Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it's not a crime to be middle class?

140 replies

upsylazy · 17/01/2011 12:23

I consider myself middle class (there, I've said it) and am a bit concerned at the current tendency to use it as a term of abuse eg "you're so middle class" with "white middle class" being a euphemism for a smug arsehole. I would definitely consider myself lower middle class, I don't live in a big house, have a cleaner or au pair and my DCs don't have stupid names. I am not heavily into organic food (too expensive) and have been known to go to (gasp) McDonalds. However, i still feel a twinge of guilt at being middle class. Hopefully, this is not a national phenomena but I have recently noted a trend among a small group of (upper) middle class women to ditch the Boden and Monsoon for Primark gear and start talking in a mock Saarrrff London accent. This seems to be taking things a step too far and is just inverted snobbery.

OP posts:
hogsback · 18/01/2011 09:37

Lucy88: You would be described by people who earn less than you but still look down on you as 'nouveau riche'. Don't let it bother you.

But Abu Dhabi? For holidays - really??? I have to go there for work a lot and would never have considered it as a holiday destination - is there anything there other than office blocks and cheesy hotels? I must be missing something...

msbossy · 18/01/2011 09:35
Deciduousblonde · 18/01/2011 09:33

''I have long had my own classifications which are:

POSH

ORDINARY PUNTERS

SCRUFF

It is easy to fit people into these categories. About 95% of us are ordinary punter''

I like Granny23's classification the best :)

hogsback · 18/01/2011 09:28

I'm excited by the use of the courgette as a class identifier, but what does it mean if you never buy them but you DO grow them?

Lucy88 · 18/01/2011 09:13

I earn a decent wage, live in a nice house, have a gardener and someone to do my ironing. We like designer clothes and have 3 holidays a year (places like Abu Dhabi).

But there is no way I would class myself as middle class. I am a single Mum who is common as muck, down to earth and am def. working class and proud of it.

Please don't shout at me for eating courgettes!

begonyabampot · 18/01/2011 01:28

Dh and I were born working class. With his earnings, education and job now, we might now officially qualify as middleclass - though who decides these things? Will always feel and identify as working class though.

Heroine · 18/01/2011 01:20

oh you are so

figcake · 17/01/2011 20:35

The courgette thing is getting stupid - courgettes appeared on the shelves of international 'supermarkets' decades before Tesco put them on their shelves or HFW started fussing over them.

They are eaten in really poor countries in vast quantities (think veg cous cous, med courgette salad) as are fennels, aubergines etc

Purple sprouting broccoli on the other hand .....

noddyholder · 17/01/2011 20:34

I think it is a crime.All that angst about who thinks what of you and the endless keeping up with the jones's

Chandon · 17/01/2011 20:31

I love love LOVE it that on this thread we have found out how to identify someone's class?background by asking one simple question:

courgettes: do you know what one is? and
you buy and eat them regularly?

THE COURGETTE TEST

could courgettes be the new Pombears???

KatieScarlett2833 · 17/01/2011 18:37

I don't have many standards but DH and Ithe kids are turning to drink and drugs, shit.......Wink

Chil1234 · 17/01/2011 18:35

Of course it's a crime to be middle-class. Because middle-class means having a decent lifestyle and that must have been gifted by the fairies, not earned by good honest sweat. And middle-class means elbowing your way to the front, having 'standards', and being judgemental about other people's lack of standards... and that kind of moral superiority simply won't do! And once you're stamped 'middle-class' you're utterly, utterly BORING!... and your children will turn to drink and drugs to escape you.

Life-sentence, I'd say... Wink

OTheHugeManatee · 17/01/2011 18:27

Woolly liberal, surely, Katie?

Very middle class.

Grin
KatieScarlett2833 · 17/01/2011 18:27

Ah, but (rolls drum) I own and proudly wear.... Ugg Kensingtons....

