Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

He wants a situationship, but is acting more like a boyfriend

155 replies

FairBee · 27/04/2026 18:15

Met a guy who goes to the same spin class as me back in December. I split from my husband 9 months ago at the time, he had just been left my an ex situationship because she wanted a real relationship with the new guy she met. He was really heartbroken.

We are both 29, same birthday month. He’s never been married, no children. I have 2 sons.

We hooked up on the first date. Second date we went got a walk and he asked me what I thought ‘this’ was. In my mind, it was casual sex with the possibility of being long term FWB.

He said he couldn’t do a relationship and wanted a situationship. I said I don’t do those. I’m not looking for a relationship really, but I’m happy to be f* buddies.

Since then, we talk every day. Meet up once or twice a week. Have been to France together for the weekend, go for lunch together and sleep together regularly at hotels. In the last 4 weeks, I’ve noticed a shift in messaging tone. Just the speed and intensity, and keenness to speak to me seems to have ramped up. Wants to talk on the phone in the evenings, and check in daily. Sends me videos and chats, wants my opinion on everything

2 weeks ago, I followed his cousin (didn’t know it was his cousin), on Instagram. He was really upset and was asking why I was looking for other men, it makes him look bad. And makes him feel like he isn’t enough. I apologised since in all fairness, I don’t want him following any of my friends or cousins, and blocked the cousin.

I sort of feel like I’ve definitely crossed my own boundary and ended up in this bloody ‘situationship’ scenario. Seems more than FWB. I have developed some feelings for him. I now care about the guy. And as a result the sex feels better. The sex is great. So I’d really miss it!

I thought, maybe, he might want a relationship after all? Maybe? I wasn’t trying to kid myself. But the signs suggested it might be true.

Today we went for coffee and a walk by the sea. Really lovely. Then someone happened between a couple, can’t even remember what they were doing, and he made a comment along the lines of ‘If we were together, which we are NOT, I’d think we’d do xyz’

I remember on our 3rd date, we had just slept together and he was speaking about his brother having problems with his partner, who has 3 kids from a previous relationship, and they gave 2 kids of their own. He said ‘it also made me further realise how much I don’t want to be a stepdad. So much work involved, and then having your own child and having to navigate that relationship being different to the one you have with step children. It’s all a bit mad’.

What do you think is going on here? I’ll be honest, I’ve really enjoyed his company. So don’t mind these outings alongside the sex. But it has ALL been instigated by him. So if he just wants sex, why all the dates and time away? Why not just stick to sex and maybe going for a drink or whatever every now and then? Keep it surface level

I have made it clear and haven’t given the impression I need dates or plans to have sex. I was happy to just keep it as sex.

Why has he pushed it into this odd set up? I’ve obviously allowed it, I know.

OP posts:
RoseField1 · 27/04/2026 19:08

FairBee · 27/04/2026 18:33

Sorry, should have clarified. FWB is someone you may send a friendly message or two every now and then. Keep it light. No constant relationship type communication. Just sex.

Situationship is going couply things and having sex. So basically, you are acting like you’re in a relationship but it’s clear you’re not boyfriend and girlfriend, and have made that clear between you

Why though??
What do you mean, basically behaving like you're in a relationship but saying you're not? What is that? I'm not ancient, I love a good non traditional relationship set up but this sounds bonkers. You act like you're a couple but somehow because you SAY you aren't one, nothing is serious between you? Meanwhile you're clearly both wanting the benefits of a relationship without the title? Mad.

Planesmistakenforstars · 27/04/2026 19:11

FairBee · 27/04/2026 18:59

Goodness, this is where I made a mistake

I apologised and baked him a school icing style cake with sprinkles as he’d been talking about it

What a silly girl I’ve been

If you're serious, and I cannot believe you're serious, you did this because you followed a man on ig that you didn't even know was his cousin. Because he got upset. He is waving warning flags of being a controlling prick if you carry on with this, and emotionally really hurting you either way. Get off this train.

DeadBug · 27/04/2026 19:16

Men can compartmentalise in a completely different way to women.

