Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that DC should not go to their grandparents abroad for 2 weeks?

204 replies

LookingforRainbows · 16/07/2017 08:54

Hi all,

DD is 4, due to start school in September, and DS is 2. DH and I both work full time, and both dc go to day nursery.

We both have time off work the last week and a half of August, to take a family holiday together. I then have the first week of September off, and DH has a few days in the week of September off (to settle DD into school before she starts breakfast club/after-school club).

DH does however have a lot more flexibility with his work - he often holds meetings via skype and teleconference, and if planned and organised in advanced, he can spend periods working from home, not needing to go into the office for a couple of weeks, whereas I work public sector, and certainly don't have that degree of flexibility.

Anyway, last week DH was talking with his family (who live abroad in Europe) in his native language. I admit I certainly am not fluent in his language, although I do know a bit, and when they were talking, I gathered that they were talking about the children, but I wasn't able to understand much as they were talking very fast. Not that it mattered I thought, as I don't need to understand, it's their conversation and doesn't concern me.
Anyway, later that eve, DH told me that he was thinking about taking 2 weeks in August to work from home, and he could go to his home country, with DD and DS, and his parents could look after them while he worked, as this would be good for their learning of his native language which is coming on slow at the moment, which I agree with, (although this is because DH is always talking to them in English and 'forgets' to speak his native language, but that's a whole other issue for a whole other thread) also that it would be good for them to bond with his parents, who they do know, as his parents come over every year, and we also visited earlier this year, and we do Skype etc.

Anyway, I wasn't keen on this idea, as I don't want to be away from DC for 2 weeks, and even though DH will be with them, he will be working, so they will be full time with their grandparents who they don't know very well, (although I do accept they are not strangers). Aside from taking them to the park when they came to visit this year, my inlaws have never looked after DC alone before, and DS in particular can be quite clingy and unsettled, especially in unfamiliar places. Also, DD can get anxious and gets upset when she doesn't understand (but she internalises it rather than letting it out) and I worry that she might be some upset if she doesn't understand the language or feels that her grandparents don't understand her.

So I told DH that I didn't think it would be a good idea, and that I wasn't comfortable with it.

Roll forward to this weekend, DH is again trying to convince me to change my mind. Again I say the same things. DH is adamant it will be fine, and tells me that his parents have already been getting ready to have the children and have been making plans for all the things they will do when they have the children, and how they are really looking forward to having them etc etc. I was a bit annoyed, because it seemed as bough he had gone and made the plans with his parents, knowing that I had already said I wasn't happy with it.
He then said to me that I was being selfish as I would have no problem with them being with my parents for two weeks (not really the same as my parents live not too far away and see DC quite often and have cared for DC on their own a few times before) and that I am being selfish because I am blocking what will be good for the children, all because I don't want to be alone and have an empty house after work, and that it would be better than the children being at nursery. He even had said I was being controlling! But I think that he is the controlling one, making plans with his parents, knowing I had already said no.

DH is frosty with me his morning, but I really don't want to back down on this. I worry that as DD is starting school soon, I don't want to add to her anxiety, and yes I guess I am being protective, I know they will be with their dad and grandparents, but I just have a bad gut feeling about this. It's not an option for me to join them I'm afraid as I wouldn't get the time off work. And it's not an option for my inlaws to fly over at the moment either.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ConstanceCraving · 16/07/2017 11:01

Also the H will be "working" at his parents house I'm assuming, meaning that he will be there for his children if they needed him which is different from them being left alone all day with their grandparents.

Shiftymake · 16/07/2017 11:02

YABU! He is going with them so they are with a parent on this trip. These are his kids and his family, and his parents did raise your husband from birth. They do have experience! You don't need to be comfortable with them seeing family, unless they have done something wrong and you are worried for their safety then you do not have a valid point in this. Other then that, I was a child that had family on the other side of the world. To ensure that me and my siblings got to know and create a relationship with that family we were sent alone, on a 13 hour trip, for a month! each summer, and this was amazing. We loved it even with the different languages. We missed our parents for 2 seconds before we were off on adventures with our gps. This isn't about you, but your children and them creating bonds and experiences. They are not too young, they have their father with them and a loving family. p.s. we were not much older than your kids when we were sent overseas alone.

WaitingTillJuly17 · 16/07/2017 11:03

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/behaviour_development/2387939-Bedwetting-anxiety-with-DD1-5-and-blaming-myself

Is this you OP? In which case aren't your children actually 7 and 5 years old? 🤔

Groupie123 · 16/07/2017 11:04

YANBU. No way I'd let MIL or DM take care of DC abroad in their home countries. They can barely take care of themselves!

PastaPosha · 16/07/2017 11:05

It's a good habit to start as when they are older you and they will benefit from this. It is quite typical for French grandparents to take their grandchildren for a couple of weeks in summer and I so wish I had parents or in law's willing and able to do this. Especially if my dc were to learn a second language at the same time.

Barbapapa1980 · 16/07/2017 11:06

I have been doing that for years, taking my dcs to my parents (abroad) and it was great. Now they are going without me.

