Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I change my will?

203 replies

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:11

Should I amend my will?

I do not have children, but have been godmother to David (name changed) for 45+ years. I told his mother before she passed that he was the benefactor of my estate when my time came.

David is doing extremely well for himself. He has married a woman from a reasonably wealthy background, they both have successful and financially rewarding careers. I know he inherted well from his mother, and his wife will inherit a decent sum unless it goes on care home fees etc.

I am not in the best of health, but not at deaths door, god willing, and should have a good ten-20 years more all being well.

I live in an affluent area in the penthouse in a block of flats, which i bought decades ago and through sheer good luck and property prices being what they are, is worth a tidy sum.

He does not need it, imo! I mean sure, it would be nice.

Conversely, there is a single mother, Kate, on one of the flats in my block raising two children in a tiny three-bed flat rental. She sleeps in the box room. She is unwell/disabled herself, and has been through a tough time. Her parents died and she will inherit nothing from anywhere else. She has no siblings, no help from anywhere. The father of her children is not on the scene. We talk, she is lovely company. She works but has little left over for anything as it all goes on rent and bills. She helps me out a lot with errands and is very kind. I have already told her in passing that my estate is going to my godson, she didn't bat an eyelid and continues to help me. It has been five years, so not a very recent friendship/neighbour.

I am now tempted to change my will to change her life. It will be so life-changing for her. It won't make much of a difference to my godson who is independently affluent. She can just move up here when I am gone, have more space, and some relief from the hard slog I know she goes through to pay her rent.

YANBU - change it to this single mum
YABU - stick with the godson

OP posts:
NewPinkJacket · 05/07/2026 14:14

I don't really know why you're asking considering the way you've written it up (completely in Kate's favour).

Just leave stuff/money to either or both.

Lexy2345 · 05/07/2026 14:14

I’m voting to give your inheritance to the single mum.

AlcoholicAntibiotic · 05/07/2026 14:16

Who do you have the strongest relationship with?

Bikergran · 05/07/2026 14:16

Yes. She needs it. He doesn't. But you should consult a solicitor and actually state in the will your reasons for this, so he can't contest it.

Blimms · 05/07/2026 14:17

Virtue signalling I expect.

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:17

NewPinkJacket · 05/07/2026 14:14

I don't really know why you're asking considering the way you've written it up (completely in Kate's favour).

Just leave stuff/money to either or both.

Edited

I suppose because I feel like I am breaking my word to David's mother. She died when he was in his early twenties at which stage some financial help from me would have really helped him. He is now in his late 40s and is doing very well for himself. He also knows he is the named recipient of all my earthly possessions.

OP posts:
Error404FucksNotFound · 05/07/2026 14:18

It is yours. Leave it to whoever you want to leave it to.

Is your godson in your life? Are you close?

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:19

AlcoholicAntibiotic · 05/07/2026 14:16

Who do you have the strongest relationship with?

Both. in different ways.

I watched him grow up, was an involved godmother, knew him as a child. He lives a fair way away now but does still pop in to see me when he is in the area (his home town), though this is not often.

Kate is a lovely woman, and I feel sorry for her. She has been dealt a bad hand. When I went through a period of severe incapacity following a medical incident, she was on hand to help me daily, on top of managing her own life/work/children. And I like her as a person.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 05/07/2026 14:19

I think as he may know, then you shouldn't just drop him totally because then he'll be forever wondering what he did for you to do this.

Leave to both and put an explanation in the will.

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:20

Blimms · 05/07/2026 14:17

Virtue signalling I expect.

Ok! Well, I'll be dead, and here I am anonymous, so if you say so!

OP posts:
thejelliclecats · 05/07/2026 14:22

Can't you split it between them?

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:22

MargaretThursday · 05/07/2026 14:19

I think as he may know, then you shouldn't just drop him totally because then he'll be forever wondering what he did for you to do this.

Leave to both and put an explanation in the will.

I have thought about this. I should have said.

If I leave them half each, it is not enough for her to own a property elsewhere - not for the next 10+ years whilst her children are tied to the area because of school, anyway. She will therefore be stuck renting. I want to help get her out of renting, really,. Half my estate actually won't cut it!

OP posts:
StrongTea · 05/07/2026 14:24

If it wouldn’t offend your friend can you make her a financial gift now? Would make her life easier as she seems to be having a tough time.

Selttan · 05/07/2026 14:25

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:22

I have thought about this. I should have said.

If I leave them half each, it is not enough for her to own a property elsewhere - not for the next 10+ years whilst her children are tied to the area because of school, anyway. She will therefore be stuck renting. I want to help get her out of renting, really,. Half my estate actually won't cut it!

