Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that DC should not go to their grandparents abroad for 2 weeks?

204 replies

LookingforRainbows · 16/07/2017 08:54

Hi all,

DD is 4, due to start school in September, and DS is 2. DH and I both work full time, and both dc go to day nursery.

We both have time off work the last week and a half of August, to take a family holiday together. I then have the first week of September off, and DH has a few days in the week of September off (to settle DD into school before she starts breakfast club/after-school club).

DH does however have a lot more flexibility with his work - he often holds meetings via skype and teleconference, and if planned and organised in advanced, he can spend periods working from home, not needing to go into the office for a couple of weeks, whereas I work public sector, and certainly don't have that degree of flexibility.

Anyway, last week DH was talking with his family (who live abroad in Europe) in his native language. I admit I certainly am not fluent in his language, although I do know a bit, and when they were talking, I gathered that they were talking about the children, but I wasn't able to understand much as they were talking very fast. Not that it mattered I thought, as I don't need to understand, it's their conversation and doesn't concern me.
Anyway, later that eve, DH told me that he was thinking about taking 2 weeks in August to work from home, and he could go to his home country, with DD and DS, and his parents could look after them while he worked, as this would be good for their learning of his native language which is coming on slow at the moment, which I agree with, (although this is because DH is always talking to them in English and 'forgets' to speak his native language, but that's a whole other issue for a whole other thread) also that it would be good for them to bond with his parents, who they do know, as his parents come over every year, and we also visited earlier this year, and we do Skype etc.

Anyway, I wasn't keen on this idea, as I don't want to be away from DC for 2 weeks, and even though DH will be with them, he will be working, so they will be full time with their grandparents who they don't know very well, (although I do accept they are not strangers). Aside from taking them to the park when they came to visit this year, my inlaws have never looked after DC alone before, and DS in particular can be quite clingy and unsettled, especially in unfamiliar places. Also, DD can get anxious and gets upset when she doesn't understand (but she internalises it rather than letting it out) and I worry that she might be some upset if she doesn't understand the language or feels that her grandparents don't understand her.

So I told DH that I didn't think it would be a good idea, and that I wasn't comfortable with it.

Roll forward to this weekend, DH is again trying to convince me to change my mind. Again I say the same things. DH is adamant it will be fine, and tells me that his parents have already been getting ready to have the children and have been making plans for all the things they will do when they have the children, and how they are really looking forward to having them etc etc. I was a bit annoyed, because it seemed as bough he had gone and made the plans with his parents, knowing that I had already said I wasn't happy with it.
He then said to me that I was being selfish as I would have no problem with them being with my parents for two weeks (not really the same as my parents live not too far away and see DC quite often and have cared for DC on their own a few times before) and that I am being selfish because I am blocking what will be good for the children, all because I don't want to be alone and have an empty house after work, and that it would be better than the children being at nursery. He even had said I was being controlling! But I think that he is the controlling one, making plans with his parents, knowing I had already said no.

DH is frosty with me his morning, but I really don't want to back down on this. I worry that as DD is starting school soon, I don't want to add to her anxiety, and yes I guess I am being protective, I know they will be with their dad and grandparents, but I just have a bad gut feeling about this. It's not an option for me to join them I'm afraid as I wouldn't get the time off work. And it's not an option for my inlaws to fly over at the moment either.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ConstanceCraving · 16/07/2017 09:00

I think two weeks maybe too long but I would agree with one week personally. The dc will be with their dad and grandparents!

sooperdooper · 16/07/2017 09:01

I agree with your DH, and how will the dc get to know his family if they don't spend time with them?

It will be good for them to get used to being in different surroundings & getting to know their other family better, plus your DH will be there

He's their parent too, it sounds like you see a lot more of your family and it's only fair he gets to introduce the kids to his family, country & language

TractorTedTed · 16/07/2017 09:03

Yabu

Sorry, but I think it would be unfair to not let dh take them. If the gps live so far away, of course they won't have spent much time with them. But if you never let the dc go, then they'll never really get to know them. It sounds like this could be really nice for everyone. And I totally understand it will be hard for you. I'd hate for my dc to go away for 2 weeks without me, so I'm not being unsympathetic.

I guess it's only fair to look at it from your dh's perspective. It's important that his family play a role in your lives as well.

welshweasel · 16/07/2017 09:04

YABU. I'd compromise on a week or 10 days.

HicDraconis · 16/07/2017 09:05

I agree with your DH. The children will be with their father and grandparents, getting experience of his culture and language. You've as good as admitted you'd be fine with them spending two weeks with your parents, why are his not good enough?

I think you sound quite selfish. Happy to have your family involved, but not happy for his to have an equal interest in their grandchildren. Assuming he has PR, he has as much right to say yes as you do to say no so why does your "no" become the final decision?

hana32 · 16/07/2017 09:06

A week seems a good compromise

Callmejudith · 16/07/2017 09:06

I think YABU sorry. It will be a great experience for them.

Think about it from another perspective - two weeks at home alone means you can do whatever you like - go out, watch what you want on tv, catch up with friends - heaven

PestoSwimissimos · 16/07/2017 09:07

Oh I think that sounds like a very good idea. Their 2nd language will come on leaps & bounds and it would be great for them to be immersed in the culture of their dad's side of the family.

NapQueen · 16/07/2017 09:07

Your title is misleading as it doesnt say that dh (their dad) will be with them.