ConstanceCraving · 16/07/2017 11:08

How strange Waiting. Confused

GhostsToMonsoon · 16/07/2017 11:08

I once went to my maternal GPs who lived two hours away when I was primary school age and was so homesick I had to come back early. I don't know why, because I loved spending time with them, and wasn't normally a child who got homesick much - I went on my first residential PGL holiday aged 7. Two weeks is a very long time for a two-year-old to not see their mum.

Guiltypleasures001 · 16/07/2017 11:09

I think it would be a great opportunity for your dd anxiety issues, she will learn that being away from mum is ok and that independence is good. Kids pick up on and learn anxiety from their parents.

This could be a huge learning curve for your dc, so it's a gentle yabu from me op

MuddlingMackem · 16/07/2017 11:11

worridmum Sun 16-Jul-17 10:54:01

Didnt the OP say she would be fine if it was her DP isn't that totally wrong

Anditstartsagain · 16/07/2017 11:13

My children wohldn't cope without me for 2 week maybe the younger as he's a baby but ds1 would not at all 2 days away he cried to come home therefor I won't let them go.

I would arrange a time I could go with them or let them go for 3/4 days max. It would also matter to me how far it is can they come back easily can I get there etc.

ItsAHardKn0ckLife · 16/07/2017 11:15

Very strange waiting

Curious to see OP's response to that...

AngelaTwerkel · 16/07/2017 11:15

That is really strange, Waiting.

Ameliablue · 16/07/2017 11:17

I think it is natural to be uneasy about being easy from such young children for this length of time but I also think your oh has a point and it will be good for them. They will be able to develop a relationship with their grandparents and your oh will be on hand if they struggle to settle. Even if he had work to do, he won't be working constantly the whole time.

WaitingTillJuly17 · 16/07/2017 11:18

Well, she's not responded to anything thus far so it might be a while...

ItsAHardKn0ckLife · 16/07/2017 11:22

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/2767538-AIBU-to-be-upset-with-Dsis-comments-about-DS-being-young-for-his-age

And in this post, her DS is 7 and an only child... Hmm

LaArdilla · 16/07/2017 11:25

If it's such an issue, why can't you go?

But no, look, they're with their dad and family, it's a good thing, it's how kids are supposed to grow up. I'd give anything for either set of 'grandparents' in my life to give a single solitary shit about my kids.

Your European in-laws are damned if they do and don't, as you feel they don't have a meaningful relationship with the kids, but they can't. And now they're trying.

needmymouthsewnup · 16/07/2017 11:27

waiting it also appears a DD has turned into a DD...

Itsjustaphase2016 · 16/07/2017 11:27

No way would I be happy with this!! They are only 4 and 2. My dc would hate to be away from me for that long! And I would be distraught!!

needmymouthsewnup · 16/07/2017 11:27

that should read a DD has turned into a DS* ...

Extua · 16/07/2017 11:41

I'm surprised so many think you are being unreasonable. Yes your husband will be there but if he's working full time they'll mostly be with their not especially well known grandparents, in an unknown country. My 2 year old DS wouldn't like this, and you know your daughter best. With starting school coming up I would be loathe to add more anxiety provoking stuff. I also wouldn't want to be away from my young children for that long no matter who they were with! Also do his parents speak good English? Will the children be forced to communicate mostly in your husband's language (since this is in part to promote their language skills) thus adding another layer of newness? All while away from their mother?

Honestly I think it doesn't sound good and quite frankly it's more for the benefit of the grandparents and your husband than the children. A lot of the yabu responses are considering the adults, their needs, wants and how it will make them feel. How are the children going to feel? Particularly your 2 year old, I know mine would find it very stressful.

I think it'd be different even if they were just a little older.

Those saying you're being selfish need to get a grip, it's so unfashionable to want to actually see your children and it seems many want rid at every opportunity. And if not wanting them to go for a fortnight is selfish it's certainly no more (and arguably less) selfish than putting them in a situation you are unsure about for the sake of the grandparents feelings. And it shouldn't be arranged without you anyway.
YANBU

Apocalyptichorsewoman · 16/07/2017 11:42

How intriguing! I can kinda understand people changing minor details to avoid being outed, but lopping a few years off their ages when these are central to your argument seems very strange... Confused

Hmm

Beeziekn33ze · 16/07/2017 11:43

Blatant bookmarking for OP's response!

DailyMaui · 16/07/2017 11:53

Yabu.

My children have been going to their grandparents in France since they were born. First with me and then staying for two weeks on their own from when they were aged 5 and 3. I missed them but I knew they'd be having a great time. I adored my grandparents and really wanted my children to have the same close relationship which was going to be hard with my parents living in another country.

It's a situation that has continued happily ever since and now they are 12 and 14 and really looking forward to this year's jaunt. We always have a family holiday just before so I feel I've had a really close time with them before they go away. In fact, they get miffy if it is just for the two weeks as in the past I've joined them for an extra week so they get three!

Consequently they have a very close relationship with their grandparents, which wouldn't have happened if they didn't get that quality time alone with them every year.

This could be the start of something wonderful...

ShastaBeast · 16/07/2017 11:56

The last link says the only child of her and his dad. Any chance the two younger kids are with a different dad? Haha probably clutching at straws. I have no idea why anyone would make stuff up on mumsnet. It's very strange.