to be disappointed that the inmate who attacked Ian Huntley didn't do a better job?

[Vallhala]

Unfortunately it appears that Huntley will survive.

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/8579226.stm

AIBU in thinking that it's a pity that the harm caused to Huntley wasn't fatal?

nice!!

Well at least he's serving a sentence
a lot of Shipman's victims families felt cheated when he committed suicide, they wanted him yo have a miserable life in prison

YABU.
What an unpleasant and unecessary post

Yes YABU theres a thread on this already

YABU. Tbh it's in really poor taste.
He may have done a dreadful thing but I don't think that makes it open-season for any nutter to have a pop at him.

Yeah torture the bastard every day for the rest of his, miserable sad existence, i hate that nasty f**king piece of shit

YADNBU.

Someone will be along in a minute to explain how murdering paedophiles arent all bad, they cant really help it and someone probably took his teddy away when he was a little boy.

Sorry, didn't spot that there is already comment on this issue. No apologies for my viewpoint though, as I know all too well the effect that Huntley's crimes have had on the families and community.

Yes YABU

Alouiseg I wanted to post something like that
imo i hope he lives to a 100 and every day is full off fear(I wish the same on JB's murderers)

I hate violence... his or anyone else's.

Lockets, I'd shake the man by the hand.

You see lockets thats why they need to impose the death sentence again, so it is legal.

YANBU. Its a gut response.

Last man who attacked him was a rapist. You'd shake him by the hand? Wonder how his victims would feel.

yabu

To the op - why do you care? what he did was terrible, and no doubt if i were the parent of one of those children i would want to kill him myself. but as someone not linked to this man in anyway why do you care what happens to him? if he had died would your life be better?

Becuase i'd imagine the guy who attacked him is an instrument of justice and virtue and not some psychopathic fuck-wit with a pseudo-moralistic stance against paedo's and nonces.

Whoever did this to Huntley will be only marginally less repellent than the man himself. Please don't make a hero out of him (because you can be sure that is the reason why he did it).

oh yes, because the man who did this will have been a fine upstanding member of the community won't he. probably another murderer looking to be turned into a hero by the idiots that think this sort of action is acceptable and should be celebrated.

The last one who attacked huntley was a rapest. But go ahead and shake his hand. I'm sure his victims are extatic that his actions are being celebrated up and down the country.

Honestly, I seriously wonder about the aledged inteligence of some people.

nancy75 "why do you care?* Because if she didn't she'd be a psychopath with zero empathy for other parents.