Thanks for the replies
Clara I know what you mean about Dr Jay...I think his approach is more me (as in it is more the approach I do naturally iyswim) but at the same time I don't do co sleeping if I can possibly avoid it and no, I do not want ds to still be waking several times a night at 30 months! I can cope with him waking once until he is about 2 because that is what dd did and now she sleeps brilliantly so I can kind of see an end to it if that is what he does. We had the same thing with dd as you with dd2-the one and only time I did CC with her she woke up the next day with a new tooth and a red raw bum
Insy I tried baby whisperer when ds was tiny and it didn't work for us at all. I liked the basics behind it but it just didn't work and ds' screaming got worse when I tried. Mind you I don't think it helped that I couldn't stand the way she wrote the book and wanted to throw things at her everytime I opened it! PUPD and shush pat just enraged him too rather than getting him to sleep...Does she do anything different for toddlers?
We did do some CC when he was 8 months because he'd stopped settling even when rocked and it worked for a while but then we went to Botswana and came back and everything changed.
Anyway, what we have been doing for a while now is me feeding ds then dh settling him for bed. Dh was going to him when he woke and he was settling fairly easily and sometimes sleeping through til 5 or 6. But then he suddenly started waking earlier and earlier and either not settling at all for dh or settling and waking again several times-hence very sleep deprived parents. So the last couple of weeks (I was feeling guilty about dh getting up to him )I have gone to him. That immediately means no crying but he wasn't settling again, just wanted to be held by me all night and was trying to feed constantly. This week I have given up trying to settle him and put him back in cot and just brought him in bed with me but refused to feed him. Night one he woke at 11ish and just tried to feed all night, night 2 he woke at 12, again kept trying to feed, night 3 he woke at 2 but accepted it when I said no boob and was ok just being cuddled then lying next to me, last night he slept til 4 and wasn't really bothered about feeding, just tried once then gave up. The next step is getting him out of my bed again! Hopefully he might carry on increasing the time he sleeps for and it won't even be an issue eg if he sleeps til 6 then I can just feed him and get up so he'll have spent all night in his own bed. Fingers crossed!
I dunno though, it just seems like everytime we make some progress with his sleep he goes backwards again so I do wonder if a harsher method would have more of a lasting effect.
Clara am very of St Lucia. Wow!
Skid not at all of the nappies (well unless the green face can also mean puke!). Could he be teething? DD used to always get horrible green runny smelly poo when she was teething, ds' nappies are SO much nicer to deal with!