He won't bring your children up or be fully involved with someone with children already. He's told you that .

If in future, he wants a full relationship or to have children of his own, he will look for a new partner for this.

Tbf, he's not lied to you. It's completely clear that you're suitable for now while he's so busy. If you're looking for more or are falling for him, then you need to end it now.

Middlechild3 · 27/04/2026 19:18

Are you teenagers? Decide what you want then decide if he fits the bill.

Patientlywaited81 · 27/04/2026 19:18

FairBee · 27/04/2026 18:59

Goodness, this is where I made a mistake

I apologised and baked him a school icing style cake with sprinkles as he’d been talking about it

What a silly girl I’ve been

You’re trying to make out that you’re someone who just wanted a some sex and no strings fun together, but you sound very similar to him

You should have made that cake for… your sons. Not this peculiar man child

Anyahyacinth · 27/04/2026 19:22

I think you are blocking the space for someone more complete.

UNLESS you are happy with the sex and willing to defer the hurt further down the line

The incongruity you are trying to rationalise is just him having a girlfriend experience…he has clearly stated his limits..listen to that ..protect your feelings

FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:25

Patientlywaited81 · 27/04/2026 19:18

You’re trying to make out that you’re someone who just wanted a some sex and no strings fun together, but you sound very similar to him

You should have made that cake for… your sons. Not this peculiar man child

Edited

It was for them too. I bake a lot

OP posts:
Patientlywaited81 · 27/04/2026 19:26

FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:25

It was for them too. I bake a lot

You cut the cake in half?

CombatBarbie · 27/04/2026 19:26

Hmmm a fwb is usually limited interaction and more focused on when are you free, can include weekends away, but certainly not the level of interaction hes doing. And getting jealous over following someone (regardless if its a family member in the scenario you are describing).

Fwb also means you are still free to continue dating. Sounds like he wants the relationship but without your kids. Tread carefully.

FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:28

Anyahyacinth · 27/04/2026 19:22

I think you are blocking the space for someone more complete.

UNLESS you are happy with the sex and willing to defer the hurt further down the line

The incongruity you are trying to rationalise is just him having a girlfriend experience…he has clearly stated his limits..listen to that ..protect your feelings

I could be wrong but I get the feeling he would now be really hurt if I ended things and try to make me stay

I struggle to understand that because if someone is just fun, you don’t feel hurt when they end it and try to make them stay… like if I did, I’d see a future with them, at least possibly

Is that just a woman thing?

OP posts:
FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:29

Patientlywaited81 · 27/04/2026 19:26

You cut the cake in half?

It’s school dinners style sprinkle cake. You make it and cake it into little squares

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 27/04/2026 19:29

Anyone who wants you to change your behaviour incase they look bad …

just no.

throw this one back.

Patientlywaited81 · 27/04/2026 19:30

FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:29

It’s school dinners style sprinkle cake. You make it and cake it into little squares

And gave half to him to apologise for following his cousin. Sweet Jesus

Error404FucksNotFound · 27/04/2026 19:33

Sounds like he wants the benefits for him of the boyfriend experience but he wants to make sure you know not to expect anything from him, while still following his rules

BreadstickBurglar · 27/04/2026 19:34

FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:28

I could be wrong but I get the feeling he would now be really hurt if I ended things and try to make me stay

I struggle to understand that because if someone is just fun, you don’t feel hurt when they end it and try to make them stay… like if I did, I’d see a future with them, at least possibly

Is that just a woman thing?

It’s not just a woman thing but it is a normal decent person thing. This guy for whatever reason has opted out of “real” relationships and been clear about that. Which is fine, but you don’t get to have a noncommittal relationship with someone and then get all upset when they don’t want to, er, commit to you. He can be upset all he wants if you break it off but that doesn’t mean he’s changed his mind on relationships full stop. And it shouldn’t change what you do. You either want FWB or a relationship and he’s offering neither. Time to get rid and keep all the cake for yourself 😁

moderate · 27/04/2026 19:35

FairBee · 27/04/2026 19:28

I could be wrong but I get the feeling he would now be really hurt if I ended things and try to make me stay

I struggle to understand that because if someone is just fun, you don’t feel hurt when they end it and try to make them stay… like if I did, I’d see a future with them, at least possibly

Is that just a woman thing?

