Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to find it a little bit pathetic when grown women say they won't drive long distances

670 replies

emkana · 30/08/2010 21:20

of more than 30 (!) miles because they are scared of the driving and navigating.

Is it really that hard, am I missing something here?

OP posts:
claig · 31/08/2010 00:05

did you go across the Arc de Triomphe, that is some experience?

hmc · 31/08/2010 00:04

I am perfectly capable of driving long distances, am a confident driver, but just find driving relentlessly tedious. Its an utterly joyless experience. For that reason I prefer not to drive long distances - although I will if required to.

MrsMadWriggle · 31/08/2010 00:03

claig - I have driven in Paris, Barcelona and Madrid amongst other places - sometimes on my own. So yes.

claig · 31/08/2010 00:02

Italian road with two lanes and filled with five lanes of cars

Hufsa · 31/08/2010 00:02

No it's certainly not rocket science. Just completely illogical.

Why would not driving at all help a person who doesn't like driving long distances?

claig · 31/08/2010 00:01

have you tried driving across the Arc de Triomphe or on an Italian road with lanes, in which there are five lanes of cars? Your mum has probably heard about it and decided to let someone else have the hassle.

JaneS · 30/08/2010 23:59

If you know you're not ok to drive distances, don't drive at all. Surely this is not rocket science?

A special circle in hell is also reserved for those who can drive, but can't park - especially the woman in the Merc four months ago, who cheerfully handed me (a complete stranger) her keys as she couldn't get the car into the space 'without worrying about bumping yours'. Well, lovely to know what you'd have done if I hadn't been there.

MrsMadWriggle · 30/08/2010 23:56

YANBU
FWIW the OP didn't mention motorways - just that some women won't go 30 miles or more.

I'm also frustrated by women (like my mum) who won't drive abroad.

MistsandMellowMilady · 30/08/2010 23:56

Shock at the Aston Expressway story. I don't drive at all. I might never bother now!

When I was blogging I "knew" a lot of Americans and many of the women would not ever consider driving a manual transmission or turning left - I think. Whichever would take them them across traffic.

I remember having to draw a little diagram to work out why they said they did several right turns instead of one left. It's mainly intersections rather than roundabouts which they were also terrified of as they were quite unused to them.

I could cope with that sort of driving I think. America here I come Grin

Hufsa · 30/08/2010 23:54

tokyonambu - accidents that happen in the home are not caused by a single activity in the way that road deaths are. And according to your link over 50% are as a result of falls amongst the over-65s.

BrightLightBrightLight · 30/08/2010 23:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MadameDefarge · 30/08/2010 23:50

Oh, for heaven's sake, there are loads and loads of things we have the option to do which we really don't like doing, I hate going to any supermarket, and will avoid it at all costs...does that make me a fool and not fit to mix with decent folk due to my pathetic attitude? Or should Real Women Just be Prepared to Tough It Out at all costs?

I am more flummoxed by the idea there are legions of apparently grown women out there who measure their standing in life, and their worth, by how far their are prepared to drive and on what particular roads...and also prepared to judge those who those choose not to follow their path (no pun intended) as pathetic...

I personally think its pathetic to give two hoots about the motivations of others when it comes to driving or not driving on motorways or anyway else.

OP, btw, do come and drive in Hackney and see how you feel then....

BrightLightBrightLight · 30/08/2010 23:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

carebear321 · 30/08/2010 23:43

Havent had a chance to read each post, just a few, its not pathetic, some people have genuine phobias and reasons for what they will/wont do. I think people here are far too judgemental and snooty.

tokyonambu · 30/08/2010 23:43

" I am willing to bet that not all of those drivers reversing up slip roads over the years and performing motorway U turns were women though."

I've not been looking to check. Nervous drivers come in both flavours. These weren't brazen young men, though, to judge from the tentative reversing.

Mind you, what does seem to be something only women do is driving around on side-lights in murky conditions. What is all that about? There's no rational reason to drive on side-lights, ever, and we should all worship the memory of Linda Chalker, one of the unsung heroines of road safety, who tried to have sidelights modified so that if the vehicle was moving you got dipped headlights anyway.

ILoveDonaldDraper · 30/08/2010 23:41

Someone who gets treatment for a phobia and deals with it, and therefore renders themselves less of a hazard to other road users is far less pathetic than someone who has to depend on someone else to transport them a distance of greater than 30 miles because they are too scared to drive a long distance. Surely that's pretty obvious Hufsa?

