Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my partner I’ll only have a 2nd child if I can be a SAHM?

225 replies

JayleaMine · 09/11/2025 23:03

Our first is 7 months old. I’ll be going back to work when he’s 9 months, I’ve had to fight tooth and nail with work for them to agree to flexible working when I go back - I’ll be doing 4 days and finishing half an hour early to do the nursery pick-up. I was mostly happy with one and done, I figured we’d have a few years that’d be a bit tight financially but then he’d start school and childcare costs would decrease and then we’d have the money to give our boy a great life.

However DP is now saying he wants 2. I can’t see how it is going to work unless I am a SAHM. I can understand DP’s reasons for wanting to give DS a sibling. DP’s family are all abroad in a country that is not feasible for us to move to (very bad economy, no jobs). My mum and dad live an hour away, and they had me older and are pushing 70, they are also full-time carers to my brother who has autism and are in denial about the fact that he’ll need to go into supportive living eventually. I’ll end up organising provision for all 3 of them in the future which makes me feel ill with dread. I have a half sibling on my dad’s side but I expect she’ll only help with my dad.

I understand DP’s perspective in that our child will be lonely - we do know other one-child families but those kids have cousins. Our child won’t have anyone at all. I remember being a lonely kid growing up with a half-sister 20 years older than me and then a non-verbal autistic sibling who never acknowledged my existence. I’d love my boy to have a sibling to grow up with.

Even though my heart wants 2, I don’t see how it will work. Especially during the stage where one child will be at school and the other at nursery, and I would spend more on childcare than I would working until they reach the age where they are both at school and then have to be in 2 places at once come 5:30 to get one from nursery and the other from school. DP has rotating shift patterns so whilst he is a hands on loving dad, we can’t plan childcare around him. Dp changing jobs in not an option as if he stays at his current job a few more years there will be opportunities for a brilliant promotion.

The reasons we want 2 (for our son to have company as no family nearby) are the same reasons I feel like we can’t have 2 (no family support nearby!).

I think the only solution is that I do go back to work after this maternity leave (and save as much as I can in that time!), and then once I go on maternity with a potential second child then I will stay out of work until both are in primary school, and then go back to work. My partner earns £600 a week after tax and we’ve figured we can make it work (if we cut back on holidays, eating out, get rid of the nice SUV lease car and get a run-around) but I think DP is apprehensive as he grew up in severe poverty in his home country.

Just curious what others would do in our situation?

OP posts:
BernardButlersBra · 10/11/2025 10:30

As is often the case then he needs to do more so all of the pick up / drop offs so they aren’t all on you and you’re more flexible for work. If he’s that bothered about another child then he can step up. Also why give up work when you aren’t even married, as it will negatively impact your pension, earning power, career etc

TrolleySculpture · 10/11/2025 10:39

Please get married. It should be the first thing on your list. It protects you and makes the home the marital home plus you are then entitled to a portion of the pension your then Dh will be paying into whilst you are not earning. He will be progressing his career of the back of your sacrifice and hard work.

I was a sahm but married. Consider a school with established wrap around care, holiday clubs, childminders etc. Inset days are the worst because nothing is set up for that. I used to have my child's best mate plus his sister because otherwise his Mum was completely stuck.

Hoppinggreen · 10/11/2025 10:41

JayleaMine · 09/11/2025 23:12

The state of everything? Charming way to describe my life, thanks a lot

I think they meant the world
I don't agree but I don't think it was aimed at you personally

ANiceCuppaTeaandBiscuit · 10/11/2025 10:44

Do you need to decide on a second child now? Why not wait a few years and see how you feel.

EveryChairIsWobbly · 10/11/2025 10:47

I think it’s good you’re thinking about this early on. Gives you both time to plan.

I think get married, and both of you commit to trying to earn/save as much as possible over the next year or two. Be realistic about his plan to earn more in the future. Carefully save baby items now so you can reuse them. If family are offering you Xmas gifts, be pragmatic and opt for money towards the next size car seat etc.

Its hard both working full time and juggling kids, lots of people manage but if you the choice and desire to be a SAHM then I’d make this the goal and both of you commit to a plan to make that work.

do think about your own needs for the future too - once kids are in secondary school they often need you less and it’s good to have your own life to fall back into again.

Brefugee · 10/11/2025 10:49

he wants the child, then he can be the SAHP. Surely?

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 10/11/2025 10:53

First thing to do is get married. If being a SAHM is what you want then save up like mad for the next couple of years. You say hopefully your DP will be promoted by then so that's the time to make the decision.

Susiy · 10/11/2025 10:55

Wait and see how things work out with the first child before having a second one. Having a child completely changes the dynamic of the relationship between husband and wife - both of you need time to adapt.
Having a 2nd child too soon could end up being too much stress for both of you.
Also, if you space them out, you could still work.
My sister had two back to back and stayed at home for 15 years and then could only find low paid work and also has no pension. Something to consider.