But you mention you’ve hopefully got 10-20 more years surely it won’t matter where her kids go to school as they’ll likely be adults.

i think split it between them.

JLou08 · 05/07/2026 14:27

It sounds like a lovely idea. Helping someone who needs it makes a lot more sense. I would talk to David first just to give him the heads up and explain your reasoning. If he is a good person, he will understand and agree.

CallNatasha · 05/07/2026 14:28

I told his mother before she passed that he was the benefactor of my estate when my time came....I have already told [friend] in passing that my estate is going to my godson, she didn't bat an eyelid and continues to help me.

I find everything about this a bit odd. Why are you telling people any of this stuff? Why is it notable that your friend didn't bat an eyelid?

Anyway, sounds fine but you should probably tell your godson now if you think he has been told that he will be inheriting from you. You might also think about whether there is a way to help your friend now rather than in 20 years.

(You might also consider that everyone's situations may have changed significantly by the time you die, which is another reason for not announcing things to people now, but it's a bit late for that.)

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:29

StrongTea · 05/07/2026 14:24

If it wouldn’t offend your friend can you make her a financial gift now? Would make her life easier as she seems to be having a tough time.

I am property-rich, but not otherwise affluent. I am comfortable enough. But not rich enough to gift her anything now. And I feel that whilst I am alive, that would alter our dynamic, even if I could. Basically, I want her to be able to get out of renting, and a monetary gift of anything less than hundreds of thousands isn't going to make that happen for her, knowing what I know of her situation (age for mortgage/health/work earnings (I don't know her exact salary but I know what she does for a living and she is simply not a high earner whilst her children still need care, and that probably won't change for several years. I may go on for 10-20+ years of course, but having recently lost a friend, it has brought home to me that we just don't know, and I could pass tonight. Obviously that's not time enough to sort this out, and I am just giving it some thought, hence this post.

OP posts:
GreatThingsAwait · 05/07/2026 14:29

How about 50/50. I’d also let your godson know. I think you should give your money to whoever you want but I think, if it were me, it would feel wrong to go back on my word about giving the money to the godson.

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:29

Selttan · 05/07/2026 14:25

But you mention you’ve hopefully got 10-20 more years surely it won’t matter where her kids go to school as they’ll likely be adults.

i think split it between them.

Well yes, hopefully! But it's not a given, is it!

OP posts:
PrizedPickledPopcorn · 05/07/2026 14:30

Can she afford to live in it? My BiL is being left his parents’ house (he lives with them), but it’s not a sensible move because he doesn’t earn enough to run a big 4 bed house on his own.

Could you leave one of them money and the other a home?

I think you should warn him, when you’ve decided. You could say you’re thinking of leaving it to charity, which would also be reasonable. It’s easy to think we know about other people’s lives, but he could have something going on you are unaware of. For example, a huge school fee debt, a child with a disability, or a life limiting illness that impacts the family’s future. None of which would be your responsibility, but do check their situation.

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 05/07/2026 14:32

Actually 50:50 will still be a life changing amount for her. Assuming it isn’t just enough to scupper her housing benefit!

BigWillieStyIe · 05/07/2026 14:32

CallNatasha · 05/07/2026 14:28

I told his mother before she passed that he was the benefactor of my estate when my time came....I have already told [friend] in passing that my estate is going to my godson, she didn't bat an eyelid and continues to help me.

I find everything about this a bit odd. Why are you telling people any of this stuff? Why is it notable that your friend didn't bat an eyelid?

Anyway, sounds fine but you should probably tell your godson now if you think he has been told that he will be inheriting from you. You might also think about whether there is a way to help your friend now rather than in 20 years.

(You might also consider that everyone's situations may have changed significantly by the time you die, which is another reason for not announcing things to people now, but it's a bit late for that.)

Edited

I suppose with David's mother, when she was dying I wanted her to know I was going to help provide for him. He was early 20s so very young and we didn't know how his life would turn out. Turns out he has done very well.

With Kate, I suppose there was an element of me testing whether she might have been befriending me for ulterior motives. I do not believe she has as she has continued to be a great support.

OP posts:
SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 05/07/2026 14:33

To avoid contesting the will etc.

I'd leave him a nominal amount like £20k "to have the holiday of a lifetime" and explain he has done exceptional well for himself you are v proud yadda yadda....and give the rest to Kate.

Nearly50omg · 05/07/2026 14:34

So he doesn’t come and visit you or make an effort to help you at all? Why should you leave him all your worldly possessions?

CinnamonBuns67 · 05/07/2026 14:35

Ultimately only you can decide who you give it to. However if I was in your position I'd give it to the one who's been there consistently in times of hardship (and in your case that sounds like Kate unless I've missed something)