No, it’s not a woman thing.

The bottom line is that you have reached the point in your relationship where you are catching feelings and you need him to show that if he wants commitment from you he needs to be prepared to take the whole package including your children.

It doesn’t sound to me like this is the case.

Chocolatefreak · 27/04/2026 19:36

Monr0e · 27/04/2026 18:39

He wants all the perks of having a girlfriend without the label. It also leaves him free to sail off into the sunset when the person he soes want a relationship with comes along, guilt free.

If you are happy with this, great, but it sounds like you want more from him. And if your dc's are a deal breaker for him then I would call a halt to this now before you become even more attached otherwise you are heading for heartbreak.

I agrée. I think he wants emotional and physical intimacy, but doesn’t want the responsibility of a relationship.

BreadstickBurglar · 27/04/2026 19:37

Also I always thought a “situationship” was a situation that wasn’t quite a relationship - usually something with a level of uncertainty about whether it’ll become a relationship etc - and definitely something people fall into by accident! Not something you decide to do from the start. That to me is like saying “hi would you like a confusing, maybe even crazymaking love life? Nothing reassuring or chill!”

Marble10 · 27/04/2026 19:40

I would be super cautious. Mr Nice Guy, Mr Good Guy.. but likes to play games.

Comtesse · 27/04/2026 19:41

FairBee · 27/04/2026 18:44

Hmm, very possibly.

He last got his heartbroken because he told the girl he wanted just a situationship. She wanted more, he didn’t. She ended up meeting someone and ended it. He developed feelings prior to this and begged her to stay and give it a go as a proper couple. She said no

6 months down the line she’s now engaged and just got given the deposit for a house (he has mutual friends with her new partner)

Something tells me he’d be hurt if I ended it too. Not because he wanted me that much. But possibly because, ego. Or is that being unfair? I don’t know

Who cares what he wants? What do you want?

He just sounds like a shit wishy-washy boyfriend to me tbh without the courage of his own convictions.

Icecreamisthebest · 27/04/2026 19:42

All those who are saying he wants all the benefits of a relationship but to be able to walk away when it suits him and justify any hurt he causes by saying well it was never a relationship.

He’s all about himself and what suits him. I mean he wants you to spend your time cooking him dinner and stay overnight with your young DC there and use your holiday home with his parents. He has user written all over him. The fact that he’s polite about it doesn’t change that

choccytime · 27/04/2026 19:48

FairBee · 27/04/2026 18:59

Goodness, this is where I made a mistake

I apologised and baked him a school icing style cake with sprinkles as he’d been talking about it

What a silly girl I’ve been

It's called school cake I make it all the time . Stick to the baking and stop all this nonsense

TheCurious0range · 27/04/2026 19:48

You said you don't want a serious relationship you want sex and you're enjoying his company for the time being. Isn't that what a situationship is? You stay at that initial dating stage not progressing to moving in together, marriage etc. You said that's what you are looking for and it sounds like he likes dating you and having sex with you but won't look for more because he doesn't want children and he's got a huge amount of care responsibility already. Surely it's the ideal set up for both of you?

Marieb19 · 27/04/2026 19:49

So he isn't interested in a LTR with you but wants sex, benefits of a relationship and even control who you link with on Instagram. You maybe happy as things are but do you want to investmore of your time in this guy who has told you he isn't interested in you or your children long term. You and your children deserve a better more stable future.

Shitmonger · 27/04/2026 20:00

FrostyMorn · 27/04/2026 18:58

Gosh, I must be even more of a dinosaur than I thought. Your description of a 'situationship' just sounds like a casual relationship. I don't understand what makes it particularly different.

No you’re right. A situationship is something different, not what she’s describing. OP means a casual relationship.