Moneyplantss · 10/11/2025 11:17

JayleaMine · 09/11/2025 23:03

Our first is 7 months old. I’ll be going back to work when he’s 9 months, I’ve had to fight tooth and nail with work for them to agree to flexible working when I go back - I’ll be doing 4 days and finishing half an hour early to do the nursery pick-up. I was mostly happy with one and done, I figured we’d have a few years that’d be a bit tight financially but then he’d start school and childcare costs would decrease and then we’d have the money to give our boy a great life.

However DP is now saying he wants 2. I can’t see how it is going to work unless I am a SAHM. I can understand DP’s reasons for wanting to give DS a sibling. DP’s family are all abroad in a country that is not feasible for us to move to (very bad economy, no jobs). My mum and dad live an hour away, and they had me older and are pushing 70, they are also full-time carers to my brother who has autism and are in denial about the fact that he’ll need to go into supportive living eventually. I’ll end up organising provision for all 3 of them in the future which makes me feel ill with dread. I have a half sibling on my dad’s side but I expect she’ll only help with my dad.

I understand DP’s perspective in that our child will be lonely - we do know other one-child families but those kids have cousins. Our child won’t have anyone at all. I remember being a lonely kid growing up with a half-sister 20 years older than me and then a non-verbal autistic sibling who never acknowledged my existence. I’d love my boy to have a sibling to grow up with.

Even though my heart wants 2, I don’t see how it will work. Especially during the stage where one child will be at school and the other at nursery, and I would spend more on childcare than I would working until they reach the age where they are both at school and then have to be in 2 places at once come 5:30 to get one from nursery and the other from school. DP has rotating shift patterns so whilst he is a hands on loving dad, we can’t plan childcare around him. Dp changing jobs in not an option as if he stays at his current job a few more years there will be opportunities for a brilliant promotion.

The reasons we want 2 (for our son to have company as no family nearby) are the same reasons I feel like we can’t have 2 (no family support nearby!).

I think the only solution is that I do go back to work after this maternity leave (and save as much as I can in that time!), and then once I go on maternity with a potential second child then I will stay out of work until both are in primary school, and then go back to work. My partner earns £600 a week after tax and we’ve figured we can make it work (if we cut back on holidays, eating out, get rid of the nice SUV lease car and get a run-around) but I think DP is apprehensive as he grew up in severe poverty in his home country.

Just curious what others would do in our situation?

I wouldn’t worry for the moment. Just wait until first child is 2 at least.

I didn’t want an only child either; it is a bit sad. I wouldn’t completely leave my job either; will look for more part time if possible while kids are little; you will manage. 600 a week is not enough to live in my opinion

MightyDandelionEsq · 10/11/2025 11:32

You’re not going to get much love on here as SAHMS get slated a lot. But you need to be married and have your ducks lined up to trust your partner with your financial security. I don’t care if it’s old fashioned it’s the best way.

I said the same to my DH and will be taking some time when my second comes along. I’m really tired of women being made to feel bad for wanting to stay at home with their kids and not believing their career is everything.

I get some women find it difficult and want to outsource the work but some of us don’t. The sooner we can all let each other get on with our own choices the better.

I personally work because I have to and even with a thriving career, I feel nothing for the job like I do being home with my kid. Being at home is harder for me than actual work. I hate being torn between the two sides of me and would rather enjoy the early years before they’re gone and the household spending thousands on childcare that I find subpar (all our nurseries are inadequate ofsted rated).

Do what you feel is best for your family.

SailingYachty · 10/11/2025 11:33

You could wait until first is about to join school before having the second, then at least you only have 1 lot of fees.
Pick up for both should be possible. I dropped one off at nursery at 8.30 then back for school run, then picked up at school for 5.30, at nursery for 5.45 (they closed at 6). Yes it’s a bit of driving around, but as we could get school and nursery near enough to each other it worked for us.

Floofle · 10/11/2025 11:39

I think lots of couples are in this position. Our parents are in this country but not local and have shown no inclination to do regular childcare!

We had 2 kids 2 years apart, so had about 2 years of double nursery fees (from when the yougest started nursery to when the oldest started school).
It is hard and a LOT of money even with the funding (£2300/month) but we managed, and now our oldest has just started school we suddenly feel rich haha.

Lots of people time the gap so that the second starts nursery when the oldest starts school (3ish years) - is that an option?

