I've been lurking on here for a while, and just wanted to say how much I've enjoyed reading this thread! I've never been that interested in perfumes and I always seemed to end up with fruity floral stuff that wasn't right on me. I came across you all a couple of months ago and have picked up loads of ideas and finally found lots of stuff that I like. Oud, booze, smoke and spice are good; figgy scents also a yes, and I love a good rose.
I haven't got a lot at the moment; Tom Ford- Noir Extreme, and Oud Wood, and Diptyque Geranium Odorata. I love all of these but I want moooorreeee!
Husband and I had a trip to Liberty yesterday, and I had a list as long as my arm of things I wanted to try. Spent a good hour pottering about and fell head over heels for Nasomatto Baraonda- like bathing in warm Jack Daniels in front of a fire while a fruit cake bakes. This will be mine for my birthday next month 
Others I really liked- Frederic Malle Noir Epices, Fracas, DS & Durga- Bowmakers and Debaser, Diptyque Tempo (already hankering after Philosykos as well but will wait till next summer). A few of the Byredo and Le Labo were quite nice but didn't really grab me enough. There were hundreds I didn't try of course, but we're in London a couple of times a month so another sniffing session is imminent. I especially want to try MM By The Fireplace- sounds like it'll be right up my street.