Therefore I am a working class chav, innit?

wizardora · 17/01/2011 18:23

KatieScarlett - I would say you were definitely Middle class

giyadas · 17/01/2011 18:22

"understand, grow and eat courgettes" Grin that's good enough for me, you can join my (wholly arbitrary and possibly too heavily vegetable oriented) middle class.

humanheart · 17/01/2011 18:21

i'm working class, married UMC (sort of - foreign though so not technically UMC, just very rich) though live a middle class lifestyle. my kids are, I guess, MC, bcs of their lifestyle and education as they were growing up; but they were brought up by a working class mother, so they have imbibed some of the working class culture. I am working class and always will be, regardless of how educated I am, my job, or how much money I may have. class is about the culture you were brought up in, and class cultures in this country are distinct. most people are part of the vast and sprawling MCs. it gets on my nerves when people say they work so they are working class, probably bcs I'm slightly protective of my class. if you don't know what class you're in you're probably MC, bcs people at either end of the class system are fully aware of what class they belong to. if you say there is no such thing as class in this country (bcs everybody has a telly) you are very probably MC (or in denial), bcs the MCs are generally blind to and touchy about the class structure in this country and think (and say) that we're all MC. we aren't.

so if I got a job as a high-court judge I would still say I am working class, which would be alluding to my cultural heritage. an example of this would be that, if I were born, say, in Italy and had lived in britain for 20 years, I would still say I am italian (alluding to my cultural heritage), even if my kids had been brought up in britain and are british with no trace of an italian accent.

fluffles · 17/01/2011 18:21

i'm never sure what to put on demographics questions about parent's education as both my parents went to further education 'college' and did quite vocational courses but in vocations which would nowadays require a degree.

so, am i the daughter of parents with a 'higher' education or not? Confused

fluffles · 17/01/2011 18:19

nah sorry i reckon you're middle class katiescarlett the fact your parents (or at least one of them) is/are uni educated probably puts you into MC.

KatieScarlett2833 · 17/01/2011 18:13

Class me please. I am Scottish and we don't do that round 'ere.

Parents were Uni lecturer and civil servant.

Went to local comp after vehemently refusing to go to Public School

Live in 4 bed det house in nice area.

Have a degree, work in Public Sector, DH ditto.

Kids go to local comp.

Understand, grow and eat courgettes.

Totally left-wing.

I say working class.

MarniesMummy · 17/01/2011 18:02

No Heroine!!!

I'm going to have to get medieval on your ass!!!

What the devil do you mean about courgettes? Can you confirm what other posters have speculated?

Middle class implies:

you know what one is
you buy and eat them regularly
or c) something else.

Just do it woman, Pandora's got nothing on me!!Grin

And while I'm at it Porcamiseria

not in italy marnies mummy!!!!

What???
Have you mixed me up? That doesn't make sense to anything I've said/askedConfused.

Look just tell me about the courgette thing and I'll be on my way!

wizardora · 17/01/2011 17:54

I think class does still exist but the lines are so blurred, there are so many different ways to catergorise and so many different opinions on what constitutes a catergory.. The majority of people fall into round about the middle in the UK. For example we have a relatively low income but I wouldn't say we were working class yet my husband would say we are.

southeastastra · 17/01/2011 17:44

i'm economy class

wouldn't it be good if being middle class was made illegal

usualsuspect · 17/01/2011 17:43

I know no one in real life who ever describes themselves by class

crazycatlady · 17/01/2011 17:38

Class as a notion is quite ridiculous in today's society as it's changing so much. It's not as simple as saying education, personal income/wealth, background etc makes you a particular 'class' anymore. Property prices spiralling and the spread of good quality education, in particular, have changed things.

I would have no idea where to classify myself by the traditional WC/MC/UC labels. I had a decidedly upper class education, lived a middle class lifestyle as a child, now have a professional career but live in a decidedly downtrodden area and have no assets/wealth to speak of.

Confused