Floofle · 10/11/2025 11:41

also on pick ups, it's totally possible with a bit of flexibility. In the morning I drop DC1 at school at 8:35, then on to nursery drop DC2 and home (if WFH) for 9.
In the afternoon, pick DC1 up from nursery at 5:15, DC2 from after school club at 5:30, and home by 5:45.

zazazaaarmm · 10/11/2025 12:09

RubySquid · 10/11/2025 10:14

Hmm since my mum died I've not seen my brothers at all. Not since her funeral.we are in our 50s. How long before they get more important?

Im sorry about that (unless you don't want to see them, then phew!). The research is not saying all people, its saying most people.

GreyPearlSatin · 10/11/2025 12:23

JayleaMine · 09/11/2025 23:12

The state of everything? Charming way to describe my life, thanks a lot

I think this poster means the state of the world/country. There is a lot of instability at the moment and it doesn't look like things will be getting better any time soon.

I find your husband's arguments for a second child very weak. Having two children does not mean they will get along. In fact, you might have to spend hours a day keeping them apart of refereeing fights. Since your partner won't be around a lot to do this kind of work, it seems madness to add another child into the mix.

You should only have another if you are both on board with the idea. It seems like you are not, so you should not have a second.

Twattergy · 10/11/2025 12:46

If you are under 40, why not just leave a bigger gap (3 or 4 years). This helps with costs and logistics. See how things progress? Maybe use the big DH promotion as the trigger point for considering baby/career plans? If DH is highly likely to be earning more in a few years that makes a big difference on choices.

SharpFox · 10/11/2025 14:52

Just came to say, your child won't be alone in life. They'll grow up, have friends, a partner and child(ren) of their own. xx

andweallsingalong · 10/11/2025 15:25

Maybe have a chat to a couple of agencies and see what the likelihood of getting work would be. If on 3 days a week you could drop everything and come in to cover unexpected sickness you might find that you would be in demand.

CliantheLang · 10/11/2025 15:42

NumbersGuy · 10/11/2025 05:51

Speaking from a pragmatic POV, the U.S. is going through a major upheaval which no one saw coming, and because I do tax work, a majority of my clients were not prepared for the amount of layoffs (1.1 million so far this year), businesses shuttering, and seeing the greatest government shutdown in history. Yes thanks to the great orange pumpkin head it's come crashing down, but these people have regretted ever believing to prepare for "what if" that no one ever saw coming. Taking emotion out of it, what if DP lost their job, lost their ability to work, wasn't around anymore? Taking so much time off and not supporting your pension is also a red flag to be a SAHM, because here people are raiding theirs traditional retirement accounts just to survive, facing a 20% withdrawal penalty on top of tax payments. Just be honest if it's financially feasible, and look for all of the worst possible scenarios mentioned throughout, because you can't let emotion guide you in this pursuit.

Surely, you can just tell them to learn to code?

SapphOhNo · 10/11/2025 15:50

Definitely wait. Don't say no now but give it a few years to see how it goes.

How good is DP at childcare stuff? how much does he do?

Also - get married.

FaithfultotheTraitors · 11/11/2025 07:01

Moneyplantss · 10/11/2025 11:17

I wouldn’t worry for the moment. Just wait until first child is 2 at least.

I didn’t want an only child either; it is a bit sad. I wouldn’t completely leave my job either; will look for more part time if possible while kids are little; you will manage. 600 a week is not enough to live in my opinion

I realise it is your opinion but please can you think for a moment before tossing out comments like having an only child 'is a bit sad'. There are all sorts of reasons why families may have just one child and labelling it 'sad' can be very hurtful. It is loaded with negative (and often wrong) assumptions about the life that child has. It's a really offensive stereotype

Radiatelikethis · 11/11/2025 09:00

FaithfultotheTraitors · 11/11/2025 07:01

I realise it is your opinion but please can you think for a moment before tossing out comments like having an only child 'is a bit sad'. There are all sorts of reasons why families may have just one child and labelling it 'sad' can be very hurtful. It is loaded with negative (and often wrong) assumptions about the life that child has. It's a really offensive stereotype

Absolutely this, it's such a shame to see in 2025, the these "lonely sad" only child stereotypes still exist. I'm one of 3, we can barely stand to be in the same room as each other, nothing is guaranteed. I know plenty only children of all ages who are happy, contented people.

HeyThereDelila · 11/11/2025 09:04

You can’t live on your DH’s wage. I’d also be aware that autism can run in families and think about how you’d cope if your second DC was autistic like your DB.

Susiy · 11/11/2025 09:47

My adult son is an only child and is one of the happiest people I know with a circle of good friends.
My husband has one brother and they hated each other as children.
They still can only stand one evening in each other's company, preferably at a restaurant as anything else results in arguments.
Lots of siblings hate one another due to sibling rivalry, jealousy, parental favoritism, etc.

You can choose your friends but not your family.

MrsPrendergast · 13/11/2025 07:21

How are you feeling about it all, now @JayleaMine?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page