Presumably he is perfectly compentent? And you trust his judgement?

Abd if is work is that flexible is he really going to be working 8 hours a day? Id imagine he will want to take the dc out and about to the places he knows?

Could you book off the last couple of days of their trip and go out?

Ceto · 16/07/2017 09:08

I think this is actually a good idea. Can you do a deal with DH whereby he's more hands on and, in particular, keeping an eye on DS? It will help your DS to learn to go to his father rather than clinging to you.

WaitingTillJuly17 · 16/07/2017 09:09

Do you have concerns for the children's safety or wellbeing? As you pointed out, DH will be on hand and presumably they have some form of parenting skills giving that they raised your DH?

As Constance said, perhaps 2 weeks is a little too long for (your) comfort but how else do you expect your PIL to get the sort of experience you are talking about with their grandchildren if you won't let them spend time together?

I think some form of compromise is required, I feel a bit sorry for your DH as if I were him I would feel like you were calling not only his parents but he himself incapable of looking after his own children.

I think YAB(a bit)U.

laurelstar · 16/07/2017 09:10

YABU. It will be a great learning experience for them and a wonderful holiday for their grandparents and your DH. How lovely that their grandparents are already planning fun activities to do when they're there. It just doesn't seem fair or normal to deny them all this experience, the chance to get to know their paternal grandparents as well as your parents and to learn DH's language.
Enjoy your two weeks of peace and freedom and let them go. Your DH sounds like he really does have their best interests at heart.

FittonTower · 16/07/2017 09:11

They'll be with there dad won't they? Sounds ok to me. My family are abroad and my 2 and 4 year old have spent 2 weeks with them in the past, both me and my husband where there but they've spent a week there with just me. My husband missed them but every one coped and it's good for the children i think.
Of course you'll miss them but I don't really understand most of your objections

Foxsox · 16/07/2017 09:11

YANBU
your children are still very young and at an awkward stage for Doing this.
I appreciate your DH will be there but it's the majority of time being spent with GPS that puts me on edge. It's not like they see them regularly.

2 weeks away from either parent is too long, I couldn't do it.

This situation is similar to that of my friend, her DC are going out to her DH's native country to spend 5 days with their grandparents but the kids are 5&7 and it's 5 days!!
She's only just OK with it.

Give it time. They are too little.

BayLeaves · 16/07/2017 09:11

They'll also both have their sibling for familiarity and company Smile

I would really miss DS after 2 weeks but 1 week is definitely doable, my DH took our then 2 year old abroad to his home country to stay with his family for a week last year - similar situation with him not speaking the language enough at home etc. DS really enjoyed it!

StillStayingClassySanDiego · 16/07/2017 09:12

I understand you'll miss them, who wouldn't?

Would you do it if you were in his flexible job with your parents abroad? I think you should relax a little.

GreenTulips · 16/07/2017 09:12

Two child free weeks! Whoop!!

Screwinthetuna · 16/07/2017 09:12

I'm in the same situation as you and still haven't let DH take the kids to his home country without me. The idea stresses me out so much, for example, if the children were in an accident and I couldn't get there quickly, if they were poorly or just home sick and missing me). However, I am a very anxious person and many wouldn't worry about these issues.

I'm guessing that you will get flamed on here as it's difficult for others to fully understand the situation if their partner is of the same nationality and culture. I don't know about yours, but my children even lose weight when they go to DH's country as they are really fussy about the different food and refuse to eat most meals.

Would you feel more comfortable with a week?

Donthate · 16/07/2017 09:13

YabU. You are stopping your DC having a meaningful relationship with one set of grandparents. I feel sorry for your DH.

RibenaMonsoon · 16/07/2017 09:13

Id maybe as a compromise agree with one week. Id be apprehensive if they were just being shipped over there but they will be with their dad. Whats the harm?

JeNeBaguetteRien · 16/07/2017 09:14

Yes I think YABU.
They will be with their parent and grandparents. The flexibility of your DH's work suggests he can see them part of the day. Surely if they were upset he would intervene. Your post comes across as s bit controlling, he is an equal parent.

Also I'd be seeing this as an opportunity for the DC to have fun and for you to relax, and then have your family holiday together when you have your leave and hear all about their adventure.

And tell DH to stop forgetting to speak his language at home so the kids can understand it better and it won't be such a big deal. OPOL One parent, one language, is really effective for bringing up bilingual children.

Let them go and you'll see them on Facetime etc and then for your own family holiday.

OliviaStabler · 16/07/2017 09:17

I think it is an excellent idea. Let them go.

GallicosCats · 16/07/2017 09:17

Some of my happiest memories are of holidays with my DF and DGPs abroad. (DM would have been working and DBs in the middle of exams).

Temporaryanonymity · 16/07/2017 09:17

My children spend a fortnight away every summer. I can't tell you how much I enjoy work when I don't have the children to think about. I feel like a new woman after!

GnomeDePlume · 16/07/2017 09:18

I think YABU.

This 2 week trip will give the DCs more time to get settled and build a relationship with their grandparents. Their language skills will come on in leaps and bounds. The earlier they really learn the language the more natural it will become.

While your DH will be working I guess he will be in the house so able to help with any language difficulties which might arise.

Of course you will miss them and they will miss you but learning to handle this is part of them growing up and learning some independence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread