Mumsnet listed as Anti-Trans

[Hoosemover]

there a list of organisations and Mumsnet is on it. Along with the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

x.com/twisterfilm/status/1888255119449268674?s=61

I see that as well as MN & the EHRC, that list includes the Cass Review, sports bodies, government departments & some groups that no longer even exist.

lol it’s just an evolution of “everything is transphobic”

Women's Equality Party on there, I see. A numpty compiled this list.

Oh noes, however will we recover from this slight 😱

In good company… any organisation that challenges them

Well, let’s face it, they have a point!

Show me any org that is pro-trans and they will be saying somewhere that is also anti-trans.

I've seen trans people say that they need to have physically female attributes to feel like a woman, yet other people equating being a woman with being physically female are anti-trans.

Oh, this is wonderful.

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/19d7adb/is_everything_is_transphobic_a_terf_dog_whistle/

You know what they say: Heaven for the climate, Hell for the company.

I'm puzzled by the inclusion of 'The Countess (NI) [sic] because I doubt very much if an organisation named after Countess Markievicz has a separate operation within NI..
And WTF did 'Belfast Health and Social Care Trust' ever do to them??

I love the comment by the poster, Malcolm Clark, regretting that it was 'in alphabetical order and not a league table. Otherwise I'd have known who to donate to.' Brilliant!

Let's all start gardening like mad for Belfast Health and Social Care Trust! Feck knows what it is, but it must be doing something right

So any organisation that fights for the sex based rights of female people and children to be prioritised over gender identity is on the list? And these people don’t see how that reflects on them.

Mumsnet IS mainly transphobic though. It is not a site I would advise anyone with trans related issues to turn to.

Anti trans = not agreeing that men are women cos they say so

I’ve seen TRA describe the guardian and the BBC as transphobic so I assume their grip on reality is tenuous

Rhona Hotchkiss has commented 🥰

I see the bat signal has gone out

No. I am not anti trans in any way shape or form. Neither is ‘MN’ fgs, a platform with, what, hundreds of topics and millions of threads. The vast majority having nothing to do with the issue of trans genderism. Goodness. What sweeping hyperbole.

Mumsnet is pro-women? Whoda thunk it.

But it is.

Would a trans person be welcome here?

Is that the Welsh spelling?

😂

lol at the fact that everyone is on the list 😂😂😂 they might be starting to get it...

Of course not. Look at all the other shit they do, pushing themselves into female only groups, insisting they should be able to join rape survivors groups etc. they are either severely thick or just don't care how they're perceived. I'm guessing it's a bit of both😂

How would we know they were trans?

Or is it the classic "man here" and eh tell us?

No one provides any ID to join the site and there is no requirement to provide personal information (beyond an anonymous email address to sign up) unless they want to.

Same reply. How on earth is ‘Mumsnet’ mainly transphobic when its millions of threads have nothing to do with trans genderism. Millions and millions of threads. Not to mention that when distraught parents do turn to FWR, the vast majority of posters are supportive and sympathetic.

Maybe you mean it’s not a site where you’d advise parents who are seeking validation that affirming their children with surgery or CSH is the best approach to a gender questioning youth. I’d agree with you on that view.

Well if a trans person shared they were trans how would they be treated?

MN HQ don't permit transphobic posts, but there are posts on here that robustly challenge the extremes of gender ideology - nothing phobic about that surely?

'Anyone with trans related issues' - does that include parents of gender-questioning or transitioning children looking for support? I've seen quite a few on here, and they've not only got emotional support but links to sources of practical help and advice.