off to bed now.

OP posts:
AnyFucker · 17/01/2011 22:09

thingy

AnyFucker · 17/01/2011 22:08

have just had a thought

do you link your face book page hingy to Mumsnet ?

here are some strange blokes on here who try to tell us wimmin what we should/shouldn't be doing and that they have "experienced" birthing and bf-ing via their wives < ahem >

breastbadger · 17/01/2011 22:06

Bugger. Preview, ALWAYS preview.Grin

OP posts:
MsKLo · 17/01/2011 22:06

I think you are brilliant AnalyticalArmadillo!

breastbadger · 17/01/2011 22:04

Thanks all, mumsnet is wise as ever! [Grin]

OP posts:
AnalyticalArmadillo · 17/01/2011 22:04

Hi
My blog piece is purely an examination of the paper that hit the headlines last week, and trying to break it down a little for confused parents who are coming up to starting solids age and unsure exactly what the paper said.

I also disagree and am a tad offended at the suggestion my blog is "anti formula". Because I acknowledge breastfeeding is the standard way to feed an infant, does NOT mean I judge other mothers, which this comment implies.

Many of my readers have formula fed previous children before managing to crack breastfeeding (as you will see from the comments on my articles) some wanted to breastfeed but it didn't work out and so formula feed or exclusively bottle feed breastmilk - and want to learn more for subsequent children. Some just wonder if there was a reason why and so are interested in reading things that can impact or how they can maximise their bottle feeding experience - as per this blog post:
www.analyticalarmadillo.co.uk/2010/10/boosting-bottle-feeding-bonding-5-top.html

Suggesting that giving evidence in a supportive, non judgmental way is "anti" something - only hinders parents getting the information and support they want or need, and serves to create further barriers between mums purely based on how they feed. Not positive for anyone.

Mumcentreplus · 17/01/2011 21:55

Men and breast-feeding...makes me itch

TheFallenMadonna · 17/01/2011 21:54

x post! Sorry!

Mumcentreplus · 17/01/2011 21:54

does not make friggin sense though...

MsKLo · 17/01/2011 21:54

I still would like a cherry on that trifle

pleaseeeee

TheFallenMadonna · 17/01/2011 21:53

Look - you posted something on a semi-public site (and although it's not public, obviously some people can read it - that's the point!), someone who read it got hold of the wrong end of the stick, you now get to explain your point better. That's it.

AnyFucker · 17/01/2011 21:52

your fb is not public ?

that changes matters somewhat Smile

so I see your point now

breastbadger · 17/01/2011 21:51

And don't worry TheFallenMadonna, discussion will ensue. Thanks.

OP posts:
breastbadger · 17/01/2011 21:49

Again, see your point AF, but my fb is not public.

OP posts:
MsKLo · 17/01/2011 21:46

can we get a cherry on that trifle?!

AnyFucker · 17/01/2011 21:45

of course you can bang on about breast feeding all day long if you wish (why you would do that is beyond me, but each to their own...)

but by putting it on a public site, you invite comment, and you might not like all of it so feeling "got at" is a trifle OTT

just like Mumsnet, in fact

that is all I am saying

MsKLo · 17/01/2011 21:42

who knows?!