GiddyPickle · 30/08/2010 23:39

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

claig · 30/08/2010 23:38

Ken Livingstone is another progressive who doesn't drive, but loves imposing charges on those that do. If the thread had been about him being pathetic, then I would have agreed.

Hufsa · 30/08/2010 23:37

So in your world, is someone who refuses to drive altogether for fear of panic attacks less pathetic than someone who only drives short distances? Do enlighten us.

tokyonambu · 30/08/2010 23:36

" Driving is by far the most dangerous activity that most people engage in on a day to day basis"

Road figures

2200 deaths, about 1100 of people in cars, 500 pedestrians, 100 on pushbikes, 500 on motorbikes.

<a class="break-all" href="http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/www.dti.gov.uk/homesafetynetwork/gh_intro.htm" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">Household accidents

3000 people per year die in domestic accidents.

prettybird · 30/08/2010 23:36

Perhaps you are being a wee bit U - but like you I do find it odd.

DH and I make a point of sharing the driving - and as a result have been able to drive all over Europe, on occasions thorugh the night, becasue when one of us tires, the other one takes over.

I passed my test aged 23 (1st attempt) on a Wednesday. Went out for a test drive of a 2nd car, with friends to help, on the Thursday, picked the car up on Friday and then, first time ever in a car on my own, drove from Harpenden to Machester Shock

Stayed on A roads initially and had written myself detailed instructions. Joined the M6 just before Stoke as I had wanted to avoid Spaghetti Junction through Birmingham because I thought it wold be too complicated Hmm.

Was sooo pleased with myself when I arrived at my friend's place in Manchster. :)

ILoveDonaldDraper · 30/08/2010 23:34

YANBU. It is pathetic.
Am puzzled by posters who can't drive long distances because of "panic attacks". If you are liable to have a panic attack whilst driving, then for the sake of the rest of us on the road please could you not drive at all? You might kill someone. Get some CBT or other treatment for your driving phobia so you can drive properly or don't drive at all.

tokyonambu · 30/08/2010 23:30

I've recently finished fifteen years of motorway commuting. I've lost count of the occasions when I've seen cars either stopped on or, even more frightening, reversing up slip roads. Presumably, they were on a roundabout (both the junctions I used regularly were both motorway access and other roads), took the wrong exit, and were so paniced by the idea of driving on a motorway that they thought stopping, or reversing, was their safest course of action. Or they can't navigate and any deviation from their assigned route inspires total panic (in both cases, the next junction is about two miles, so the next result of carrying on to the next junction, going round the roundabout and coming back is five minutes' delay, ten if the traffic's a bit heavy).

This week however took the "stupid nervous driver who shouldn't be on the roads" biscuit. End of the Aston Expressway at Spaghetti Junction, you have a variety of options, including the M6(N) and the M6(S). Someone got into the lane for the M6(S) and, after passing the slip to the M6(N), decided that was where they wanted to go. So they stopped. Indicated left. And turned dead slow across three lanes onto the northbound M6. For fuck's sake: again, it's about ten minutes to go to the next junction and spin round, and instead you attempt to kill everyone around you. It was a total miracle, and a testament to modern brakes, that no-one hit them (I was watching from about 400 yards back, so had plenty of time to stop).

I passed them, or a very similar car, about ten minutes later, stopped on the hard shoulder, speaking to the nice policeman, so presumably someone watching the CCTV had been alert.

If you can't recover from taking the wrong turn without endangering both yourself and everyone else, you really shouldn't be on the roads.

Hufsa · 30/08/2010 23:30

YABU. Driving is by far the most dangerous activity that most people engage in on a day to day basis. But for some reason we ignore the huge numbers of deaths and serious injuries that happen every year on the roads and pretend that it's all perfectly safe.

Lucky for you if you're too dim to realise what is at stake when you get behind the wheel. Perhaps some women just have a more realistic sense of the risks involved.

elastamum · 30/08/2010 23:28

YABU (a bit). If you dont drive much it is reasonable to be a bit nervous as cars are potentially very dangerous.

I drive over 20000 miles a year for wk and have a 55 mile commute to work across the peak district. Not much fun in winter and I do see a selection of nasty accidents each year. Most of these are caused by idiots overtaking. I make no apologies for driving a large 4x4 volvo. It was the safest thing I could buy.